Is the adoption of Strategic Management Accounting techniques really “strategy-driven”? Evidence from a survey

Cinquini, Lino and Tenucci, Andrea (2007): Is the adoption of Strategic Management Accounting techniques really “strategy-driven”? Evidence from a survey.

Abstract

Several different approaches to Strategic Management Accounting (SMA) can be found in the literature of management ac counting since Simmonds (1981) coined the term. However, there is a little survey research about SMA practice, with the exception of the studies of Guilding et al. (2000) and Cravens & Guilding (2001).

The paper aims to enrich the fragmented knowledge on t he topic by a contingency research study based on an internet questionnaire survey on Italian companies. The study focuses on the characteristics at the heart of SMA techniques that may help in classifying and grouping them and on the investigation of vari ables that may influence/explain the use of SMA techniques within companies. Company size, industry and strategy (in the sub -dimensions of pattern, mission and positioning) are the variables considered in the exploration.

The findings reveal that SMA techn iques appear to be extensively used. Attribute costing, Customer accounting, Strategic Pricing and Competitive Position Monitoring represent the most widely used SMA techniques. Four features of the pattern of Strategic Management Accounting practice emerg e clearly from the factor analysis: competitor, long run, process and customer orientation. In the correlation analysis only strategic positioning is weakly found to play a contingent role in SMA technique usage, while strategic pattern, strategic mission, company size and industry variables do not provide any results. Such a finding reveal that, surprisingly, SMA techniques adoption doesn't seem to be "strategy -driven".

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Strategic Management Accounting, Strategy
• Subjects: M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M4 - Accounting and Auditing > M41 - Accounting

References

Abernethy M.A., Guthrie C.H., 1994, An empirical assessment of the “Fit” between strategy and management information systems design, Accounting and Finance, 34, pp. 9-66.

Arena M., Azzone G., 2005, ABC, Balanced Scorecard, EVA TM: an empirical study on the diffusion of innovative management accounting techniques, InternationalJournal of Accounting, Auditing and Performance evaluation , 2 (3), pp. 206-225.

Bellis-Jones R., 1989, Customer Profitability Analysis, Management Accounting, 67 (2), pp. 26-28.

Berliner C., Brimson J., 1988, Cost Management for Today's Advanced Manufacturing, Harvard Business School Press, Boston.

Bouwens J., Abernethy M.A., 2000, The consequences of customization on management accounting system design, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 25 (3), pp. 221-259.

Bromwich M., 1990, The case for strategic management accounting: the role of accounting information for strategy in competitive markets, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 15 (1/2), pp. 27-46.

Bruggeman W., Van der Stede W., 1993, Fitting management control systems to competitive advantage, British Journal of Management, Vol. 4, pp. 205-218.

Bruns Jr., W.J., Waterhouse J.H., 1975, Budgetary control and organizational structure, Journal of Accounting Research, Autumn, pp. 177-203.

Cadez S., 2006, Strategy, Market orientation, and Company performance: the mediating role of Strategic Management Accounting Systems , paper presented at the Conference “Integrating Global Organization: the role of Performa nce Measurement Systems”, July 13-14, Siena, Italy.

Carr L., Tyson T., 1992, Planning quality cost expenditures, Management Accounting, October, pp. 52-56. Chapman C.S., 1997, Reflections on a contingent view of accounting, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 22 (2), pp. 189- 205.

Chenhall R.H., 2003, Management Control System design within its organizational context: findings from contingency -based research and directions for future, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 28, pp. 123-168.

Chenhall R.H., 2005a, Integrative strategic performance management systems, strategic alignment of manufacturing, learning and strategic outcomes: an exploratory study, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 30, pp. 395-422.

Chenhall R.H., 2005b, Content and Process App roaches to Studying Strategy and Management Control Systems, in Chapman C.S. (ed.), Controlling Strategy: Management, Accounting and Performance Measurement , Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Chenhall R.H., Langfield-Smith K., 1998, The relationship between strategic priorities, management techniques and management accounting: an empirical investigation using a system approach, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 23 (3), pp. 243- 264.

Cinquini L., Collini P., Marelli A., Quagli A., Silvi R., 1999, A survey on cost accounting practices in Italian large and medium size manufacturing firms , Paper presented at the 22th Annual Congress of the European Accounting Association, Bordeaux, May, 5-7.25

Cooper R., Kaplan R.S., Maisel R.S., Morrissey E., Oehm R.M., 1992, Implementing Activity-based Cost Management – Moving From Analysis To Action , Ima, New York.

