Kirdar, Murat G. (2008): Estimating the impact of immigrants on the host country social security system when return migration is an endogenous choice.
Download (573Kb) | Preview
In this paper, I examine the impact of immigrants on the social security system in Germany when return migration is an endogenous choice. For this purpose, I develop a dynamic stochastic model of joint return migration and saving decisions that accounts for uncertainty in future employment and income and estimate this model using a longitudinal dataset on immigrants from five different source countries. I find that immigrants make positive net contributions to both the pension and unemployment insurance systems in Germany regardless of their country of origin and age-at-entry. Moreover, the magnitudes of the net contributions are remarkable for certain groups. Return migration plays a critical role in generating these positive net contributions. In a counterfactual, I examine how much exogenous modeling of the return decision, which has been the practice of the literature so far, changes immigrants’ net contributions. Such a restriction causes a serious misestimation of net contributions. I also examine the impact of a counterfactual policy experiment in which financial bonuses are provided conditional on return to certain unemployed immigrants. Such a policy turns out to be ineffective in a number of dimensions.
|Item Type:||MPRA Paper|
|Original Title:||Estimating the impact of immigrants on the host country social security system when return migration is an endogenous choice|
|Keywords:||Immigrant Workers, Life Cycle Models and Saving, Social Security and Public Pensions, Unemployment Insurance, Public Policy|
|Subjects:||H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H55 - Social Security and Public Pensions
J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, and Vacancies > J65 - Unemployment Insurance; Severance Pay; Plant Closings
J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, and Vacancies > J61 - Geographic Labor Mobility; Immigrant Workers
D - Microeconomics > D9 - Intertemporal Choice and Growth > D91 - Intertemporal Consumer Choice; Life Cycle Models and Saving
|Depositing User:||Murat Kirdar|
|Date Deposited:||17. Mar 2008 13:44|
|Last Modified:||13. Feb 2013 12:16|
 Auerbach, Alan J., Gokhale, Jagadeesh and Laurance Kotlikoff. "Generational Accounts: A Meaningful Alternative to Deficit Accounting," in D. Bradford, ed., Tax Policy and the Economy, Vol.5. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1991, pp.55-110.  –and Philip Oreopoluos. "Analyzing the Fiscal Impact of U.S. Immigration" American Economic Review 89 (1999), 176-80.  Aydemir, A. and Robinson, C. "Global Labor Markets, Return and Onward Migration." Working Paper #2006-1, CIBC Working Paper Series (2006)  Berninghaus Siegfried and Hans Günther Siefer-Vogt. "The Role of the Target Savings Motive in Guest Worker Migration." Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 17 (1993): 181-205.  Bönin, H., Raffelhüschen, B., and J. Walliser. "Can Immigration Alleviate the Demographic Burden?", FinanzArchiv 57 (2000), 1-21.  Börsch-Supan, Axel. "Migration, Social Security Systems, and Public Finance," in Siebert.Horst, ed., Migration: A Challenge for Europe. (Tübingen, 1994)  –. "A Model under Siege: A Case Study of the German Retirement Insurance System." Economic Journal 110 (2000): F24-45.  –, Kohnz, Simone and Reinhold Schnabel. "Micro Modeling of Retirement Decisions in Germany." Social Security Programs and Retirement Around the World: Microestimation 2004. (NBER Conference Report series. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press, 2004).  –and Reinhold Schnabel. "Social Security and Retirement in Germany." Social Security and Retirement Around the World. Ed. Jonathan Gruber and DavidWise. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1999. 135-180. 40  –and ChristinaWilke. "The German Social Security System: How itWas, How itWill Be". NBER Working Paper No. 10525. (2004).  Borjas, George J. "The Economics of Immigration". Journal of Economic Literature 32 (1994): 1667-1717  –and Bratsberg, Bernt. "Who Leaves? The Outmigration of the Foreign-born". Review of Economics and Statistics 78 (1996): 165-176.  Büchel, Felix and Joachim R. Frick "The Income Portfolio of Immigrants in Germany - Effects of Ethnic Origin and Assimilation Or: Who Gains fromIncome Re-Distribution", Quarterly Journal of Economic Resarch 70(1), Special Issue, (2001): 135-145.  Cohen, Yinon and Yitchak Haberfeld. "Self-selection and ReturnMigration: Israeli-born Jews Returning Home from the United States during the 1980s." Population Studies 55 (2001), 79-91.  Djajic, S., and R. Milbourne. "A General EquilibriumModel of Guest-workerMigration: A Source-Country Perspective", Journal of International Economics 25 (1988), 335-351.  