Resolving the Halperín Paradox: The Terms of Trade and Argentina’s Expansion in the Long Nineteenth Century

Francis, Joseph A. (2014): Resolving the Halperín Paradox: The Terms of Trade and Argentina’s Expansion in the Long Nineteenth Century.

Abstract

Since the pioneering work of Tulio Halperín Donghi, historians have tried to explain why Argentina experienced a dramatic pastoral expansion in the first half of the nineteenth century even though there were no price incentives for increasing output. Here this ‘Halperín paradox’ is resolved by correcting the methodological error that underlies it. Halperín Donghi made the mistake of looking at the nominal prices of Argentina’s exports in Britain, whereas he should have looked at their prices in Argentina deflated by the prices of the country’s imports – that is, its terms of trade. When this methodological error is corrected, a massive term-of-trade boom can be seen from the 1780s through to the First World War. It is likely that Argentina’s terms of trade improved by at least 2,000 percent over this period, so there were considerable price incentives for the expansion on the Pampas. With the Halperín paradox resolved, future research should look less at the Pampean zone and more at the effects of the terms-of-trade boom on the relatively land-scarce regions of the Interior.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Argentina; nineteenth century; terms of trade; expansion.
• Subjects: N - Economic History > N9 - Regional and Urban History > N96 - Latin America ; Caribbean

References

Adelman, J., Republic of Capital: Buenos Aires and the Legal Transformation of the Atlantic World, Stanford, 1999.

Álvarez, J., Temas de historia económica argentina, Buenos Aires, 1929.

Amaral, S., ‘Free Trade and Regional Economies: San Juan and Mendoza, 1780-1820’, in M.D. Szuchman and J.C. Brown, eds., Revolution and Restoration: The Rearrangement of Power in Argentina 1860, Lincoln, NE, 1994, pp. 124-49.

Amaral, S., The Rise of Capitalism on the Pampas: The Estancias of Buenos Aires, 1785-1870, Cambridge, 1998.

An Englishman, A Five Years Residence in Buenos Ayres During the Years 1820 to 1825, 2nd ed., London, 1827.

Anon., ‘Report on the Trade of the River Plate’, 1824, reproduced in R.A. Humphreys, British Consular Reports on the Trade and Politics of Latin America 1824-26, London, (1824) 1940, p. 28-54.

Anon., ‘Precios corrientes de productos en Buenos Aires en los años 1821, 1822 y 1823’, in E.M. Barba, ed., Informes sobre el comercio exterior de Buenos Aires durante el gobierno de Martín Rodríguez, Buenos Aires, (1824) 1978, p. 60.

Arroyo Abad, L., ‘Persistent Inequality? Trade, Factor Endowments, and Inequality in Republican Latin America’, Economic History Review, 73:1, 2013, pp. 38-78.

Assadourian, C.S., El sistema de la economía colonial: Mercado interno, regiones y espacio económico, Lima, 1982.

Assadourian, C.S., and S. Palomeque, ‘Las relaciones mercantiles de Córdoba (1800-1830): Desarticulación y desmonetización del mercado interno colonial en el nacimiento del espacio económico nacional’, in M.A. Irigoin and R. Schmit, eds., La desintegración de la economía colonial: Comercio y moneda en el interior del espacio colonial (1800-1860), Buenos Aires, 2003, pp. 201-16.

Balboa, M., ‘La evolución del balance de pagos de la República Argentina, 1913-1950’, Desarrollo Económico, 12:45, 1972, pp. 151-72.

Barbier, J.A., and H.S. Klein, ‘Revolutionary Wars and Public Finance: The Madrid Treasury, 1784-1807’, Journal of Economic History, 41:2, 1981, pp. 315-39.

Blattman, C., J. Hwang, and J.G. Williamson, ‘Winners and Losers in the Commodity Lottery: The Impact of Terms of Trade Growth and Volatility in the Periphery 1870-1939’, Journal of Development Economics, 82:1, 2007, pp. 156-79.

