Kraaijenbrink, Jeroen and Spender, JC and Groen, Aard (2009): The resource-based view: A review and assessment of its critiques. Published in: Journal of Management , Vol. 36, No. 1 (2010): pp. 349-372.
Download (287kB) | Preview
The resource-based view (RBV) of the firm has been around for over twenty years - during which time it has been both widely taken up and subjected to considerable criticism. The authors review and assess the principal critiques evident in the literature, arguing they fall into eight categories. They conclude the RBV’s core message can withstand criticism from five of these quite well provided the RBV’s variables, boundaries and applicability are adequately specified. Three critiques that cannot be readily dismissed call for further theorizing and research. They arise from the indeterminate nature of two of the RBV's basic concepts – resource and value – and the narrow conceptualization of a firm's competitive advantage. The authors feel the RBV community has clung to an inappropriately narrow neo-classical economic rationality, thereby diminishing its opportunities for progress. Their suggestions may assist with developing the RBV into a more viable theory of competitive advantage, especially if it is moved into a genuinely dynamic framework.
|Item Type:||MPRA Paper|
|Original Title:||The resource-based view: A review and assessment of its critiques|
|Keywords:||resource-based view; sustained competitive advantage; Austrian economics|
|Subjects:||B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925 > B21 - Microeconomics
D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations > D20 - General
B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B5 - Current Heterodox Approaches > B53 - Austrian
|Depositing User:||JC Spender|
|Date Deposited:||18. Mar 2010 23:50|
|Last Modified:||11. Feb 2013 17:23|
Acedo, F. J., Barroso, C., & Galan, J. L. 2006. The Resource-Based Theory: Dissemination and Main Trends. Strategic Management Journal, 27: 621-636.
Alchian, A. A. 1977. Some Economics of Property Rights. In A. A. Alchian (Ed.), Economic Forces at Work: 127-149. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund.
Alchian, A. A., & Demsetz, H. 1973. The Property Rights Paradigm. The Journal of Economic History, 33(1): 16-27.
Alvarez, S. A., & Busenitz, L. W. 2001. The Entrepreneurship of Resource-Based Theory. Journal of Management, 27: 755-775.
Amit, R., & Schoemaker, P. J. H. 1993. Strategic Assets and Organizational Rent. Strategic Management Journal, 14: 33-46.
Anderson, J. C., & Narus, J. A. 1998. Business Marketing: Understand What Customers Value. Harvard Business Review, November-December: 53-65.
Anderson, J. C., & Narus, J. A. 1999. Business Market Management, Understanding, Creating and Delivering Value. New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
Argyris, C., & Schön, D. A. 1978. Organizational Learning: A Theory of Action Perspective: Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
Armstrong, C. E., & Shimizu, K. 2007. A Review of Approaches to Empirical Research on the Resource-Based View of the Firm. Journal of Management, 33: 959-986.
Bain, J. S. 1968. Industrial Organization. New York: John Wiley.
Baker, T., & Nelson, R. E. 2005. Creating Something from Nothing: Resource Construction through Entrepreneurial Bricolage. Administrative Science Quarterly, 50: 329-366.
Barney, J. B. 1986a. Organizational Culture: Can It Be a Source of Sustained Competitive Advantage? Academy of Management Review, 11: 656-665.
Barney, J. B. 1986b. Strategic Factor Markets: Expectations, Luck, and Business Strategy. Management Science, 32: 1231-1241.
Barney, J. B. 1991a. Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage. Journal of Management, 17: 99-120.
Barney, J. B. 1991b. Special Theory Forum: The Resource-Based Model of the Firm: Origins, Implications, and Prospects. Journal of Management, 17: 97-98.
Barney, J. B. 1994. Bringing Managers Back In: A Resource-Based Analysis of the Role of Managers in Creating and Sustaining Competitive Advantages for Firms, Does management matter? On competencies and competitive advantage. The 1994 Crafoord lectures: 1-36. Lund, Sweden: Institute of Economic Research, Lund University.
Barney, J. B. 1996. The Resource-Based Theory of the Firm. Organization Science, 7: 469.
Barney, J. B. 1999. How a Firm's Capabilities Affect Boundary Decisions. Sloan Management Review, 40: 137-145.
