On the political economy of environmental survival versus collapse. Clarifying the work done by Tinbergen & Hueting vis-à-vis Weitzman, Nordhaus and Stern

Colignatus, Thomas (2008): On the political economy of environmental survival versus collapse. Clarifying the work done by Tinbergen & Hueting vis-à-vis Weitzman, Nordhaus and Stern. Unpublished.

Abstract

The Stern Review (2006) on the economics of climate change presented a cost estimate of perhaps even 20% of national income and subsequently was criticized by Weitzman and Nordhaus and others in a discussion that centered on the use of the calculus of variations and the choice of the proper rate of discount. The Tinbergen & Hueting (1991) approach deals with the wider environmental collapse, is not formulated in the form of the calculus of variations, and arrives at a sustainable level of national income of about 50% of national income. The Tinbergen & Hueting (TH) approach appears to be neglected by Weitzman, Nordhaus and Stern (WNS) but appears to be better grounded in economic theory, mathematically richer and empirically more relevant. This paper clarifies the misunderstandings and omissions in the work by WNS on environmental economics.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Social welfare; national income; sustainable national income; economic growth; sustainable economic growth; sustainability; environment
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E0 - General > E01 - Measurement and Data on National Income and Product Accounts and Wealth; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q0 - General > Q01 - Sustainable Development; A - General Economics and Teaching > A1 - General Economics > A11 - Role of Economics; Role of Economists; Market for Economists

References

PM 1. Colignatus is the science name of Thomas Cool, see http://www.dataweb.nl/~cool

PM 2. See http://www.sni-hueting.info for more works by Hueting

Ahmad, Y., S. El Serafy, E. Lutz (eds.) (1989), Environmental Accounting for Sustainable Development, The World Bank, Washington, D.C.

Aronson, E. (1992), The social animal, Freeman

Boumans, M.J. (1992), ‘A case of limited physics transfer. Jan Tinbergen's resources for re-shaping economics’, Tinbergen Institute Research Series, 38

Bovenberg, L. & R.A. de Mooij (1994), ‘Environmental levies and distortionary taxation’, American Economic Review, 94, 1085-89

Colignatus (1992), Definition and Reality in the general theory of political economy; Some background papers 1989-1992, Magnana Mu Publishing and Research, Rotterdam

Colignatus, Th. (1995), On the political economy of employment in the welfare state, improved from the version included in Colignatus (1992), ewp-mac/9509001, with an again improved version in Colignatus (2005)

Colignatus, Th. (1999, 2001), Proper definitions for Risk and Uncertainty, ewp-get/9902002, included in Colignatus (2005). See also http://www.dataweb.nl/~cool/Risk/index.html

Colignatus, Th. (2000), The choice on sustainability: information or the meta-SWF approach to a shift of preferences, ewp-othr/0004004, own website has proper figures

Colignatus, Th. (2001, 2007), Voting Theory for Democracy, (VTFD) Thomas Cool Consultancy & Econometrics (first edition 2001, second edition 2007)

Colignatus, Th. (2005), Definition & Reality in the General Theory of Political Economy, 2nd edition, Dutch University Press

Colignatus, Th. (2006), Two extravagant ideas on global warming and cooling Holland, Samuel van Houten Genootschap, http://www.dataweb.nl/~cool/Papers/Environment/2006-12-14-GlobalWarming-CoolingHolland.pdf

Colignatus, Th. (2007), ‘Klimaatbeleid is een kwestie van beschaving’, Economisch Statistische Berichten, June 1, p317 (“Climate policy is a matter of civilization’)

Colignatus, Th. (2008), The Old Man and the SNI: A review of advance and adversity in Hueting's research in economic growth and the new scarcity from the environment and sustainable national income (SNI), Samuel van Houten Genootschap, http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/9152

Dasgupta, P. (2007a), ‘Commentary: The Stern Review’s Economics of Climate Change’, National Institute Economic Review, Vol 199, p 4–7

Dasgupta, P. (2007b), Discounting Climate Change, Cambridge University mimeo

Dupont, A. (2008), ‘Climate catastrophe? The strategic implications of climate change, Survival Vol 50 no 3 p29-54 Hicks, J.R. (1939), Value and Capital, 2nd edition, Oxford: Clarendon Press

Hornby (1985), Oxford advanced learner’s dictionary of current English, Oxford

Hueting, R. (1974, 1980), New Scarcity and Economic Growth: More Welfare Through Less Production?, Dutch edition: Agon Elsevier, Amsterdam; English edition: North-Holland Publishing Company, Amsterdam, New York, Oxford, 1980

Hueting, R. (1989), ‘Correcting National Income for Environmental Losses: Towards a Practical Solution’, in Y. Ahmad, S. El Serafy, E. Lutz (eds.) (1989)

Hueting, R. (2001), ‘Rejoinders to symposium authors: Ekins, Daly, Norgaard et al., Beckerman, El Serafy, Pearce et al., Faucheux and O’Connor, Verbruggen et al., Goodland and Mäler’, pp 333-378 in E.C. van Ierland et al. (2001)

Hueting, R. and B. de Boer (2001), ‘Environmental valuation and sustainable national income according to Hueting’, p17-77 in E.C. van Ierland et al. (2001)

Hueting, R. (2008), Why environmental sustainability can most probably not be attained with growing production, Conference on “Economic de-growth for ecological sustainability and social equity”, Paris, 18-19 April