Bragoni, B., ‘Condiciones y estímulos en la recuperación de una economía regional: Prácticas mercantiles e instituciones empresarias en Mendoza, 1820-1880’, in M.A. Irigoin and R. Schmit, eds., La desintegración de la economía colonial: Comercio y moneda en el interior del espacio colonial (1800-1860), Buenos Aires, 2003, pp. 278-79.

Broide, J., ‘La evolución de los precios pecuarios argentinos en el periodo 1830-1850’, mimeo, 1951; also published in Revista de la Facultad de Ciencias Económicas, 4:32, 1951, pp. 113-83.

Buenos Ayres, Gazeta, 1, 1810.

Bunge, A., Intercambio económico de la República, 1910-1917, Buenos Aires, 1919.

Burgin, M., The Economic Aspects of Argentine Federalism 1820-1852, Cambridge, MA, 1946.

Cárcano, M.A., Evolución histórica del régimen de la tierra pública 1810-1916, 3rd ed., Buenos Aires, 1972.

Chilosi, D., and G. Federico, ‘Asian Globalizations: Market Integration, Trade and Economic Growth, 1800-1938’, Economic History Working Paper 183, London School of Economics and Political Science, 2013.

Comadrán Ruiz, J., Evolución demográfica argentina durante el período hispano: 1535-1810, Buenos Aires, 1969.

Comisión Directiva, Segundo censo de la República Argentina, II, Población, Buenos Aires, 1898.

Comisión Nacional del Censo (CNC), Tercer censo nacional, III, Población, Buenos Aires, 1916.

Comisión Nacional del Censo (CNC), Tercer censo nacional, IV, Población, Buenos Aires, 1916.

Cortés Conde, R., El progreso argentino: 1880-1914, Buenos Aires, 1979.

Cortés Conde, R., ‘The Export Economy of Argentina 1880-1920’, in idem and S.J. Hunt, eds., The Latin American Economies: Growth and the Export Sector 1880-1930, New York, 1985, pp. 319-31.

Cortés Conde, R., ‘The Growth of the Argentine Economy, c. 1870-1914’, in L. Bethall, ed., The Cambridge History of Latin America, V, c. 1870-1930, Cambridge, 1986, pp. 327-57.

Cortés Conde, R., ‘Export-Led Growth in Latin America: 1870-1930’, Journal of Latin American Studies, 24, Quincentenary Supplement, 1992, pp. 163-79.

Cortés Conde, R., La economía argentina en el largo plazo: Ensayos de historia económica de los siglos XIX y XX, Buenos Aires, 1997.

Cortés Conde, R., ‘The Vicissitudes of an Exporting Economy: Argentina (1975-1930)’, in E. Cárdenas, J.A. Ocampo, and R. Thorp, eds., An Economic History of Twentieth-Century Latin America, I, The Export Age, Oxford, 2000, pp. 265-98.

Cortés Conde, R., T. Halperin Donghi, and H. Gorostegui de Torres, ‘Evolución del comercio exterior argentino: Tomo I Exportaciones: Parte primera 1864-1930’, mimeo, 1965.

Cuenca Esteban, J., ‘The Rising Share of British Industrial Exports in Industrial Output, 1700- 1851’, Journal of Economic History, 57:4, 1997, pp. 879-906.

Cuenca Esteban, J., ‘Was Spain a Viable Fiscal-Military State on the Eve of the French Wars?’, in S. Conway and R. Torres Sánchez, eds., The Spending of States: Military Expenditure During the Long Eighteenth Century: Patterns, Organisation, and Consequences, 1650-1815, Saarbrücken, 2011, pp. 247-56.

Diéguez, H., ‘Crecimiento e inestablidad del valor y el volumen físico de las exportaciones argentinas en el periodo, 1864-1963’, Desarrollo Económico, 12:46, 1972, pp. 333-49.

Dirección General de Estadística de la Nación (DGEN), Extracto estadístico de la República Argentina correspondiente al año 1915, Buenos Aires, 1916. Di Tella, G., and M. Zymelman, Las etapas del desarrollo económico argentino, Buenos Aires, 1973.

