Immigration, Ethics and the Capabilities Approach

Risse, Mathias (2009): Immigration, Ethics and the Capabilities Approach. Published in: Human Development Research Paper (HDRP) Series , Vol. 34, No. 2009

Abstract

Often, immigration debates are conducted under the presumption that immigration policies must be justifiable only to those who already live in the respective country. Alas, reflection on the justifiability of immigration policies to those excluded becomes ever more important in a politically and economically increasingly interconnected world. This study explores two approaches to the normative reflection on immigration at some depth, namely, the idea that restrictive immigration policies are problematic because they are hampering the development of human capabilities, as well as the idea that such policies are problematic because they are at odds with the fact that our planet belongs to humanity collectively. On both of these proposals, less restrictive immigration policies are not merely demanded as one possible way of aiding the poor, but would be required as such. Both of these approaches can be treated within the same framework, the grounds-of-justice framework, which allows us to focus on the idea that states must also be justified to those who do not belong to them. Central to the proposal about immigration that can be made within this approach are ideas of over- and under-use of commonly owned resources and spaces.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Immigration, justice, capabilities, common ownership of the earth, resources
• Subjects: O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O15 - Human Resources ; Human Development ; Income Distribution ; Migration

References

Abizadeh, Arash. 2008. “Democratic Theory and Border Coercion: No Right to Unilaterally Control Your Own Borders.” Political Theory 36 (1): pp 37-65

Abraham, Katharine, and Christopher Mackie. 2005. Beyond the Market: Designing Nonmarket Accounts for the United States. Washington, D. C.: The National Academy Press

Alkire, Sabina. 2002. Valuing Freedoms. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Alkire. Sabina. 2006. “Needs and Capabilities.” In Reader (2006): pp 229-51

Anderson, James, and Eric van Wincoop. 2004. “Trade Costs.” Journal of Economic Literature 42(3): pp 691-751

Attfield, Robin. 2003. Environmental Ethics. An Overview for the Twenty-First Century. Oxford: Polity

Auty, Richard (ed.). 2001. Resource Abundance and Economic Development. Oxford: Oxford University Press: pp. 3–16

Barry, Brian. 1982. “Humanity and Justice in Global Perspective.” In J. R. Pennock and J. W. Chapman, Ethics, Economics, and the Law. Nomos XXIV. New York: New York University Press, pp 219-252

Barry, Brian, and Robert Goodin (eds.). 1992. Free Movement: Ethical Issues in the Transnational Migration of People and of Money. University Park: The Pennsylvania State University Press

Beck, Roy. 1996. The Case Against Immigration. New York: Norton

Becker, Lawrence. 1977. Property Rights: Philosophical Foundations. Boston: Routledge and Kegan Paul

Beitz, Charles. 1999. Political Theory and International Relations (revised edition), Princeton: Princeton University Press

Birdsall, Nancy, Dani Rodrik, and Arvind Subramanian. 2005. “How to Help Poor Countries.” Foreign Affairs 84 (4): pp. 136–152.

Blake, Michael. 2002. “Discretionary Immigration.” Philosophical Topics 30 (2): pp 273- 291

Blake, Michael. 2001a. “Immigration,” in R. G. Frey and Christopher Wellman (eds.), A Companion to Applied Ethics. London: Blackwell

Blake, Michael. 2001b. “Distributive Justice, State Coercion, and Autonomy”,. Philosophy and Public Affairs, 30 (2001), 257-96

Blake, Michael, and Mathias Risse. Forthcoming. “Immigration and Original Ownership of the Earth,” forthcoming in the Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics, and Public Policy Vol. 23 (special issue on immigration)

Blake, Michael, and Mathias Risse. 2007. “Migration, Territoriality, and Culture,” in New Waves in Applied Ethics, ed. Jesper Ryberg, Thomas Petersen, and Clark Wolf, Ashgate Publishers: pp 153-182

Borjas, George. 2001. Heaven’s Door. Immigration Policy and the American Economy. Princeton: Princeton University Press

