Science and Technology Parks impacts on tenant organisations: a review of literature

Albahari, Alberto and Pérez-Canto, Salvador and Landoni, Paolo (2010): Science and Technology Parks impacts on tenant organisations: a review of literature.

Abstract

Sixty years after the establishment of the first science park at Stanford University, Science and Technology Parks (STPs) have reached a worldwide diffusion. Many papers have discussed parks’ role in promoting new technology-based firms (NTBFs) and their impacts on firms’ performances, often drawing contrasting conclusions. On the one hand, some authors believe that STPs have generally failed to foster the establishment and growth of NTBFs or to encourage technology transfer among firms and public research organisations. These authors’ opinion on STPs is that those that are “successful” do nothing more than group successful firms together in the same area. According to other authors STPs are instead of actual added value to the on-park firms and to the territory in which they are located. The added value is measured for instance by the increased growth rate in turnovers and number of employees, greater resource diversification, and lower mortality rates. In particular, in some cases, science parks seem to be able to positively affect the innovative activities of tenant firms (in terms of R&D expenditure and intensity, number of patent applications, number of copyrights and publications, number of new products/services launched, etc.). In this paper we comprehensively analyse the literature on STPs, emphasizing the role that parks play in supporting R&D activities both in public research organisations and firms, assessing, according to literature, the added value of an on-park location. Finally, we discuss the limits of the literature and provide suggestions for future research.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: science parks, science and technology parks, literature review
• Subjects: L - Industrial Organization > L2 - Firm Objectives, Organization, and Behavior > L25 - Firm Performance: Size, Diversification, and Scope; H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H54 - Infrastructures ; Other Public Investment and Capital Stock; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O2 - Development Planning and Policy > O25 - Industrial Policy; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O3 - Innovation ; Research and Development ; Technological Change ; Intellectual Property Rights > O38 - Government Policy; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O3 - Innovation ; Research and Development ; Technological Change ; Intellectual Property Rights > O30 - General; L - Industrial Organization > L3 - Nonprofit Organizations and Public Enterprise > L38 - Public Policy; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O3 - Innovation ; Research and Development ; Technological Change ; Intellectual Property Rights > O32 - Management of Technological Innovation and R&D

References

AABOEN, L. (2009): “Explaining incubators using firm analogy”. Technovation, 29, 657-670.

AL-SULTAN, Y. Y. (1998): “The concept of science park in the context of Kuwait”. International Journal of Technology Management, 16, 800-807.

APPOLD, S. J. (2004): “Research parks and the location of industrial research laboratories: an analysis of the effectiveness of a policy intervention”. Research Policy, 33, 225-243.

AURP, 2010. Association of Universities and Research Parks -http://www.aurp.net/about/whatis.cfm [accessed 10th September 2010]

BAKOUROS, Y. L., MARDAS, D. C. and VARSAKELIS, N. C. (2002): “Science park, a high tech fantasy?: an analysis of the science parks of Greece”. Technovation, 22, 123-128.

BARTLETT, W. and CUCKOVIC, N. (2006): “Knowledge transfer, institutions, and innovation in Croatia and Slovenia”. Drustvena Istrazivanja, 15, 371-399.

BASS, S.J. (1998): “Japanese Research Parks: National Policy and Local Development”. Regional Studies, 32, 391 — 403.

BIGLIARDI, B., DORMIO, A. I., NOSELLA, A. and PETRONI, G. (2006): “Assessing science parks' performances: directions from selected Italian case studies”. Technovation, 26, 489-505.

BISWAS, R. R. (2004): “Making a technopolis in Hyderabad, India: the role of government IT policy”. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 71, 823-835.

BOZZO, U. (1998): “Technology Park: an enterprise model”. Progress in Planning, 49, 215-225.

BRUTON, G. D. (1998): “Incubators as a small business support in Russia: Contrast of university-related US incubators with the Zelenograd Scientific and Technology Park”. Journal of Small Business Management, 36, 91-94.

CABRAL, R. (1998): “Refining the Cabral-Dahab Science Park Management Paradigm”. International Journal of Technology Management, 16, 813-818.

CABRAL, R. (2004): “The Cabral-Dahab Science Park Management Paradigm applied to the case of Kista, Sweden”. International Journal of Technology Management, 28, 419-443.

CABRAL, R. and DAHAB, S. S. (1998): “Science parks in developing countries: the case of BIORIO in Brazil”. International Journal of Technology Management, 16, 726-739.

CAO, C. (2004): “Zhongguancun and China's high-tech parks in transition - "Growing pains" or "premature senility"?”. Asian Survey, 44, 647-668.

