Two ethnic security dilemmas and their economic origin

Khemraj, Tarron (2019): Two ethnic security dilemmas and their economic origin.

Abstract

The paper outlines two ethnic security dilemmas (ESDs) that permeate Guyanese economic and political life. At the heart of the ESDs are strategic uncertainty of voters and the joy of destruction (envy) of political leaders. Most voters vote pro-ethnically and leaders of one political party find strategies to undermine the other. The prize is the control of government and associated economic opportunities. This view is supported by a survey of Guyanese historical political and economic contests. The dilemmas occur because the interrelated political strategies of the two ethnic-based parties produce a sub-optimal economic outcome for everyone, although a superior economic outcome (equilibrium) exists but cannot be achieved because the dominant parties find it impossible to coordinate and cooperate within the confines of the present constitutional and electoral frameworks. High strategic uncertainty and low inter-group trust fuel the inherent dilemmas among voters and political leaders. Ideas or metaphors from applied game theory are used to define the ESDs more precisely and suggest possible solutions.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: prisoners’ dilemma; stag hunt; inequality; economic underdevelopment
• Subjects: O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O10 - General; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O5 - Economywide Country Studies; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O5 - Economywide Country Studies > O54 - Latin America ; Caribbean; Z - Other Special Topics > Z1 - Cultural Economics ; Economic Sociology ; Economic Anthropology

References

Abbink, K., J. Brandt, B. Herrmann and H. Orzen (2010) ‘Intergroup conflict and intra-group punishment,’ The American Economic Review 100 (1), 420 – 447.

Abbink, K. and A. Sadrieh (2009) ‘The pleasure of being nasty,’ Economics Letters 105 (3), 306 – 308.

Acemoglu, D., S. Johnson and J. Robinson (2002) ‘Reversal of fortune: geography and institutions in making the modern world income distribution,’ The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 117 (4) 1231 – 1294.

Adamson, A. (1972) Sugar without Slaves: The Political Economy of British Guiana, 1838–1904, New Heaven and London: Yale University Press.

Bowles, S. and H. Gintis (2011) A Cooperative Species: Human Reciprocity and its Evolution, Princeton and Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Bissessar, A. (2002) ‘Addressing ethnic imbalances in the public services of plural societies: the case of Guyana and Trinidad and Tobago,’ International Journal of Public Sector Management 15 (1) 55 – 68.

Brown, D. (1999) ‘Ethnic politics and public sector management in Trinidad and Guyana,’ Public Administration and Development 19 (4), 367 – 379.

Bulkan, J. (2014), ‘Forest grabbing through forest concession practices: the case of Guyana,’ Journal of Sustainable Forestry 33 (4), 407 – 434.

Bulmer-Thomas, V. (2012) The Economic History of the Caribbean since the Napoleonic War, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Casal, S., W. Guth, M. Jia and M. Ploner (2012) ‘Would you mind if I get more? An experimental study of the envy game,’ Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 84 (3), 857 – 856.

Collins, A. (1998) ‘The ethnic security dilemma: evidence from Malaysia,’ Contemporary Southeast Asia 20 (3), 261 – 278.

Constantine, C. (2017a) ‘Economic structures, institutions and economic performance,’ Journal of Economic Structures 6 (2), 1 – 18.

Constantine, C. (2017b) ‘The rise of income inequality in Guyana,’ Social and Economic Studies 66 (3&4), 65 – 95.

Constantine, C. and T. Khemraj (2019) ‘Geography, economic structures and institutions: a synthesis,’ Structural Change and Economic Dynamics 51 (December), 371 – 379.

DaCosta, M. (2007) ‘Colonial origins, institutions and economic performance in the Caribbean: Guyana and Barbados,’ IMF Working Paper WP/07/43, International Monetary Fund.

Danns, G. K. (1982) Domination and Power in Guyana: A Study of the Police in a Third World Context, New Brunswick and London: Transaction Books,

Despres, L. A. (1975, reprint 2011) ‘Ethnicity and resource competition in Guyanese society,’ in L. A. Despres (ed.) Ethnicity and Resource Competition in Plural Societies, The Hague and Paris: DeGruyter.

Despres, L. A. (1969) ‘Differential adaptations and micro-cultural evolution in Guyana,’ Southwestern Journal of Anthropology 25 (1), 14 – 44.

Despres, L. A. (1967) Cultural Pluralism and Nationalist Politics in British Guiana, Chicago: Rand McNally and Company.

