Are renewables profitable in 2030 and do they reduce carbon emissions effectively? A comparison across Europe

Bertsch, Valentin and Di Cosmo, Valeria (2020): Are renewables profitable in 2030 and do they reduce carbon emissions effectively? A comparison across Europe.

Abstract

The European Union has set ambitious targets for expanding renewable energy to meet emission reduction goals. After a period of subsidy-driven investments, the costs of renewables decreased strongly and renewable support schemes shift towards more market-based approaches. We therefore analyse the market-based profitability of wind onshore and offshore and solar PV across Europe to determine where it is optimal to invest and understand which factors drive the profitability of investments. We use a power systems model to simulate the whole European electricity market in 2030. Using the renewables’ revenues determined by the model, we calculate the profitability of each technology in each country. We also analyse how effective renewables are in terms of emission reduction. Investments are found not to be homogeneously profitable across Europe, i.e. cooperation between European countries can be expected to achieve the overall targets at lower costs than nationally-driven approaches. We also find that in many countries, wind onshore and solar PV are profitable by 2030 in absence of any financial support, whereas wind offshore does never seem profitable without support. Finally, RES expansion alone will not guarantee an effective reduction of CO2 emissions.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Renewable Energy; Renewable Energy Target; Renewable Electricity Target; EU Electricity Market; Profitability; Emission Reduction; Carbon Price; Carbon Price Floor
• Subjects: Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q4 - Energy > Q42 - Alternative Energy Sources; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q52 - Pollution Control Adoption and Costs ; Distributional Effects ; Employment Effects; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q58 - Government Policy

References

European Commission. Impact Assesment accompayning the document Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament , the Council, the European Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions. A Policy Framework for Climate and Energy in the period from 2020 up to 2030. 2014.

EU Council. European Council (23 and 24 October 2014) Conclusions. Technical report, European Council, 10 2014. URL http://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cms_data/docs/pressdata/en/ec/145397.pdf.

European Commission. Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament , the Council, the European Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions. A Policy Framework for Climate and Energy in the period from 2020 up to 2030. 2014.

EUROSTAT. Greenhouse gas emission statistics. Technical report, EUROSTAT, 2017. URL http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/ Greenhouse_gas_emission_statistics.

European Commission. European Commission – Statement: Europe leads the global clean energy transition: Commission welcomes ambitious agreement on further renewable energy development in the EU. Statement/18/4155, 14 June 2018. 2018.

G. Papaefthymiou and Ken Dragoon. Towards 100% renewable energy systems: Uncapping power system flexibility. Energy Policy, 92:69 – 82, 2016.

Anne Held, Mario Ragwitz, Frank Sensfuß, Gustav Resch, Luis Olmos, Andrés Ramos, and Michel Rivier. How can the renewables targets be reached costeffectively? Policy options for the development of renewables and the transmission grid. Energy Policy, 116:112 – 126, 2018.

Carlo Cambini and Laura Rondi. Incentive regulation and investment: evidence from European energy utilities. Journal of Regulatory Economics, 38(1):1–26, 2010.

Trine Krogh Boomsma, Nigel Meade, and Stein-Erik Fleten. Renewable energy investments under different support schemes: A real options approach. European Journal of Operational Research, 220(1):225 – 237, 2012.

Ottmar Edenhofer, Lion Hirth, Brigitte Knopf, Michael Pahle, Steffen Schömer, Eva Schmid, and Falko Ueckerdt. On the economics of renewable energy sources. Energy Economics, 40(Supplement 1):S12–S23, 2013.

G. S. Sisodia and I. Soares. Panel data analysis for renewable energy investment determinants in Europe. Applied Economics Letters, 22(5):397–401, 2015.

Jenny Winkler, Alberto Gaio, Benjamin Pfluger, and Mario Ragwitz. Impact of renewables on electricity markets - do support schemes matter? Energy Policy, 93: 157 – 167, 2016.

IRENA. Renewable power generation costs in 2012: An overview. Technical report, IRENA, 2012. URL http://www.irena.org/DocumentDownloads/factsheet/ costing%20factsheet.pdf.

