English Individualism and Continental Altruism? Servants, Remittances and Welfare in Eighteenth-Century Rural Europe.

Lambrecht, Thijs A. (2012): English Individualism and Continental Altruism? Servants, Remittances and Welfare in Eighteenth-Century Rural Europe.

Abstract

Life-cycle service was one of the characteristic aspects of the European Marriage Pattern. The majority of the children of labourers and peasants left the household of their parents during adolescence to acquire material resources and skills in preparation of marriage. Whilst in service, adolescents could save part of their wages. As most of them worked in close geographical proximity to their family, children in service were also a potential source of income for their parents. This paper studies the nature, frequency and value of remittances from farm servants to their parents in three countries during the eighteenth century. Important differences emerge from this comparative study. Farm servants in Belgium and France frequently supported their parents financially with their earnings. In England parents could in most cases not rely on structural assistance from their unmarried adolescent children. I argue that property rights explain these differences. The absence of land that could be passed on through inheritance operated as a check to intergenerational solidarity.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: welfare; servants; wages; remittances; household economy; poor relief; property rights
• Subjects: N - Economic History > N1 - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics ; Industrial Structure ; Growth ; Fluctuations > N13 - Europe: Pre-1913; D - Microeconomics > D6 - Welfare Economics > D64 - Altruism ; Philanthropy

References

Alcock, T. (1752), Observations on the defects of the poor law. London: Baldwin.

Allen, R. (1992), Enclosure and the yeoman. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Arnouet, P. (1962), Le livre de raison de Nicolas Gillet, labourer à Droyes, Cahiers Haut-Marnais 7, 153-185.

Béaur, G. (1991), Investissement foncier, épargne et cycle de vie dans les pays chartrain au XVIIIe siècle, Histoire et Mesure 6, 275-288.

Béaur, G. (1998), Land accumulation, life course, and inequalities among generations in eighteenth-century France : the winegrowers of the Chartres region, History of the Family 3, 285-302.

Béaur, G. (2000), Histoire agraire de la France au XVIIIe siècle. Inerties et changements dans les campagnes françaises entre 1715 et 1815. Paris : SEDES.

Bentham, J. (1796), Collateral uses derivable from a system of industry houses, in: M. Quinn (ed.), Writings on the Poor Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 66-140.

Bentham, J. (1798), Pecuniary remittance facilitated to the poor, Annals of Agriculture 3, 490-494.

Bertaud, J.-P. (1990), La crise sociale (septembre 1792-juilet 1796), in: J. Imbert (ed.), La protection sociale sous la Révolution française. Paris : Association pour l'Etude de l'Histoire de la Sécurité Sociale, 205-280.

Boehler, J.-M. (1994), La paysannerie de la plaine d’Alsace (1648-1789). Strasbourg, Presses Universitaires de Strasbourg, III vol.

Carling, J. (2008), The determinants of migrant remittances, Oxford Review of Economic Policy 24, 582-899.

Chapalain-Nougaret, C. (1989), Misère et assistance dans le pays de Rennes au XVIIIe siècle. Nantes : CID Editions.

Charbonneau, J. (1970), ‘Les livres de comptes de la bourgeoisie rurale de l’Agenais au XVIIIe siècle’, Revue de l’Agenais 97, 165-171.

Claverie E. and Lamaison P. (1982), L’impossible mariage. Violence et parenté en Gévaudan XVIIe, XVIIIe et XIXe siècles. Paris : Hachette.

Crawford, P. (2010), Parents of poor children in England, 1580-1800. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Dalle, G. (1953-1954), De volkstelling van 1697 in Veurne-Ambacht en de evolutie van het Veurnse bevolkingscijfer in de XVIIe eeuw, Handelingen van het Genootschap voor Geschiedenis te Brugge 40-41, 95-130 and 18-54.

Davies, D. (1795), The case of labourers in husbandry. Bath: Cruttwell.

De Calonne, A. (1920), La vie agricole sous l’ancien regime dans le nord de la France. Paris : Societe des Antiquaires de Picardie.