CHAN, K. F. and LAU, T. (2005): “Assessing technology incubator programs in the science park: the good, the bad and the ugly”. Technovation, 25, 1215-1228.

CHAN, K. Y. A., OERLEMANS, L. A. G. and PRETORIUS, M. W. (2010): “Knowledge exchange behaviours of science park firms: the innovation hub case”. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management, 22, 207-228.

CHEN, C. J. and HUANG, C. C. (2004): “A multiple criteria evaluation of high-tech industries for the science-based industrial park in Taiwan”. Information & Management, 41, 839-851.

CHEN, C. J., WU, H. L. and LIN, B. W. (2006): “Evaluating the development of high-tech industries: Taiwan's science park”. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 73, 452-465.

CHORDA, I. M. (1996): “Towards the maturity stage: An insight into the performance of French technopoles”. Technovation, 16, 143-152.

CHOU, T. L. and LIN, Y. C. (2007): “Industrial park development across the Taiwan strait”. Urban Studies, 44, 1405-1425.

COLOMBO, M. G. and DELMASTRO, M. (2002): “How effective are technology incubators? Evidence from Italy”. Research Policy, 31, 1103-1122.

CRICELLI, L., GASTALDI, M. and LEVIALDI, N. (1997): “A system of Science and Technology Parks for the Rome area”. International Journal of Technology Management, 13, 140-152.

DAHAB, S. S. and CABRAL, R. (1998): “Services firms in the IDEON Science Park”. International Journal of Technology Management, 16, 740-750.

DE MELLO, J. M. C. and ROCHA, F. C. A. (2004): “Networking for regional innovation and economic growth: the Brazilian Petropolis technopole”. International Journal of Technology Management, 27, 488-497.

DETTWILER, P., LINDELÖF, P. and LÖFSTEN, H. (2006): “Utility of location: A comparative survey between small new technology-based firms located on and off Science Parks -Implications for facilities management”. Technovation, 26, 506-517.

DURÃO, D., SARMENTO, M., VARELA, V. and MALTEZ, L. (2005): “Virtual and real-estate science and technology parks: a case study of Taguspark”. Technovation, 25, 237-244.

ECHOLS, A. E. and MEREDITH, J. W. (1998): “A case study of the Virginia Tech Corporate Research Center in the context of the Cabral-Dahab Paradigm, with comparison to other US research parks”. International Journal of Technology Management, 16, 761-777.

ETO, H. J. (2005): “Obstacles to emergence of high/new technology parks, ventures and clusters in Japan”. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 72, 359-373.

EUROPEAN COMMISSION, 2002. Benchmarking of Business Incubators, final report, February 2002.

FELDMAN, J. M. (2007): “The managerial equation and innovation platforms: The case of Linkoping and Berzelius Science Park”. European Planning Studies, 15, 1027-1045.

FELSENSTEIN, D. (1994): “University-related Science Parks - Seedbeds or enclaves of innovation”. Technovation, 14, 93-110.

FERGUSON, R. (2004): “Why firms on science parks should not be expected to show better performance - the story of twelve biotechnology firms”. International Journal of Technology Management, 28, 470-482.

FREIER, S. (1986): “Parks of science based industries in Israel”. Technovation, 4, 183-187.

FUKUGAWA, N. (2006): “Science parks in Japan and their value-added contributions to new technology-based firms”. International Journal of Industrial Organization, 24, 381-400.

GARNSEY, E. and LONGHI, C. (2004): “High technology locations and globalisation: converse paths, common processes”. International Journal of Technology Management, 28, 336-355.

HANSSON, F., HUSTED, K. and VESTERGAARD, J. (2005): “Second generation science parks: from structural holes jockeys to social capital catalysts of the knowledge society”. Technovation, 25, 1039-1049.

HARPER, J. C. and GEORGHIOU, L. (2005): “Foresight in innovation policy: Shared visions for a science park and business - University links in a city region”. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management, 17, 147-160.

HERMOSA, J. D. and BARROETA, B. (1998): “The technology park at Beocillo: an instrument for regional development in Castilla-Leon”. Progress in Planning, 49, 241-254.

HOMMEN, L., DOLOREUX, D. and LARSSON, E. (2006): “Emergence and growth of Mjardevi Science Park in Linkoping, Sweden”. European Planning Studies, 14, 1331-1361.

HU, A. G. Z. (2007): “Technology parks and regional economic growth in China”. Research Policy, 36, 76-87.

HU, T. S. (2008): “Interaction among high-tech talent and its impact on innovation performance: A comparison of Taiwanese science parks at different stages of development”. European Planning Studies, 16, 163-187.