Boswell, Christina. 2008. “The Elusive Rights of an Invisible Population.” Ethics and International Affairs 22 (2): pp 187-192

Braybrooke, David. 1987. Meeting Needs. Princeton: Princeton University Press

Brock, Gillian (ed.). 1998a. Necessary Goods: Our Responsibilities to Meet Others’ Needs. New York: Rowman and Littlefield

Brock, Gillian. 1998b. Introduction to Brock (1998a)

Brimelow, Peter. 1995. Alien Nation. Common Sense About America’s Immigration Disaster. New York: Random House

Buck, Susan. (1998). The Global Commons. An Introduction. Washington D.C.: Island Press

Caney, Simon. 2005. Justice Beyond Borders. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Carens, Joseph. 2008. “The Rights of Irregular Migrants.” Ethics and International Affairs 22 (2): pp 162-186

Carens, Joseph. 2003. “Who Should Get In? The Ethics of Immigration Decisions,” Ethics and International Affairs, v. 17, pp 95-110

Carens, Joseph. 1992. “Migration and Morality: A Liberal-Egalitarian Perspective.” In Barry and Goodin (1992) Carens, Joseph. 1989. “Membership and Morality: Admission to Citizenship in Liberal Democratic States.” In William Brubaker (ed.), Immigration and the Politics of Citizenship in Europe and North America. New York: University Press of America, pp 31-51

Carens, Joseph. 1987. “Aliens and Citizens: The Case for Open Borders,” Review of Politics 49, pp 251-73

Cavallero, Eric. 2006. “An Immigration-Pressure Model of Global Distributive Justice.” Politics, Philosophy, and Economics 5(1): pp 97-127

Clemens, Michael, Claudio Montenegro, and Lant Pritchett. 2008. “The Place Premium: Wage Differences for Identical Workers Across the US Border.” Center for Global Development, Working Paper 148, to be found at http://www.cgdev.org/content/publications/detail/16352

Cohen. G. A. 1993. “Equality of What? On Welfare, Goods, and Capabilities.” In Nussbaum and Sen (1993): pp 9-29

Cohen, Joshua. 1995. Review of Inequality Re-examined. Journal of Philosophy 95 (5): pp 275-88

Cohen, Joshua, and Charles Sabel. 2006. “Extra Rempublicam, Nulla Justitia?” Philosophy and Public Affairs 34 (2): pp 147-175

Collier, Paul, and Anke Hoeffler, 2005. “Coup Traps: Why Does Africa Have So Many Coups d'Etat?” Centre for the Study of African Economies

Collier, Paul, and Anke Hoeffler. 1998. “On Economic Causes of Civil War,” Oxford Economic Papers 50: pp 563–73

Comim, Falvio, Mozaffar Qizilbash, and Sabina Alkire (eds.), The Capabilities Approach: Concepts, Measures, and Applications. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Cooper, Richard. 1994. Environment and Resource Policies for the World Economy. Washington D. C.: Brookings

Daniels, Norman. 1985. Just Health Care. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Danto, Arthur. 1984. “Constructing an Epistemology of Human Rights: A Pseudo- Problem?” In E F Paul, J. Paul, F D. Miller (eds.), Human Rights. Oxford: Blackwell

Dowding. Keith. 2006. “Can Capabilities Reconcile Freedom and Equality?” Journal of Political Philosophy 14 (3): pp 323-336

Doyal, Len, and Ian Gough. 1991. A Theory of Human Need. London: Macmillan

Dummett, Michael. 2001. On Immigration and Refugees. New York: Routledge

Dummett, Michael. 2004. “Immigration.” Res Publica 10 (2): pp 115-122

Edmundson, William. 2004. An Introduction to Rights. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Finnis, John. 1980. Natural Law and Natural Rights. Oxford: Clarendon

Freeman, Samuel. 2007b. Justice and the Social Contract. Essays on Rawlsian Political Philosophy. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Gewirth, Alan. 1984. “The Epistemology of Human Rights” In E F Paul, J. Paul, F D. Miller (eds.), Human Rights. Oxford: Blackwell

