Cognitive load in the multi-player prisoner's dilemma game: Are there brains in games?

Duffy, Sean and Smith, John (2012): Cognitive load in the multi-player prisoner's dilemma game: Are there brains in games?

Abstract

We find that differences in the ability to devote cognitive resources to a strategic interaction imply differences in strategic behavior. In our experiment, we manipulated the availability of cognitive resources by applying a differential cognitive load. In cognitive load experiments, subjects are directed to perform a task which occupies cognitive resources, in addition to making a choice in another domain. The greater the cognitive resources required for the task implies that fewer such resources are available for deliberation on the choice. In our experiment, subjects played a finitely repeated multi-player prisoner's dilemma game under two cognitive load treatments. In one treatment, subjects were placed under a high cognitive load (given a 7 digit number to recall) and subjects in the other were placed under a low cognitive load (given a 2 digit number). According to two different measures, we find evidence that the low load subjects behaved more strategically. First, the low load subjects exhibited more strategic defection near the end of play than the high load subjects. Second, we find evidence that low load subjects were better able to condition their behavior on the outcomes of previous periods.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: bounded rationality; experimental economics; experimental game theory; public goods game; strategic sophistication; rational inattention
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C7 - Game Theory and Bargaining Theory > C72 - Noncooperative Games; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C9 - Design of Experiments > C91 - Laboratory, Individual Behavior

References

Agranov, Marina, Caplin, Andrew, and Tergiman, Chloe, 2013. "Naive Play and the Process of Choice in Guessing Games." Working paper, California Institute of Technology.

Allred, Sarah, Duffy, Sean and Smith, John, 2013. "Cognitive Load and Strategic Sophistication." working paper Rutgers University-Camden.

Andreoni, James and Miller, John H., 1993. "Rational Cooperation in the Finitely Repeated Prisoner's Dilemma: Experimental Evidence." Economic Journal 103(418), 570--585.

Arruñada, Benito, Casari, Marco, and Pancotto, Francesca, 2012. "Are Self-regarding Subjects More Rational?" working paper Universita'di Bologna.

Baghestanian, Sascha and Frey, Seth, 2012. "GO Figure: Analytic and Strategic Skills are Separable." working paper, Indiana University.

Ballinger, T. Parker, Hudson, Eric, Karkoviata, Leonie, and Wilcox, Nathaniel T., 2011. "Saving behavior and cognitive abilities." Experimental Economics 14, 349--374.

Bayer, Ralph and Renou, Ludovic, 2012. "Logical abilities and behavior in strategic-form games." working paper University of Essex.

Béal, Sylvain, 2010. "Perceptron versus automaton in the finitely repeated prisoner's dilemma." Theory and Decision 69, 183--204.

Bednar, Jenna, Chen, Yan, Liu, Tracy Xiao, and Page, Scott, 2012. "Behavioral Spillovers and Cognitive Load in Multiple Games: An Experimental Study." Games and Economic Behavior 74(1): 12-31

Benjamin, Daniel, Brown, Sebastian, and Shapiro, Jesse, 2013. "Who is 'Behavioral?' Cognitive Ability and Anomalous Preferences." Journal of the European Economic Association 11(6), 1231--1255..

Ben-Ner, Avner, Kong, Fanmin and Putterman, Louis, 2004. "Share and share alike? Gender-pairing, personality, and cognitive ability as determinants of giving." Journal of Economic Psychology 25, 581--589.

Brañas-Garza, Pablo, Meloso, Debrah and Miller, Luis, 2012. "Interactive and moral reasoning: A comparative study of response times." working paper Bocconi University.

Brañas-Garza, Pablo, Garcia-Muñoz, Teresa and Hernan Gonzalez, Roberto, 2012. "Cognitive effort in the Beauty Contest Game." Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 83(2), 254--260.

