Hard to get: The scarcity of women and the competition for high-income men in urban China

Ong, David and Yang, Yu and Zhang, Junsen (2020): Hard to get: The scarcity of women and the competition for high-income men in urban China. Published in: Journal Development Economics No. 144 (May 2020)

Abstract

Reports of the difficulties of elite women in finding suitable mates have been increasing despite the growing availability and value of men in China. We rationalize this “leftover women” phenomenon within the directed/competitive search framework, which uniquely allows for equilibrium crowding out. Within this framework, we show that the leftover women phenomenon can be the result of women’s aversion to men who have a lower income than themselves (hereafter, ALM) and the long-predicted complementarity between women’s non-market traits (in particular, beauty) and male earnings. For high-income (h-)women, even when high-income (H-)men are more plentiful and richer, the direct effect of the greater number of desirable men can be overwhelmed by the indirect effect of competitive ‘entry’ by low-income (l-)women, particularly, the beautiful. We test for these competitive search effects using online dating field experimental, Census, and household survey data. Consistent with the competitive entry of l-women, when sex ratio and H-men’s income increase, the search intensity of beautiful l-women for H-men increases. In response to this competitive entry, plain h-women, who are constrained by their ALM to search predominantly for H-men, also increase their search intensity. However, only their marriage probability decreases. Our evidence is consistent with intra-female competitive search for spouses who can cover the labor market opportunity cost of marriage and childbirth, which increases with a woman’s income.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: directed search, marriage, sex ratio, online dating, aversion to lower income men, beauty
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C9 - Design of Experiments > C93 - Field Experiments; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J0 - General > J01 - Labor Economics: General; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J1 - Demographic Economics > J12 - Marriage ; Marital Dissolution ; Family Structure ; Domestic Abuse

References

Abramitzky, Ran, Delavande, Adeline, & Vasconcelos, Luis. (2011). Marrying Up: The Role of Sex Ratio in Assortative Matching. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 3(July), 124–157.

Andresen, Martin Eckho, & Nix, Emily. (2019). What Causes the Child Penalty? Evidence from Same-Sex Couples and Policy Reforms. Working Paper.

Arcidiacono, Peter, Beauchamp, Andrew, & McElroy, Marjorie. (2016). Terms of Endearment: An Equilibrium Model of Sex and Matching. Quantitative Economics, 7(1), 117–156.

Autor, David, Dorn, David, & Hanson, Gordon. (2018). When Work Disappears: Manufacturing Decline and the Falling Marriage-Market Value of Young Men. American Economic Review: Insights, Forthcoming.

Bartik, Timothy J. (1991). Boon or Boondoggle? The Debate Over State and Local Economic Development Policies. In Who Benefits from State and Local Economic Development Policies? (Vol. 45, pp. 1–16). Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.

Becker, Gary S. (1973). A Theory of Marriage: Part I. Journal of Political Economy, 81(4), 813–46.

Bertrand, Marianne, Cortes, Patricia, Olivetti, Claudia, & Pan, Jessica. (2018). Social Norms, Labor Market Opportunities, and the Marriage Market Penalty for Skilled Women. Working Paper.

Bertrand, Marianne, Goldin, Claudia, & Katz, Lawrence F. (2010). Dynamics of the Gender Gap for Young Professionals in the Financial and Corporate Sectors. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 2(3), 228–255.

Bertrand, Marianne, Kamenica, Emir, & Pan, Jessica. (2015). Gender Identity and Relative Income Within Households. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 130(2), 571–614.

Blau, Francine D., & Kahn, Lawrence M. (2017). The Gender Wage Gap: Extent, Trends, and Explanations. Journal of Economic Literature, 55(3), 789–865.

Boulier, Bryan L., & Rosenzweig, Mark R. (1984). Schooling, Search, and Spouse Selection: Testing Economic Theories of Marriage and Household Behavior. Journal of Political Economy, 92(4), 712.

Brandt, Loren, Turner, Laura, Li, Hongbin, & Zou, Iaqi. (2018). Are China’s “Leftover Women” Really Leftover?: An Investigation of Marriage Market Penalties in Modern-day China, 1–53.

Bruch, Elizabeth E., & Newman, M. E. J. (2018). Aspirational Pursuit of Mates in Online Dating Markets. Science Advances, 4(8), eaap9815.

Burdett, Kenneth, Shi, Shouyong, & Wright, Randall. (2001). Pricing and Matching with Frictions. Journal of Political Economy, 109(5), 1060–1085.

Bütikofer, Aline, Jensen, Sissel, & Salvanes, Kjell G. (2018). The Role of Parenthood on the Gender Gap Among Top Earners. European Economic Review, 109, 103–123.

Caucutt, Elizabeth M., Guner, Nezih, & Knowles, John. (2002). Why do Women Wait? Matching, Wage Inequality, and the Incentives for Fertility Delay. Review of Economic Dynamics.

Chade, Hector, Eeckhout, Jan, & Smith, Lones. (2017). Sorting Through Search and Matching Models in Economics. Journal of Economic Literature, 55(2), 493–544.