Gewirth, Alan. 1978. Reason and Morality. Chicago: University of Chicago Press

Goodin, Robert. 1985. Protecting the Vulnerable. A Reanalysis of Our Social Responsibilities. Chicago: University of Chicago Press

Hampton, Jean. 1995. “Immigration, Identity, and Justice.” In Warren Schwartz (ed.), Justice in Immigration. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp 67-94

Haq, Mahbub ul. 1995. Reflections on Human Development. Delhi: Oxford University Press

Hart, H. L. A. 1982. Essay on Bentham. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Hayter, Teresa. 2000. Open Borders: The Case Against Immigration Controls. London: Pluto Press

Hing, Bill Ong. 2002. “Answering Challenges of the New Immigrant-Driven Diversity: Considering Integration Strategies,” 40 Brandeis L. J. (Summer 2002)

Honore, A. M. 1961. “Ownership.” In Making Law Bind: Essays Legal and Philosophical. Oxford: Clarendon

Hospers, John. 1971. Libertarianism. Nash Publishing: Los Angles

Humphreys, Macartan, Jeffrey Sachs and Joseph Stiglitz (eds.) 2007. Escaping the Resource Curse. New York: Columbia University Press

Huntington, Samuel. 2004. Who are We? The Challenges to America’s National Identity. New York: Simon and Schuster

Jaggar, Alison. 2006. “Reasoning about Well-Being: Nussbaum’s Methods of Justifying the Capabilities.” Journal of Political Philosophy 14 (3): pp 301-322

Jones, Peter. 1994. Rights. London: Macmillan

Kukathas, Chandran. 2005. “The Case for Open Immigration.” In Andrew Cohen (ed.), Contemporary Debates in Applied Ethics. Oxford Blackwell

Kurjanska, Malgorzata, and Mathias Risse. 2008. “Fairness in Trade II: Export Subsidies and the Fair Trade Movement.” Politics, Philosophy, and Economics 7 (1): pp 29-56

Le Billon, Philippe. 2001. “The Political Ecology of War: Natural Resources and Armed Conflicts,” Political Geography 20: pp 561–84

Lederman, Daniel, and William Maloney (eds.). 2006. Natural Resources: Neither Curse nor Destiny. Washington DC: World Bank

Malanczuk, Peter. 1997. Akehurst’s Modern Introduction to International Law. Seventh Edition. London: Routledge

Miller, David. 2007. National Responsibility and Global Justice. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Miller, David. 2005. “Immigration: The Case for Limits.” In Andrew Cohen (ed.), Contemporary Debates in Applied Ethics. Malden: Blackwell

Miller, David. 1999. Principles of Social Justice. Cambridge: Harvard University Press

Millman, Joel. 1997. The Other Americans. How Immigrants Renew Our Country, Our Economy, and Our Values. New York: Viking

Nagel, Thomas. 2005. “The Problem of Global Justice,” Philosophy and Public Affairs 33: pp 113-47

Nett, Roger. 1971. “The Civil Right We are Not Ready for: the Right of Free Movement of People on the Face of the Earth.” Ethics 81, pp 212-227

Nordhaus, William and Edward Kokkelenberg (eds.). 1999. Nature’s Numbers. Expanding the National Economic Accounts to Include the Environment. Washington D.C.: National Academy Press

Nussbaum, Martha. 2006. Frontiers of Justice: Disability, Nationality, Species Membership. Cambridge: Harvard University Press

Nussbaum, Martha. 2000. Women and Human Development: The Capabilities Approach (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Nussbaum, Martha. 1993. “Non-Relative Virtue: An Aristotelian Approach.” In Nussbaum and Sen (1993): pp 242-269

Nussbaum, Martha. 1988. “Nature, Function, and Capability: Aristotle on Political Distribution.” Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy (Supplementary Volume): 145-184

Nussbaum, Martha, and Amartya Sen (eds.) 1993. The Quality of Life. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Okin, Susan Moller. 2003. “Poverty, Well-Being, and Gender: What Counts, Who’s Heard?” Philosophy and Public Affairs 31 (3): pp 280-316