Brañas-Garza, Pablo, Guillen, Pablo and Lopez del Paso, Rafael, 2008. "Math skills and risk attitudes." Economics Letters 99, 332--336.

Brañas-Garza, Pablo, Paz Espinosa, Maria and Rey-Biel, Pedro, 2011. "Travelers' types." Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 78, 25--36.

Brandstätter, Hernann and Güth, Werner, 2002. "Personality in Dictator and Ultimatum Games." Central European Journal of Operations Research 10(3), 191--215.

Buckert, Magdalena, Oechssler, Jörg, and Schwieren, Christiane, 2013. "Imitation under stress." working paper University of Heidelberg.

Burchardi, Konrad B. and Penczynski, Stefan P., 2013. "Out Of Your Mind: Eliciting Individual Reasoning in One Shot Games." Games and Economic Behavior, forthcoming.

Burgess, Gregory C. Gray, Jeremy R., Conway, Andrew R.A., Braver, Todd S., 2011. "Neural Mechanisms of Interference Control Underlie the Relationship Between Fluid Intelligence and Working Memory Span." Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 140(4), 674--692.

Burks, Stephen V., Carpenter, Jeffrey P., Götte, Lorenz and Rustichini, Aldo, 2009. "Cognitive Skills Explain Economic Preferences, Strategic Behavior, and Job Attachment." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 106(19), 7745--7750.

Burnham, Terence C., Cesarini, David, Johannesson, Magnus, Lichtenstein, Paul and Wallace, Björn, 2009. "Higher cognitive ability is associated with lower entries in a p-beauty contest." Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 72, 171--175.

Camerer, Colin F., Ho, Teck-Hua, and Chong, Juin Kuan, 2004. "A Cognitive Hierarchy Model of Games." Quarterly Journal of Economics 119(3), 861--898.

Camerer, Colin F., and Hogarth, Robin M., 1999. "The effects of financial incentives in experiments: a review and capital-labor-production framework." Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 19(1-3), 7--42.

Camerer, Colin F., Johnson, Eric J., Rymon, Talia and Sen, Sankar, 1993. "Cognition and Framing in Sequential Bargaining for Gains and Losses." In Binmore, Ken, Kirman, Alan and Tani, Piero (Eds.), Frontiers of Game Theory, 27--47. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Cappelletti, Dominique, Güth, Werner, and Ploner, Matteo, 2011. "Being of two minds: Ultimatum offers under cognitive constraints." Journal of Economic Psychology 32(6), 940--950.

Carpenter, Jeffrey, Graham, Michael and Wolf, Jesse, 2013. "Cognitive Ability and Strategic Sophistication." Games and Economic Behavior 80(1), 115--130.

Chen, Chia-Ching, Chiu, I-Ming, Smith, John, and Yamada, Tetsuji, 2013. "Too smart to be selfish? Measures of intelligence, social preferences, and consistency." Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 90, 112--122.

Chen, Chun-Ting, Huang, Chen-Ying and Wang, Joseph Tao-yi, 2010. "A Window of Cognition: Eyetracking the Reasoning Process in Spatial Beauty Contest Games." working paper National Taiwan University.

Chen, Shu-Heng, Du, Ye-Rong, and Yang, Lee-Xieng, 2013. "Cognitive capacity and cognitive hierarchy: a study based on beauty contest experiments." Journal of Economic Interaction and Coordination, forthcoming.

Cheremukhin, Anton, Popova, Anna and Tutino, Antonella, 2012. "Rationalizing Variations in Behavioral Decisions." working paper Federal Reserve of Dallas.

Conway, Andrew R.A. and Getz, Sarah J., 2010. "Cognitive Ability: Does Working Memory Training Enhance Intelligence?" Current Biology 20(8), R362--R364.

Conway, Andrew R.A., Kane, Michael J., and Engle, Randall W., 2003. "Working memory capacity and its relation to general intelligence." Trends in Cognitive Sciences 7(12), 547--552.