HU, T. S., CHANG, S. L., LIN, C. Y. and CHIEN, H. T. (2006): “Evolution of knowledge intensive services in a high-tech region: The case of Hsinchu, Taiwan”. European Planning Studies, 14, 1363-1385.

HU, T. S., LIN, C. Y. and CHANG, S. L. (2005): “Technology-based regional development strategies and the emergence of technological communities: a case study of HSIP, Taiwan”. Technovation, 25, 367-380.

IASP 2002. IASP International Board, 6 February 2002

JENKINS, J. C., LEICHT, K. T. and JAYNES, A. (2008): “Creating high-technology growth: High-tech employment growth in US metropolitan areas, 1988-1998”. Social Science Quarterly, 89, 456-481.

KAUFMANN, A. and TODTLING, F. (2002): “How effective is innovation support for SMEs? An analysis of the region of Upper Austria”. Technovation, 22, 147-159.

KIHLGREN, A. (2003): “Promotion of innovation activity in Russia through the creation of science parks: the case of St. Petersburg (1992-1998) ”. Technovation, 23, 65-76.

KIM, H. Y. and JUNG, C. M. (2010): “Does a Technology Incubator Work in the Regional Economy? Evidence from South Korea”. Journal of Urban Planning and Development-Asce, 136, 273-284.

KOH, F. C. C., KOH, W. T. H. and TSCHANG, F. T. (2005): “An analytical framework for science parks and technology districts with an application to Singapore”. Journal of Business Venturing, 20, 217-239.

KU, Y. L., LIAU, S. J. and HSING, W. C. (2005): “The high-tech milieu and innovation-oriented development”. Technovation, 25, 145-153.

LAI, H. C. and SHYU, J. Z. (2005): “A comparison of innovation capacity at science parks across the Taiwan strait: the case of Zhangjiang High-Tech Park and Hsinchu Science-based Industrial Park”. Technovation, 25, 805-813.

LEE, W. H. and YANG, W. T. (2000): “The cradle of Taiwan high technology industry development -Hsinchu Science Park (HSP)”. Technovation, 20, 55-59.

LEYDEN, D., LINK, A. N. and SIEGEL, D. S. (2008): “A theoretical and empirical analysis of the decision to locate on a university research park”. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, 55, 23-28.

LI, L. J., HU, P. and ZHANG, L. (2004): “Roles, models and development trends of hi-tech industrial development zones in China”. International Journal of Technology Management, 28, 633-645.

LIEFNER, I., HENNEMANN, S. and XIN, L. (2006): “Cooperation in the innovation process in developing countries: empirical evidence from Zhongguancun, Beijing”. Environment and Planning A, 38, 111-130.

LIN, C. L. and TZENG, G. H. (2009): “A value-created system of science (technology) park by using DEMATEL”. Expert Systems with Applications, 36, 9683-9697.

LIN, G. T. R. and SUN, C. C. (2010): “Driving industrial clusters to be nationally competitive”. Technology Analysis and Strategic Management, 22, 81-97.

LINDELÖF, P. and LÖFSTEN, H. (2002): “Growth, management and financing of new technology-based firms - assessing value-added contributions of firms located on and off Science Parks”. Omega-International Journal of Management Science, 30, 143-154.

LINDELÖF, P. and LÖFSTEN, H. (2003): “Science Park location and new technology-based firms in Sweden - Implications for strategy and performance”. Small Business Economics, 20, 245-258.

LINDELÖF, P. and LÖFSTEN, H. (2005): “Academic versus corporate new technology-based firms in Swedish science parks: an analysis of performance, business networks and financing”. International Journal of Technology Management, 31, 334-357.

LINDELÖF, P. and LÖFSTEN, H. (2006): “Environmental hostility and firm behavior - An empirical examination of new technology-based firms on science parks”. Journal of Small Business Management, 44, 386-406.

LINK, A. N. and SCOTT, J. T. (2003): “US science parks: the diffusion of an innovation and its effects on the academic missions of universities”. International Journal of Industrial Organization, 21, 1323-1356.

LINK, A. N. and SCOTT, J. T. (2005): “Opening the ivory tower's door: An analysis of the determinants of the formation of US university spin-off companies”. Research Policy, 34, 1106-1112.

LINK, A. N. and SCOTT, J. T. (2006): “US university research parks”. Journal of Productivity Analysis, 25, 43-55.

LINK, A. N. and SCOTT, J. T. (2007): “The economics of university research parks”. Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 23, 661-674.

LIU, C.C. (2006): “A computable general equilibrium model of the southern region of Taiwan: the impact of the Tainan science-based industrial park”. Applied Economics, 38, 1655-1661.