Samuel C Huntington, Pablo Rodilla, Ignacio Herrero, and Carlos Batlle. Revisiting support policies for RES-E adulthood: Towards market compatible schemes. Energy Policy, 104:474–483, 2017.

Wen-Shan Tan, Mohammad Yusri Hassan, Md Shah Majid, and Hasimah Abdul Rahman. Optimal distributed renewable generation planning: A review of different approaches. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 18:626 – 645, 2013.

Vicki Duscha, Arnaud Fougeyrollas, Carsten Nathani, Matthias Pfaff, Mario Ragwitz, Gustav Resch, Wolfgang Schade, Barbara Breitschopf, and Rainer Walz. Renewable energy deployment in Europe up to 2030 and the aim of a triple dividend. Energy Policy, 95:314 – 323, 2016.

Karolina Safarzynska and Jeroen C.J.M. van den Bergh. Financial stability at risk due to investing rapidly in renewable energy. Energy Policy, 108:12 – 20, 2017.

Brigitte Knopf, Paul Nahmmacher, and Eva Schmid. The European renewable energy target for 2030 - An impact assessment of the electricity sector. Energy Policy, 85:50 – 60, 2015.

Manish Ram, Michael Child, Arman Aghahosseini, Dmitrii Bogdanov, Alena Lohrmann, and Christian Breyer. A comparative analysis of electricity generation costs from renewable, fossil fuel and nuclear sources in g20 countries for the period 2015-2030. Journal of Cleaner Production, 199:687 – 704, 2018. ISSN 0959-6526.

IEA. World energy outlook. techreport, OECD/IEA, 2018.

Farfan J. Sadovskaia K. et al. Bogdanov, D. Radical transformation pathway towards sustainable electricity via evolutionary steps. Nature Communications, 10 (1077), 2019.

Laura Malaguzzi Valeri. Not all electricity is equal – uses and misuses of levelized cost of electricity (lcoe). Internet, August 2019. URL https://www.wri.org/blog/2019/08/ insider-not-all-electricity-equal-uses-and-misuses-levelized-cost-electricity-lcoe.

Muireann Lynch, Mel T Devine, and Valentin Bertsch. The role of power-to-gas in the future energy system: Market and portfolio effects. Energy, 185:1197–1209, 2019.

F. Egli, B. Steffen, and T.S Schmidt. Bias in energy system models with uniform cost of capital assumption. Nature Communications, 10, 2019.

Christiane Hennig, Andre Brosowski, and Stefan Majer. Sustainable feedstock potential - a limitation for the bio-based economy? Journal of Cleaner Production, 123 (Supplement C):200 – 202, 2016.

Florian Egli, Bjarne Steffen, and Tobias S Schmidt. A dynamic analysis of financing conditions for renewable energy technologies. Nature Energy, 3(12):1084–1092, 2018.

Bjarne Steffen. Estimating the cost of capital for renewable energy projects. USAEE Working Paper, 2019.

EU Commission. Taxonomy: Final report of the technical expertgroup on sustainable finance. Technical report, European Commission, 2020.

Dimitrios Angelopoulos, Robert Brückmann, Filip Jirouš, Inga Konstantinavici ut˙c, Paul Noothout, John Psarras, Lucie Tesniére, and Barbara Breitschopf. Risks and cost of capital for onshore wind energy investments in eu countries. Energy & Environment, 27(1):82–104, 2016.

Robin Leisen, Bjarne Steffen, and Christoph Weber. Regulatory risk and the resilience of new sustainable business models in the energy sector. Journal of Cleaner Production, 219:865 – 878, 2019. ISSN 0959-6526.

Arthur Bossavy, Maxime Chammas, Jeanne Fauquet, Maxime Fender, Laurent Fournié, Paul Khallouf, and Bertrand Texier. METIS Technical Note T6 – METIS Power System Module. Technical report, European Commission, Directorate-General for Energy, 5 2017. URL https://ec.europa.eu/energy/sites/ener/files/ power_system_module.pdf.

