The indeterminacy of price-value correlations: a comment on papers by Simo Mohun and Anwar Shaikh

Freeman, Alan (1998): The indeterminacy of price-value correlations: a comment on papers by Simo Mohun and Anwar Shaikh. Published in: Bellofiore, R (ed) Marxian Economics: a Reappraisal, Volume 2, pp139-162. Basingstoke: McMillan. ISBN 0 333 64411 5 (1998): pp. 139-162.

Abstract

This paper is the first published critique of the indeterminacy of price-value correlations and their inadequacy as empirical evidence for the determination of prices by values. It comments on the approach developed by Shaikh, Petrovic, Parys, Ochoa and others, according to which prices, as asserted by Ricardo, are empirically ‘97%’ determined by values.

This method calculates measures of distance (according to some or other measure such as Mean Absolute Distance, or correlation) between a vector of empirically-observed average price of a set of industrial sectors, and a vector of aggregate values calculated as the vertically-integrated labour coefficients of the same set of industrial sectors.

The present paper suggests, and establishes using a Monte Carlo method, that the observed correlations are most likely to ‘spurious’ since they can be entirely accounted for by variations in the size of the industrial sectors concerned.

The paper was published in the same volume as the paper from Anwar Shaikh to which it responds, as well as another by Simon Mohun on which the paper also comments. (Bellofiore, R (ed) Marxian Economics: a Reappraisal, Volume 2, pp139-162. Basingstoke: McMillan)

The controversy was subsequently developed in a number of exchanges including, in particular, papers in the Cambridge Journal of Economics between Andrew Kliman, Paul Cockshott and Allin Cottrell. It has further been discussed in papers by Ruben Osuna and Emilio Diaz which are at the time of submission unpublished, and in papers by Tsoulfidis and Maniatis also in the Cambridge Journal of Economics.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Institution: The University of Greenwich
• Language: English
• Keywords: TSSI; Temporalism; Temporal; Marx; Value; Price; Transformation; non-equilibrium; history of thought
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C4 - Econometric and Statistical Methods: Special Topics > C43 - Index Numbers and Aggregation; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C0 - General > C02 - Mathematical Methods; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C4 - Econometric and Statistical Methods: Special Topics > C46 - Specific Distributions ; Specific Statistics; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925 > B24 - Socialist ; Marxist ; Sraffian; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B4 - Economic Methodology > B40 - General; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925 > B23 - Econometrics ; Quantitative and Mathematical Studies; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B1 - History of Economic Thought through 1925 > B14 - Socialist ; Marxist

References

Cockshott, P. and Cottrell, A. 2003. Robust Correlations between sectoral prices and labour values: a comment, Cambridge Journal of Economics, forthcoming Cockshott, P. and Cottrell, A. 1998. Does Marx need to transform?, in Bellofiore, R. (ed), Marxian Economics: A reappraisal, vol. 2, Houndmills, Macmillan, pp 70-85 Cockshott, P. and Cottrell, A. and Michaelson, G. ‘Testing Marx: some new results from UK data’, Capital and Class 55. Freeman, A. (1992) ‘National Accounts in Value Terms: The Social Wage and Profit Rate in Britain 1950-1986’ in Dunne, P. (1992), Quantitative Marxism, Cambridge:Polity Press. Kliman, A. (2004) ‘Spurious Value-Price Correlations: Some Additional Evidence and Arguments’ in Research in Political Economy, Vol. 21, 2004: Neoliberalism in Crisis, Accumulation, and Rosa Luxemburg’s Legacy; P. Zarembka, S. Soederberg (eds.), pp. 223-38 Kliman, A. 2002. The law of value and laws of statistics: sectoral values and prices in the US economy, 1977–97, Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 26, 299-311 Kliman, A. 2005. ‘Reply to Cockshott and Cottrell.’ Cambridge Journal of Economics; Mar 2005; 29, 2; p 317 Mandel, E. And Freeman, A. (1984), Ricardo, Marx and Sraffa, the Langston Memorial Volume. London: Verso. Mohun, S (1998) ‘Unproductive Labour and the Rate of Profit in Australia’ in Bellofiore, R (ed) Marxian Economics: a Reappraisal, Volume 2, pp 252-269 Moseley, Fred. (1990) ‘The Decline of the Rate of Profit in the Postwar U.S. Economy: An Alternative Marxist Explanation’, Review of Radical Political Economics, 22, (2-3), 17-37. Ochoa, E.M. (1984) Labour Values and Prices of Production: an Interindustry Study of the US Economy, 1947-1972, PhD Thesis, New School for Social Research. Ochoa, E.M.,(1985) ‘Labour Values and Prices of Production: an Inter-industry Study of the U.S. Economy, 1947-1972, PhD Thesis, New School for Social Research Ochoa, E.M. (1989) ‘Values, prices and wage-profit curves in the US Economy’,Cambridge Journal of Economics 13: 413-429 Osuna Guerrero, R. 2003. Un Modelo Secuencial para el Cálculo de Precios. El Caso Español 1986-1994. Ph.D. dissertation, Departamento de Análisis Económico I, Facultad de Ciencias Económicas y Empresariales. Universidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia (UNED), Spain. Parys, W. (1982) ‘The Deviation of Prices from Labour Values’, American Economic Review 72: 1208-1212 Petrovic, P (1987) ‘The deviationof production prices from labour values: some methodology and empirical evidence’. Cambridge Journal of Economics 11:197-210 Shaikh, A and Tonak, Ahmet E.(1994). Measuring the Wealth of Nations, Cambridge: CUP. Shaikh, A. (1981), ‘The Poverty of Algebra’ in Steedman (1981). Shaikh, A.. (1982), ‘Neoricardian Economics: A Wealth of Algebra, a Poverty of Theory’, Review of Radical Political Economics, 14 (2), pp67﷓83. Shaikh, A.. (1984), ‘The Transformation from Marx to Sraffa’, in Mandel and Freeman (1984), Ricardo, Marx and Sraffa, the Langston Memorial Volume. London: Verso. Shaikh, A.. (1998), ‘The Empirical Strength of the Labour Theory of Value’in Bellofiore, R (ed) Marxian Economics: a Reappraisal, Volume 2, pp225-251. Steedman, I. and Tomkins, J. 1998. On measuring the deviation of prices from values, Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 22, 379-85 Trigg, A. B. 2002. Using micro data to test the divergence between prices and labour values, International Review of Applied Economics, vol. 16, 169-86 Tsoulfidis, L. and Maniatis, T (2002). ‘Values, prices of production and market prices: Some more evidence from the Greek Economy’ Cambridge Journal of Economics; May 2002; 26, 3; p 359