Willingness to Pay for Organic Foods: A Comparison between Survey Data and Panel Data from Denmark

Katrin, Millock and Hansen, Lars Gårn (2002): Willingness to Pay for Organic Foods: A Comparison between Survey Data and Panel Data from Denmark. Published in: (2002)

Abstract

We present a project aiming at estimating the willingness to pay for organic foods through panel data and a survey. The panel data is based on weekly reporting of household purchases by 2000 Danish households with information on their demographic and socio-economic characteristics. Detailed information on organic foods exist from 1997. A questionnaire asking consumers to distinguish and rank various food attributes will be sent out to all households in the sample in June 2002. For survey purposes, organic foods are defined as products carrying the Danish state label guaranteeing public control and certification of organic production. The food product attributes include environmental concerns, animal welfare, and food safety (health concerns). Here we present the results from the pilot study sent out in 2001 to 400 randomly chosen households, representatively distributed on geographical regions however. Among the results we note that the order of valued attributes do not differ across organic product types and that avoidance of chemicals is the highest valued attribute. We also present some preliminary estimations on purchase data in order to compare the contingent valuation results with observed willingness to pay. Both valuation methods entail uncertainty, and a comparison may indicate the magnitude of this.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Willingness to Pay Organic Foods
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture

References

Beharrell, B. and J.H. MacFie (1991), "Consumer Attitudes to Organic Foods", British Food Journal, 93: 25-30.

Bjerke, F. (1992), Forbrugernes interesse for økologiske produkter, Roskilde University.

Brombacher, J. (1992), Ökonomische Analyse des Einkaufsverhaltens bei einer Ernährung mit Produkten des Økologischen Landbaus (in German). Institut für Agrarpolitik, Universität Hohenheim. Landwirtschaftverlag, Stuttgart.

Brunsoe, K. (1996), Fødevarerelateret livsstil - udvikling af et måleinstrument til markedsovervågning af forbrugere for fødevareindustrien. PhD dissertation, MAPP center, Aarhus School of Business, Aarhus

Brunsoe, K. and L. Bredahl (1997), ”Fødevarerelaterede livsstile i forskellige europæiske kulturer”, Dansk Sociologi, 8: 23-35.

Bugge, A. and M. Wandel (1995), ”Forbrukerholdninger til moderne matvareproduksjon”, in Landbruksøkonomisk Forum, 12: 15-25.

Byrne, P.J., J.R. Bacon and U.C. Toensmeyer (1994), “Pesticide Residue Concerns and Shopping Location Likelihood”, Agribusiness, 10: 491-501.

Carson, R., N.E. Flores, K.M. Martin and J.L. Wright (1996), "Contingent Valuation and Revealed Preference Methodologies: Comparing the Estimates for Quasi-Public Goods", Land Economics, 72: 80-99.

CMA (1996), Einstellungen und Marktschätzungen aus Verbrauchersicht zu “alternativen Nahrungsmitteln/Biokost/Ökoprodukten” insbesondere zu Obst und Gemüse. MAFO-Briefe. Bestell-Nr. K 621, Centrale Marketing-Gesellschaft der deutschen Agrarwirtschaft, Bonn.

Cook, R. (1991), “Consumer Demand for Food Safety-Oriented Marketing Labels: Implications for Sustainable Agriculture”, paper presented at the International Agricultural Economics Association Meeting, August 1991, Tokyo, Japan

Coopers and Lybrand Deloitte (1992), Going organic - The Future for Organic Food and Drink Products in the UK, Birmingham, UK.

Cummings, R. G. Harrison and E. Rutstrom (1995), "Home-grown values and hypothetical surveys: Is the dichotomous choice approach incentive compatible", American Economic Review 85, 260-266.

Drake, L. and H.Holm (1989), Konsumenternes attityder till alternativt producerat kött - preliminär redovisning av intervju och enkätstudie, Institute of Economics, Uppsala.

Fricke, A. (1996), Das Käuferverhalten bei Öko-Produkten. Eine Längsschnittanalyse unter besonderer Berücksichtigung des Kohortenkonzepts. Europäische Hochschulschriften, Reihe V, Volks- und Betriebswirtschaft, Bd./Vol. 1960, Peter Lang, Frankfurt/M.

Fricke, A. and R. von Alvensleben (1997), “Consumer Attitudes towards Organic Food and an Application of Cohort Analysis - 1984 - 1989 – 1994”. Working Paper No. 1, Lehrstuhl für Agrarmarketing, Christian-Albrechts University, Kiel.

Frykblom, P. (1997), "Hypothetical question modes and real willingness to pay", Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 34, 275-287.

Glaser, L.K. and G.D. Thompson (1998), Demand for Organic and Conventional Frozen Vegetables. Paper presented at the American Agricultural Economics Association Annual Meeting, August 8-11, Nashville, Tennessee.

Glaser, L.K. and G.D. Thompson (2000), Demand for Organic and Conventional Beverage Milk. Paper presented at the Western Agricultural Economics Association Annual Meeting, June 29-July 1, Vancouver, British Columbia.

Grunert, S. and K. Kristensen (1995), Den danske forbruger og økologiske fødevarer, Odense University.