Hueting, R., P. Bosch and B. de Boer (1992), ‘Methodology for the Calculation of Sustainable National Income’, Statistical Essays, M44, CBS Statistics Netherlands, SDU/Publishers, ‘s-Gravenhage 64 p. Also published as WWF International report, Gland, Switzerland, June 1992

Hueting, R. and B. de Boer (2001), ‘Environmental valuation and sustainable national income according to Hueting’, p17-77 in Van Ierland et al. (2001)

Ierland, E.C. van, J. van der Straaten and H.R.J. Vollebergh (eds) (2001), Economic growth and valuation of the environment, A debate, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, UK – Northhampton, MA, USA

Jolink, A. (2007), Weaving threads: Jan Tinbergen’s statistical contribution to economic policy, Erasmus University Rotterdam, working paper mimeo

Jones, A. (2007), Earth. Cuckoo in the phoenix nest, Stichting Fantastische Vertellingen, http://www.lulu.com/content/1305054

Lomborg, B. (2007), Cool it ! The skeptical environmentalist’s guide to global warming, Knopf

Mooij, R.A. de (1999), Environmental taxation and the double dividend, Ph. D. Thesis Erasmus University Rotterdam

Nordhaus, W. D. and J. Tobin (1971, 1973), ‘Is Growth Obsolete?’, Cowles Foundation Discussion Paper CFDP 319, CFP 398 with Comments and Reply. In Milton Moss, ed., ‘The Measurement of Economic and Social Performance’, Studies in Income and Wealth, Vol. 38, National Bureau of Economic Research, 1973, pp. 509-532, http://dido.econ.yale.edu/P/au/nordhaus.htm

Nordhaus, W. D. (1976, 1977), ‘Economic Growth and Climate: The Carbon Dioxide Problem’, CFDP 435, CFP 443, American Economic Association (February 1977), 67(1): 341-346

Nordhaus, W.D. (1994), ‘Reflections on the Concept of Sustainable Economic Growth’ CFP 951, in Luigi L. Pasinetti and Robert M. Solow (eds), Economic Growth and the Structure of Long-Term Development, St. Martin’s Press

Nordhaus, W. D. (1995), ‘How Should We Measure Sustainable Income?’, Cowles Foundation Discussion Paper CFDP 1101

Nordhaus, W.D. (2007a) ‘The Stern Review on the Economics of Climate Change’, JEL Vol 45 No 3 September, p686-702

Nordhaus, W.D. (2007b), Key Potential Improvements in Statistics and Data for Policies Concerning Global Warming: The Role of Federal Statistical Agencies, Prepared for National Research Council (U.S.) Committee on National Statistics, May 10

Pratchett, T. (2007), Making money, Corgy

Quiggin, J. (2006), Stern and the critics on discounting, University of Queensland, mimeo

Scarf, H.E. (not dated), ‘Tjalling Charles Koopmans. August 28, 1910 — February 26, 1985’, http://www.nap.edu/html/biomems/tkoopmans.html

Schuiling R.D. and P. Krijgsman (2006), ‘Enhanced weathering: An effective and cheap tool to sequester CO2’. Climatic Change 74, 349 - 354. See also the poster ftp://ftp.geog.uu.nl/pub/posters/2008/Let_the_earth_help_us_to_save_the_earth-Schuiling_June2008.pdf

Stern, N. (2006), The economics of climate change: Stern Review on the Economics of Climate Change, Cambridge

Sterner, Th. and U.M. Persson (2007), An Even Sterner Review. Introducing Relative Prices into the Discounting Debate, Discussion Paper RFF DP 07-37, July, Resources for the Future

Tinbergen, J. (1985), Production, income and welfare: The search for an optimal social order, University of Nebraska Press

Tinbergen, J. and R. Hueting (1991), ‘GNP and Market Prices: Wrong Signals for Sustainable Economic Success that Mask Environmental Destruction’, (with Jan Tinbergen). In (R. Goodland, H. Daly, S. El Serafy and B. von Droste zu Hulshoff (eds)), Environmentally Sustainable Economic Development: Building on Brundtland, Ch 4: 51-57, United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, Paris, 1991. Also published in (R. Goodland et al. (eds)), Population, Technology and Lifestyle: The Transition to Sustainability, Ch. 4: 52-62. Island Press,  The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development and UNESCO, Washington, D.C., 1992. Also published in (R. Goodland et al. (eds)), Environmentally Sustainable Economic Development: Building on Brundtland, Environment Working Paper 46, The World Bank, Washington, D.C. See also www.sni-hueting.info

Tol, R.S.J. (2006), “The Stern Review of the economics of climate change: A comment”, Hamburg, Vrije and Carnegie Mellon Universities, mimeo

Weitzman, M.L. (1976), ‘On the Welfare Significance of National Product in a Dynamic Economy’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol 90 No 1, p156-62

Weitzman, M.L. (2001), ‘A Contribution to the Theory of Welfare Accounting’, The Scandinavian Journal of Economics, Vol. 103, No. 1 (Mar., 2001), pp. 1-23

Weitzman, M.L. (2007a), ‘A Review of the Stern Review on the Economics of Climate Change’, JEL Vol 45 No 3 September, p703-724

Weitzman, M.L. (2007b), The Role of Uncertainty in the Economics of Catastrophic Climate Change, Discussion Paper, Department of Economics, Harvard University

World Commission on Environment and Development (WCED) (a.k.a. Brundtland Commission) (1987), Our common future, Oxford University Press