Chen, Yi, Zhang, Hong, & Zhou, Li-An. (2018). Motherhood and Gender Wage Differentials Within the Firm: Evidence from China. SSRN Electronic Journal.

Chiappori, Pierre-André, Ong, David, Yang, Yu, & Zhang, Junsen. (2017). Marrying Up: Trading off Spousal Income and Spousal Height. Working Paper.

Chung, Yoon Kyung, Downs, Barbara, Sandler, Danielle, & Sienkiewicz, Robert. (2019). The Parental Gender Earnings Gap in the United States. Working Paper, Center for Economic Studies, U.S. Census Bureau.

Dellavigna, Stefano, Lindner, Attila, Reizer, Balázs, & Schmieder, Johannes F. (2017). Reference-Dependent Job Search: Evidence from Hungary. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 132(4), 1969–2018.

Du, Julan, Wang, Yongqin, & Zhang, Yan. (2015). Sex Imbalance, Marital Matching, and Intra-household Bargaining: Evidence from China. China Economic Review, 35(September), 197–218.

Edlund, Lena, Li, Hongbing, Yi, Junjian, & Zhang, Junsen. (2013). Sex Ratios and Crime: Evidence from China. Review of Economics and Statistics, 95(5), 1520–1534.

Eeckhout, Jan, & Kircher, Philipp. (2010). Sorting and Decentralized Price Competition. Econometrica, 78(2), 539–574.

Feng, Shuaizhang, Hu, Yingyao, & Moffitt, Robert. (2017). Long-Run Trends in Unemployment and Labor Force Participation in Urban China. Journal of Comparative Economics, 45(2), 304–324.

Fincher, Leta H. (2012). China’s “Leftover” Women. The New York Times.

Fisman, Raymond, Iyengar, Sheena S., Kamenica, Emir, & Simonson, Itamar. (2006). Gender Differences in Mate Selection: Evidence from a Speed Dating Experiment. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 121(2), 673–697.

Ge, Suqin, & Yang, Dennis Tao. (2014). Changes in China’s Wage Structure. Journal of the European Economic Association, 12(2), 300–336.

Goldin, Claudia. (2014). A Grand Gender Convergence: Its Last Chapter. American Economic Review, 104(4), 1091–1119.

Gould, Eric D., & Paserman, M. Daniele. (2003). Waiting for Mr. Right: Rising Inequality and Declining Marriage Rates. Journal of Urban Economics, 53(2), 257–281.

Goussé, Marion, Jacquemet, Nicolas, & Robin, Jean-marc. (2018). Marriage, Labor Supply, and Home Production. Econometrica, 85(6), 1873–1919.

Hamermesh, Daniel, & Biddle, Jeff E. (1994). Beauty and the Labor Market. American Economic Review, 84(5), 1174–94.

Hare, Denise. (2016). What Accounts for the Decline in Labor Force Participation Among Married Women in Urban China, 1991-2011? China Economic Review, 38, 251–266.

Harsanyi, John C. (1973). Games with Randomly Disturbed Payoffs: A New Rationale for Mixed-Strategy Equilibrium Points. International Journal of Game Theory, 2(1), 1–23.

Hersch, Joni. (2013). Opting Out Among Women with Elite Education. Review of Economics of the Household, 11(4), 469–506.

Hitsch, Günter J., Hortaçsu, Ali, & Ariely, Dan. (2010a). Matching and Sorting in Online Dating. American Economic Review, 100(1), 130–163.

Hitsch, Günter J., Hortaçsu, Ali, & Ariely, Dan. (2010b). What Makes You Click?-Mate Preferences in Online Dating. Quantitative Marketing and Economics, 8(4), 393–427.

Hopcroft, Rosemary L. (2006). Sex, Status, and Reproductive Success in the Contemporary United States. Evolution and Human Behavior, 27(2), 104–120.

Hwang, Jisoo. (2016). Housewife, “Gold Miss,” and Equal: The Evolution of Educated Women’s Role in Asia and the US. Journal of Population Economics, 29(2), 529–570.

Isen, Adam, & Stevenson, Betsey. (2010). Women’s Education and Family Behavior: Trends in Marriage, Divorce, and Fertility. Demography and Economy, 107–140.

Jeon, Gahye, & Ong, David. (2018). Is Female Competitiveness Influenced by Gender Identity? Working Paper.

Jiang, Quanbao, Feldman, Marcus W., & Li, Shuzhuo. (2014). Marriage Squeeze, Never-Married Proportion, and Mean Age at First Marriage in China. Population Research and Policy Review, 33, 189–204.

Jokela, Markus. (2009). Physical Attractiveness and Reproductive Success in Humans: Evidence from the Late 20th century United States. Evolution and Human Behavior, 30(5), 342–350.

Kleven, Henrik Jacobsen, Landais, Camille, & Søgaard, Jakob Egholt. (2018). Children and Gender Inequality: Evidence from Denmark. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, Forthcoming.