Dev, R. (2019) ‘The same politics of domination,’ Guyana Times, Features, January 20, retrieved from: https://guyanatimesgy.com/ .

Dev, R. (2011) ‘Ethnic impact statement,’ Kaieteur News, Features, July 17: https://www.kaieteurnewsonline.com/.

Dev, R. (1991) ‘For a new political culture in Guyana,’ Discussion Paper, The Jaguar Committee for Democracy.

Dixit, A., S. Skeath and D. Reiley (2015) Games of Strategy, 4th edition, New York and London: W. W. Norton & Company.

D.W. (2019) ‘No plan to resign, will exhaust appeals – Granger; Harmon deems UN official’s position against gov’t “premature”,’ Demerara Waves, in Elections, National News, Politics, February 3: retrieved from: http://demerarawaves.com/.

Edwards, D. (2017) ‘Corruption and state capture in Guyana: a plural approach,’ Transition 44, 86 – 124.

Fader, P. S. and J. R. Hauser (1988) ‘Implicit coalitions in a generalized prisoners’ dilemma,’ Journal of Conflict Resolution 32 (3), 553 – 582.

Fang, C., S. Orla Kimbrough, S. Pace, A. Valluri and Z. Zheng (2002) ‘On adaptive emergence of trust behaviour in the game of stag hunt,’ Group Decision and Negotiation 11 (6), 449 – 467.

Farley, R. (1954) ‘The rise of the peasantry in British Guiana,’ Social and Economic Studies 2 (4), 87 – 103.

Gafar, J. (1996) ‘From cooperative socialism to economic liberalization and growth: 1976 – 1994,’ Journal of Developing Areas 31 (1), 41 – 74.

Gampat, R. (2015) Guyana: From Slavery to the Present, Vol. 1: Health System, Bloomington, Indiana: Xlibris.

Greenidge, C. B. (2001) Empowering a Peasantry in a Caribbean Context: The case of Land Settlement Schemes in Guyana, 1865 – 1985. Barbados, Jamaica, and Trinidad and Tobago: University of West Indies Press.

Hinds, D. (2019) ‘For a change, the PPP is being outmanoeuvred by the Coalition,’ Kaieteur News, Hinds’ Sight, January 27, retrieved from: https://www.kaieteurnewsonline.com/.

Hinds, D. (2010a) ‘Ethnicity and the elusive quest for power sharing in Guyana,’ Ethnopolitics 9 (3&4), 333 – 355.

Hinds, D. (2010b) Ethno-Politics and Power Sharing in Guyana: History and Discourse, Washington, DC: New Academia Publishing.

Hinds, D. (2005) ‘Problems of democratic transition in Guyana: mistakes and miscalculations in 1992,’ Social and Economic Studies 54 (1), 67 – 82.

Hintzen, P. (1989) The Cost of Regime Survival: Racial Mobilization, Elite Domination and the Control of the State in Guyana and Trinidad, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

James, R. (2006) ‘The Constitution of Guyana,’ Transition, Special Issue 35 – 36, University of Guyana.

Jansson, F. and K. Eriksson (2015) ‘Cooperation and shared beliefs about trust in the assurance game,’ PLoS One 10 (12), doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0144191.

Jeffrey, H. (2019) ‘Guyanese democracy has not yet been born,’ Stabroek News, Future Notes, March 6, retrieved from: https://www.stabroeknews.com/.

Jervis, R. (1978) ‘Cooperation under the security dilemma,’ World Politics 30 (2), 167 – 214.

Josiah, B. (1997) ‘After emancipation: aspects of village life in Guyana, 1869 – 1911,’ Journal of Negro History 82 (1), 105 – 121.

Kaufman, S. (1996) ‘An international theory of inter-ethnic war,’ Review of International Studies 22 (2), 149 – 171.

Khemraj, T. (2016) ‘The political economy of Guyana’s underdevelopment,’ Review of Black Political Economy 43 (3 & 4), 325 – 342.

Khemraj, T. (2015) ‘The colonial origins of Guyana’s underdevelopment,’ Social and Economic Studies 64 (3 & 4), 151 – 185.

Kissoon, F. (2019) ‘A brief history of instabilities in Guyana, 1953-2019,’ Kaieteur News, Features, March 7, retrieved from: https://www.kaieteurnewsonline.com/.

Kissoon, F. (2007) ‘African extremism in the age of political decay: the case of Guyana,’ In C. Grant and R. Mark Kirton (eds.) Conflict Analysis and Conflict Resolution, Kingston: Ian Randle Publishers.