Desaive, J.-P. (2005), Etre vieux et survivre : la démission de biens en Basse-Bourgogne (XVIIe-XVIIIe siècles), in : L. Lorenzetti, A.-L. Head-König and J. Goy (eds.), Marchés, migrations et logiques familiales dans les espaces français, canadien et suisse, 18e-20e siècles. Berlin: Peter Lang, 279-286.

de Vries, J. (1981), Barges and capitalism: passenger transportation in the Dutch economy, 1632-1839. Utrecht, HES Publishers.

Eden, F. M. (1797), The state of the poor. London: Davis, III vol.

Festy, O. (1947), L’agriculture pendant la Révolution française. Les conditions de production et de récolte des céréales. Paris: Gallimard.

Fillon, A. (1991), A la recherche des aïeuls du Maine, Annales de Démographie Historique, 33-50.

Gordon, W. M. (2005), ‘What, I pray, shall I do with the ballance?’ Single women’s economy of migration, International Review of Social History 50, 53-70.

Gradish, S. F. (1978), Wages and manning: the Navy act of 1758, English Historical Review 93, 46-67. Gross, J.-P. (2000), Egalitarisme jacobin et droits de l’homme, 1793-1794. Paris: Arcantères.

Gutton, J.-P. (1981), Domestiques et serviteurs dans la France de l’ancien régime. Paris: Aubier Montaigne.

Hajnal, J. (1982), Two kinds of preindustrial household formation system, Population and Development Review 8, 449-494.

Hamy, E. T. (1906), La vie rurale au XVIIIe siècle dans le pays reconquis. Etude de sociologie et d’ethnographie, Mémoires de la société académique de l’arrondissement de Boulogne-sur-Mer 24, 333-397.

Hanway, J. (1774), Virtue in humble life containing reflections on the reciprocal duties of the wealthy and indigent. London: Dodsley.

Haweis, T. (1788), Hints respecting the poor. London: Dilly.

Heywood, C. (1988), Childhood in nineteenth-century France. Work, health and education among the classes populaires. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Hill, B. (1996), Servants. English domestics in the eighteenth century. Oxford : Oxford University Press.

Hoddinott (1994), A model of migration and remittances applied to Western Kenya, Oxford Economic Papers 46, 459-476.

Hubscher, R.-H. (1969), Une contribution à la connaissance des milieux populaires ruraux au XIXe siècle. Le livre de compte de la famillie Flahaut (1811-1877), Revue d’histoire économique et sociale 47, 361-403.

Hudson, P. (1991), Landholding and the organization of textile manufacture in Yorkshire rural townships c. 1660-1810, in: M. Berg (ed.), Markets and manufacture in early industrial Europe. London-New York: Routledge, 261-291.

Hufton, O. (1974), The poor of eighteenth-century France 1750-1789. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Humphries, J. (2010), ‘The first industrial nation and the first modern family’, in : T. Addabbo et. al. (eds.), Gender inequalities, households and the production of well-being in Europe. Farnham: Ashgate, 41-58.

Jollet, A. (1998), Terre et paysans: la propriété paysanne en France aux XVIIe et XVIIIe siècles, in: J. Marseille (ed.), La terre et les paysans en France 1600-1800. Paris : Association pour le Développement de l’Histoire Economique, 99-122.

Kames, H. (1775), Sketches of the history of man. Dublin: Creech.

Keir, W. (1807), A summons of awakening. Hawick: Armstrong.

King, S. (2005), “It is impossible for our vestry to judge his case into perfection from here”: managing the distance dimensions of poor relief, 1800-40’, Rural History 16, 161-189.

Krausman Ben-Amos, I. (1994), Adolescence and youth in early modern England. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.

Krausman Ben-Amos, I. (2000); Reciprocal bonding: parents and their children in early modern England, Journal of Family History 25, 291-312.

Kussmaul, A. (1981a), The ambiguous mobility of farm servants, Economic History Review 34, 222-235.

