Environmental managment without environmental valuation?

Spash, Clive L. (1996): Environmental managment without environmental valuation?

Abstract

There is a rising tendency for environmental economics to be viewed as exclusively concerned with valuing everything in monetary terms and there are certainly some among its ranks whose own self-interest leads them to preach that line in public. However, acceptance of the many valid criticisms of monetary valuation and our limited understanding of environmental systems makes this extreme untenable as all economists will admit (if some only in private) and which ecological-economics recognises as a central issue. Yet the danger in characterising the preoccupation of economists with monetary valuation as in some sense wrong assumes this is something which can be excluded from resource allocation decisions. The critics of monetary valuation also tend to believe in an unspecified alternative approach which is often associated with scientifically defined limits and cost-effectiveness. The problem explored in this paper is the extent to which a concern for costs and benefits can be excluded from environmental management and if, as argued, a role for valuation is required how can the critics concerns be taken into account in defining that role.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Environmental valuation, cost-benefit analysis
• Subjects: A - General Economics and Teaching > A1 - General Economics > A13 - Relation of Economics to Social Values; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q51 - Valuation of Environmental Effects; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q58 - Government Policy; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B4 - Economic Methodology > B41 - Economic Methodology

References

Ayres R U and J Walters (1991) The greenhouse effect: damages, costs and abatement Environmental and Resource Economics 1 no.3: 237-270.

Boyce R R, T C Brown, G H McClelland, G L Peterson and W D Schulze (1992) An experimental examination of intrinsic values as a source of the WTA-WTP disparity American Economic Review 82 no.5: 1366-1373.

Cline W R (1992) The Economics of Global Warming Harlow, Essex: Longman.

Craig P, H Glasse and W Kempton (1993) Ethics and values in environmental policy Environmental Values 2 no.2: 137-157.

Daily G C, P R Ehrilich, H A Mooney and A H Ehrilich (1991) Greenhouse economics: learn before you leap Ecological Economics (October) 4 no.1: 1-10.

Dunn P (1994) A setback for Green lobby over valley. Independent 7th September.

English Nature (1992) Strategic Planning and Sustainable Development Peterborough: English Nature.

English Nature (1994) Planning for Environmental Sustainability Peterborough: English Nature.

Fankhauser (1995) Valuing Climate Change: The Economics of the Greenhouse London: Earthscan.

Friends of the Earth Scotland (1995) The Environmental Space for Scotland: Interim Summary (draft), Friends of the Earth Scotland, Edinburgh.

Gordon (1991) The History and Philosophy of Social Science London: Routledge.

Hahn R W (1989) Economic prescriptions for environmental problems: how the patient followed the doctor’s orders. Journal of Economic Perspectives 3 no.2: 95-114.

Hanley N, A Munro and D Jamieson (1991) Environmental economics and sustainable development in nature conservation. Unpublished report to Nature Conservancy Council, Economics Department, University of Stirling.

Hutchinson T W (1938) The Significance and Basic Postulates of Economic Theory London: Macmillan & Co. Ltd.

Idso S B (1984) A review of recent reports dealing with the Greenhouse Effect of atmospheric carbon dioxide Journal of Air Pollution Control Association 34 no.5: 553-555.

Jacobs M (1993) Sense and Sustainability: Land Use Planning and Environmentally Sustainable Development London: Council for the Protection of Rural England.

Jacobs M (1991) The Green Economy: Environment, Sustainable Development and the Politics of the Future London: Pluto Press.

Lange O (1970) Introduction to Economic Cybernetics Oxford: Pergamon Press.

Lecomber R (1979) The Economics of Natural Resources London: Macmillan.

Meadows D H, D L Meadows, J Randers (1992) Beyond the Limits: Global Collapse or a Sustainable Future London: Earthscan.

Meadows D H, D L Meadows, J Randers and W W Behrens (1972) The Limits to Growth London: Pan Books.

Nature Conservancy Council (1990) The Treatment of Nature Conservation in the Appraisal of Trunk Roads Submission to the Standing Committee on Trunk Road Assessment prepared by P G Hopkinson, J Bowers and C A Nash, Institute for Transport Studies, University of Leeds.

Nordhaus (1991) To slow or not to slow: the economics of the greenhouse effect Economic Journal 101: 920-938.

Norgaard R B (1994) Development Betrayed: the End of Progress and a Coevolutionary Revisioning of the Future London: Routledge.

Pearce D, A Markandya and E B Barbier (1989) Blueprint for a Blue Economy London: Earthscan.

Pearce F (1992) The battle for Britain’s bogs. New Scientist 28th November.

Sagoff M (1988) The Economy of the Earth Cambridge: University Press.

Smith P G R and J B Theberge (1986) A review of criteria for evaluation of natural areas Environmental Management 10: 715-734.

Spash C L (1995) The political economy of Nature Review of Political Economy 7 no.3: 279-293.

Spash C L (1994a) Double CO2 and beyond: benefits, costs and compensation Ecological Economics 10: 27-36.

Spash C L (1994b) Trying to find the right approach to greenhouse economics: some reflections upon the role of cost-benefit analysis Analyze & Kritik 16: 186-199.

Spash C L (1993) Estimating the importance of inviolable rights: the case of long term damages and future generations, unpublished report to the Scottish Economic Society.

Spash C L and N D Hanley (1995) Preferences, information and biodiversity preservation Ecological Economics 12: 191-208.

Spash C L and I A Simpson (1994) Utilitarian and rights based alternatives for protecting sites of special scientific interest. Journal of Agricultural Economics 45 no.1: 15-26.

Spash C L and I A Simpson (1993) Protecting sites of special scientific interest. Journal of Environmental Management 39: 213-227.

Willis K G and J F Benson (1988) Valuation and wildlife In R K Turner (editor) Sustainable Environmental Management: Principles and Practice Boulder, CO: Westview Press.