O’Neill, Onora. 1985. “Rights, Obligations, and Needs.” Logos 6: pp 29-47 (reprinted in Brock (1998a)

Passmore, John. 1974. Man’s Responsibility for Nature. Ecological Problems and Western Traditions. London: Duckworth

Pogge, Thomas. 2002. World Poverty and Human Rights. Cambridge: Blackwell

Pogge, Thomas, 1989. Realizing Rawls. Ithaca: Cornell University Press

Rawls, John. 1999a. The Law of Peoples. Cambridge: Harvard University Press

Rawls, John. 1999b (2nd edition). A Theory of Justice. Cambridge: Harvard University Press

Rawls, John. 1993. “The Basic Structure as Subject.” In Political Liberalism. New York: Columbia University Press, pp 257-289

Reader, Soran. 2007. Needs and Moral Necessity. London: Routledge

Reader, Soran. 2006a. “Does a Basic Needs Approach Need Capabilities?” Journal of Political Philosophy 14 (3): pp 337-350

Reader, Soran (eds.) 2006b. The Philosophy of Need. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Reeve, Andrew. 1986. Property. Atlantic Highlands: Humanities Press

Risse, Mathias. Forthcoming/a. “Who Should Shoulder the Burden? Climate Change and Common Ownership of the Earth.” Kennedy School of Government Working Paper RWP08-075

Risse, Mathias. Forthcoming/b. “Original Ownership of the Earth: A Contemporary Approach.” Kennedy School of Government Working Paper RWP08-073

Risse, Mathias. 2009. “Common Ownership of the Earth as a Non-Parochial Standpoint: A Contingent Derivation of Human Rights,” forthcoming in European Journal of Philosophy

Risse, Mathias. 2008a. “On the Morality of Immigration,” Ethics and International Affairs 22 (1): pp 25-33

Risse, Mathias. 2008b. “’Imagine There’s No Countries: A Reply to John Lennon.” Kennedy School of Government Working Paper RWP08-020

Risse, Mathias. 2007a. “Fairness in Trade I: Obligations from Trading and the Pauper Labor Argument.” Politics, Philosophy, and Economics 6 (3): pp 355-377

Risse, Mathias. 2007b. “The Grounds of Justice.” Kennedy School of Government Working Paper RWP07-048

Risse, Mathias. 2006. “What to Say about the State.” Social Theory and Practice, Vol, 32 (4): pp 671-698

Risse, Mathias. 2005a. “What We Owe to the Global Poor,” The Journal of Ethics, Vol. 9, No. 1-2, pp 81-117

Risse, Mathias. 2005b. “How Does the Global Order Harm the Poor?,” Philosophy and Public Affairs, Vol. 33, No. 4, pp 349-376

Risse, Mathias. 2005c. “Do We Owe the Poor Assistance or Rectification?,” Ethics and International Affairs, Vol. 19, No. 1: pp 9-18

Rodriguez, Francisco, and Jeffrey Sachs. 1999. “Why Do Resource-Abundant Economies Grow More Slowly?” Journal of Economic Growth 4 (3): pp 277-303

Rorty, Richard. 1993. “Sentimentality, Rationality, and Sentimentality”, in S. Shute and S. Hurley (eds.) On Human Rights (New York: Basic Books

Rorty, Richard. 1990. "The Priority of Democracy to Philosophy," Objectivity, Relativism, and Truth: Philosophical Papers, Volume 1. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Rorty, Richard. 1985. “Solidarity or Objectivity?”, in John Rajchman and Cornel West (eds.), Post-Analytic Philosophy. New York: Columbia University Press

Ross, Michael. 2003. “The Natural Resource Curse: How Wealth Can Make You Poor.” In I. Bannon and P. Collier (eds.), Natural Resources and Violent Conflict: Options and Actions. Washington, DC: World Bank, pp. 1–37

Ross, Michael. 2001. “Does Oil Hinder Democracy?” World Politics 53.(3): pp 325–61