Kollock, P. (1998) ‘Social dilemmas: the anatomy of cooperation,’ Annual Review of Sociology 24 (August), 183 – 214.

Mandle, J. (1973) The Plantation Economy: Population and Economic Change in Guyana, 1838 – 1960, Philadelphia: Temple University Press.

Mars, P. (1990) ‘Ethnic conflict and political control: the Guyana case,’ Social and Economic Studies 93 (3), 65 – 94.

Moohr, M. (1972) ‘The economic impact of slave emancipation in British Guiana, 1832 – 1852,’ The Economic History Review 25 (4), 588 – 607.

Myers, R. J. Calder (2011) ‘Toward ethnic conflict transformation: a case study of citizen peacebuilding initiatives on the 2006 General Elections,’ Occasional Paper: Peace Building Series No. 4, Future Generations Graduate School.

Norton, A. (2007) ‘Governance in an ethnically divided society: the Guyana case,’ in C. H. Grant and R. M. Kirton (eds.), Governance, Conflict Analysis and Conflict Resolution. Miami and Kingston, Jamaica: Ian Randle Publishers.

Olesker, R. (2011) ‘Israel’s societal security dilemma and the Israeli-Palestinian peace process,’ Nationalism and Ethnic Politics 17 (2), 382 – 401.

Panaritis, E. and A. Kostopoulos (2010) ‘Guyana property rights study,’ Discussion Paper No. IDB-DP-141, Inter-American Development Bank.

Potter, L. (1998) ‘Breaking away from sugar? East Indians and the rice industry of Guyana, 1905-1940,’ South Asia: Journal of South Asian Studies 21(1), 137 – 160.

Powers, M. and Z. Shen (2008) ‘Social stability and catastrophic risk: lessons from the stag hunt,’ Journal of Theoretical Politics 20 (4), 477 – 497.

Premdas, R. (2004) ‘The Guyana ethnic quagmire: problems and solutions for reconciliation,’ Nationalism and Ethnic Politics 10 (2), 251 – 268.

Premdas, R. (1995) Ethnic Conflict and Development: The Case of Guyana, Avebury: Brookfield, USA, Hong Kong, Singapore and Sydney and the United Nations Research Institute for Social Development.

Posen, B. R. (1993) ‘The security dilemma and ethnic conflict,’ Survival 35 (1), 27 – 47.

Ramharack, B. (1992) ‘Consociational democracy: a democratic option for Guyana,’ Caribbean Studies 25 (1&2), 75 – 101.

Reinert, E. S. (2008) How Rich Countries Got Rich…and Why Poor Countries Stay Poor, New York: Carroll and Graf Publishers.

Reinert, E. S. (2006) ‘Institutionalism ancient, old and new,’ Research Paper No. 2006/77, World Institute for Development Economics Research, United Nations University.

Roe, P. (1999) ‘The intrastate security dilemma: ethnic conflict as a ‘tragedy’,’ Journal of Peace Research 36 (2), 183 – 202.

Schelling, T. C. (1960) The Strategy of Conflict, Cambridge, MA and London: Harvard University Press.

Sen, A. (1967) ‘Isolation, assurance and the social rate of discount,’ The Quarterly Journal of Economics 81 (1), 112 – 124.

Singh, T. B. (2009) ‘Social norms and interpersonal trust,’ Working Paper, University of Kent.

Singh, T. B. (2007) ‘Poverty, economics and conflict management,’ in C. H. Grant and R. M. Kirton (eds.), Governance, Conflict Analysis and Conflict Resolution. Miami and Kingston, Jamaica: Ian Randle Publishers.

S.N. (2018) ‘The only friends I got is PNC, so the only people I could give work to is PNC – Lawrence tells PNCR conference,’ Stabroek News, Local News, November 30.

S.N. (2017) ‘Lincoln Lewis produces transport for Berbice village bought by ancestor in 1800s,’ Stabroek News, Local News, August 30.

Straub, P. (1995) ‘Risk dominance and coordination failures in static games,’ Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance 35 (4), 339 – 363.

Williams, E. (1945) ‘The historical background of British Guiana’s problems,’ Journal of Negro History 30 (4), 357 – 381.

Zizzo, D. and A. Oswald (2001) ‘Are people willing to reduce others’ incomes?’ Annals of Economics and Statistics 63 (64), 39 – 65.