Coricelli, Giorgio and Nagel, Rosemarie, 2009. "Neural correlates of depth of strategic reasoning in medial prefrontal cortex." Proceeings of the National Academy of Science 106 (23), 9163--9168.

Coricelli, Giorgio and Nagel, Rosemarie, 2012. "The neural basis of bounded rational behavior." Revista Internacional de Sociología 70, 39--52.

Cornelissen, Gert , Dewitte, Siegfried, Warlop, Luk, and Yzerbyt, Vincent, 2007. "Whatever people say I am, that's what I am: Social labeling as a social marketing tool." International Journal of Research in Marketing 24, 278--288.

Cornelissen, Gert, Dewitte, Siegfried, and Warlop, Luk, 2011. "Are Social Value Orientations expressed automatically? Decision making in the dictator game." Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 37(8), 1080--1090.

Costa-Gomes, Miguel A., Crawford, Vincent P. and Broseta, Bruno, 2001. "Cognition and Behavior in Normal-Form Games: An Experimental Study." Econometrica 69(5), 1193--1235.

Costa-Gomes, Miguel A., and Crawford, Vincent P., 2006. "Cognition and Behavior in Two-Person Guessing Games: An Experimental Study." American Economic Review 96(5), 1737--1768.

Cowan, Nelson, 2001. "The magical number 4 in short-term memory: A reconsideration of mental storage capacity." Behavioral and Brain Sciences 24(1), 87--185.

Crawford, Vincent P., 2008. "Look-ups as the Windows of the Strategic Soul." In Caplin, Andrew and Schotter, Andrew (Eds.) The Foundations of Positive and Normative Economics: A Handbook, 249--280. Oxfort: Oxford University Press.

Crawford, Vincent P., Costa-Gomes, Miguel A. and Iriberri, Nagore, 2013. "Structural Models of Nonequilibrium Strategic Thinking: Theory, Evidence, and Applications." Journal of Economic Literature 51(1), 5--62.

Dahremöller, Carsten and Fels, Markus, 2012. "Product Lines, Product Design and Limited Attention." Working paper, Bonn Graduate School of Economics.

Deck, Cary and Jahedi, Salar, 2013. "The Effect of Cognitive Load on Economic Decisions." working paper, University of Arkansas.

Devetag, Giovanna and Warglien, Massimo, 2003. "Games and phone numbers: Do short-term memory bounds affect strategic behavior?" Journal of Economic Psychology 24, 189--202.

Dewitte, Siegfried, Pandelaere, Mario, Briers, Barbara, and Warlop, Luk, 2005. "Cognitive load has negative after effects on consumer decision making." working paper Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium.

Dohmen, Thomas, Falk, Armin, Huffman, David, and Sunde, Uwe, 2010. "Are Risk Aversion and Impatience Related to Cognitive Ability?" American Economic Review 100(3), 1238--1260.

Fischbacher, Urs, 2007. "z-Tree: Zurich Toolbox for Ready-made Economic Experiments." Experimental Economics 10(2), 171--178.

Frank, Björn, 2010. "The effects of enforced reflection in three simple experiments." working paper University of Marburg.

Frederick, Shane, 2005. "Cognitive Reflection and Decision Making." Journal of Economic Perspectives 19(4), 25--42.

Georganas, Sotiris, Healy, Paul J., and Weber, Roberto A., 2010. "On the Persistence of Strategic Sophistication." working paper Ohio State University.

Gilbert, Daniel T., Pelham, Brett W., and Krull, Douglas S., 1988. "On Cognitive Busyness: When Person Perceivers Meet Persons Perceived." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 54 (5), 733--740.

Gill, David and Prowse, Victoria, 2012. "Cognitive ability and learning to play equilibrium: A level-k analysis." working paper Oxford University and Cornell University.