Rosser, Andrew. 2006. “The Political Economy of the Resource Curse: A Literature Survey,” IDS Working Paper 268

Rothbard, Murray. 1996. For a New Liberty. The Libertarian Manifesto. San Francisco: Fox and Wilkes

Ruggie, John. 1998. “Territoriality and Millennium’s End.” In Ruggie, Constructing the World Polity. Essays on International Institutionalization. New York: Taylor and Francis

Ryan, Alan. 1987. Property. Milton Keynes: Open University Press

Saches, Jeffrey, and Andrew Warner. 2001. “The Curse of Natural Resources.” European Economic Review 45: pp 827–38

Sangiovanni, Andrea. 2007. “Global Justice, Reciprocity, and the State.” Philosophy and Public Affairs 35 (1): pp 3-39

Sassen, Saskia. 2008. Territory, Authority, rights: From Medieval to Global Assemblages. Princeton: Princeton University Press

Sen, Amartya. 2005. “Capabilities, Lists, and Public Reason: Continuing the Conversation.” Feminist Economics 10: pp 77-80

Sen, Amartya. 2004. “Human Rights and Capabilities.” Journal of Human Development 6: pp 157-160

Sen, Amartya. 1999. Development as Freedom. New York: Random House

Sen, Amartya. 1997. Resources, Values, and Development. Cambridge: Harvard University Press

Sen, Amartya. 1993. “Capability and Well-Being.” In Nussaum and Sen (1993): pp 30-53

Sen, Amartya. 1992. Inequality Re-examined. New York: Russell Sage

Sen, Amartya. 1987. “The Standard of Living.” Tanner Lectures on Human Values, ed. by Geoffrey Hawthorne. Cambridge: Cambridge University Presss

Sen, Amartya. 1983. Poverty and Famines: An Essay on Entitlement and Deprivation. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Sen, Amartya. 1985. Commodities and Capabilities. Amsterdam: North Holland

Sen, Amartya. 1980. “Equality of What?” In S. McMurrin (ed.), Tanner Lectures on Human Values. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Singer, Peter. 1972. “Famine, Affluence, and Morality,” Philosophy and Public Affairs 1: pp 229-243

Steiner, Hillel. 1992. “Libertarianism and the Transnational Migration of People.” In Brian Barry and Robert Goodin (1982), Free Movement: Ethics Issues in the Transnational Migration of People and Money.” Hemel Hempstead, UK: Harvester Wheatsheaf

Stewart, Frances. 1985. Basic Needs in Developing Countries. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press

Streeten, Paul (with S. J. Burki, M. ul Haq, N. Hicks, and F. Stewart). 1981. First Things First: Meeting Basic Human Needs in Developing Countries. Oxford: Oxford University Press

for the World Bank Thomson, Garrett. 1987. Needs. London: Routledge

Tushnet, Mark. 1995. “Immigration policy and Liberal Political Theory.” In Warren Schwartz (ed.), Justice in Immigration. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Vallentyne, Peter, and Hillel Steiner (2000a). Left-Libertarianism and Its Critics: The Contemporary Debate. London: McMillan

Vallentyne, Peter., and Hillel Steiner (2000b). The Origins of Left-Libertarianism: An Anthology of Historical Writings. London: McMillan

Walzer, Michael. 1983. Spheres of Justice. New York: Basic Books

Wellman, Christopher. 2008. “Immigration and Freedom of Association.” Ethics 119: pp 109-141

Wenar, Leif. 2008. “Property Rights and the Resource Curse.” Philosophy and Public Affairs 36 (1): pp. 2-32

Wenar. Leif. 2005. “The Nature of Rights.” Philosophy and Public Affairs (33): pp 223- 253

White, Stuart. 1997. “Freedom of Association and the Right to Exclude.” Journal of Political Philosophy 5 (4): pp 373-391

Wiggins, David. 1987. “Claims of Need.” In Wiggins, Needs, Values, Truth. Oxford: Oxford University Press: pp 1-57