Barney, J. B. 2001. Is the Resource-Based "View" a Useful Perspective for Strategic Management Research? Yes. Academy of Management Review, 26: 41-56.
Barney, J. B. 2002. Gaining and Sustaining Competitive Advantage: Prentice Hall.
Barney, J. B. 2005. Where Does Inequality Come From? The Personal and Intellectual Roots of Resource-Based Theory. In K. G. Smith, & M. A. Hitt (Eds.), Great Minds in Management: The Process of Theory Development: 280-303. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Barney, J. B., & Clark, D. N. 2007. Resource-Based Theory: Creating and Sustaining Competitive Advantage. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Barney, J. B., & Hansen, M. H. 1994. Trustworthiness as a Source of Competitive Advantage. Strategic Management Journal, 15: 175-190.
Barney, J. B., Wright, M., & Ketchen Jr., D. J. 2001. The Resource-Based View of the Firm: Ten Years After 1991. Journal of Management, 27: 625-641.
Becerra, M. 2008. A Resource-Based Analysis of the Conditions for the Emergence of Profits. Journal of Management, 34: 1110-1126.
Bowman, C., & Ambrosini, V. 2000. Value Creation Versus Value Capture: Towards a Coherent Definition of Value in Strategy. British Journal of Management, 11: 1-15.
Bowman, C., & Swart, J. 2007. Whose Human Capital? The Challenge of Value Capture When Capital is Embedded. Journal of Management Studies, 44: 488-505.
Bromiley, P., & James-Wade, S. 2003. Putting Rational Blinders Behind Us: Behavioural Understandings of Finance and Strategic Management. Long Range Planning, 36: 37-48.
Bromiley, P., & Papenhausen, C. 2003. Assumptions of Rationality and Equilibrium in Strategy Research: The Limits of Traditional Economic Analysis Strategic Organization, 1: 413-437.
Castanias, R. P., & Helfat, C. E. 1991. Managerial Resources and Rents. Journal of Management, 17: 155-171.
Chadwick, C., & Dabu, A. 2009. Human Resources, Human Resource Management, and the Competitive Advantage of Firms: Toward a More Comprehensive Model of Causal Linkages. Organization Science, 20: 253-272.
Coase, R. 1960. The Problem of Social Cost. Journal of Law and Economics, 3(October): 1-44.
Coff, R. W. 1997. Human Assets and Management Dilemmas: Coping with Hazards on the Road to Resource-Based Theory. Academy of Management Review, 22: 374-402.
Coff, R. W. 1999. When Competitive Advantage Doesn't Lead to Performance: The Resource-Based View and Stakeholder Bargaining Power. Organization Science, 10: 119-133.
Collis, D. J. 1994. Research Note: How Valuable Are Organizational Capabilities? Strategic Management Journal, 15 (Winter: Special Issue): 143-152.
Connell, C. M. 2007. Fritz Machlup's Methodology and The Theory of the Growth of the Firm. Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics, 10: 300-312.
Conner, K. R. 1991. A Historical Comparison of Resource-Based Theory and Five Schools of Thought Within Industrial Organization Economics: Do We Have a New Theory of the Firm? Journal of Management, 17: 121-154.
Conner, K. R., & Prahalad, C. K. 1996. A Resource-Based Theory of the Firm: Knowledge versus Opportunism. Organization Science, 7: 477-501.
Connor, T. 2002. The Resource-Based View of Strategy and Its Value to Practising Managers. Strategic Change, 11: 307-316.
D'Aveni, R. 1994. Hypercompetition: Managing the Dynamics of Strategic Maneuvering. New York: Free Press.
Dean, A., & Kretschmer, M. 2007. Can Ideas Be Capital? Factors of Production in the Postindustrial Economy: A Review and Critique. Academy of Management Review, 32: 573-594.
Demsetz, H. 1967. Toward a Theory of Property Rights. The American Economic Review, 57: 347-359.
Denrell, J., Fang, C., & Winter, S. G. 2003. The Economics of Strategic Opportunity. Strategic Management Journal, 24: 977-990.