Hauge, Karen Evelyn, Brekke, Kjell Arne, Johansson, Lars-Olof, Johansson-Stenman, Olof, and Svedsäter, Henrik, 2009. "Are Social Preferences Skin Deep? Dictators under Cognitive Load." working paper University of Gothenburg.

Hinson, John M., Jameson, Tina L., and Whitney, Paul, 2002. "Somatic markers, working memory, and decision making." Cognitive, Affective, and Behavioral Neuroscience 2(4), 341--353.

Hinson, John M., Jameson, Tina L., and Whitney, Paul, 2003. "Impulsive Decision Making and Working Memory." Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 29(2), 298--306.

Hogarth, Robin M., 1975. "Decision time as a function of task complexity." In Wendt, Dirk and Vlek, Charles (Eds.), Utility, probability, and human decision making, 321--338. Boston: D. Reidel Publishing.

Johnson, Eric J., Camerer, Colin, Sen, Sankar, and Rymon, Talia, 2002. "Detecting Failures of Backward Induction Monitoring Information Search in Sequential Bargaining." Journal of Economic Theory 104, 16--47.

Jones, Garett, 2008. "Are smarter groups more cooperative? Evidence from prisoner's dilemma experiments, 1959-2003." Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 68, 489--497.

Jones, Matthew T., 2013. "Strategic Complexity and Cooperation: An Experimental Study." working paper Federal Trade Commission.

Keser, Claudia and van Winden, Frans, 2000. "Conditional Cooperation and Voluntary Contributions to Public Goods." Scandinavian Journal of Economics 102(1), 23--39.

Komorita, S. S., Sweeney, James, and Kravitz, David A., 1980. "Cooperative Choice in the N-Person Dilemma Situation." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 38 (3), 504--516.

Maćkowiak, Bartosz and Wiederholt, Mirko, 2009. "Optimal sticky prices under rational inattention." American Economic Review 99(3), 769--803.

Matthey, Astrid and Regner, Tobias, 2011. "Do I Really Want to Know? A Cognitive Dissonance-Based Explanation of Other-Regarding Behavior." Games 2, 114--135.

Milinski, Manfred, and Wedekind, Claus, 1998. "Working memory constrains human cooperation in the Prisoner's Dilemma." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 95(23), 13755--13758.

Miller, George, 1956. "The magical number seven, plus or minus two: Some limits on our capacity for processing information." Psychological Review 63 (2), 343--355.

Millet, Kobe and Dewitte, Siegfried, 2007. "Altruistic Behavior as a Costly Signal of General Intelligence." Journal of Research in Personality 41, 316--326.

Nagel, Rosemarie, 1995. "Unraveling in Guessing Games: An Experimental Study." American Economic Review 85(5), 1313--1326.

Neyman, Abraham, 1985. "Bounded complexity justifies the cooperation in the finitely repeated prisoner's dilemma." Economic Letters 19, 227--229.

Neyman, Abraham, 1998. "Finitely repeated games with finite automata." Mathematics of Operations Research 23, 513--552.

Oechssler, Jörg, Roider, Andreas and Schmitz, Patrick W., 2009. "Cognitive abilities and behavioral biases." Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 72, 147--152.

Palacios-Huerta, Ignacio, 2003. "Learning to Open Monty Hall's Doors." Experimental Economics 6(3), 235--251.

Pan, Wei, 2001. "Akaike's Information Criterion in Generalized Estimating Equations." Biometrics 57, 120--125.

Persson, Petra, 2012. "Attention Manipulation and Information Overload." Working paper, Columbia University.

Piovesan, Marco and Wengström, Erik, 2009. "Fast or Fair? A Study of Response Times." Economics Letters 105, 193--196.

Putterman, Louis, Tyran, Jean-Robert and Kamei, Kenju, 2011. "Public goods and voting on formal sanction schemes." Journal of Public Economics 95, 1213--1222.

Rand, David G., Greene, Joshua D. and Nowak, Martin A., 2012. "Spontaneous giving and calculated greed." Nature 489, 427--430.

