Do faith-inspired health care providers in Africa reach the poor more than other providers?

Olivier, Jill and Tsimpo, Clarence and Wodon, Quentin (2012): Do faith-inspired health care providers in Africa reach the poor more than other providers?

Abstract

Faith-inspired institutions (FIIs) commonly have as their stated mission a desire to provide quality health services to all, and in particular a commitment to serve the poor, for example, by providing services in remote areas where there are none, or by making services more affordable for those in need. Yet it is unclear whether they are able to fulfil this commitment in the current contexts in which they operate – for example by serving the poor proportionately more than other (wealthier) households, or being utilized by the poor more than other providers. Using data from 14 recent nationally representative household surveys in Africa, this paper suggests that when compared with public providers on a broad macro scale, FIIs currently tend to serve the poor slightly less than other population groups. The data also suggest that on average, beyond differences between countries, FIIs do not serve the poor proportionately more than public providers (the most relevant comparison, given that non-religious for-profit private providers tend to be more oriented towards serving wealthier groups). This does not mean that FIIs do not make special efforts to reach the poor, for example by subsidizing them in order to make services more affordable. However, it suggests that in current African health contexts, FIIs may no longer be that different from public providers in the clientele they serve.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Health; Faith; Private Providers; Africa; Christian Health Associations; Poverty
• Subjects: I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health > I11 - Analysis of Health Care Markets; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health > I15 - Health and Economic Development; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health > I18 - Government Policy ; Regulation ; Public Health

References

African Health Assets Programme (ARHAP). 2006. Appreciating Assets: The Contribution of Religion to Universal Access in Africa. Cape Town: African Religious Health Assets Programme.

Asante, R. K. O. 1998. Sustainability of Church Hospitals in Developing Countries: A Search for Criteria for Success. Geneva: (WCC) World Council of Churches, 1998.

Banda, M., E. Ombaka, S. Logez, and M. Everard. 2006. Multi-Country Study of Medicine Supply and Distribution Activities of Faith-Based Organizations in sub-Saharan African Countries. Geneva: World Health Organization and Ecumenical Pharmaceutical Network.

Christian Health Association of Ghana (CHAG). 2006. “Annual Report: June 2005 - May 2006.” Accra.

Christian Health Association of Malawi (CHAM). 2008. “HMIS Status Report.”Lilongwe. .

Christian Health Association of Nigeria (CHAN). 2007. Christian Health Association of Nigeria website.. http://channigeria.org/aboutus.html [Accessed 15/08/2011].

Coulombe, H., and Q. Wodon. 2012a. “Mapping Religious Health Assets: Are Faith-Inspired Facilities Located in Poor Areas in Ghana?” In J. Olivier and Q. Wodon, eds, Mapping, Cost, and Reach to the Poor of Faith-inspired Health Care Providers in sub-Saharan Africa. HNP Discussion Papers, World Bank, Washington, DC.

Coulombe, H., and Wodon Q. 2012b. “Benefit Incidence of Public Health Spending in Ghana: Comparing Public and Faith-Inspired Providers.” In J. Olivier and Q. Wodon, eds, Mapping, Cost, and Reach to the Poor of Faith-inspired Health Care Providers in sub-Saharan Africa. HNP Discussion Papers, World Bank, Washington, DC.

CSSC. 2007. “Christian Health Associations at Crossroad Toward Achieving Health Millenium Development Goals.” Christian Health Association’s Conference, 16-18 January 2007, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania: Christian Social Services Commission.

De Jong, J. 1991. “Nongovernmental Organizations and Health Delivery in Sub-Saharan Africa.” World Bank Working Paper, Population and Human Resources Department, World Bank, Washington, DC.

Gemignani, R., Q. Wodon, and C. Tsimpo. 2012. “Making Quality Care Affordable for the Poor: Faith-Inspired Health Facilities in Burkina Faso.” In J. Olivier and Q. Wodon, eds, Mapping, Cost, and Reach to the Poor of Faith-Inspired Health Care Providers in sub-Saharan Africa. HNP Discussion Papers, World Bank, Washington, DC.

Ghana-MOH and CHAG. 2006. “Memorandum of Understanding and Administrative Instructions.” Accra: Ministry of Health and Christian Health Association of Ghana.

Gilson, L, P. D. Sen, S. Mohammed, and P. Mujinja. 1994. “The Potential of Health Sector Nongovernmental Organizations - Policy Options.” Health Policy and Planning 9(1): 14-24.