Dierickx, I., & Cool, K. 1989. Asset Stock Accumulation and Sustainability of Competitive Advantage. Management Science, 35): 1504-1511.
Dosi, G., Faillo, M., & Marengo, L. 2008. Organizational Capabilities, Patterns of Knowledge Accumulation and Governance Structures in Business Firms: An Introduction. Organization Studies, 29: 1165-1185.
Eisenhardt, K. M., & Martin, J. A. 2000. Dynamic Capabilities: What are They? Strategic Management Journal, 21: 1105-1121.
Fiol, C. M. 1991. Managing Culture as a Competitive Resource: An Identity-Based View of Sustainable Competitive Advantage. Journal of Management, 17: 191-211.
Fiol, C. M. 2001. Revisiting an Identity-Based View of Sustainable Competitive Advantage. Journal of Management, 27: 691-699.
Foss, K., & Foss, N. J. 2008. Understanding Opportunity Discovery and Sustainable Advantage: The Role of Transaction Costs and Property Rights. Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal, 2: 191-207.
Foss, K., Foss, N. J., & Klein, P. G. 2007a. Original and Derived Judgment: An Entrepreneurial Theory of Economic Organization. Organization Studies, 28: 1-20.
Foss, K., Foss, N. J., Klein, P. G., & Klein, S. K. 2007b. The Entrepreneurial Organization of Heterogeneous Capital. Journal of Management Studies, 44: 1165-1186.
Foss, N. J. 1994. The Theory of the Firm: The Austrians as Precursors and Critics of Contemporary Theory. Review of Austrian Economics, 7(1): 31-65.
Foss, N. J. 1996a. Knowledge-Based Approaches to the Theory of the Firm: Some Critical Comments. Organization Science, 7: 470-476.
Foss, N. J. 1996b. More Critical Comments on Knowledge-Based Theories of the Firm. Organization Science, 7: 519-523.
Foss, N. J. 2007. The Emerging Knowledge Governance Approach: Challenges and Characteristics. Organization, 14: 29-52.
Foss, N. J., & Ishikawa, I. 2007. Towards a Dynamic Resource-based View: Insights from Austrian Capital and Entrepreneurship Theory. Organization Studies, 28: 749-772.
Foss, N. J., & Klein, P. G. 2005. Entrepreneurship and the Economic Theory of the Firm: Any Gains from Trade? In R. Agarwal, S. A. Alvarez, & O. Sorensen (Eds.), Handbook of Entrepreneurship: Disciplinary Perspectives. Norwell, MA: Kluwer.
Foss, N. J., Klein, P. G., Kor, Y. Y., & Mahoney, J. T. 2008. Entrepreneurship, Subjectivism, and the Resource-Based View: Toward a New Synthesis. Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal, 2: 73-94.
Foss, N. J., & Knudsen, T. 2003. The Resource-Based Tangle: Towards a Sustainable Explanation of Competitive Advantage. Managerial and Decision Economics, 24: 291-307.
Ghoshal, S. 2005. Bad Management Theories are Destroying Good Management Practices. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 4(1): 75-91.
Ghoshal, S., & Moran, P. 1996. Bad for Practice: A Critique of the Transaction Cost Theory. Academy of Management Review, 21: 13-47.
Gibbert, M. 2006a. Generalizing About Uniqueness: An Essay on an Apparent Paradox in the Resource-Based View Journal of Management Inquiry, 15: 124-134.
Gibbert, M. 2006b. Munchausen, Black Swans, and the RBV: Response to Levitas and Ndofor. Journal of Management Inquiry, 15: 145-151.
Gibbons, R. 2005. Four Formal(izable) Theories of the Firm? Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 58: 200-245. Grant, R. M. 1996a. Prospering in Dynamically-Competitive Environments: Organizational Capability as Knowledge Integration. Organization Science, 7: 375-387.
Grant, R. M. 1996b. Toward a Knowledge-Based Theory of the Firm. Strategic Management Journal, 17(Winter): 109-122.
Groen, A. J., Wakkee, I. A. M., & De Weerd-Nederhof, P. C. 2008. Managing Tensions in a High-tech Start-up: An Innovation Journey in Social System Perspective. International Small Business Journal, 26(1): 57-81.
