Banking and Financial Crises in United States History: What Guidance can History Offer Policymakers?

Tallman, Ellis W and Wicker, Elmus R. (2009): Banking and Financial Crises in United States History: What Guidance can History Offer Policymakers?

Abstract

This paper assesses the validity of comparisons of the current financial crisis with past crises in the United States. We highlight aspects of two National Banking Era crises (the Panic of 1873 and the Panic of 1907) that are relevant for comparison with the Panic of 2008. In 1873, overinvestment in railroad debt and the default of railroad companies on that debt led to the failure of numerous brokerage houses, an antecedent to the modern investment bank. For the Panic of 1907, panic-related deposit withdrawals centered on the less regulated trust companies, which were less directly linked to the existing lender of last resort, similar to investment banks in 2008. The popular press has made numerous references to the banking crises (there were three main ones) of the Great Depression as relevant comparisons to the present crisis. This paper argues that such an analogy is inaccurate in general.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Systemic Risk, Financial Crises, Bank Failures
• Subjects: N - Economic History > N2 - Financial Markets and Institutions > N22 - U.S. ; Canada: 1913-; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E4 - Money and Interest Rates > E44 - Financial Markets and the Macroeconomy; N - Economic History > N2 - Financial Markets and Institutions > N21 - U.S. ; Canada: Pre-1913

References

Balke, Nathan S. and Robert J. Gordon. 1986. “Appendix: Historical Data,” Robert J. Gordon, ed. The American Business Cycle. University of Chicago Press: Chicago.

Bliss, Robert R. and George G. Kaufman. 2006. “Derivatives and Systemic Risk: Netting, Collateral, and Closeout.” Journal of Financial Stability. 2, 55-70.

Calomiris, Charles W., and Gary Gorton (1991). "The Origins of Banking Panics: Models, Facts, and Bank Regulation," pp. 109-173, in R. Glenn Hubbard (ed.), Financial Markets and Financial Crises.Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Calomiris , Charles W., and Berry Wilson. 2004. "Bank Capital and Portfolio Management: The 1930s 'Capital Crunch' and Scramble to Shed Risk," Journal of Business 77, July, pp. 421-55.

Dwyer, Gerald and R. Alton Gilbert. 1989. “Bank Runs and Private Remedies.” Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Economic Review, (May/June)

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. 1940. Annual Report. Pages 61-73.

Fisher, Irving. 1930. The Stock Market Crash and After. The Macmillan Company: New York.

Flannery, Mark. 2009. “Financial System Instability: Threats, Prevention, Management, and Resolution.” Journal of Financial Stability. 5: 221-23.

Friedman, Milton, and Anna J. Schwartz. 1963. A Monetary History of the United States, 1867–1960. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press for NBER.

Gorton, Gary B. 2009. “Slapped in the Face by the Invisible Hand: Banking and the Panic of 2007.” Yale University Working Paper.

Gorton, Gary B.,Slapped in the Face by the Invisible Hand: Banking and the Panic of 2007(May 9, 2009). Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1401882

Kaufman, George G. 2004. “Too Big to Fail in U.S. Banking: Quo Vadis?” in Too Big to Fail: Policies and Practices in Government Bailouts, 77-105, edited by Benton E. Gup. Westport, CT: Praeger.

Larson, Henrietta. 1936. Jay Cooke, Private Banker. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Lo, Andrew W. 2008. “Hedge Funds, Systemic Risk, and the Financial Crisis of 2007–2008.” Written Testimony Prepared for the U.S. House of Representatives 49 Committee on Oversight and Government Reform. November 13, 2008. Hearing on Hedge Funds.

Mason, Joseph. 2000. “Reconstruction Finance Corporation Assistance to Financial Intermediaries and Commercial and Industrial Enterprise in the US, 1932-1937. Prepared for the World Bank. January. Available at SSRN:http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfmabstract_id=1337171

McGrane, Reginald Charles. 1924. The Panic of 1837: Some Financial Problems of the Jacksonian Era. The University of Chicago Press: Chicago.

Moen, Jon R. and Ellis W. Tallman. "The Bank Panic of 1907: The Role of Trust Companies," Journal of Economic History, (September 1992), 52, 3, 611-30.

___________________ 2000 "Clearinghouse Membership and Deposit Contraction During the Panic of 1907" (with Jon R. Moen), Journal of Economic History (March), 60, 1, 145-63.

Myers, Margaret G..1970. A Financial History of the United States. Columbia University Press: New York.

Nadler, Marcus and Jules I. Bogen 1933. The Banking Crisis: The End of an Epoch. Dodd, Mead, and Company: New York.

NBER Macro History Database, various series. http://www.nber.org/databases/macrohistory/contents/

Richardson, Gary. (2007). “Categories and causes of bank distress during the great depression, 1929–1933: The illiquidity versus insolvency debate revisited.” Explorations in Economic History Volume 44, Issue 4, October, Pages 588-607.

Romer, Christina. 1989. “The Pre-War Business Cycle Reconsidered: New Estimates of Gross National Product: 1869-1908” Journal of Political Economy, February, 97, 1-37.

Romer, Christina D. 1986. “Spurious Volatility in Historical Unemployment Data.” Journal of Political Economy. February, 94, pp. 1–37.

Silber, William L. 2007. When Washington Shut Down Wall Street: The Great Financial Crisis of 1914 and the Origins of America’s Monetary Supremacy. Princeton University Press: Princeton, New Jersey.

Stern, Gary H. and Ron J. Feldman. 2004. Too Big to Fail : The Hazards of Bank Bailouts. Brookings Institution Press: Washington, D.C.

Studentski, Paul and Herman E. Krooss. 1963. Financial History of the United States: Fiscal, Monetary, Banking and Tariff, including Financial Administration and State and Local Finance. McGraw-Hill: New York, Second Edition.

Tallman, Ellis W. and Jon R. Moen. 1990 "Lessons from the Panic of 1907,” Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta Economic Review 75 (May/June): 2 13.

Tallman, Ellis W. and Jon R. Moen. 2006 “Liquidity Creation without a Lender of Last Resort: Clearing House Loan Certificates in the Banking Panic of 1907,” Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta Working Paper 2006-23 (November).

Wicker, Elmus R. 2005. The Great Debate on Banking Reform: Nelson Aldrich and the Origins of the Fed. Ohio State University Press: Columbus.

Wicker, Elmus R. 2000. The Banking Panics of the Guilded Age. Cambridge University Press: New York.

Wicker, Elmus R. 1996. The Banking Panics of the Great Depression. Cambridge University Press: New York.

Wicker, Elmus R. 1966. Federal Reserve Monetary Policy: 1917-33. Random House: New York.

Wilmarth, Arthur E. 2004. "Does Financial Liberalization Increase the Likelihood of a Systemic Banking Crisis? Evidence from the Past Three Decades and the Great Depression," in Too Big to Fail: Policies and Practices in Government Bailouts, 77-105, edited by Benton E. Gup. Westport, CT: Praeger.(Working paper version available at http://ssrn.com/abstract=547383).