Dolores-Collado M., Iturbe-Ormaetxe I., and G. Valera. "Quantifying the Impact of Immigration on the Spanish Welfare State." International Tax and Public Finance 11 (2004): 335-353.  Duleep, H.O. "Social Security and the Emigration of Immigrants." Social Security Bulletin 57 (1994), 37-52.  Dustmann, Christian. "Savings Behavior of Temporary Migrants - A Life Cycle Analysis." Zeitschrift für Wirtschafts und Socialwissenschaften 115 (1995): 511-533  – . "Return Migration, Uncertainty and Precautionary Savings”. Journal of Development Economics 52 (1997): 295-316  –and Oliver Kirschkamp. "The Optimal Migration Duration and Activity Choice after Re-migration." Journal of Development Economics 67 (2002): 351-372  Eckstein, Zvi and Kenneth Wolpin. "The Specification and Estimation of Dynamic Stochastic Discrete Choice Models: A Survey." Journal of Human Resources 24 (1989): 562-598. 41  European Health Statistics of the World Health Organization. http://data.euro.who.int/hfadb/.  Freeman, Richard B. and Remco Oostendorp. "Wages Around the World: Pay Across Occupations and Countries." NBER Working Paper No. 8058. (2000)  Friedberg, Rachel M. and Jennifer Hunt. "The Impact of Immigrants on Host Country Wages, Employment and Growth". Journal of Economic Perspectives 9 (1995): 23-44.  German Ministry of Finance, "The Tax Policy of the Federal Government", October 2004  Goeree, Jacob K., Holt, Charles A. and Thomas R. Palfrey. "Risk Averse Behavior in Generalized Matching Pennies Games," Games and Economic Behavior 45 (2003), 97-113.  Heckman, J. and B. Singer. "A Method for Minimizing the Impact of Distributional Assumptions in Econometric Models for Duration Data." Econometrica 52 (1984): 271- 320.  Hill, John K. "Immigrant Decisions Concerning Duration of Stay and Migration Frequency." Journal of Development Economics 25 (1987): 221-234  Istituto Di Studi E Analisi Economica, Rapporto ISAE, October 2004.  Jasso, G. and Mark Rosenzweig. "Estimating the Emigration Rates of Legal Immigrants Using Administrative and Survey Data: The 1971 Cohort of Immigrants to the United States." Demography 19 (1982), 279-290.  Keane, Michael P. and Robert M. Sauer. "A Computationally Practical Simulation Estimation Algorithm for Dynamic Panel Data Models with Unobserved Endogenous State Variables.", mimeo.  – and Kenneth I. Wolpin. "The Career Decisions of Young Men." Journal of Political Economy 105 (1997): 473-522.  –and Kenneth I.Wolpin. "The Effect of Parental Transfers and Borrowing Constraints on Educational Attainment." International Economic Review 42 (2001): 1051-1104 42  Koç, ˙Ismet and I¸sıl Onan. "International Migrants’ Remittances and Welfare Status of the Left-Behind Families in Turkey," International Migration Review 38 (2004), 78-112.  Kumcu, Ercan M. "The Savings Behavior of Migrant Workers: Turkish Workers in W. Germany." Journal of Development Economics 30 (1989): 273-286  LaLonde Robert J. and Robert H. Topel. "Immigrants in the American Labor Market: Quality, Assimilation, and Distributional Effects". American Economic Review 81 (1991): 297-302.  Lam, Kit-Chun. "Outmigration of Foreign-Born Members in Canada." Canadian Journal of Economics 27 (1994), 352-370.  Lee, Ronald and Timothy Miller. "Immigration, Social Security, and Broader Fiscal Impacts." American Economic Review 90 (2000): 350-354.  Mayr, Karin. "The Fiscal Impact of Immigrants in Austria - A Generational Accounting Analysis." Empirica 32 (2005): 181-216.  Organization for Economic Development and Cooperation (OECD), OECD Indicators, Benefits and Wages, 2002.  Paine, Suzanne. Exporting Workers: the Turkish Case. Cambridge: Cambridge, 1974.  Pischke, Jorn-Steffen and Johannes Velling. "Employment Effects of Immigration to Germany: An Analysis Based on Local Labor Markets". Review of Economics and Statistics 79 (1997): 594-604.  Reagan, Patricia B. and Randall J. Olsen. "You Can Go Home Again: Evidence from Longitudinal Data." Demography 37 (2000), 339-350.  Schou, Poul. "Immigration, Integration and Fiscal Sustainability." Journal of Population Economics 19 (2006), 671-689.  Storesletten, Kjetil. "Sustaining Fiscal Policy Through Immigration". Journal of Political Economy 108.2 (2000): 300-23.  –. "Fiscal Implications of Immigration - A Net Present Value Calculation". Scandinavian Journal of Economics 105.3 (2003): 487-506. 43  Tunalı, ˙Insan. "Rationality of Migration". International Economic Review 41 (2000): 893-920.  Turkish Statistical Institute, Population and Development Indicators, Population and Demography. http://nkg.die.gov.tr/en/goster.asp?aile=1.  Türkiye Cumhuriyeti Merkez Bankası. Yurt Dı¸sındaki Vatanda¸slarımızın Tasarruf E˘gilimleri Ara¸stırması. Ankara, 1986.