Economic Approach to Counteracting Cartels

Fornalczyk, Anna (2009): Economic Approach to Counteracting Cartels. Published in: Yearbook of Antitrust and Regulatory Studies , Vol. 2009, No. 2(2) (2009): pp. 33-48.

Abstract

Horizontal agreements between competitors concerning price fixing, quotas, distribution and/or supply market share – cartels – represent the most severe form of competition law infringement. Why are these agreements subject to the highest fines and, in some countries (USA, Canada, Mexico, UK), subject to both fines as well as imprisonment? What are the economic grounds for such severe punishment? How important is an economic analysis for the results of anti-cartel proceedings considering that they are prohibited per se, that is, absolutely and unconditionally? Does growing market concentration and resulting transparency increase the significance of the economic approach to the evaluation of market effects of the behaviour of business? Which methods make it possible to differentiate cartels from competition in oligopolistic markets including economic and econometric analyses? This paper will present an answer to the aforementioned questions on the basis of literature studies, an analysis of Polish case law between 2000–2009 as well as the author’s extensive experience in the field of antitrust consultancy.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: cartels, collusions, explicit and tacit collusions, transparent markets, relevant markets, anti-competitive agreements
• Subjects: K - Law and Economics > K2 - Regulation and Business Law > K21 - Antitrust Law

References

Bain J., Barriers to New Competition, Augustus M. Kelly Publishers, USA 1993.

Baumol W.J., Blinder A.S., Economics Principles and Policy, San Diego 1988.

Bernatt M., Jurkowska A., Skoczny T., Ochrona konkurencji i konsumentów [Competition and Consumers Protection], Warszawa 2007.

Branderburger A.M., Nalebuff B.J., Co-opetition, New York 1998.

Cabral L.M.B., Introduction to Industrial Organization, Cambridge 2000.

Czarny E., Nojszewska E., Mikroekonomia [Microeconomics],Warszawa 2000.

Fornalczyk A., Biznes a ochrona konkurencji [Business and Competition Protection], Kraków 2007.

Fox E.M., The Competition Law of the European Union In Comparative Perspective, St. Paul, MN: West Publishing Co. 2009.

Gronowski S., Ustawa antymonopolowa – komentarz [Antimonopoly Law – Commentary]Warszawa 1999.

Hovenkamp H., Federal Antitrust Policy. The Law of Competition and its Practice, St. Paul, MN: West Publishing Co. 1994.

Hovenkamp H., The Antitrust Enterprise. Principle and Execution, Harvard 2005.

Hylton K. N., Antitrust Law. Economic Theory & Common Law Evolution, Cambridge 2003.

Motta M., Competition Policy. Theory and Practice, Cambridge 2005.

Posner R.A., Easterbrook F.H., Antitrust Cases. Economic Notes and Other Materials. Second Edition, West Publishing 1981.

Rahl J.A., “Conspiracy and the Anti-Trust Laws” (1950) 44 Illinois Law Review 743.

Samuelson P.A., Nordhaus W.D., Ekonomia [Economics], vol. 1, Warszawa 1998.

Stiglitz J.E., Economics of the Public Sector, New York 1988.

Tirole J., The Theory of Industrial Organization, The MIT Press 1988.

Varian H.R., Mikroekonomia [Microeconomics], Warszawa 1997. Whish R., Competition Law, London, Edinburgh 1993.

Williamson O.E., Markets and Hierarchies. Analysis and Antitrust Implications, New York 1983.

Zmowy cenowe [Price-fixing agreements], UOKiK, Warszawa 2009.

Znajomość prawa o ochronie konkurencji i zasadach przydzielania pomocy publicznej wśród polskich przedsiębiorców [Polish entrepreneurs’ knowledge about competition law and principles of granting state aid], UOKiK, Warszawa 2009.