The Pension Scheme in Vietnam: Current Status and Challenges in an Aging Society

Giang, Thanh Long (2004): The Pension Scheme in Vietnam: Current Status and Challenges in an Aging Society. Published in: Vietnam Development Forum , Vol. Discus, (April 2004)

Abstract

The publicly-managed Pay-As-You-Go (PAYG) defined-benefit pension scheme in Vietnam is described, with an analysis of its financial sustainability in the context of an aging society in a dynamically efficient economy. By using actuarial models developed by the International Labor Organization (ILO), the paper finds that the implicit pension debt (IPD) of the scheme is high in comparison with GDP of the year 2000, which is the base year for projections. Regarding the social aspect, a high IPD implies that the burden of maintaining this scheme is borne by the current and future participants. For this reason, the pension scheme in Vietnam will cause not only financial instability but also inter-generational inequity. In order to avoid this situation, the current scheme needs to be reformed. In particular, Vietnam should move to a partially-funded defined-contribution scheme with careful considerations of social and economic impacts so as to avoid both financial instability and inter-generational inequity.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Institution: Vietnam Development Forum (VDF)
• Language: English
• Keywords: aging population; pension scheme; pension debt; financial sustainability; Vietnam
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H55 - Social Security and Public Pensions

References

Anh, V. (2002). “Pension Reform in Vietnam” in Pension Reforms in Asian Countries, Proceedings of the International Symposium, Hitotsubashi University, Japan. pp.263-284. Auerbach, A., Kotlikoff, L., Hagemann, R., and Nicoletti, G. (1989). “The Economic Dynamics of Ageing Population: the Case of Four OECD Countries”. Department of Economics and Statistics, the OECD, Paris. Beekman, J.A. (1985). “Actuarial Assumptions and Models for Social Security Projections” in Actuarial Mathematics, Vol. 35, Proceedings of Symposia in Applied Mathematics. American Mathematical Society, U.S.A, pp.85-112. Blanchard, O.J., Weil, P. (2002). “Dynamically Efficiency, the Riskless Rate and Debt Ponzi Games under Uncertainty”. NBER Working Paper No. 3992. Bui, C., Truong, A., Goodkin, D., Knodel, J., and Friedman, J. (1999). “Vietnam Elderly Admist Transformations of Social Welfare Policy”. Population Study Center, Research Reports No.99-436, University of Michigan. Drouin, A., Pierre P., Gylles B., Michael C., Warren R. McGillivray, Michel B., and Hernando P. M. (2002). “Actuarial Practice in Social Security”. International Labor Organization (ILO), and International Social Security Association (ISSA). Estelle, James. (1998). “Social Security Reform-Lessons from Other Nations”. Heritage Foundation. Faruquee, H., Muhleisen, M. (2001). “Population Aging in Japan: Demographic Shock and Fiscal Sustainability”. Research and Asia and Pacific Departments, Working Paper WP/01/40, IMF. Feldstein, M. (1998). “A New Era of Social Security” in The Public Interest No.130, Winter 1998: Financing Our Old Age. Friedman, B., Estelle James, Kane, C., and Queisser, M. (1996). “How Can China Provide Income Security for Its Rapidly Aging Population?”. Policy Research Working Paper No.1674, Policy Research Department, Poverty and Human Resources Division, the World Bank. Gokhale, J. (1996). “Demographic Change, Generational Accounts, and National Saving in the United States”. Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, Working Paper No.9603, the U.S. ________. (1998). “Generational Equity and Sustainability in U.S Fiscal Policy”. Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, the U.S. Hagemann, R., and Nicolleti, G. (1989). “Aging Populations: Economic Effects and Implications for Public Finance”. Department of Economics and Statistics, the OECD. Holzmann, R. (1997, 1998). “Financing the Transition to Multi-pillar”. Department of Education and Social Policy, the World Bank. Holzmann, R; Palacios, R., and Zvinienne, A. (2001). “Implicit Pension Debt: Issues, Measurement, and Scope in International Perspective”. Social Protection, Human Development Department, the World Bank. Holzmann, R., Stiglitz, J.E (Eds). (2001). “New Ideas about Old Age Security: Toward Sustainable Pension Systems in the 21st Century”. The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD), the World Bank. International Labor Organization. (1997). “ILO Social Budgeting Model (ILO-SOCBUD): A Technical Guide”, Geneva. ________. (1997, 2002). “ILO Population Projection Model (ILO-POP): A Technical Guide”, Geneva. ________. (1998). “Vietnam: Report to the Government on Social Protection Development and Training-Actuarial Valuation of the Vietnam Social Security Scheme”, VIE24V3.598, Geneva. ________. (1998). “Internal Guidelines for Actuarial Analysis of a National Social Security Pension Scheme”. International Financial and Actuarial Service ILO FACTS, Social Security Department, Geneva. International Monetary Fund (IMF). (Various years). “Vietnam: Selected Issues, IMF Country Report”. The IMF. Iyer, S. (1999). “Actuarial Mathematics of Social Security Pensions”. International Labor Organization (ILO), and International Social Security Association (ISSA). Kotlikoff, L, J., and Leibfritz, W. (1998). “An International Comparison of Generational Accounts”. NBER Working Paper Series No. 6447. Kunieda, S., (2002). “Japanese Pension Reform: Can We Get Out of Inter-generational Exploitation?” in Pension Reforms in Asian Countries, Proceedings of the International Symposium, Hitotsubashi University, Japan. p.23-63. Noord, P., and Herd, R. (1993). “Pension Liabilities in Seven Major Economies”. Economics Department Working Paper No. 142, the OECD. Paris. Oshio, T. (2002). “Net Pension Liabilities, Inter-generational Equity, and Pension Reforms”. Tokyo Gakugei University, 2002. Socialist Republic of Vietnam. (2002). “Labor Code: Amended and Supplemented in 2002”, Labor and Social Affairs Publishing House, Hanoi, Vietnam. Takayama, N., Kitamura, Y., and Yoshida, H. (1998). “Generational Accounting in Japan”. Institute for Monetary and Economic Studies (IMES) Discussion Paper Series No. 98-E-1, Bank of Japan. World Bank. (1994). “Averting the Old-Age Crisis: Policies to Protect the Old and Promote Growth”, the World Bank, Washington, D.C.