Green, A., and A. Matthias. 2005. “Where do NGOs Fit In? Developing a Policy Framework for the Health Sector.” Development in Practice 5(4): 313-323.

Haddad, B., J. Olivier, and S. De Gruchy. 2008. The Potential and Perils of Partnership: Christian Religious Entities and Collaborative Stakeholders Responding to HIV and AIDS in Kenya, Malawi and the DRC. Cape Town: Africa Religious Health Assets Programme.

Hanson, K., and P. Berman. 1994. “Non-Government Financing and Provision of Health Services in Africa: A Background Paper.” Washington, DC: United States Agency for International Development.

Kitchen, M. 2002. “World Must Coordinate Efforts, end Waste, says Wolfensohn.” UN Wire

Knowles, J. C., A. S. Yazbeck, and S. Brewster. 1994. The Private Sector Delivery of Healthcare: Senegal. Bethesda, MD: Health Financing and Sustainability (HFS) Project.

Lusey-Gekawaku, H. 2003. The Churches Confronted with the Problem of HIV/AIDS: Analysis of the Situation in Five Countries of Central Africa. Geneva: World Council of Churches.

Marshall, K. and M. Van Saanen. 2007. Development and Faith: Where Mind Heart and Soul Work Together. World Bank, Washington, DC.

Marshall, K, and L. Keough. 2005. Finding Global Balance: Common Ground Between the Worlds of Development and Faith. World Bank, Washington, DC.

McGilvray, J. 1981. The Quest for Health and Wholeness. Tübingen: German Institute for Medical Mission.

Mogedal, S., and S. H. Steen. 1995. “Health Sector Reform and Organizational Issues at the Local Level: Lessons From Selected African Countries.” Journal of International Development 7 (3):349-67.

Muriithi, P., N. Munguti, R. Ayah, and D. Ongore. 2007. “A situational Analysis Study of the Faith-Based Health Services Vis-a-vis the Government Health Services.” Nairobi, Kenya: Ministry of Health Republic of Kenya, Christian Health Association of Kenya and German Technical Cooperation.

Nussbaum, S., editor. 2005. The Contribution of Christian Congregations to the Battle with HIV and AIDS at the Community Level. Oxford: Global Mapping International.

Olivier, J., and G. Paterson. 2011. “Religion and Medicine in the Context of HIV and AIDS: A Landscaping Review.” In B. Haddad, editor, Religion and HIV/AIDS: Charting the Terrain, Pietermaritzburg: Cluster Publications.

Olivier, J., and Q. Wodon. 2012. “Playing Broken Telephone: Assessing Faith-Inspired Health Care Provision in Africa.” Development in Practice, 22(5-6): 819-34.

Olivier, J., and Q. Wodon. 2012. “Market Share of Faith-Inspired Health Care Providers in Africa: Comparing Facilities and Multi-Purpose Integrated Household Survey Data.” In J. Olivier and Q. Wodon, eds, The Role of Faith-Inspired Health Care Providers in sub-Saharan Africa and Public-Private Partnerships, HNP Discussion Papers, World Bank, Washington DC.

Parry, S. 2003. Responses of the Faith-Based Organisations to HIV/AIDS in sub-Saharan Africa. Geneva: World Council of Churches and Ecumenical HIV/AIDS Initiative in Africa.

Reinikka, R., and J. Svensson. 2010. “Working for God? Evidence from a Change in Financing of Not-For-Profit Health Care Providers in Uganda.” Journal of European Economic Association 8(6):1159-1178.

Todd, S., G. Brubaker, S. Chand, C. Franzén, C. Hafner, A. Kimambo, and P. Pamba. 2009. Human Resources-Geographical Information Systems Data Development and Systems Implementation for the Christian Social Services Commission of Tanzania: Final Report. Washington, DC: USAID and The Capacity Project.

Ward, N., J. Kaybryn, and K. Akinola. 2010. Faith in the System: The Impact of Local HIV Responses on Strengthening Health Systems in Malawi and Chad. Teddington, UK: Tearfund.

WHO-CIFA. 2009. “Report on WHO-CIFA Consultation: NGO Mapping Standards Describing Religious Health Assets.” 10-12 November 2009, Chateau de Bossey, Bogis-Bossey, Switzerland.

World Bank. 1983. “Country Population and Health Sector Reviews (1983–1992).” Unpublished Country Memoranda, Washington, DC.

Wodon, Q. 2013. Faith and Human Development: Education and Health Services in Africa, New York: Palgrave MacMillan.