Federico, G., S. Natoli, G. Tattara, and M. Vasta, Il commercio estero italiano 1862-1950, Rome, 2011.

Feinstein, C.H., National Income, Expenditure and Output of the United Kingdom, 1855-1965, Cambridge, 1972.

Ferns, H.S., Britain and Argentina in the Nineteenth Century, Oxford, 1960.

Ferreres, O.J., Dos siglos de economía argentina, 1810-2004: Historia argentina en cifras, Buenos Aires, 2005.

Ford, A.G., ‘Export Price Indices for the Argentine Republic, 1881-1914’, Inter-American Economic Affairs, 9:2, 1955, pp. 42-54.

Francis, J.A., ‘The Terms of Trade and the Rise of Argentina in the Long Nineteenth Century’, PhD diss., London School of Economics and Political Science, 2013.

Francis, J.A., ‘The Periphery’s Terms of Trade in the Nineteenth Century: A Methodological Problem Revisited’, Technical Paper 1, 2014, online at http://www.joefrancis.info/pdfs/Francis_TP_1.pdf (accessed 8 August 2014).

Garavaglia, J.C., ‘La economía rural de la campaña de Buenos Aires vista a través de sus precios: 1756-1852’, in R. Fradkin and J.C. Garavaglia, eds. En busca de un tiempo perdido: La economía de Buenos Aires en el país de la abundancia, 1750-1865, Buenos Aires, 2004, pp. 119-29.

Gayer, A.D., W.W. Rostow, and A.J. Schwartz, The Growth and Fluctuation of the British Economy 1790-1850, I and II, Oxford, 1953.

Grafe, R., and M.A. Irigoin, ‘The Spanish Empire and Its Legacy: Fiscal Redistribution and Political Conflict in Colonial and Post-Colonial Spanish America’, Journal of Global History, 1:2, 2006, pp. 241-67.

Halperín Donghi, T., ‘La expansión ganadera en la campaña de Buenos Aires (1810-1852)’, Desarrollo Económico, 3:1/2, 1963, pp. 57-110.

Halperín Donghi, T., ‘La expansión de la frontera de Buenos Aires (1810-1852)’, in A. Jara, ed., Tierras nuevas: Expansión territorial y ocupación del suelo en América (siglos xvi-xix), México, DF, 1969, pp. 77-91.

Halperín Donghi, T., Politics, Economics and Society in Argentina in the Revolutionary Period, Cambridge, 1975.

Halperín Donghi, T., Guerra y finanzas en los origenes del Estado argentino (1791-1850), Buenos Aires, (1982) 2005.

Halperín Donghi, T., ‘The Buenos Aires Landed Class and the Shape of Argentine Politics (1820-1930)’, in E. Huber and F. Safford, eds., Agrarian Structure & Political Power: Landlord & Peasant in the Making of Latin America, Pittsburgh, 1995, pp. 39-66.

Hermitte, E., and H.S. Klein, ‘Crecimiento y estructura de una comunidad provinciana de tejedores de ponchos: Belén, 1678-1869’, Documento de Trabajo 78, Centro de Investigaciones Sociales, Instituto Torcuato Di Tella, 1972.

Hill, R.J., and K.J. Fox, ‘Splicing Index Numbers’, Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, 15:3, 1997, pp. 387-89.

Hoffmann, W.G., Das Wachstum der deutschen Wirtschaft seit der Mitte des 19. Jahrhunderts, Berlin, 1965.

Hora, R., ‘Landowning Bourgeoisie or Business Bourgeoisie? On the Peculiarities of the Argentine Economic Elite, 1880-1945’, Journal of Latin American Studies, 34:3, 2002, pp. 587-623.

Hora, R., ‘El perfil económico de la elite de Buenos Aires en las décadas centrales del siglo XIX’, Revista de Historia Económica, 24:2, 2006, pp. 297-332.