Cravens K.S., Guilding C., 2001, An empirical study of the application of Strategic Management Accounting Techniques, Advances in Management Accounting, 10, pp. 95-124.

Cross K., Lynch R., 1989, Accounting for competitive performance, Journal of Cost Management, Spring, pp. 20-28.

Dent J.F., 1990, Strategy, Organization and Control: some possibilities for accounting research, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 15 (1/2), pp. 3- 25.

Ellram L.M., Siferd S.P., 1998, Total Cost of Ownership: a key concept in Strategic Cost Management Decisions, Journal of Business Logistics, 19 (1), pp. 55-84.

Ewert R., Ernst C., 1999, Target Costing, co -ordination and Strategic Cost Management, European Accounting Review, 8 (1), pp. 23-49.

Govindarajan V., 1988, A contingency approach to strategy implementation at the business-unit level: integrating administrative mechanisms with strategy, The Academy of Management Journal, 31, pp. 828-853.

Govindarajan V., Fisher J., 1990, Strategy, control systems, and Resource sharing: Effects on Business-unit performance, The Academy of Management Journal, 33 (2), pp. 259-285.

Govindarajan V., Gupta A.K., 1985, Linking control systems to business unit strategy: impact on performance, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 10, pp. 51-56.

Guilding C., 1999, Competitor -focused accounting: an exploratory note, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 24 (7), pp. 583-595.

Guilding C., Cravens K.S., Tayles M., 2000, An international comparison of strategic management accounting practices, Management Accounting Research, 11 (1), pp.113-135.

Guilding C., McManus L., 2002, The incidence, perceived merit and antecedents of customer accounting: an exploratory no te, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 27, pp. 45-59.

Gupta A.K., Govindarajan V., 1984, Business unit strategy, Managerial characteristics, and Business unit effectiveness at strategy implementation, The Academy of Management Journal, 27 (1), pp. 25-41.

Heagy C.D. , 1991, Determining optimal quality costs by considering cost of lost sales, Journal of Cost Management, Fall, pp. 64-72.

Hoque Z., 2002, Strategic Management Accounting: Concepts, Processes and Issues , Spiro Press, London.

Jones L., 1988, Competitor cost analysis at Caterpillar, Management Accounting, October, pp. 32-38.

Kald M., Nilsson F., Rapp B., 2000, On strategy and Management Control: The importance of Classifying the strategy of the Business, British Journal of Management, Vol. 11, pp. 197-212.

Khandwalla P.N., 1972, The Effect of different types of competition on the use of Management Controls, Journal of Accounting Research, Autumn, pp. 275-285.

Kaplan R.S., Norton D.P., 1996a, Using the balanced scorecard as a strategic management system, Harvard Business Review, January-February, pp. 75–85.

Kaplan R.S., Norton D.P., 1996b, Linking the balanced scorecard to strategy, California Management Review, Fall, pp. 53-79.

Kaplan R.S., Norton D.P., 2000, The Strategy-Focused Organization, Harvard Business School Press, Boston. 26

Kittleson M.J., 1997, Determining effective follow -up of e-mail surveys, American Journal of Health Behaviour, 21(3), pp. 193-196.

Kotha S., Vadlamani B.L., 1995, Assessing generic strategies: an empirical investigation of two competing typologies in discrete manufacturing industries, Strategic Management Journal, Vol. 16, pp. 75-83.

Langfield-Smith K., 1997, Management Control Systems and Strategy: A Critical Review, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 22 (2), pp. 207-232.

Langfield-Smith K., 2005, What do we know about Management Control Systems and Strategy?, in Chapman C.S. (ed.), Controlling Strategy: Management, Accounting and Performance Measurement , Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Lord B., 1996, Strategic Management Accounting: the emperor's new clothes, Management Accounting Research, 7 (3), pag.347-366.

Malina N.A., Selto F.H., 2001, Communicating and controlling strategy: an empirical study of the effectiveness of the Balanced Scorecard, Journal of Management Accounting Research, Vol. 13, pp. 47-90.

McNair C.J., Leibfried K., 1992, Benchmarking: A Tool for Continuous Improvement, Omneo, Texas.

Merchant K., 1981, The design of the corporate budgeting system: influences on managerial behaviour and performance, The Accounting Review, October, pp. 813-829.

Miles R.E., Snow C.G., 1978, Organizational strategy, structure, and process, McGraw-Hill, New York.