Hack, M.D. (1995), “Organically Grown Products: Perception, Preferences and Motives of Dutch Consumers”, Acta Horticulturae, 340: 247-253.

Haest, C. (1990), “From Farmer to Shelf: Trade of Organically Grown Products”, Ecology and Farming, 1: 9-11.

Hamm, U. and J.Michelsen (1996), “Organic Agriculture in a Market Economy. Perspectives from Germany and Denmark”, in

Østergaard, T. (ed.), Fundamentals of Organic Agriculture - Proceedings from the 11th IFOAM International Scientific Conference, August 11-15, 1996, Copenhagen.

Hansen, J.K. and H. C. Sorensen (1993), The Importance of Price for the Sale of Ecological Products. MAPP working paper no.13, Aarhus School of Business, Aarhus.

Huang, C.L. (1996), “Consumer Preferences and Attitudes Towards Organically Grown Produce”, European Review of Agricultural Economics, 23: 331-342.

Huang, C.L, S. Misra and S.L. Ott (1990), “Modeling Consumer Risk Perception and Choice Behavior: The Case of Chemical Residues in Fresh Produce”, in Mayer, R.N (ed.), Enhancing Consumer Choice, Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Research in the Consumer Interest, Snowbird, Utah, USA, August, 1990, American Council on Consumer Interests, Columbia, Missouri, USA.

Infood (1997), Forbrugernotat.

Infood (1998), Kvalitativ analyse af forbrugernes holdninger til økologiske fødevarer.

Jolly, D.A. (1991), Differences Between Buyers and Nonbuyers of Organic Produce and Willingness to Pay Organic Price Premiums, Journal of Agribusiness, Spring 1991, pp. 97-111.

Jörgensen, C. (2001), Prisbildning och Efterfrågan på Ekologiska Livsmedel (in Swedish). Livsmedelsekonomiska institutet, Lund.

Kafka, C. and R. von Alvensleben (1998), Consumer Perceptions of Food-Related Hazards and the Problem of Risk Communication.

Kramer, C. (1990), “Food safety: The Consumer Side of the Environmental Issue”, Southern Journal of Agricultural Economics, July 1990, pp.33-40.

Krämer, A., B.Harting and S.Stadtfeld (1998), Siegeszug der “Bio-Lebensmittel” im Handel?.

Land, B (1998), “Consumers´ Dietary Patterns and Desires for Change”, MAPP Working paper, No.31, Roskilde University, Roskilde.

McCluskey, J. (2000), "A Game Theoretic Approach to Organic Foods: An Analysis of Asymmetric Information and Policy", Agricultural and Resource Economics Review, 29/1: 1-9.

Meier-Ploeger, A., W. Merkle, I. Mey and F. Wörner (1996), Stärkung des Verbrauchs ökologischer Lebensmittel. Hessisches Ministerium des Innern und für Landwirtschaft, Forsten und Naturschutz, Wiesbaden.

Menghi, A. (1997), Consumer Response to Ecological Milk in Sweden, Swedish Agricultural University, Uppsala.

Michelsen, J., U. Hamm, E. Wynen and E. Roth (1999), The European Market for Organic Products: Growth and Development. Stuttgart-Hohenheim: 1999.

Misra, S., C.L.Huang and S.L.Ott (1991), Consumer Willingness to Pay for Pesticide-Free Fresh Produce, Western Journal of Agricultural Economics, 16:218-227.

Produce Studies (1998), The European Organic Food Market. Final Report. The United States Department of Agriculture, The Hague.

Scan-Ad (1998), Grøn Analyse, Part 1 and 2, Scan-Ad, Odense.

Sylvander, B. (1995), “Conventions on Quality in the Fruit and Vegetables Sector: Results on the Organic Sector”, Acta Horticulture, 340: 241-246.

Thompson, G.D. (1998), “Consumer Demand for Organic Foods: What we know and what we need to know”. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 80: 1113-1118.

Trijp, H.C.M., J-B.E.M. Steenkamp and M.J.J.M. Candel (1997), Quality Labeling as Instrument to Create Product Equity: The case of IKB in the Netherlands, Dordrecth: Kluwer Academic Publishers.

Vogtmann, H. (1988), "Organic Foods: An Analysis of Consumer Attitudes in West Germany", in Allen, P and D. van Dusen (eds.), Global Perspectives on Agroecology and Sustainable Agricultural Systems, Proceedings of the Sixth International Scientific Conference of the International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements, University of California, Santa Cruz.

von Alvensleben, R. (1998), Ecological Aspects of Food Demand: The Case of Organic Food in Germany.

von Alvensleben, R. and Altmann, M. (1986), „Die Nachfrage nach alternativen Nahrungsmitteln“, Agrarwirtschaft, 35: 289-295.

Wier, M. and L. Mørch Andersen (2001), Designing and Testing the Questionnaire - Results and Considerations, Working Paper #3, Project on Consumer Demand for Organic Foods - Domestic and Foreign Market Perspectives, AKF, Denmark.

Wier, M. and C. Calverley (2002), Market Perspectives for Organic Foods in Europe, British Food Journal, 104: 45-62.

Wier, M, L.G. Hansen and S. Smed (2001), Explaining Demand for Organic Foods. Paper for the 11th annual EAERE conference, Southampton, June 2001.