Hora, R., ‘La evolución de la desigualdad en la Argentina del siglo XIX: Una agenda en construcción’, Desarrollo Económico, 47:187, 2007, pp. 487-501.

Imlah, A.H., Economic Elements in the Pax Britannica: Studies in British Foreign Trade in the Nineteenth Century, Cambridge, MA, 1958.

Infesta, M.E., ‘Aportes para el estudio del poblamiento de la frontera del Salado’, in Archivo Histórico de la Provincia de Buenos Aires, ed., Estudios sobre la Provincia de Buenos Aires, La Plata, 1991, pp. 61-76.

Infesta, M.E., ‘La enfiteusis en Buenos Aires, 1820-1850’, in S. Amaral and M. Valencia, eds., Argentina: El país puevo: Problemas de historian económica, 1800-1914, La Plata, 1999, pp. 89-115.

Infesta, M.E., La pampa criolla: Usufructo y apropiación privada de tierras públicas en Buenos Aires, 1820-1850, Mar del Plata, 2006.

Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística (IBGE), Estatísticas Históricas do Brasil: Séries Econômicas Demográficas e Sociais de 1550 a 1988, 2nd ed., Rio de Janeiro, 1990.

International Monetary Fund, Producer Price Index: Theory and Practice, Washington, DC, 2004.

Irigoin, A., ‘Finance, Politics and Economics in Buenos Aires, 1820s-1860s: The Political Economy of Currency Stabilisation’, PhD diss., University of London, 2000.

Irigoin, A., ‘Inconvertible Paper Money, Inflation and Economic Performance in Early Nineteenth Century Argentina’, Journal of Latin American Studies, 32:2, 2000, pp. 333-59.

Irwin, D.A., ‘Exports and Imports of Merchandise – Price Indexes and Terms of Trade: 1790-2002’, in S.B. Carter, S.S. Gartner, M.R. Haines, A.L. Olmstead, R. Sutch, and G. Wright, eds., Historical Statistics of the United States: Earliest Times to the Present: Millennial Edition, New York, 2006, online at http://hsus.cambridge.org/HSUSWeb/HSUSEntryServlet (accessed 15 November 2013).

Jastram, R.W., Silver: The Restless Metal, New York, 1981.

Jacks, D.S., K.H. O’Rourke, and J.G. Williamson, ‘Commodity Price Volatility and World Market Integration since 1700’, Review of Economics and Statistics, 93:3, 2011, pp. 800-13.

Johnson, L.L., ‘Distribution of Wealth in Nineteenth-Century Buenos Aires Province: The Issue of Social Justice in a Changing Economy’, in K.J. Andrien and L.L. Johnson, eds., The Political Economy of Spanish America in the Age of Revolution, 1750-1850, Albuquerque, 1994, pp. 197-213.

Kaukiainen, Y, ‘Shrinking the World: Improvements in the Speed of Information Transmission, c. 1820–1870’, European Review of Economic History, 5:1, 2001, pp. 1-28.

Korthals Altes, W.L., Changing Economy in Indonesia: A Selection of Statistical Source Material from the Early 19th Century up to 1940, XV, Prices (Non-Rice) 1814–1940, Amsterdam, 1994.

Lévy-Leboyer, M., ‘L’héritage de Simiand: Prix, profit et termes d'échange au XIX e siècle’, Revue Historique, 243, 1970, pp. 77-120.

Lewis, C.M., ‘La consolidación de la frontera argentina a fines de la década del 70: Los indios, Roca y los ferrocarriles’, in G. Ferrari and E. Gallo, eds., La Argentina del ochenta al centenario, Buenos Aires, 1980, pp. 469-96.

Lewis, C.M., British Railways in Argentina 1857-1914: A Case Study of Foreign Investment, London, 1983.

Llorca-Jaña, M., ‘Knowing the Shape of Demand: Britain's Exports of Ponchos to the Southern Cone, c. 1810s–70s’, Business History, 51:4, 2009, pp. 602-21.