Knight, John, Deng, Quheng, & Li, Shi. (2017). China’s Expansion of Higher Education: The Labour Market Consequences of a Supply Shock. China Economic Review, 43, 127–141.

Kőszegi, Botond, & Rabin, Matthew. (2012). Reference-Dependent Consumption Plans. American Economic Review, 99(3), 909–936.

Lang, Kevin, Manove, Michael, & Dickens, William T. (2005). Racial Discrimination in Labor Markets with Posted Wage Offers. American Economic Review, 95(4), 1327–1340.

Leung, Man Yee Mallory, Groes, Fane, & Santaeulalia-Llopis, Raul. (2016). The Relationship between Age at First Birth and Mother’s Lifetime Earnings: Evidence from Danish Data. PloS One, 11(1), e0146989.

Lundberg, Shelly, & Rose, Elaina. (2000). Parenthood and the Earnings of Married Men and Women. Labour Economics, 7(June), 689–710.

Lundborg, Petter, Plug, Erik, & Rasmussen, Astrid Würtz. (2017). Can Women Have Children and a Career? American Economic Review, 107(6), 1611–1637.

McCrary, Justin. (2008). Manipulation of the Running Variable in the Regression Discontinuity Design: A Density Test. Journal of Econometrics, 142(2), 698–714.

Neyt, Brecht, Vandenbulcke, Sarah, & Baert, Stijn. (2019). Are Men Intimidated by Highly Educated Women? Undercover on Tinder. Economics of Education Review.

Niederle, Muriel, & Vesterlund, Lise. (2007). Do Women Shy Away From Competition? Do Men Compete Too Much? Quarterly Journal of Economics, 122(3), 1067–1101.

Ong, David. (2016). Education and Income Attraction: An Online Dating Field Experiment. Applied Economics, 48(19).

Ong, David, & Wang, Jue. (2015). Income Attraction: An Online Dating Field Experiment. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 111(March), 13–22.

Ong, David, Yang, Yu, & Zhang, Junsen. (2015). Hard to Get: The Scarcity of Women and the Competition for High-income Men in Chinese Cities. Working Paper.

Parish, William L., Luo, Ye, Stolzenberg, Ross, Laumann, Edward O., Farrer, Gracia, & Pan, Suiming. (2007). Sexual Practices and Sexual Satisfaction: A Population-Based Study of Chinese Urban Adults. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 36(1), 5–20.

Parker, Kim, & Wang, Wendy. (2013). Modern Parenthood: Roles of Moms and Dads Converge as They Balance Work and Family. Pew Research Center.

Pollet, Thomas V., & Nettle, Daniel. (2009). Partner Wealth Predicts Self-Reported Orgasm Frequency in a Sample of Chinese Women. Evolution and Human Behavior, 30(2), 146–151.

Qian, Yue, & Qian, Zhenchao. (2014). The Gender Divide in Urban China: Singlehood and Assortative Mating by Age and Education. Demographic Research, 31, 1337–1364.

Rhodes, Gillian. (2006). The Evolutionary Psychology of Facial Beauty. Annual Review of Psychology, 57(1), 199–226.

Ruffle, Bradley J., & Shtudiner, Ze’ev. (2014). Are Good-Looking People More Employable? Management Science, 61(8), 1760–1776.

Shenhav, Na’ama. (2020). Lowering Standards to Wed? Spouse Quality, Marriage, and Labor Market Responses to the Gender Wage Gap. Forthcoming Review of Economics and Statistics.

Stockley, Paula, & Campbell, Anne. (2013). Female Competition and Aggression: Interdisciplinary Perspectives. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences, 368(1631), 20130073.

Wei, Shang-Jin, & Zhang, Xiaobo. (2011). The Competitive Saving Motive: Evidence from Rising Sex Ratios and Savings Rates in China. Journal of Political Economy, 119(3), 511–564.

Weiss, Yoram, Yi, Junjian, & Zhang, Junsen. (2019). Hypergamy, Cross-boundary Marriages, and Family Behavior. International Economic Review.

Wiswall, Matthew, & Zafar, Basit. (2016). Human Capital Investments and Expectations about Career and Family. NBER Working Papers Series.

Wiswall, Matthew, & Zafar, Basit. (2018). Human Capital Investments and Expectations about Career and Family. NBER Working Papers Series.

Wright, Randall, Kircher, Philipp, Julien, Benoît, & Guerrieri, Veronica. (2020). Directed Search and Competitive Search: A Guided Tour. Journal of Economic Literature, Forthcoming

Xu, Yujing, & Yang, Huanxing. (2016). Targeted Search with Horizontal Differentiation in the Marriage Market, (December), 1–53.

Yuan, Yan, Rong, Zhao, & Xu, Lihe. (2012). Sex Imbalance, Marriage Competition, and Entrepreneurship: Evidence from rural China. Working Paper.

Zhang, Junsen, & Liu, Pak-wai. (2003). Testing Becker’s Prediction on Assortative Mating on Spouses’ Wages. Journal of Human Resources, 38(1), 99–110.