In Vietnamese General Statistical Office (GSO). (Various years). “Nien giam thong ke” (Statistical Yearbook), GSO, Vietnam. Ministry of Labor, Invalids, and Social Affairs (MOLISA). (1993). “Mot so van de ve chinh sach bao dam xa hoi o nuoc ta hien nay” (The Current Situations of Social Protection in Our Country). National Project KX.04.05, Institute of Labor Sciences and Social Affairs, MOLISA, Hanoi, Vietnam. ________. (1993-2000). “Nien giam thong ke lao dong, thuong binh va xa hoi” (Statistical Yearbook on Labor, Invalids, and Social Affairs), Hanoi, Vietnam. ________. (1997). “Co so ly luan va thuc tien de hoan thien che do, chinh sach doi voi nguoi ve huu” (Theoretical Background and Empirical Evidence to Complete Regulations on Retirement), Institute of Labor Sciences and Social Affairs, Hanoi, Vietnam. ________. (1999). “Bao cao danh gia thuc trang bao hiem xa hoi o Vietnam” (Evaluation Report on the Current Status of Social Insurance in Vietnam), Social Insurance Department, MOLISA, Vietnam. ________. (2001). “Cai cach bao hiem xa hoi o Vietnam: tham luan ve su giam sat va quan ly” (Reforming Social Insurance in Vietnam: Discussion on Supervision and Management). ILO Hanoi, Vietnam. National Assembly Office. (2003). “Nghi dinh 218-CP ngay 27/12/1961 ve ban hanh Dieu le tam thoi ve cac che do bao hiem xa hoi doi voi cong nhan, vien chuc Nha nuoc” (Decree 218-CP dated December 27th, 1961 on the Issuance of Temporary Regulations of Social Insurance Schemes for Public Sector Employees”. ________. (2003). “Nghi dinh cua Hoi dong Chinh phu so 39-CP ngay 22/3/1962 ve noi dung thu, chi Quy bao hiem xa hoi cua Nha nuoc” (Government Committee Decree 39-CP dated March 22nd, 1962 on Revenue, Expenditure of Social Insurance Fund of the Government). ________. (2003). “Nghi quyet cua Tong Cong doan so 6-NQ-TCD ngay 21/2/1981 ve Dieu le quan ly Quy bao hiem xa hoi” (Resolution of the General Union N0 6-NQ-TCD dated February 21st, 1981 on Regulations on the Management of Social Insurance Fund). ________. (2003). “Nghi dinh so 43-CP cua Chinh phu ve Quy dinh tam thoi ve cac che do bao hiem xa hoi” (The Government Decree 43-CP dated June 22nd, 1993 on Temporary Regulations of Social Insurance Schemes). ________. (2003). “Nghi dinh 12/CP cua Chinh phu ngay 26/1/1995 ve che do bao hiem xa hoi moi” (The Government Decree N012/CP dated January 26th, 1995 on Regulations of New Social Insurance Scheme). ________. (2003). ”Nghi dinh cua chinh phu so 93/1998/ND-CP ve sua doi va bo sung cac dieu khoan trong Quy dinh ve bao hiem xa hoi ban hanh trong Nghi dinh 12/CP ngay 26/1/1995” (The Government Decree Number 93/1998/ND-CP on Amending and Supplementing Provisions of Social Insurance Regulations, Issued in Attachment to the Government Decree No. 121/CP dated 26/1/1995). Vietnam Social Insurance (VSI). (2000). “So lieu thong ke ve tinh hinh thuc hien bao hiem xa hoi giai doan 1995-1999” (Statistical Data on the Social Insurance Implementation in the period 1995-1999), Hanoi, Vietnam.