Llorca-Jaña, M., The British Textile Trade in South America in the Nineteenth Century, Cambridge, 2012.

Lynch, J., The Spanish American Revolutions, 1808-1826, 2nd ed., London, 1986.

McCaa, R., M.R. Haines, and E.M. Mulhare, ‘Argentina: The First National Historical Census Microdata’, in P.K. Hall, R. McCaa, and G. Thorvaldsen, eds., Handbook of International Historical Microdata for Population Research, Minneapolis, 2000, pp. 13-21.

Maddison, A., The World Economy, I and II, Paris, 2006.

Marichal, C., ‘Beneficios y costes fiscales del colonialismo: Las remesas americanas a España, 1760-1814’, Revista de Historia Económica, 15:3, 1997, pp. 475-505.

Marques de Sobre Monte, ‘Sobre la Intendencia de Córdoba del Tucumán (1788)’, Revista de Buenos Aires, 2:6, 1865, pp. 475-514.

Márquez, G., ‘Commercial Monopolies and External Trade’, in V. Bulmer-Thomas, J. Coatsworth, and R. Cortés Conde, eds., The Cambridge History of Latin America, I, The Colonial Era and the Short Nineteenth Century, Cambridge, 2005, pp. 395-422.

Mayo, C.A., ‘Landed but not Powerful: The Colonial Estancieros of Buenos Aires (1750-1810)’, Hispanic American Historical Review, 71:4, 1991, pp. 761-79.

Mayo, C.A., Estancia y sociedad en la Pampa 1740-1820, Buenos Aires, 1995. Moreno, D.M., Representación que el apoderado de los hacendados de las campañas del Río de la Plata, Buenos Aires, (1809) 1874.

Moutoukias, Z., ‘Power, Corruption, and Commerce: The Making of the Local Administrative Structure in Seventeenth-Century Buenos Aires’, Hispanic American Historical Review, 68:4, 1988, pp. 771-801.

Moutoukias, Z., ‘El crecimiento en una economía colonial de antiguo regimen: Reformismo y sector externo en el Río de la Plata’, Arquivos do Centro Cultural Calouste Gulbenkian, 34, 1995, pp. 771-813.

Moutoukias, Z., ‘Comercio y producción’, in Academia Naional de Historia, ed., Nueva historia de la Nación Argentina, IV, Buenos Aires, 2000, pp. 72-90.

Newland, C., ‘Puramente animal: Exportaciones y crecimiento en Argentina 1810-1870’, mimeo, 1990.

Newland, C., ‘Exports and Terms of Trade in Argentina, 1811-1870’, Bulletin of Latin American Research, 17:3, 1998, pp. 409-16.

Newland, C., and J. Ortíz, ‘The Economic Consequences of Argentine Independence’, Cuadernos de Economía, 38:115, 2001, pp. 275-90.

Officer, L.H., ‘Dollar-Sterling Exchange Rates: 1791–1914’, in S.B. Carter, S.S. Gartner, M.R. Haines, A.L. Olmstead, R. Sutch, and G. Wright, eds., Historical Statistics of the United States: Earliest Times to the Present: Millennial Edition, New York, 2006, online at http://hsus.cambridge.org (accessed 19 November 2013).

Officer, L.H., ‘Bilateral Exchange Rates’, in S.B. Carter, S.S. Gartner, M.R. Haines, A.L. Olmstead, R. Sutch, and G. Wright, eds., Historical Statistics of the United States: Earliest Times to the Present: Millennial Edition, New York, 2006, online at http://hsus.cambridge.org (accessed 19 November 2013).

Oribe Stemmer, J.E., ‘Freight Rates in the Trade Between Europe and South America, 1840-1914’, Journal of Latin American Studies, 21:1, 1989, pp. 23-59.

Palermo, S.A., ‘The Nation Building Mission: The State-Owned Railways in Modern Argentina, 1870-1930’, PhD diss., State University of New York, 2001.

Parish, W., Buenos Ayres and the Provinces of the Rio de la Plata, 2nd ed., London, 1852.

