The impossibility of social evaluations of infinite streams with strict inequality aversion

Alcantud, José Carlos R. (2011): The impossibility of social evaluations of infinite streams with strict inequality aversion.

Abstract

We are concerned with the problem of aggregating infinite utility streams and the possible adoption of consequentialist equity principles. We find a virtually universal incompatibility between the Basu-Mitra approach (that advocates for social welfare functions and renounces continuity assumptions) and postulates that capture various forms of strict preference for a reduction in inequality like the Strong Equity Principle, the Pigou-Dalton Transfer principle, or Altruistic Equity. We also prove that the Hara-Shinotsuka-Suzumura-Xu impossibility for semicontinuous social welfare relations remains under the latter distributional postulate.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Social welfare functions; Strong Equity Principle; Pigou-Dalton Transfer principle; Altruistic Equity; monotonicity
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D6 - Welfare Economics > D63 - Equity, Justice, Inequality, and Other Normative Criteria and Measurement; D - Microeconomics > D7 - Analysis of Collective Decision-Making > D71 - Social Choice ; Clubs ; Committees ; Associations; D - Microeconomics > D9 - Intertemporal Choice > D90 - General

References

Alcantud JCR (2010) The compromise efficiency vs. egalitarianism among generations with an infinite horizon. MPRA Paper No. 22467, http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/22467/

Alcantud JCR (2012) Inequality averse criteria for evaluating infinite utility streams: The impossibility of Weak Pareto. Journal of Economic Theory 147, 353–363.

Alcantud, J.C.R. and Garcia-Sanz, M.D. (2010) Evaluations of infinite utility streams: Pareto-efficient and egalitarian axiomatics. MPRA Paper No. 20133, http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/20133/

Asheim GB, Mitra T, Tungodden B (2012) Sustainable recursive social welfare functions. Economic Theory 49, 267-292.

Banerjee K (2006) On the equity-efficiency trade off in aggregating infinite utility streams. Economics Letters 93, 63-67.

Basu K, Mitra T (2003) Aggregating infinite utility streams with intergenerational equity: the impossibility of being Paretian. Econometrica 71, 1557-1563.

Bossert W, Sprumont Y, Suzumura K (2007) Ordering infinite utility streams. Journal of Economic Theory 135, 579-589.

Crespo J, Nuñez C, Rincon-Zapatero JP (2009) On the impossibility of representing infinite utility streams. Economic Theory 40, 47-56.

Dalton H (1920) The measurement of inequality of incomes. Econ J 30, 348–61.

Dubey RS (2011) Fleurbaey-Michel conjecture on equitable weak Paretian social welfare order. Journal of Mathematical Economics 47 434–439.

Dubey RS, Mitra T (2011) On equitable social welfare functions satisfying the weak pareto axiom: a complete characterization. International Journal of Economic Theory 7, 231-250.

Fleurbaey M, Trannoy A (2003) The impossibility of a Paretian egalitarian. Social Choice and Welfare 21, 243–263.

Fleurbaey M, Tungodden B (2011) The tyranny of non-aggregation versus the tyranny of aggregation in social choices: a real dilemma. Economic Theory 44, 399–414.

Hara C, Shinotsuka T, Suzumura K, Xu Y (2006) On the possibility of continuous, Paretian and egalitarian evaluation of infinite utility streams. Mimeo.

Hara C, Shinotsuka T, Suzumura K, Xu Y (2008) Continuity and egalitarianism in the evaluation of infinite utility streams. Social Choice and Welfare 31, 179-191.

Kolm SC (1977) Multidimensional egalitarianisms. Quarterly Journal of Economics 91, 1–13.

Lauwers L (2010) Ordering infinite utility streams comes at the cost of a non-Ramsey set. Journal of Mathematical Economics 46, 32–37.

Moulin H (1991) Axioms of Cooperative Decision-Making. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Pigou AC (1912) Economics of Welfare, 4th edition, 1932. Macmillan, London.

Sakai T (2006) Equitable intergenerational preferences on restricted domains. Social Choice and Welfare 27, 41-54.

Sakamoto N (2011) Impossibilities of Paretian social welfare functions for infinite utility streams with distributive equity. Discussion Paper #2011-09. Hitotsubashi University.

Zame WR (2007) Can intergenerational equity be operationalized? Theoretical Economics 2, 187–202.