Hamel, G., & Prahalad, G. K. 1994. Competing for the Future. Boston, Massachusetts: Harvard Business School Press.
Helfat, C. E., Finkelstein, S., Mitchell, W., Peteraf, M. A., Singh, H., Teece, D. J., & Winter, S. G. 2007. Dynamic Capabilities: Understanding Strategic Change in Organizations. New York: Wiley.
Helfat, C. E., & Lieberman, M. B. 2002. The Birth of Capabilities: Market Entry and the Importance of Pre-History. Industrial and Corporate Change, 11: 725-760.
Helfat, C. E., & Peteraf, M. A. 2003. The Dynamic Resource-Based View: Capability Lifecycles. Strategic Management Journal, 24: 997-1010.
Hodgson, G. M. 2008. The Concept of a Routine. In M. C. Becker (Ed.), The Handbook of Organizational Routines: 15-29. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Holcomb, T. R., Holmes Jr., R. M., & Connelly, B. L. 2009. Making the most of what you have: managerial ability as a source of resource value creation. Strategic Management Journal, 30: 457-485.
Hoopes, D. G., & Madsen, T. L. 2008. A Capability-Based View of Competitive Heterogeneity. Industrial and Corporate Change, 17: 393-426.
Hoopes, D. G., Madsen, T. L., & Walker, G. 2003. Guest Editors' Introduction to the Special Issue: Why is there a Resource-Based View? Toward a Theory of Competitive Heterogeneity. Strategic Management Journal, 24: 889-902.
Kim, J., & Mahoney, J. T. 2005. Property Rights Theory, Transaction Costs Theory, and Agency Theory: An Organizational Economics Approach to Strategic Management. Managerial and Decision Economics, 26: 223-242.
Knight, F. H. 1921. Risk, Uncertainty, and Profit. New York: August M. Kelley.
Kogut, B., & Zander, U. 1992. Knowledge of the Firm, Combinative Capabilities, and the Replication of Technology. Organization Science, 3: 383-397.
Kogut, B., & Zander, U. 1996. What Firms Do? Coordination, Identity, and Learning. Organization Science, 7: 502-518.
Kor, Y. Y., & Leblebici, H. 2005. How Do Interdependencies Among Human-Capital Deployment, Development and Diversification Strategies Affect Firms' Financial Performance. Strategic Management Journal, 26: 967-985.
Kor, Y. Y., & Mahoney, J. T. 2004. Edith Penrose's (1959) Contributions to the Resource-Based View of Strategic Management. Journal of Management Studies, 41: 183-191.
Kor, Y. Y., Mahoney, J. T., & Michael, S. C. 2007. Resources, Capabilities, and Entrepreneurial Perceptions. Journal of Management Studies, 44: 1187-1212.
Kraaijenbrink, J., & Wijnhoven, F. 2008. Managing Heterogeneous Knowledge: A Theory of External Knowledge Integration. Knowledge Management Research & Practice, 6: 274-286.
Lado, A. A., Boyd, N. G., Wright, P., & Kroll, M. 2006. Paradox and Theorizing Within the Resource-Based View. Academy of Management Review, 31: 115-131.
Langlois, R. 2007. The Entrepreneurial Theory of the Firm and the Theory of the Entrepreneurial Firm. Journal of Management Studies, 44: 1107-1124.
Lavie, D. 2006. The Competitive Advantage of Interconnected Firms: An Extension of the Resource-Based View. Academy of Management Review, 31: 638-658.
Leiblein, M. J. 2003. The Choice of Organizational Governance Form and Performance: Predictions from Transaction Cost, Resource-based and Real Options Theories. Journal of Management, 29: 937-961.
Lepak, D. P., Smith, K. G., & Taylor, S. 2007. Special Topic Forum on Value Creation. Academy of Management Review, 32: 180-292.
Levitas, E., & Ndofor, H. A. 2006. What to Do With the Resource-Based View: A Few Suggestions for What Ails the RBV That Supporters and Opponents Might Accept. Journal of Management Inquiry, 15: 135-144.
Liebeskind, J. P. 1996. Knowledge, Strategy, and the Theory of the Firm. Strategic Management Journal, 17(Winter): 93-107.