Platt, D.C.M., Latin America and British Trade 1806-1914, London, 1972.

Reber, V.B., British Mercantile Houses in Buenos Aires, 1810-1880, Cambridge, MA, 1979.

Recchini de Lattes, Z., and A.E. Lattes, eds., La población de Argentina, Buenos Aires, 1975.

Regalsky, A.M., ‘Políticas públicas, capital extranjero y estructura de mercado: El desarrollo de los ferrocarriles en la Argentina antes de 1914’, Revista de Instituciones, Ideas y Mercados, 46, 2007, pp. 171-203.

Robertson, J.P., and W.P. Robertson, Letters on South America: Comprising Travels on the Banks of the Paraná and Rio de la Plata, I, London, 1843.

Robinson, K., ‘The Merchants of Post-Independence Buenos Aires’, in M.L. Moorhead and W.S. Coker, eds., Hispanic-American Essays in Honor of Max Leon Moorhead, Pensacola, 1979, pp. 111-132.

Romano, S., Economía, sociedad y poder en Córdoba: Primera mitad del siglo XIX, Córdoba, 2002.

Rosal, M.A., and R. Schmit, ‘Del reformismo colonial borbónico al libre comercio: Las exportaciones pecuarias del Río de la Plata (1768-1854)’, Boletín del Instituto de Historia Argentina y Americana ‘Dr Emilio Ravignani’, 3:20, 1999, pp. 69-109.

Sabato, H., Agrarian Capitalism and the World Market: Buenos Aires in the Pastoral Age, 1840-1890, Albuquerque, 1990.

Salvatore, R.D., ‘The Breakdown of Social Discipline in the Banda Oriental and the Littoral, 1790-1820’, in M.D. Szuchman and J.C. Brown, eds., Revolution and Restoration: The Rearrangement of Power in Argentina 1860, Lincoln, NE, 1994, pp. 74-102.

Salvatore, R., and C. Newland, ‘Between Independence and the Golden Age: The Early Argentine Economy’, in G. della Paolera and A.M. Taylor, eds., A New Economic History of Argentina, Cambridge, 2003, pp. 19-45.

Santos Martínez, P., Las industrias durante el Virreinato (1776-1810), Buenos Aires, 1969.

Sawers, L., The Other Argentina: The Interior and National Development, Oxford, 1996.

Schneider, J., O. Schwarzer, and M.A. Denzel, Währungen der Welt, VII, Lateinamerikanische Devisenkurse im 19. und 20. Jahrhundert, Stuttgart, 1997.

Socolow, S.M., The Merchants of Buenos Aires, 1778-1810, Cambridge, 1978. Superintendente del Censo, Primer censo de la República Argentina, Buenos Aires, 1872.

Tandeter, E., ‘El eje Potosí-Buenos Aires en el imperio español’, in M. Ganci and R. Romano, eds., Governare il mondo: L’imperio spagnolo dal XV al XIX secolo, Palermo, 1991, pp. 185-201.

Tornquist, E., The Economic Development of the Argentine Republic in the Last Fifty Years, Buenos Aires, 1919.

United Nations, Relative Prices of Exports and Imports of Under-Developed Countries: A Study of Post-War Terms of Trade Between Under-Developed and Industrialized Countries, Lake Success, 1949.

United Nations, ‘International Trade Statistics 1900-1960’, mimeo, 1962, online at http://unstats.un.org/unsd/trade/imts/historical_data.htm (accessed 1 July 2014).

Vázquez-Presedo, V., Estadísticas históricas argentinas (comparadas), II, Segunda parte 1914-1939, Buenos Aires, 1971.

Williamson, J.G., ‘Globalization and the Great Divergence: Terms of Trade Booms, Volatility and the Poor Periphery, 1782-1913’, European Review of Economic History, 12:3, 2008, pp. 355-91.

Williamson, J.G., Trade and Poverty: When the Third World Fell Behind, Cambridge, MA, 2011.