The dogs that didn’t bark: Marx and Engels and statistical fatalism

Wells, Julian (2006): The dogs that didn’t bark: Marx and Engels and statistical fatalism.

Abstract

This paper is about a nineteenth-century debate about causality – but, unusually, we emphasise what was not said, and those who did not take part. We begin by recapitulating the debate on so-called statistical fatalism, precipitated by the discovery of dependable regularities in such social phenomena as suicide and crime, and fuelled by the notorious claim that ‘society ... prepares the crime’ (Quetelet 1832). Our account follows Hacking (1990), but we emphasise the links between the protagonists’ views on statistical fatalism and their positions on other questions in social and economic thought. Next we review the familiar claim that the doctrines of Marx and Engels were determinist in character, a claim which this paper is intended to help refute. We then show that Marx and Engels, taken together, were (a) interested in and familiar with the relevant issues, as well as with Quetelet’s work, (b) had distinctive views on the philosophical issues involved, and (c) would have been motivated to intervene given the wider positions of the actual participants. In the course of this we suggest what their response might have looked like, had they provided one; little space is devoted to the question of why they did not do so.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Eduard Bernstein, Friedrich Engels, Karl Marx, Lambert Adolphe Jacques Quetelet, James Clerk Maxwell, statistical fatalism, determinism, suicide, social statistics
• Subjects: B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B1 - History of Economic Thought through 1925 > B14 - Socialist ; Marxist; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B3 - History of Economic Thought: Individuals > B31 - Individuals

References

Bernstein, Eduard (1961) Evolutionary socialism (Schocken Books, New York)

Bernstein, Eduard ([1930] 1980) Cromwell and communism ([George Allen and Unwin] Spokesman)

Bernstein, Eduard (1993) The preconditions of socialism (ed. and trans. Henry Tudor) (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)

Carver, Terrell (1975) Texts on method Oxford: Blackwell.

Colletti, Lucio (1975) ‘Introduction', Karl Marx: early writings Harmondsworth: Penguin.

Davis, L. J. (1997) ‘Constructing normalcy: the bell curve, the novel, and the invention of the disabled body in the nineteenth century', The disability studies reader. L. J. Davis. London, Routledge: 9-28.

Engels, Friedrich (1940): Dialectics of nature (Lawrence and Wishart, London)

Engels, Friedrich (1976): Anti-Dühring (Foreign Languages Press, Peking)

Evans, M. (2004 [1975]) Karl Marx, London: Routledge.

Gay, Peter (1952) The dilemma of democratic socialism (Columbia University Press)

Hacking, Ian (1990) The taming of chance (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)

Hodgson, Geoffrey M. (2001) ‘Darwin, Veblen, and the problem of causality in economics', History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 23 pp. 382-422.

Horvath, R. A. (1977) ‘Quetelet et Marx. Essai de synthèse de leurs pensées au point de vue statistique et sociologique', Adoplphe Quetelet 1796-1874. Mémorial Adolphe Quetelet No. 4. Brussel: Palais des Académies: 87-99.

Marx, Karl (1881) ‘Notes on Adolph Wagner's Lehrbuch der politischen Ökonomie (second edition), Volume I, 1879'

Marx, Karl (1975) ‘Difference between the Democritean and Epicurean philosophy of nature', Marx-Engels Collected Works Volume I, London: Lawrence and Wishart.

Marx, Karl (1976) Capital Vol.1 (Penguin, Harmondsworth)

Marx, Karl (1981) Capital Vol.3 (Penguin, Harmondsworth)

McLellan, David (1980) Marx before marxism, London: Macmillan.

Mosselmans, Bert (2005) ‘Adolphe Quetelet, the average man and the development of economic methodology' European Journal of the History of Economic Thought 12(4): 565-582.

Pearson, Karl (1978): The history of statistics in the 17th and 18th centuries (Charles Griffin, London and High Wycombe)

Plaut, E. A. and K. Anderson, Eds. (1999) Marx on suicide Evanston, Illinois: Northwestern University Press

Quetelet, L. A. J. (1842 [1969]) A treatise on man and the development of his faculties Gainesville, Florida: Scholars' Facsimiles and Reprints

Russell, Bertrand (1896/1965) German Social Democracy (George Allen and Unwin, Woking and London)

Watkins, John (1984) Science and scepticism (Hutchinson, London)