Kussmaul, A. (1981b), Servants in husbandry in early modern England. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Lambrecht, T. (2003), Reciprocal exchange, credit and cash: agricultural labour markets and local economies in the southern Low Countries during the eighteenth century, Continuity and Change 18, 237-261.

Lambrecht, T. (2007), Krediet en de rurale economie in Vlaanderen tijdens de 18de eeuw. Ghent: Unpublished PhD.

Lambrecht, T. (2009), ‘Peasant labour strategies and the logic of family labour in the southern Low Countries during the 18th century’, in S. Cavaciocchi (ed.), The economic role of the family in the European economy from the 13th to the 18th centuries, Florence: Florence University Press, 637-649.

Lambrecht, T. (2012a), ‘Unmarried adolescents and filial assistance in eighteenth-century Flanders’, in: G. Fertig (ed.), Social networks, political institutions, and rural societies. Turnhout: Brepols, 1-28 (in press, but available at http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/35400/)

Lambrecht, T. (2012b), Eigendomsstructuren in Oost-Vlaanderen tijdens de 17de en 18de eeuw, in: C. Vancoppenolle (ed.), Oost-Vlaamse landboeken en ommelopers, 16de-18de eeuw. Brussels: State Archives, 1-33 (in press).

Laslett, P. (1988), Family, kinship and collectivity as systems of support in pre-industrial Europe: a consideration of the nuclear hardship hypothesis, Continuity and Change 3, 153-175.

Lin, P. (1997), Extending her arms. Military families and the transformation of the British state, 1793-1815. Berkeley: unpublished PhD.

Lis, C. and Vantemsche, G. (1995), De sociale zekerheid in historisch perspectief, in: M. Despontin en M. Jegers (eds.), De sociale zekerheid verzekerd ? Brussels: VUB Press, 23-79.

Lis C. and Soly H. (2009), Care partnership, welfare and work: a historical perspective, in: K. De Boyser et. al. (eds.), Between the social and the spatial. Exploring the multiple dimensions of poverty and social exclusion. London: Ashgate, 71-87.

Lucas R.E.B. and Stark O. (1988), Motivations to remit: evidence from Botswana, Journal of Political Economy 93, 901-918.

Moriceau J.M. and Postel-Vinay G. (1992), Ferme, entreprise, famille. Grande exploitation et changements agricoles: les Chartier XVIIe-XIXe siècles. Paris : EHESS.

Muldrew, C. and King, S. (2004), Cash, wages and the economy of makeshifts in England, 1650-1800, in : P. Scholliers and L. Schwarz (eds.), Experiencing wages: social and cultural aspects of wage forms in Europe since 1500. London: Berghan Books, 155-182.

Muldrew, C. (2007), Wages and the problem of monetary scarcity in early modern England, in: J. Lucassen (ed.), Wages and currency: global comparisons from Antiquity to the twentieth century. Berlin: Peter Lang, 391-410.

Ottaway, S.R. (1998), Providing for the elderly in eighteenth-century England, Continuity and Change 13, 391-418.

Parmentier, J. (2002), Oostende & Co. Het verhaal van de Zuid-Nederlandse Oost- Indiëvaart 1715-1735. Ghent: Ludion.

Placcaert-boek van Vlaenderen (1763). Ghent: de Goesin, vol. IX.

Poitrineau, A. (1981), Minimum vital catégoriel et conscience populaire : les retraites conventionelles des gens agés dans le pays de Murat au XVIIIe siècle, French Historical Studies 12, 165-176.

Pollock, V. (1995), Contract and consumption : labour agreements and the use of money in eighteenth-century rural Ulster, Agricultural History Review 43, 19-34.

Rodger, N. A. M. (1986), The wooden world. An anatomy of the Georgian Navy. London: Norton.

Sabean, D.W. (1990), Property, production and family in Neckarhausen 1700-1870. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Selection of parochial examinations relative to the destitute classes in Ireland (1835). Dublin: Milliken.