Karsten Neuhoff, Julian Barquin, Maroeska G. Boots, Andreas Ehrenmann, Benjamin F. Hobbs, Fieke A.M. Rijkers, and Miguel Vázquez. Network-constrained Cournot models of liberalized electricity markets: the devil is in the details. Energy Economics, 27(3):495 – 525, 2005.

JP Deane, M Ó Ciaráin, and BP Ó Gallachóir. An integrated gas and electricity model of the EU energy system to examine supply interruptions. Applied Energy, 193:479–490, 2017.

European Commission, August 2018. URL https://ec.europa.eu/commission/ presscorner/detail/en/STATEMENT_18_4155.

Iratxe Gonzales Aparicio, Andreas Zucker, Francesco Careri, Fabio Monforti, Thomas Huld, and Jake Badger. Part I: Wind power generation European Meteorological derived High resolution RES generation time series for present and future scenarios. Technical Report EUR 28171 EN; 10.2790/831549, JRC (Joint Research Centre) EU Commission and Emhires dataset, 2016.

ENTSOE. Ten Year National Developement Plan 2016 Scenario Developement Report. Technical report, ENTSOE, 2016.

DECC. Decc fossil fuel price projection. Technical report, Department of Energy and Climate Change UK, 2016.

Viktor Slednev, Valentin Bertsch, Manuel Ruppert, and Wolf Fichtner. Highly resolved optimal renewable allocation planning in power systems under consideration of dynamic grid topology. Computers & Operations Research, 96:281 – 293, 2018.

Michael Taylor, Pablo Ralon, and Andrei Ilas. The power to change: solar and wind cost reduction potential to 2025. International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA), 2016.

EU Commission Staff. Impact Assestment Accompanying the document Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions A policy framework for climate and energy in the period from 2020 up to 2030. Technical report, European Commission, 2014. URL http://bit.ly/1qlgII5.

Andres P Perez, Enzo E Sauma, Francisco D Munoz, Benjamin F Hobbs, et al. The economic effects of interregional trading of renewable energy certificates in the US WECC. The Energy Journal, 37(4), 2016.

David Toke. The EU Renewables Directive—What is the fuss about trading? Energy Policy, 36(8):3001–3008, 2008.

RJ Green, Danny Pudjianto, Iain Staffell, and Goran Strbac. Market design for long-distance trade in renewable electricity. The Energy Journal, 37:5–22, 2016.

Reinhard Haas, Gustav Resch, Christian Panzer, Sebastian Busch, Mario Ragwitz, and Anne Held. Efficiency and effectiveness of promotion systems for electricity generation from renewable energy sources–Lessons from EU countries. Energy, 36(4): 2186–2193, 2011.

María Teresa García-Álvarez, Laura Cabeza-García, and Isabel Soares. Analysis of the promotion of onshore wind energy in the EU: Feed-in tariff or renewable portfolio standard? Renewable Energy, 111:256 – 264, 2017.

Anna Bergek, Ingrid Mignon, and Gunnel Sundberg. Who invests in renewable electricity production? Empirical evidence and suggestions for further research. Energy Policy, 56:568 – 581, 2013.

Andrea Masini and Emanuela Menichetti. Investment decisions in the renewable energy sector: An analysis of non-financial drivers. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 80(3):510 – 524, 2013.

Valentin Bertsch, Jutta Geldermann, and Tobias Lühn. What drives the profitability of household PV investments, self-consumption and self-sufficiency? Applied Energy, 204:1–15, 2017.

Wander Jager. Stimulating the diffusion of photovoltaic systems: A behavioural perspective. Energy Policy, 34(14):1935 – 1943, 2006.

Calvin Lee Kwan. Influence of local environmental, social, economic and political variables on the spatial distribution of residential solar PV arrays across the United States. Energy Policy, 47:332 – 344, 2012.

Markus Graebig, Georg Erdmann, and Stefan Röder. Assessment of residential battery systems (RBS): profitability, perceived value proposition, and potential business models. In 37th IAEE international conference, volume 25, pages 1–15, 2014.

