How best to measure pension adequacy

Grech, Aaron George (2013): How best to measure pension adequacy.

Abstract

Though the main benchmark used to assess pension reforms continues to be the expected resulting fall in future government spending, the impact of policy changes on pension adequacy is increasingly coming to the fore. As yet, there does not seem to be a broad consensus in policymaking circles and academic literature on what constitutes the best measure of pension adequacy. While various indicators have been developed and utilised, no single measure appears to offer a clear indication of the extent to which reforms will impact on the achievement of pension system goals. Many indicators appear ill-suited to study the effective impact of reforms, particularly those that change the nature of the pension system from defined benefit to defined contribution.

Existing measures are frequently hard to interpret as they do not have an underlying benchmark which allows their current or projected value to be assessed as adequate or inadequate. Currently used pension adequacy indicators tend to be point-in-time measures which ignore the impact of benefit indexation rules. They also are unaffected by very important factors, such as changes in the pension age and in life expectancy. This tends to make existing indicators minimise the impact of systemic reforms on the poverty alleviation and income replacement functions of pension systems. The emphasis on assumptions which are very unrepresentative of real-life labour market conditions also makes current indicators deceptive, particularly in relation to outcomes for women and those on low incomes.

This paper posits that these defects can be remedied by using adequacy indicators based on estimates of pension wealth (i.e. the total projected flow of pension benefits through retirement) calculated using more realistic labour market assumptions. These measures are used to give a better indication of the effective impact of pension reforms enacted since the 1990s in ten major European countries. They suggest that these reforms have decreased generosity significantly, but that the poverty alleviation function remains strong in those countries where minimum pensions were improved. However, moves to link benefits to contributions have raised clear adequacy concerns for women and for those on low incomes which policymakers should consider and tackle.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Social Security and Public Pensions; Retirement; Poverty; Retirement Policies
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H55 - Social Security and Public Pensions; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I38 - Government Policy ; Provision and Effects of Welfare Programs; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J2 - Demand and Supply of Labor > J26 - Retirement ; Retirement Policies

References

Abatemarco, Antonio (2009) Measurement issues for adequacy comparisons among pension systems, ENEPRI Research Report No. 64. Brussels: Centre for European Policy Studies.

Avram, Silvia and Holly Sutherland (2012) Baseline results from EUROMOD: 2006-2009 policies, EUROMOD Working Paper No. EM 1/2012. Colchester: ISER.

Bardasi, Elena, Stephen Jenkins and John Rigg (2000) Retirement and the economic well-being of the elderly: A British perspective, Institute for Social and Economic Research Working Paper 2000-33. Colchester: University of Essex.

Barr, Nicholas and Peter Diamond (2006) “The economics of pensions”, Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 22(1):15-39.

Blondell, Sveinbjorn and Stefano Scarpetta (1999) The retirement decision in OECD Countries, OECD Economics Department Working Papers No.202. Paris: OECD.

Bridgen, Paul and Traute Meyer (2008) “Politically dominant but socially flawed: Projected pension levels for citizens at risk in six European Multi-pillar pension systems” in Martin Seeleib-Kaiser (ed.), Welfare State Transformations: Comparative Perspectives. Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan.

Brugiavini, Agar, Karen Maser and Annika Sunden (2005) Measuring pension wealth, Paper prepared for a meeting of the Luxembourg Wealth Study held in January 2005: http://www.lisproject.org/lws/introduction/files/brugiavini_rev.pdf

Caucutt, Elizabeth, Thomas Cooley and Nezih Guner (2007) The farm, the city and the emergence of social security, NBER Working Paper No.12854. Cambridge MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.

Dekkers, Gijs, Hermann Buslei, Maria Cozzolino, Raphael Desmet, Johannes Geyer, Dirk Hofmann, Michele Raitano, Viktor Steiner, Paola Tanda, Simone Tedeschi and Frederic Verschueren (2009) What are the consequences of the AWG-projections for the adequacy of social security pensions?, ENEPRI Research Report No.65. Brussels: Centre for European Policy Studies.

Draxler, Juraj and Jorgen Mortensen (2009) Towards sustainable but still adequate pensions in the EU: Theory, trends and simulations, ENEPRI Research Report No.67. Brussels: Centre for European Policy Studies.

EBRI (2006) Measuring retirement income adequacy: Calculating realistic income replacement rates, Issue Brief No.297. Washington: Employee Benefit Research Institute.

Eckardt, Martina (2005) “The open method of coordination on pensions: an economic analysis of its effects on pension reforms”, Journal of European Social Policy, 15(3): 247-267.

Eckstein, Zvi, Martin Eichenbaum, and Dan Peled (1985) “Uncertain lifetime and the welfare enhancing properties of annuity markets and social security”, Journal of Public Economics, 26: 303–26.

Emmerson, Carl, Howard Reed and Andrew Shephard (2004) An assessment of Pensim2, IFS Working Paper 04/21. London: Institute for Fiscal Studies.

European Central Bank (2009) Workshop on pensions. Frankfurt am Main: European Central Bank. http://www.ecb.int/pub/pdf/other/ecbeurostatworkshoponpensions201002en.pdf

European Commission (2005) Working together, working better: A new framework for the open coordination of social protection and inclusion policies in the European Union, Communication from the Commission to the Council, the European Parliament, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions, COM(2005) 706 final, Brussels: European Commission.

European Commission (2006) Current and prospective theoretical pension replacement rates. Brussels: European Commission.

European Commission (2009) Portfolio of indicators for the monitoring of the European Strategy for Social Protection and Social Inclusion – 2009 update, Brussels: European Commission.

