Incentive Effects of Retirement Income Transfers

Piggot, John and Robalino, David and Jimenez-Martin, Sergi (2008): Incentive Effects of Retirement Income Transfers.

Abstract

The paper explores the incentive effects of retirement income transfers – essentially, non-contributory cash transfers aimed at reducing poverty among the elderly. A literature review reveals how little academic analysis of the impact of these transfers has been completed. We begin with a taxonomy of retirement income transfers, differentiating between ex-ante and ex-post interventions and universal and targeted arrangements. This distinction allows important differences across designs to be highlighted. We then provide a simple framework for thinking about what the incentive impacts of the transfers might be, distinguishing between effects related to the transfer itself and those related to the financing mechanism. Thus, from theory and available empirical evidence we derive a few policy relevant findings. First, incentive effects will depend on the level of the transfer relative to average earnings and the degree of integration between the formal and informal sectors in the economy. In general, for modest transfers, negative impacts on savings and labor supply would be contained. Second, we highlight the tradeoff between maintaining low effective marginal tax rates (EMTRs) to reduce distortions and keeping the program costs at affordable levels. This tradeoff suggests that universal programs are suboptimal. Third, in terms of design features, we emphasize the importance of implementing a gradual withdrawal of the benefit to avoid crowding-out contributory pensions among low income individuals and of indexing the eligibility age with life expectancy to contain costs. Finally we find that matching contributions can be a promising instrument to promote savings among individuals with limited savings capacity.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Social pensions, Pension coverage, Retirement Insurance, matching contributions
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E6 - Macroeconomic Policy, Macroeconomic Aspects of Public Finance, and General Outlook > E62 - Fiscal Policy; H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H55 - Social Security and Public Pensions; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J4 - Particular Labor Markets > J41 - Labor Contracts

References

Ardington, C., Case A. and Hosegood V. (2007), “Labor Supply Responses to Large Social Transfers: Longitudinal Evidence from South Africa”, Working Paper 13442, NBER, Cambridge

Atkinson T., Bourguignon F, O’Donoghue C., Sutherland H. and Utili F. (2002), “Microsimulation of Social Policy in the European Union: Case Study of a European Minimum Pension”, Economica, New Series, 69, 274, May, 229-243

Berstein, Solange; Larrain, Guillermo and Pino, Ariel (2006), "Chilean Pension Reform: Coverage Facts and Policy Alternatives", Economia 6(2), 227-279

Bertrand, Marianne, Sendhil Mullainathan and Douglas Miller. 2003. “Public Policy and Extended Families: Evidence from Pensions in South Africa.” The World Bank Economic Review 17(1): 27-50.

Blondäl, S. and S. Scarpetta (1998), “The retirement decision in OECD countries”, OECD Economics Department, WP 20.

Boldrin M, Jiménez-Martín M, Peracchi F. 2004. Micromodeling of social security and retirement in Spain. In Social Security and Retirement around the world: micro-estimation, Jonathan Gruber and David Wise (eds). University of Chicago Press for the NBER: Chicago.

Bosh Mariano and William Maloney. 2007. “Comparative Analysis of Labor Market Dynamics Using Markov Processes: An Application to Informality.” IZA Discussion Paper Series. IZA DP No. 3038.

Carvalho, Irineu E. 2002: "Old-Age Benefits and Retirement Decisions of Rural Elderly in Brazil" mimeo, Department of Economics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, November 15, 2002.

Case, Anne and Angus Deaton. 1998. “Large Cash Transfers to the Elderly in SouthAfrica.” Economic Journal 108(450): 1330-1261.

Creedy, John and Guyonne Kalb (2006), Labour Supply and Microsimulation: The Evaluation of Tax Policy Reforms, Edward Elgar.

Blinder, Alan and Harvey Rosen (1985), “Notches”, American Economic Review, 75, 4, September, 736-47

Gruber J, Wise D (eds). 1999. Social Security and Retirement around the World. University of Chicago Press: Chicago.