Shaw-Taylor,L. (2004), Access to land by labourers and tradesmen in 18th-century England, in: B.J.P. van Bavel and P. Hoppenbrouwers (eds.), Landholding and land transfer in the North Sea area (late Middle Ages-19th century). Turnhout: Brepols, 265-281 (CORN Publications Series; 5)

Smith, R. (1981), Fertility, economy and household formation in England over three centuries, Population and Development Review 7, 595-622.

Smith, R. (1984), Some issues concerning families and their property in rural England 1250-1800, in: R. Smith (ed.), Land, kinship and life-cycle. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1-86.

Smith, R. (1996), Charity, self-interest and welfare: reflections from demographic and family history, in: M. Daunton (ed.), Charity, self-interest and welfare in the English past. London: UCL Press, 23-49.

Smith, R. (1998), Ageing and well-being in early modern England: pension trends and gender preferences under the English Old Poor Law, c. 1650-1800, in: P. Johnson and P. Thane (eds.), Old age from Antiquity to post-modernity. London: Routledge, 64-95.

Smith, S. (1810), General view of the agriculture of Galloway. London: Sherwood.

Snell, K.D.M. (1985), Annals of the labouring poor. Social change and agrarian England, 1660-1900. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Sokoll, T. (1991), Early attempts at accounting the unaccountable: Davies’ and Eden’s budget of agricultural labouring families in late eighteenth-century England, in: T. Pierenkemper (ed.), Zur Ökonomik des privaten Haushalts. Haushaltrechnungen als Quelle historischer Wirtschafts- und Sozialforschung. Frankfurt – New York: Campus Verlag, 34-58.

Stark O. and Lucas R.E.B. (1985), Motivations to remit: evidence from Botswana, Journal of Political Economy 93, 901-918.

Tadmor, N. (2010), Early modern English kinship in the long run: reflections on continuity and change’, Continuity and Change 25, 15-48.

Tholin, G. (1880), De quelques livres de raison des familles agenaises, Revue de l’Agenais, 34-396.

Thomson, D. (1984), I am not my father’s keeper: families and the elderly in nineteenth-century England, Law and History Review 2, 265-286.

Thuillier, G. (1988), Les secours aux parents des défenseurs de la patrie (792-1796): orientations de recherche’, Actes du colloque sur l’histoire de la sécurité sociale 2, 459-489.

Valette, J. (1989), Les secours aux parents de défenseurs de la patrie : l’exemple de la Gironde (an II-an IV), Actes du colloque sur l’histoire de la sécurité sociale 2, 321-328.

Van der Heijden M. and van den Heuvel D. (2007), Sailors' families and the urban institutional framework in early modern Holland, History of the Family 12, 296-309.

Vanhaute, E. (1993), Eigendomsverhoudingen in de Belgische landbouw tijdens de 18de en de 19de eeuw, Belgisch Tijdschrift voor Nieuwste Geschiedenis 24, 185-226.

Vanhaute, E. and Lambrecht, T. (2011), Famine, exchange networks and the village community. A comparative analysis of the subsistence crises of the 1740s and the 1840s in Flanders, Continuity and Change 26, 155-186.

Vigneron, S. (2007), La pierre et la terre. Le marché foncier et immobilier dans les dynamiques sociales du Nord de la France aux XVIIe et XVIIIe siècles. Villeneuve d’Ascq : Presses Universitaires du Septentrion.

Whittle, J. (2005), Servants in rural England c. 1450-1650: hired work as a means of accumulating wealth and skills before marriage, in: M. Agren and A. L. Erickson (eds.), The marital economy in Scandinavia and Britain 1400-1900, London: Ashgate, 89-110.

Williamson, J. G. (1990), Coping with city growth during the British Industrial Revolution. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Wilssens, M.-A. (1992), Bevolkingsdruk en boerenverstand. Evolutie van de levensstandaard in het Waasland in de 18de eeuw. Brussels: Gemeentekrediet.

Z.A. (1838), On the New Poor Law, The Christian Guardian, 135-137.