LÖFSTEN, H. and LINDELÖF, P. (2001): “Science parks in Sweden - industrial renewal and development?” R & D Management, 31, 309-322.

LÖFSTEN, H. and LINDELÖF, P. (2002): “Science Parks and the growth of new technology-based firms - academic-industry links, innovation and markets”. Research Policy, 31, 859-876.

LÖFSTEN, H. and LINDELÖF, P. (2003): “Determinants for an entrepreneurial milieu: Science Parks and business policy in growing firms”. Technovation, 23, 51-64.

LÖFSTEN, H. and LINDELÖF, P. (2005): “R&D networks and product innovation patterns - academic and non-academic new technology-based firms on Science Parks”. Technovation, 25, 1025-1037.

MA, B. Q. (1998): “A project for the 21st century in China: Kwanghua Science Park”. International Journal of Technology Management, 16, 808-812.

MALAIRAJA, C. and ZAWDIE, G. (2008): “Science parks and university-industry collaboration in Malaysia”. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management, 20, 727-739.

MARKMAN, G. D., SIEGEL, D. S. and WRIGHT, M. (2008): “Research and Technology Commercialization”. Journal of Management Studies, 45, 1401-1423.

MASSA, S. and TESTA, S. (2008): “Innovation and SMEs: Misaligned perspectives and goals among entrepreneurs, academics, and policy makers”. Technovation, 28, 393-407.

MATHEWS, J. A. (1997): “A Silicon Valley of the East: Creating Taiwan's semiconductor industry”. California Management Review, 39, 26-&.

MCADAM, M. and MCADAM, R. (2008): “High tech start-ups in University Science Park incubators: The relationship between the start-up's lifecycle progression and use of the incubator's resources”. Technovation, 28, 277-290.

MILLAR, C., CHOI, C. J. and CHU, R. T. J. (2005): “The state in science, technology and innovation districts: Conceptual models for China”. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management, 17, 367-373.

MUKKALA, K. (2010): “The Role of Regional Policies in Promoting Networking and Innovative Activity: Evidence from Small Finnish High-tech Firms”. European Planning Studies, 18, 1057-1076.

NBIA, 2010. National Business Incubation Association -http://www.nbia.org/resource_library/what_is [accessed 10th September 2010]

OAKEY, R. (2007): “Clustering and the R&D management of high-technology small firms: in theory and practice”. R & D Management, 37, 237-248.

PARK, S. C. (2004): “The city of brain in South Korea: Daedeok Science Town”. International Journal of Technology Management, 28, 602-614.

PELKONEN, A. (2005): “State restructuring, urban competitiveness policies and technopole building in Finland: A critical view on the glocal state thesis”. European Planning Studies, 13, 685-705.

PHILLIMORE, J. (1999): “Beyond the linear view of innovation in science park evaluation - An analysis of Western Australian Technology Park”. Technovation, 19, 673-680.

PHILLIPS, S. A. M. and YEUNG, H. W. C. (2003): “A place for R&D? The Singapore Science Park”. Urban Studies, 40, 707-732.

QUINTAS, P., WIELD D. and MASSEY, D. (1992): “Academic-industry links and innovation - Questioning the science park model”. Technovation, 12, 161-175.

RADOSEVIC, S. and MYRZAKHMET, M. (2009): “Between vision and reality: Promoting innovation through technoparks in an emerging economy”. Technovation, 29, 645-656.

RAMASAMY, B., CHAKRABARTY, A. and CHEAH, M. (2004): “Malaysia’s leap into the future: an evaluation of the multimedia super corridor”. Technovation, 24, 871-883.

RATINHO, T. and HENRIQUES, E. (2010): “The role of science parks and business incubators in converging countries: Evidence from Portugal”. Technovation, 30, 278-290.

REID, S. and GARNSEY, E. (1997): “The growth of small high-tech firms: destinies and destinations of innovation Centre 'graduates'”. New Technology Work and Employment, 12, 84-90.

ROBERTS, R. (2005): “Issues in modelling innovation intense environments: The importance of the historical and cultural context”. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management, 17, 477-495.

SCANDIZZO, P. L. (2005): “Financing technology: an assessment of theory and practice”. International Journal of Technology Management, 32, 1-33.

SCHWARTZ, M. (2009): “Beyond incubation: an analysis of firm survival and exit dynamics in the post-graduation period”. Journal of Technology Transfer, 34, 403-421.

SHEARMUR, R. and DOLOREUX, D. (2002): “Science parks: actors or reactors? Canadian science parks in their urban context”. Environment and Planning A, 32, 1065-1082.