Reis, Ricardo, 2006. "Inattentive consumers." Journal of Monetary Economics 53, 1761--1800.

Roch, Sylvia G., Lane, John A. S., Samuelson, Charles D., Allison, Scott T. and Dent, Jennifer L., 2000. "Cognitive Load and the Equality Heuristic: A Two-Stage Model of Resource Overconsumption in Small Groups." Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 83(2), 185--212.

Rubinstein, Ariel, 2007. "Instinctive and Cognitive Reasoning: A Study of Response Times." Economic Journal 117, 1243--1259.

Rydval, Ondrej, 2011. "The Causal Effect of Cognitive Abilities on Economic Behavior: Evidence from a Forecasting Task with Varying Cognitive Load." working paper CERGE-EI.

Rydval, Ondrej and Ortmann, Andreas, 2004. "How financial incentives and cognitive abilities affect task performance in laboratory settings: an illustration." Economics Letters 85, 315--320.

Sanjurjo, Adam, 2012a. "Search, Memory, and Choice: An Experiment." Working paper. University of Alacant.

Sanjurjo, Adam, 2012b. "Using a Model of Memory Load to Explain Deviations from Optimal Search." Working paper. University of Alacant.

Savikhin, Anya and Sheremeta, Roman M., 2013. "Simultaneous Decision-Making in Competitive and Cooperative Environments." Economic Inquiry 51(2), 1311--1323.

Schnusenberg, Oliver and Gallo, Andrés, 2011. "On cognitive ability and learning in a beauty contest." Journal for Economic Educators 11(1), 13--24.

Schulz, Jonathan F., Fischbacher, Urs, Thöni, Christian, Utikal, Verena, 2012. "Affect and fairness: Dictator games under cognitive load." Journal of Economic Psychology forthcoming.

Shiv, Baba and Fedorikhin, Alexander, 1999. "Heart and Mind in Conflict: The Interplay of Affect and Cognition in Consumer Decision Making." Journal of Consumer Research 26(3), 278--292.

Sims, Christopher, 2003. "Implications of Rational Inattention." Journal of Monetary Economics 50(3), 665--690.

Stahl, Dale and Wilson, Paul, 1994. "Experimental Evidence on Players' Models of Other Players." Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 25, 309--327.

Stahl, Dale, and Wilson, Paul, 1995. "On Players' Models of Other Players: Theory and Experimental Evidence." Games and Economic Behavior 10, 218--254.

Süß, Heinz-Martin, Oberauer, Klaus, Wittmann, Werner W., Wilhelm, Oliver and Schulze, Ralf, 2002. "Working-memory capacity explains reasoning ability---and a little bit more." Intelligence 30(3), 261--288.

Swann, William B., Hixon, Gregory, Stein-Seroussi, Alan, and Gilbert, Daniel T., 1990. "The Fleeting Gleam of Praise: Cognitive Processes Underlying Behavioral Reactions to Self-Relevant Feedback." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 59 (1), 17--26.

Van den Bos, Kees, Peters, Susanne L., Bobocel, D. Ramona, and Ybema, Jan Fekke, 2006. "On preferences and doing the right thing: Satisfaction with advantageous inequity when cognitive processing is limited." Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 42, 273--289.

Wang, Joseph Tao-yi, Spezio, Michael and Camerer, Colin F., 2010. "Pinocchio's Pupil: Using Eyetracking and Pupil Dilation To Understand Truth Telling and Deception in Sender-Receiver Games." American Economic Review 100(3), 984--1007.

Ward, Andrew and Mann, Traci, 2000. "Don't Mind If I Do: Disinhibited Eating Under Cognitive Load." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 78 (4), 753--763.

Wiederholt, Mirko, 2010. "Rational Inattention." In Durlauf, Steven and Blume, Lawrence (Eds.) The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, Online Edition. Palgrave Macmillan.