Lockett, A., Thompson, S., & Morgenstern, U. 2009. The Development of the Resource-Based View of the Firm: A Critical Appraisal. International Journal of Management Reviews, 11: 9-28.
Mahoney, J. T. 1995. The Management of Resources and the Resource of Management. Journal of Business Research, 33: 91-101.
Mahoney, J. T. 2001. A Resource-Based Theory of Sustainable Rents. Journal of Management, 27: 651-660.
Mahoney, J. T., & Pandian, J. R. 1992. The Resource-Based View Within the Conversation of Strategic Management. Strategic Management Journal, 13: 363-380.
Makadok, R. 2001a. Dialogue: A Pointed Commentary on Priem and Butler. Academy of Management Review, 26: 498-499.
Makadok, R. 2001b. Towards a Synthesis of Resource-Based and Dynamic Capability Views of Rent Creation. Strategic Management Journal, 22: 387-402.
Makadok, R. 2003. Doing the Right Thing and Knowing the Right Thing to Do: Why the Whole is Greater than the Sum of the Parts. Strategic Management Journal, 24: 1043-1055.
Makadok, R., & Coff, R. W. 2002. Dialogue: The Theory of Value and the Value of Theory: Breaking New Ground versus Reinventing the Wheel. Academy of Management Review, 27: 10-13.
March, J. G. 1991. Exploration and Exploitation in Organizational Learning. Organization Science, 2: 71-87.
McGuinness, T., & Morgan, R. E. 2000. Strategy, Dynamic Capabilities and Complex Science: Management Rhetoric vs. Reality. Strategic Change, 9: 209-220.
Menger, C. 1871. Principles of Economics (1985 ed.). New York: New York University Press.
Miller, D. 2003. An Asymmetry-Based View of Advantage: Towards an Attainable Sustainability. Strategic Management Journal, 24: 961-976.
Nelson, R. R. 1991. Why do Firms Differ, and Does it Matter? Strategic Management Journal, 12(Winter: Special Issue): 61-74.
Newbert, S. L. 2007. Empirical Research on the Resource-Based View of the Firm: An Assessment and Suggestions for Future Research. Strategic Management Journal, 28: 121-146.
Penrose, E. T. 1959. The Theory of the Growth of the Firm (1995 ed.). New York: John Wiley and Sons.
Peteraf, M. A. 1993. The Cornerstones of Competitive Advantage: A Resource-Based View. Strategic Management Journal, 14: 179-191.
Peteraf, M. A., & Barney, J. B. 2003. Unraveling the Resource-Based Tangle. Managerial and Decision Economics, 24: 309-323.
Pitelis, C. N. 2007. Twenty Years Resource-Based Vview (or Is it 50?): Some (Old and) New Challenges and Need for Extensions. International Journal of Learning and Intellectual Capital, 4(1-2): 47-56.
Porter, M. E. 1979. How Competitive Forces Shape Strategy. Harvard Business Review (March-April): 137-145.
Porter, M. E. 1980. Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors. New York: The Free Press.
Porter, M. E. 1985. Competitive Advantage. New York: The Free Press.
Powell, T. C. 2001. Competitive Advantage: Logical and Philosophical Considerations. Strategic Management Journal, 22: 875-888.
Priem, R. L., & Butler, J. E. 2001a. Is the Resource-Based "View" a Useful Perspective for Strategic Management Research? Academy of Management Review, 26: 22-40.
Priem, R. L., & Butler, J. E. 2001b. Tautology in the Resource-Based View and the Implications of Externally Determined Resource Value: Further Comments. Academy of Management Review, 26: 57-66.
Pringle, C. D., & Kroll, M. J. 1997. Why Trafalgar Was Won Before it Was Fought: Lessons from Resource-based Theory. Academy of Management Executive, 11(4): 73-89.
Romer, P. M. 1990. Endogenous Technological Change. Journal of Political Economy, 98 (Supplement): S71-S102.
