The Political Economy of Global Outsourcing

Sharma, Chanchal Kumar (2004): The Political Economy of Global Outsourcing. Published in: South Asian Journal of Socio-political studies (SAJOSPS) , Vol. Vol:5, No. No: 2 (June 2005): pp. 76-82.

Abstract

What is outsourcing and why India is being considered as BPO destination of the world? Why jobs are coming to India and why there is a downturn in the US economy and loss of jobs in that country. Even though these are two different things that happened simultaneously, they sadly managed to be mixed up. Academicians are groping to understand the phenomenon and are still in the process of disentangling themselves from the wave of confusion that exists. Politicization of the issue has made the concept of outsourcing a highly debatable, perplexing and controversial. The debate has conceptual, moral, economic, political and policy dimensions. The debate centers on the theoretical issue of globalization verses protectionism. In addition, it has a moral and human dimension that compels one to ponder over the hopeless uncertainty and misery that has dawned upon of those displaced due to outsourcing in the developed countries. Apart from these, there are certain practical policy issues that have become part of the debate such as theft of crucial information by the offshore workers, threat to the safety of Intellectual Property and the concern over the quality of services being delivered by the BPO companies in India and other developing countries. Finally the political dimension of this contentious issue that has forced the federal government of USA to make a law against outsourcing of the government contracts cannot be ignored. A fall out of Globalization, outsourcing is being discussed around the world from a renewed perspective, sometimes with delight and at other times with fury, depending upon which side of outsourcing the person is supporting. Taking exception from the subjective and partial treatment as the supporters and opponents of the phenomenon around the globe are offering, like six blind men trying to expound the outlines of an elephant the paper deals with the theme in its totality, while avoiding the prejudiced approach of a religious enthusiast. To the supporters the problem of job loss is not very serious thus they oppose protectionist attitude of the U.S government. But the fact is that the problem of job loss is quite critical yet pursuing protectionism as stipulated by the opponents is not a solution. Supporters have relied upon the traditional ‘job replacement argument’ to dissipate the fears regarding job loss. But it has been argued that the problem of job loss is serious and no replacements are going to take place in near future to substitute the quantum of jobs being lost. Thus unemployment, intended or unintended, will be the consequence. But protectionism, far from solving the problem, will create the new ones. Paper suggests certain alternatives on the basis of the model of job-protection exemplified by the British government.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Additional Information: Edited by Dr. M.R.Biju
• Language: English
• Keywords: Outsoursing; Bpo; USA; India; Political Economy
• Subjects: Y - Miscellaneous Categories > Y8 - Related Disciplines; G - Financial Economics > G0 - General; Z - Other Special Topics > Z0 - General

References

Bardhan, Ashok Deo and Kroll, Cynthia (2003), The New Wave of Outsourcing, Fisher Center Research Reports: Report No:1103. Fisher Center for Real Estate & Urban Economics. UC Berkeley's Haas School of Business, USA, November, 2, 2003.

Evalueserve NASSCOM report (2003), Impact of Global Sourcing on the US Economy, 2003 – 2010. NASSCOM, New Delhi, October 9, 2003.

Lappe, Frances Moore and Lappe, Anna (2002), Hope's Edge: The Next Diet for a Small Planet J. P. Tarcher Publications (January 31, 2002) ISBN: 1585421499.

Mander, Jerry and Goldsmith, Edward (1997), The Case Against the Global Economy : For a Turn Toward the Local, Sierra Club Books; (September 23, 1997) ISBN: 0871568659.

Martorelli, William (2004), “Best Practices in Offshore Outsourcing: A Sampling From Two Recent User Conferences”, Idea Byte RIB-012004-00011.Forrester Research Inc Cambridge, USA January 5, 2004.

McCulloch J. R., (Ed), (1881), The Works of David Ricardo, London: John Murray.

Finch Julia (2003) “In India, it's service with a compulsory smile”, The Guardian, November 17, 2003.

Moore Stephanie (2002) “IT Trends 2003: Offshore Outsourcing”, Idea Bite, RIB-102002-00184 Giga Information group, inc , USA. , October 21, 2002.

Moore Stephanie (2003), “IT Trends 2004: Offshore Outsourcing”, Planning Assumption, RPA-122003-00014 Giga Research. (a wholly owned subsidiary of Forrester Research, Inc. since Feb,2003) Forrester Research Inc. Cambridge, Mass. 02139 USA, December 17, 2003. Ricardo David (1817), The Principles of Political Economy and Taxation, London, John Murray, Albemarle Street, 1817.

Ricardo David (1815), An Essay on Profits , London, John Murray, Albemarle Street, 1815.

Sharma,.Chanchal Kumar (2004), “BPO Business: It’s A Win-Win Situation”, The Financial World, Vol III No.276. February 13, 2004

Sharma, Chanchal Kumar (2004), “Why the Outsourcing hungama”, The Tribune, Chandigarh. Feb.23, 2004. Also Available at: http://www.tribuneindia.com/2004/20040223/login/main1.htm

Sharma, Chanchal Kumar (2004), “BPO Tide: Political Economic and Moral Overtones.” M-World, The Journal of Ludhiana Management Association, Vol.2, issue 3 Oct-Dec, 2003.

US Bureau of Labor Statistics, National Compensation Survey, July 2002