Jiménez-Martin S., and Sánchez-Martín AR. (2006), “An Evaluation of the Life-cycle effects of minimum pension on retirement behavior: Extended version”, Forthcoming in Journal of Applied Econometrics.

Jiménez-Martín S, Sánchez-Martín AR. (2007). “An evaluation of the life-cycle effects of minimum pensions on retirement behaviour”, Journal of Applied Econometrics, 22, 923-950.

Mirrlees, J. (1971) “An exploration in the theory of optimum income taxation”, Review of Economic Studies, 38, 175-208.

Moffitt, Robert. 1992. “Incentive Effects of the U.S. Welfare System: A Review,”Journal of Economic Literature 30(1): 1-61.

Piggott, John and John Whalley (2001), “VAT Base Broadening, the Informal Sector, and Self Supply”, American Economic Review, 91, 4, 1084-1094, September.

Neumark D., and Powers E., 2000, “Welfare for the elderly: the effects of SSI on pre-retirement labor supply”, Journal Public Economics 78, 51-80

Posel, Dorrit, James A. Fairburn and Frances Lund. 2006. “Labour Migration and Households: A Reconsideration of the Effects of the Social Pension on Labour Supply in South Africa.” Economic Modelling 23: 836-853.

Poblete, Dante (2005) “Grado de Focalización Óptimo de las Pensiones No Contributivas en el Tercer Mundo”, Tesis de Economía, Instituto de Economía PUC, 1er semestre.

Robalino David. 2008. “Labor Markets In Latin America: Structure, Dynamics and Implications for the Design of Social Protection Policies. Draft Manuscript. World Bank. Washington DC.

Robalino David, Eduardo Zylberstajn, Helio Zylberstajn, and Luis Eduardo Afonso. 2008a. “An Ex-Ante Evaluation of the Impact of Social Insurance Policies on Labor Supply in Brazil: The Case for Explicit over Implicit Redistribution.” Forthcoming. Social Protection Discussion Papers. World Bank. Washington DC.

Robalino David, Gudivada Venkateswara Rao and Oleksiy Sluchinsky. 2008b. Preventing Poverty Among the Elderly in MENA Countries: Role and Optimal Design of Old-Age Subsides. Forthcoming in Pensions Primer Series. World Bank. Washington DC.

Rofman Rafael, Eduardo Fajnzylber and German Herrera. 2008. “Reforming the pension reforms: The recent initiatives and actions on pensions in Argentina and Chile.” Primer Pensions Series. World Bank. Washington DC.

Rust J, Phelan C. 1997. How social security and medicare affect retirement behavior in a world of incomplete markets. Econometrica 65: 781-831.

Samwick A. 1998. New evidence on pensions, social security and the timing of retirement. Journal of Public Economics 70: 207-236.

Sane, Renuka and John Piggott, 2008. “Does the Owner-Occupier Exemption from the Pensions Means Test Affect Housing Choice of the Elderly? Evidence from Australia” SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1276854

Sefton, James, Justin van de Ven and Martin Weale (2008), “Means Testing Retirement Benefits: Fostering Equity or Discouraging Savings”, Economic Journal, 118, April, 556-590.

Valdez Prieto Salvador. 2007. “Pensión Solidaria: evaluación económica y política.” Unpublished Manuscript. Santiago de Chile.

Whitehouse, Edward (2005), Pensions at a Glance, OECD, Paris.

Willmore Larry, 2007, “Universal Pension for Developing Countries”, World Development, 35, 1, 24-51.

World Bank 2006. “Egypt: Improving The Welfare Of Future Generations Through Pension Reform.” Report. Middle East and North Africa Region. Human Development Department. World Bank. Washington DC.

World Bank. 2008. “Brazil: Social Insurance And Labor Supply: Assessing Incentives And Redistribution”. Draft Technical Report. World Bank. Washington DC.