Reti di trasporto nazionale e concorrenza nei mercati del gas: il caso Eni-Snam Rete Gas

Testa, Federico and Stagnaro, Carlo (2011): Reti di trasporto nazionale e concorrenza nei mercati del gas: il caso Eni-Snam Rete Gas. Published in: Sinergie No. 86 (2011): pp. 187-203.

Abstract

In transposing EU Directive 73/2009/CE on natural gas infrastructures into Italy’s national legislation, the country opted for a Independent Transmission Operator (ITO) model instead of full ownership unbundling. ITO allows the essential facility to be controlled by a vertically integrated incumbent who is also in charge of choosing the company’s directors, even though within a strictly regulated context. Regulation applies both to the use of the infrastructure itself and information flow to and from it. This paper explores the costs and benefits of ownership unbundling in the light of the literature. The Italian case is studied by developing a simple econometric model that compares the investment policy of Snam Rete Gas – i.e. the operator of Italy’s natural gas transportation network, which is controlled by the former monopolist Eni - with that of Terna, operator of the electricity transmission grid, which has been unbundled from the formerly-vertically integrated incumbent since 2004.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• English Title: Networks and competition in natural gas markets: the case of Eni-Snam Rete Gas
• Language: Italian
• Keywords: competition; natural gas; regulation;ownership unbundling; essential facility
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D4 - Market Structure, Pricing, and Design > D47 - Market Design; L - Industrial Organization > L1 - Market Structure, Firm Strategy, and Market Performance > L13 - Oligopoly and Other Imperfect Markets; L - Industrial Organization > L4 - Antitrust Issues and Policies > L43 - Legal Monopolies and Regulation or Deregulation; L - Industrial Organization > L9 - Industry Studies: Transportation and Utilities > L95 - Gas Utilities ; Pipelines ; Water Utilities

References

AEEG, “Segnalazione dell’Autorità per l’energia elettrica e il gas al Parlamento e al Governo in merito all’assetto proprietario e gestionale delle reti di trasmissione/trasporto del gas naturale e dell’energia elettrica in occasione della pubblicazione del documento per la consultazione ‘Primi orientamenti in materia di disciplina delle procedure di certificazione delle imprese che agiscono in qualità di gestore di un sistema di trasporto del gas naturale o di trasmissione dell’energia elettrica’ (di cui ai Capi IV, V, VI della Direttiva 2009/72/C, e ai Capi III, IV, V della Direttiva 2009/73/CE)”, PAS 27/10, 2010a.

AEEG, Relazione annuale sullo stato dei servizi e l’attività svolta, disponibile su www.autorita.energia.it, 2010b.

AEEG, “Osservazioni e proposte dell’Autorità per l’energia elettrica e il gas in ordine allo schema di decreto legislativo recante attuazione delle direttive europee 2009/72/CE, 2009/73/CE e 2008/92/CE relative a norme comuni per il mercato interno dell’energia elettrica e del gas naturale”, PAS 10/11, 2011a.

AEEG, Relazione annuale sullo stato dei servizi e l’attività svolta, disponibile su www.autorita.energia.it, 2011b.

AEEG, "Segnalazione dell'Autorità per l'energia elettrica e il gas sullo stato dei mercati dell'energia elettrica e del gas naturale e le relative criticità", PAS 21/11, 2011c.

ALESINA A., ARDAGNA S., NICOLETTI G., SCHIANTARELLI F., “Regulation and Investment”, Journal of the European Economic Association, vol. 3, n. 4, pp. 791-825, 2005.

BAARSMA B., NOOIJ M., KOSTER W., WEIJDEN C., “Divide and rule. The economic and legal implications of the proposed ownership unbundling of distribution and supply companies in the Dutch electricity sector”, Energy Policy, vol. 35, n. 3, pp. 1785-1794, 2007.

BECCARELLO M., PIRON F., La regolazione del mercato del gas naturale, Rubbettino-Facco, Soveria Mannelli (CZ),2008.

BECCARELLO M., FLORO D., “Il mercato del gas naturale”, in STAGNARO C. (a cura di), Indice delle liberalizzazioni 2011, IBL Libri, Torino, pp. 93-114, 2011.

BERTRAND M., DUFLO E., MULLAINATHAN S., “How Much Should We Trust Difference-in-Differences Estimates?”, Mit, Working Paper, n. 01-34, 2001.

BRAU, R., DORONZO, R., FIORIO, C., FLORIO, M., "EU Gas Industry Reforms and Consumers' Prices", The Energy Journal, vol. 31, n. 4, pp. 163-178, 2010.

CAILLAUD B., TIROLE J., “Essential Facility Financing and Market Structure”, Journal of Public Economics, vol. 88, n. 3-4, pp. 667-694, 2004.

CAMBINI, C., RONDI, L., "Incentive Regulation and Investment: Evidence from European Energy Utilities", Journal of Regulatory Economics, vol. 38, n. 1, pp. 1-26, 2010.

CARD D., KRUEGER A.B., “Minimum Wages and Employment: A Case Study of the Fast-Food Industry in New Jersey and Pennsilvanya”, American Economic Review, vol. 84, n. 4, pp. 772-793, 1994.