European Commission (2009) The 2009 ageing report: Economic and budgetary projections for the 27 EU Member States (2008-2060), European Economy 2/2009, Brussels: European Commission.

European Commission (2010) Progress and key challenges in the delivery of adequate and sustainable pensions in Europe, European Economy Occasional Papers 71, Brussels: European Commission.

European Commission (2012) An agenda for adequate, safe and sustainable pensions, White Paper COM(2012) 55 final. Brussels: European Commission.

European Commission (2012) The 2012 ageing report: Economic and budgetary projections for the 27 EU Member States (2010-2060), European Economy 2/2012, Brussels: European Commission.

European Commission (2012) Pension adequacy in the European Union 2010-2050, Council of the European Union doc. 10488/12 ADD 1. Brussels: European Commission.

Feldstein, Martin (1974) “Social security, induced retirement and aggregate capital accumulation”, The Journal of Political Economy, Vol.82, No.5, 905-926.

Forster, Michael and Marco Mira D’Ercole (2005) Income distribution and poverty in OECD countries in the second half of the 1990s, Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers No.22, DELSA/ELSA/WD/SEM(2005)1. Paris: OECD.

Frommert, Dina and Thorsten Heien (2006) “Retirement pension provision schemes in Germany 1996 and 2005”, Journal of Applied Social Science Studies, 126(2): 329-336.

Goodin, Robert, Bruce Headey, Ruud Muffels and Henk-Jan Dirven (1999) The real worlds of welfare capitalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Grech, Aaron George (2010) Assessing the sustainability of pension reforms in Europe, CASEpaper 140. London: Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion.

Grech, Aaron George (2012) Evaluating the possible impact of pension reforms on future living standards in Europe, CASEpaper 161. London: Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion.

Gruat, Victor (1998) Adequacy and social security principles in pension reform, Ageing Working Papers 3.1. Paris: OECD.

Holzmann, Robert and Richard Hinz (2005) Old-age income support in the 21st century: An international perspective on pension systems and reform. Washington D.C.: The World Bank.

Humblet, Martine and Rosinda Silva (2002) Standards for the XXIst century: Social Security. Geneva: International Labour Office.

Hurd, Michael and Susan Rohwedder (2008) Adequacy of economic resources in retirement and returns-to-scale in consumption, MRRC Working Paper WP 2008-1974. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan.

International Labour Office (1952) Social Security (Minimum Standards) Convention No.102. Geneva: ILO.

International Labour Office (2001) Social Security: A new consensus. Geneva: ILO.

Kotlikoff, Laurence (1999) The World Bank’s approach and the right approach to pension reform, Mimeo: http://people.bu.edu/kotlikoff/adb.pdf

Jousten, Alain (2007) Public pension reform: A primer, IMF Working Paper WP/07/28. Washington DC: International Monetary Fund.

Madrian, Brigitte, Olivia Mitchell and Beth Soldo (2007) Redefining retirement: How will the boomers fare?. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Mitchell, Olivia S. and John W.R. Phillips (2006), Social Security replacement rates for alternative earnings benchmarks, MRRC Working Paper WP 2006-116. Michigan: University of Michigan.

Modigliani, Franco and Arun Muralidhar (2005) Rethinking pension reform. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Munnell, Alicia and Mauricio Soto (2005) How much pre-retirement income does Social Security replace?, CRR Issue Brief 36. Boston: Center for Retirement Research.

OECD (2005) Pensions at a glance 2005: Public policies across the OECD. Paris: OECD.

OECD (2007) Pensions at a glance 2007: public policies across the OECD. Paris: OECD.

OECD (2011) Pensions at a glance 2011: retirement-income systems in OECD and G20 countries. Paris: OECD.

Orszag, Peter and Joseph Stiglitz (1999) Rethinking pension reform: Ten myths about Social Security systems. Washington D.C.: The World Bank.

Palacios, Roberto and Oleksiy Sluchynsky (2006) Social Pensions – Part I: Their role in the overall pension system, Pension Reform Primer Series Discussion Paper No.0601. Washington DC: World Bank.

Pensions Commission (2004) Pensions: Challenges and choices. London: The Stationery Office.

Rettenmaier, Andrew J. and Thomas R. Saving (2006) How generous are Social Security and Medicare?, NCPA Policy Report No.290. Dallas: National Center for Policy Analysis.

Schneider, Ondrej (2009) Reforming pensions in Europe: Economic fundamentals and political factors, CESifo Working Paper No. 2572. Munich: CESifo Group.

Social Security Administration (2012) The 2012 annual report of the Board of Trustees of the Federal Old-age and Survivors Insurance and Federal Disability Insurance Trust Funds, Washington D.C.: Social Security Administration.

Sutherland, Holly, Ruth Hancock, John Hills and Francesca Zantomio (2009) “Failing to keep up? The long-term effects of current benefit and tax uprating policies”, Benefits, 17(1): 47-56.

Whitehouse, Edward (2003) The value of pension entitlements: A model of nine OECD countries, OECD Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers no.9. Paris: OECD.

World Bank (1994) Averting the Old-Age crisis: Policies to protect the old and promote growth. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

World Bank Independent Evaluation Group (2006) Pension reforms and the development of pension systems: An evaluation of World Bank assistance, Report to the World Bank’s Board of Executive Directors. Washington D.C.: World Bank.

Zaidi, Asghar, Aaron George Grech and Michael Fuchs (2006) Pension policy in EU25 and its possible impact on elderly poverty, CASEpaper 116. London: LSE Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion.

Zaidi, Asghar and Aaron George Grech (2007) “Pension policy in EU25 and its impact on pension benefits”, Benefits: The journal of poverty and social justice, 15(3): 229-311.