Miller A., Dess G.G., 1993, Assessing Porter's (1980) Model in terms of its generalizability, accuracy and simpl icity, Journal of Management Studies , 30 (4), pp. 553-585.

Miller D., Friesen P.H., 1982, Innovation in conservative and entrepreneurial firms: two models of strategic momentum, Strategic Management Journal, 3, pp. 1- 25.

Miller G., De Meyer A., Nakane J. , 1992, Benchmarking Global Manufacturing, Business One Irwin, Illinois.

Monden Y., Hamada K., 1991, Target Costing and Kaizen Costing in Japanese Automobile Companies, Journal of Management Accounting Research, Fall, pp.16-34.

Moon P., Bates K., 1993, Core analysis in strategic performance appraisal, Management Accounting Research, 4 (4), pp.139-152.

Morgan M.J., 1993, Accounting for strategy, Management Accounting , May, pp.20-24.

Nanni A.J., Dixon J.R., Vollman T.E., 1992, Integrated performance measurement:Management accounting to support the new manufacturing realities, Journal of Management Accounting Research, Fall, pp. 1-19.

Narver J.C., Slater S.F. , 1990, The effect of a market orientation on business profitability, Journal of Marketing, October, pp. 20-35.

Palmer R.J., 1992, Strategic goals and the design of strategic management accounting systems, Advances in Management Accounting , 1, pp. 179-204.

Porter M., 1980, Competitive Strategy, Free Press, New York. Porter M., 1985, Competitive Advantage, Free Press, New York.

Roslender R., Hart S.J., 2002, Integrating Management Accounting and Marketing in the pursuit of competitive advantage: the case for Strategic Management Accounting, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 13, pp. 255-277.

Roslender R., Hart S.J., 2003, In search of strategic management accounting: theoretical and field study perspectives, Management Accounting Research, 14 (3), pp. 255-279.

Shank J.K., Govindarajan V., 1989, Strategic Cost Analysis: the evolution from managerial to strategic accounting, Homewood, Richard Irwin Inc.

Shank J.K., Govindarajan V., 1992a, Strategic Cost Management: Tailoring Controls to Strategies, Journal of Cost Management, Fall, pp. 14-24.

Shank J.K., Govindarajan V., 1992b, Strategic Cost Management: The Value Chain perspective, Journal of Management Accounting Research, Fall, pp. 179-198.

Shank J.K., Govindarajan V., 1993a, What "drives" cost? A strategic cost management perspective, Advances in Management Accounting, 2, pp. 27-46.

Shank J.K., Govindarajan V., 1993b, Strategic Cost Management: The new tool for competitive advantage, Free Press, New York.

Sharma S., 1996, Applied Multivariate Techniques, Wiley and sons Inc., New York.

Shields M.D., Young S.N., 1991, Managing product life cycle costs: an or ganizational model, Journal of Cost Management, 5 (3), pp.39-52.

Shortell S.M, Zajack E.J., 1990, Perceptual and Archival Measures of Miles and Snow's Strategic Types: A Comprehensive Assessment of Reliability and Validity, The Academy of Management Journal, 3 (4), pp. 817- 832.

Simmonds K., 1981, Strategic Management Accounting, Management Accounting (UK), April, pp.26-29.

Simmonds K., 1982, Strategic Management Accounting for Pricing: A Case Example, Accounting and Business Research, 12 (47), pp. 206-214.

Simmonds K., 1986, The Accounting Assessment of Competitive Position, European Journal of Marketing, 20 (1), pp. 16-32.

Simons R., 1987, Accounting control systems and business strategy: an empirical analysis, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 12 (4), pp. 357-374.

Simons R., 1990, The role of management control systems in creating competitive advantage: new perspectives, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 15 (1/2), pp. 127-143.

Simpson J.B., Muthler D.L. , 1987, Quality costs: facilitating the qu ality initiative, Journal of Cost Management, Spring, pp. 25-34.

Tomkins C., Carr C., 1996, Reflections on the papers in this issue and a commentary on the state of strategic management accounting, Management Accounting Research, 7 (2), pp. 271-280.

Ward K., 1992, Strategic Management Accounting, Butterworth-Heineman, Oxford. Weick K., 1979, The social psychology of organizing , Josey Bass, San Francisco.

Wilson R.M.S., 1991, Strategic management accounting, in Issues in Management Accounting, Ashton D.J., Hopper T.M., and Scapens R.W., editors. Prentice -Hall, London.