CLO’ A., “Riflessioni a caldo sull’emergenza gas e dintorni”, Energia, anno XXII, n. 1, pp. 2-13, 2006.

CLO’ A., “Il futuro energetico italiano: il tempo delle scelte”, Energia, anno XXIX, n. 3, pp. 2-14, 2008. COPENHAGEN ECONOMICS, Market Opening in Network Industries: Part II Sectoral Analyses, Copenhagen Economics for DG Internal Market, 2005.

DE PAOLI L., GULLÌ F., “Bilancio della liberalizzazione del mercato dell’elettricità e del gas in Italia: 1999-2009”, Economia delle Fonti di Energia e dell’Ambiente, vol. 53, n. 2, pp. 5-38, 2010.

DORIGONI S., PONTONI F., “Ownership Separation and the Gas Transportation Network: Theory and Practice”, Economia delle Fonti di Energia e dell’Ambiente, vol. 53, n. 2, pp. 57-84, 2010.

ECONOMIDES M.J., GLOVER P.C., Energy and Climate Wars, Continuum Publishing, Londra, 2010.

ERNST AND YOUNG, Final Report Research Project: The Case for Liberalisation, su www.dti.gov.uk, 2006 EUROPEAN COMMISSION, DG Competition Report on Energy Sector Inquiry. Part I, 2007.

GROWITSCH C., STRONZIK M., “Ownership Unbundling of Gas Transmission Networks - Theoretical Background and Empirical Evidence”, paper presentato alla prima conferenza della rivista Competition and Regulation in Network Industries, 18 novembre 2008.

GROWITSCH C., STRONZIK M., " Ownership Unbundling of Gas Transmission Networks - Empirical Evidence", EWI, Working Paper, no.11/7, 2011.

HAASE N., BRESSERS H., “New market designs and their effect on economic performance in European Union's natural gas markets”, paper presentato alla prima conferenza della rivista Competition and Regulation in Network Industries, 18 novembre 2008. HAASE N., European Gas Market Liberalisation, Groningen, Energy Delta Institute, 2009.

HAYEK F.A., “The Use of Knowledge in Society”, American Economic Review, vol. 35, n. 4, pp. 519-530, 1945.

HATTORI T., TSUTSUI M., “Economic Impact of Regulatory Reforms in the Electricity Supply Industry: A Panel Data Analysis for OECD Countries”, Energy Policy, vol. 32, n. 6, pp. 823-832, 2004.

IMBENS G., WOOLRIDGE J., “Difference-in-Differences Estimation”, NBER, Lecture, n. 10, 31 luglio 2007.

JP MORGAN, “Eni”, Europe Equity Research, 7 luglio 2011.

KLEIT A. K., TERRELL D., "Measuring Potential Efficiency Gains from Deregulation of Electricity Generation: A Bayesian Approach", Review of Economics and Statistics, vol. 83, n. 3, pp. 523-530, 2001.

KV, “Eni Valuation”, su www.knightvinke.com, 2010.

KWOKA J. E., Power Structure, Ownership, Integration and Competition in the US Electricity Industry, Boston, Kluwe, 1996.

MARTIN S., VANSTEENKISTE I., "EU Telecommunications and Electricity Markets - Heading Towards Price Convergence?", Intereconomics, maggio-giugno, pp. 131-141, 2001.

MULDER D., SHESTALOVA V., “Costs and benefits of vertical separation of the energy distribution industry: the Dutch case”, Competition and Regulation in Network Industries, vol. 7, n. 2, pp. 197-231, 2006.

NEWBERY D.M.,"Privatising Network Industries", CESifo, Working Paper, n. 1132, 2004.

POLLITT M., “The arguments for and against ownership unbundling of energy transmission networks”, Energy Policy, vol. 36, n. 2, pp. 704-713, 2008.

REBECCHINI S., “La concorrenza nelle reti di trasmissione dell’energia: Italia ed Europa di fronte a un crocevia”, in RABITTI BEDOGNI C., BARUCCI P. (a cura di), 20 Anni di Antitrust, Giappichelli, Torino, 2010.

REY P., TIROLE J., “A Primer on Foreclosure”, in ARMSTRONG M., PORTER R.H. (a cura di), Handbook of Industrial Organization III, North Holland, Amsterdam, 2007.

STAGNARO C., TESTA F., “Non indurli in tentazione. Elementi per una decisione informata su Snam Rete Gas”, IBL, Briefing Paper, n. 98, 2011.

STEINER F., “Regulation, Industry Structure and Performance in the Electricity Supply Industry”, OECD, Economic Studies, n. 32., pp. 143-182, 2001.

VAN KOTEN S., ORTMANN A., “The Unbundling Regime for Electricity Utilities in the EU: A Case of Legislative and Regulatory Capture?”, Charles University Center for Economic Research and Graduate Education Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic Economics Institute, Working Paper, n. 328, 2007.

WADDAMS PRICE C. , "The effect of liberalizing UK retail energy markets on consumers", Oxford Review of Economic Policy, vol. 21, n. 1, pp. 128-144, 2005.

ZHANG Y-F., PARKER D., KIRKPATRICK C., Electricity Sector Reform in Developing Countries: An Econometric Assessment of the Effects of Privatisation, Competition and Regulation, Birmingham, Aston Business School Research Institute, 2002.