Towhidul Islam. Household level innovation diffusion model of photo-voltaic (PV) solar cells from stated preference data. Energy Policy, 65:340 – 350, 2014.

Olivier De Groote, Guido Pepermans, and Frank Verboven. Heterogeneity in the adoption of photovoltaic systems in Flanders. Energy Economics, 59:45 – 57, 2016.

Yuliya Karneyeva and Rolf Wüstenhagen. Solar feed-in tariffs in a post-grid parity world: The role of risk, investor diversity and business models. Energy Policy, 106: 445–456, 2017.

Alain Bonnafous and Pablo Jensen. Ranking transport projects by their socioeconomic value or financial internal rate of return? Transport Policy, 12(2):131 – 136, 2005.

Sarah LaMonaca and Lisa Ryan. Solar PV where the sun doesn’t shine: Estimating the economic impacts of support schemes for residential PV with detailed net demand profiling. Energy Policy, 108:731 – 741, 2017.

Olivier De Groote and Frank Verboven. Subsidies and Myopia in New Technology Adoption: Evidence from Solar Photovoltaic Systems. SSRN Electronic Journal, DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.2828062, 2016.

Richard Green and Nicholas Vasilakos. The economics of offshore wind. Energy Policy, 39(2):496–502, 2011.

Daniel Radov, Carmel Alon, and Clemens Koenig. Gale Force Competition? Auctions and Bidding Strategy for Offshore Wind. Technical report, NERA, 2016.

Craig Brown, Rahmatallah Poudineh, and Benjamin Foley. Achieving a costcompetitive offshore wind power industry: what is the most effective policy framework? Technical report, The Oxford Institute for Energy Studies, 2015. URL https://www.oxfordenergy.org/wpcms/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/ Executive-Summary-Achieving-a-cost-competitive-offshore-wind-power-industry. pdf.

Joao Gorenstein Dedecca, Rudi A. Hakvoort, and J. Roland Ortt. Market strategies for offshore wind in Europe: A development and diffusion perspective. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 66:286 – 296, 2016.

Valentin Bertsch, Marie Hyland, and Michael Mahony. What drives people’s opinions of electricity infrastructure? Empirical evidence from Ireland. Energy Policy, 106: 472 – 497, 2017.

Marie Hyland and Valentin Bertsch. The role of community involvement mechanisms in reducing resistance to energy infrastructure development. Ecological Economics, 146:447–474, 2018.

Desta Z Fitiwi, Muireann Lynch, and Valentin Bertsch. Power system impacts of community acceptance policies for renewable energy deployment under storage cost uncertainty. Renewable Energy, 2020.

Rolf Wüstenhagen, Maarten Wolsink, and Mary Jean Bürer. Social acceptance of renewable energy innovation: An introduction to the concept. Energy Policy, 35(5): 2683 – 2691, 2007.

Valentin Bertsch, Margeret Hall, Christof Weinhardt, and Wolf Fichtner. Public acceptance and preferences related to renewable energy and grid expansion policy: Empirical insights for Germany. Energy, 114:465 – 477, 2016.

Jason Harold, Valentin Bertsch, Thomas Lawrence, and Magie Hall. Drivers of people’s preferences for spatial proximity to energy infrastructure technologies: a crosscountry analysis. The Energy Journal (accepted), 2020.

Adriane Schmidt. Need for a wind of change? Use of offshore wind messages by stakeholders and the media in Germany and their effects on public acceptance. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 60(8):1391–1411, 2017.

Matthias Kalkuhl, Ottmar Edenhofer, and Kai Lessmann. Renewable energy subsidies: Second-best policy or fatal aberration for mitigation? Resource and Energy Economics, 35(3):217 – 234, 2013.

E.A. Martínez Ceseña, J. Mutale, and F. Rivas-Dávalos. Real options theory applied to electricity generation projects: A review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 19:573 – 581, 2013.

Lucia Santos, Isabel Soares, Carla Mendes, and Paula Ferreira. Real options versus traditional methods to assess renewable energy projects. Renewable Energy, 68:588 – 594, 2014.