SIEGEL, D. S., WESTHEAD, P. and WRIGHT, M. (2003): “Assessing the impact of university science parks on research productivity: exploratory firm-level evidence from the United Kingdom”. International Journal of Industrial Organization, 21, 1357-1369.

SMILOR, R., O'DONNELL, N., STEIN, G. and WELBORN, R. S. (2007): “The research university and the development of high-technology centers in the United States”. Economic Development Quarterly, 21, 203-222.

SOFOULI, E. and VONORTAS, N. S. (2007): “S&T parks and business incubators in middle-sized countries: the case of Greece”. Journal of Technology Transfer, 32, 525-544.

SQUICCIARINI, M. (2008): “Science Parks' tenants versus out-of-Park firms: who innovates more? A duration model”. Journal of Technology Transfer, 33, 45-71.

SQUICCIARINI, M. (2009): “Science parks: seedbeds of innovation? A duration analysis of firms' patenting activity”. Small Business Economics, 32, 169-190.

STERNBERG, R. (1989): “Innovation centers and their importance for the growth of new technology-based firms - Experience gained from the Federal-Republic-of-Germany”. Technovation, 9, 681-694.

STERNBERG, R. (2004): “Technology centres in Germany: economic justification, effectiveness and impact on high-tech regions”. International Journal of Technology Management, 28, 444-469.

STOREY, D. J. and TETHER, B. S. (1998): “Public policy measures to support new technology-based firms in the European Union”. Research Policy, 26, 1037-1057.

SUNG, T. K., GIBSON, D. V. and KANG, B. S. (2003): “Characteristics of technology transfer in business ventures: the case of Daejeon, Korea”. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 70, 449-466.

SUZUKI, S. (2004): “Technopolis: science parks in Japan”. International Journal of Technology Management, 28, 582-601.

TAN, J. (2006): “Growth of industry clusters and innovation: Lessons from Beijing Zhongguancun Science Park”. Journal of Business Venturing, 21, 827-850.

THIERSTEIN, A. and WILHELM, B. (2001): “Incubator, technology, and innovation centres in Switzerland: features and policy implications”. Entrepreneurship and Regional Development, 13, 315-331.

UKSPA, 2010. United Kingdom Science Parks Association - http://www.ukspa.org.uk/about_ukspa/ [accessed 10th September 2010]

VAIDYANATHAN, G. (2008): “Technology parks in a developing country: the case of India”. Journal of Technology Transfer, 33, 285-299.

VANDIJK, M. P. (1993): “Industrial districts and urban economic-development”. Third World Planning Review, 15, 175-186.

VEDOVELLO, C. (1997): “Science parks and university-industry interaction: geographical proximity between the agents as a driving force”. Technovation, 17, 491-502.

WATKINS-MATHYS, L. and FOSTER, M. J. (2006): “Entrepreneurship: the missing ingredient in China's STIPs? ” Entrepreneurship and Regional Development, 18, 249-274.

WESTHEAD, P. (1997): “R&D 'inputs' and 'outputs' of technology-based firms located on and off science parks”. R & D Management, 27, 45-62.

WESTHEAD, P. and BATSTONE, S. (1998): “Independent technology-based firms: The perceived benefits of a science park location”. Urban Studies, 35, 2197-2219.

WESTHEAD, P. and STOREY, D. J. (1995): “Links between higher-education institutions and high-technology firms”. Omega-International Journal of Management Science, 23, 345-360.

WILLIAMS, J. C. (1998): “Frederick E. Terman and the rise of Silicon Valley”. International Journal of Technology Management, 16, 751-760.

WONGLIMPIYARAT, J. (2010): “Commercialization strategies of technology: lessons from Silicon Valley”. Journal of Technology Transfer, 35, 225-236.

WRIGHT, M., LIU, X. H., BUCK, T. and FILATOTCHEV, I. (2008): “Returnee entrepreneurs, science park location choice and performance: An analysis of high-technology SMEs in China”. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 32, 131-155.

XUE, L. (1997): “Promoting industrial R&D and high-tech development through science parks: The Taiwan experience and its implications for developing countries”. International Journal of Technology Management, 13, 744-761.

YANG, C. H., MOTOHASHI, K. and CHEN, J. R. (2009): “Are new technology-based firms located on science parks really more innovative? Evidence from Taiwan”. Research Policy, 38, 77-85.

ZHOU, Y. (2005): “The making of an innovative region from a centrally planned economy: institutional evolution in Zhongguancun Science Park in Beijing”. Environment and Planning A, 37, 1113-1134.

ZHU, D. and TANN, J. (2005): “A regional innovation system in a small-sized region: A clustering model in Zhongguancun Science Park”. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management, 17, 375-390.