Rumelt, R. P. 1984. Towards a Strategic Theory of the Firm. In R. Lamb (Ed.), Competitive Strategic Management: 556-570. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Sarasvathy, S. D. 2001. Causation and Effectuation: Toward a Theoretical Shift from Economic Inevitability to Entrepreneurial Contingency. Academy of Management Review, 26: 243-263.
Sarasvathy, S. D., & Dew, N. 2005. New Market Creation through Transformation. Journal of Evolutionary Economics, 15: 533-565.
Sirmon, D. G., Gove, S., & Hitt, M. A. 2008. Resource Management in Dyadic Competitive Rivalry: The Effects of Resource Bundling and Deployment. Academy of Management Journal, 51: 919-935.
Sirmon, D. G., Hitt, M. A., & Ireland, R. D. 2007. Managing Firm Resources in Dynamic Environments to Create Value: Looking Inside the Black Box. Academy of Management Review, 32: 273-292.
Spender, J.-C. 1983. Strategic Management: A Property Rights Approach, UCLA Working Paper.
Spender, J.-C. 1994. Organizational Knowledge, Collective Practice, and Penrose Rents. International Business Review, 3: 353-367.
Spender, J.-C. 1996. Making Knowledge the Basis of a Dynamic Theory of the Firm. Strategic Management Journal, 17(Winter: Special Issue): 45-62.
Spender, J.-C. 2005. An Overview: What's New and Important about Knowledge Management? Building New Bridges between Managers and Academics. In S. Little, & T. Ray (Eds.), Managing Knowledge: An Essential Reader: 127-154. London: Sage.
Spender, J.-C. 2006. The RBV, Methodological Individualism, and Managerial Cognition: Practicing Entrepreneurship. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Academy of Management, Atlanta.
Spender, J. C., & Scherer, A. G. 2007. The Philosophical Foundations of Knowledge Management: Editors' Introduction. Organization, 14: 5-28.
Stieglitz, N., & Heine, K. 2007. Innovations and the Role of Complementarities in a Strategic Theory of the Firm. Strategic Management Journal, 28: 1-15.
Teece, D. J. 2007. Explicating Dynamic Capabilities: The Nature and Microfoundations of (Sustainable) Enterprise Performance. Strategic Management Journal, 28: 1319-1350.
Teece, D. J., Pisano, G. P., & Shuen, A. 1997. Dynamic Capabilities and Strategic Management. Strategic Management Journal, 18: 509-533.
Tirole, J. 1988. The Theory of Industrial Organization. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Van de Ven, A. H. 2007. Engaged Scholarship: A Guide for Organizational and Social Research Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Van de Ven, A. H., & Polley, D. 1992. Learning While Innovating. Organization Science, 3: 92-116.
von Hippel, E. 1986. Lead Users: A Source of Novel Product Concepts. Management Science, 32: 791-805.
von Mises, L. 1949. Human Action: A Treatise on Economics. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Wade, M., & Hulland, J. 2004. Review: The Resource-Based View and Information Systems Research: Review, Extention, and Suggestions for Future Research. MIS Quarterly, 28: 107-142.
Wernerfelt, B. 1984. A Resource-Based View of the Firm. Strategic Management Journal, 5: 171-180.
Wernerfelt, B. 1995. The Resource-Based View of the Firm: Ten Years After. Strategic Management Journal, 16: 171-174.
Williamson, O. E., & Winter, S. G. (Eds.). 1991. The Nature of the Firm: Origins, Evolution, and Development. . New York: Oxford University Press.
Winter, S. G. 2003. Understanding Dynamic Capabilities. Strategic Management Journal, 24: 991-995.
Winter, S. G., & Szulanski, G. 2001. Replication as Strategy. Organization Science, 12: 730-743.
Witt, U. 1998. Imagination and Leadership - The Neglected Dimension of an Evolutionary Theory of the Firm. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 35: 161-177.
Witt, U. 1999. Do Entrepreneurs Need Firms? A Contribution to a Missing Chapter in Austrian Economics. Review of Austrian Economics, 11: 99-109.
Witt, U. 2007. Firms as Realizations of Entrepreneurial Visions. Journal of Management Studies, 44: 1124-1140.
Yelle, L. E. 1979. The Learning Curve: Historical Review and Comprehensive Survey. Decision Sciences, 10: 302-328.