Toxic famine research and how it suppresses its critics

Bowbrick, Peter (2020): Toxic famine research and how it suppresses its critics.

Abstract

Bad economic theory can cause famines or stop governments from taking appropriate action to prevent famines. This can kill millions. Amartya Sen’s theory of the cause of the Bengal Famine, which is the inspiration for his ‘entitlement approach’, has been refuted again and again, in different ways, by economists of different theoretical persuasions and by statisticians expert in this area. Sen has been shown to systematically misrepresent the evidence, to make repeated, elementary, theoretical mistakes, and to use and misuse ‘meaningless’ statistics. No attempt has been made by anyone to challenge these refutations: they are incontrovertible. Sen has not retracted his theory, or any of it, which implies fraud. Yet Sen’s work is widely believed and used in famine situations. His ‘entitlement approach’, based largely on his theory of the Bengal famine, is the basis of a research programme. This paper examines how the research programme suppressed the criticisms, ignoring the normal requirements of academic and professional research and integrity. It also produced new falsehoods.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Famine,refutation,fabrication, false evidence, false statistics, Bengal famine, suppressing,
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H56 - National Security and War; H - Public Economics > H8 - Miscellaneous Issues > H84 - Disaster Aid; N - Economic History > N5 - Agriculture, Natural Resources, Environment, and Extractive Industries; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O12 - Microeconomic Analyses of Economic Development; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q11 - Aggregate Supply and Demand Analysis ; Prices; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q13 - Agricultural Markets and Marketing ; Cooperatives ; Agribusiness; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q18 - Agricultural Policy ; Food Policy

References

Agne, H. (2010). Does global democracy matter? Hypotheses on famine and war. In C. a. Jönsson, Transnational Actors in Global Governance: Patterns, Explanations, and Implications. Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 177-196.

Amery, L. (1988). The Empire at Bay: the Leo Amery Diaries, 1929–1945, [J.Barnes and D. Nicholson, eds.] . London: Hutchinson.

Arendt, H. (1964). Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil .

Aristotle. (350 BC). Nicomachean Ethics’ (translated by Ross, W. D.). Available at http://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/nicomachaen.html.

Aristotle. (n.d.). Rhetoric.

Aykroyd, W. (1974). The conquest of famine. London: Chatto and Windus.

B.R. Sen. (1982). Towards a Newer World. Dublin: Tycooly International Publishing Ltd.

Babbage, C. (1864). Passages from the Life of a Philosopher. Longman and Co.

Basu, D. (1986). Sen's analysis of famine: a critique. The Journal of Development Studies, 22:3.

Beard, M. (2008). Pompeii: the life of a Roman Town. London: Profile Books.

Bengal Administration. (1897.). Bengal Famine Code, (Revised edition of December 1895). Calcutta.

Bengal Government. (1913). Bengal Famine Code. Calcutta.

Bengal Government. (1941). Famine Manual. Alipore: Revenue Department India.

Bengal Land Revenue Commission. (1940). Report cited in Mahalanobis (1944).

Bhatia, B. (1967). Famines in India. Bombay : Asia Publishing House.

Blackman, C. (1986, July). Personal Communication.

Blyn, G. (1966). Agricultural Trends in India 1891-1947: Output Availability and Production. University of Pennsylvania Press.

Bowbrick, P. (1985). How Professor Sen’s theory can cause famines. Agricultural Economics Society Conference.

Bowbrick, P. (1986). The Causes of Famine - A refutation of Professor Sen's theory. Food Policy, 11(2) 105-124.

Bowbrick, P. (1987). Rejoinder: an untenable hypothesis on the causes of famine. Food Policy. , 12(1) 5-9, February.

Bowbrick, P. (1988). Are price reporting systems of any use? British Food Journal, 90(2) 65-69 March/April.

Bowbrick, P. (1988, 2008). A Refutation of Sen's Theory of Famines. Retrieved May 27, 2013, from Peter Bowbrick: http://www.bowbrick.org.uk/Publications/Complete%20Sen%20July08.pdf

Bowbrick, P. (1992). The Economics of Quality, Grades and Brands. London: Routledge.

Bowbrick, P. (2012). From Economic Research to Policy in 32 Years. Eurochoices, 11 (3) 44-47.

Bowley, A., & Robertson, D. (1934). A Scheme for an Economic Census of India, Delhi. Cited in Dewey, C., (1978) ‘Patwari and Chaukidar: subordinate officials and the reliability of India’s agricultural statistics.’ pp 280–314.

Braund, H. (1944). Famine in Bengal. Typescript, British Library Doc D792.

Brown, M. (1944). India need not starve! Bombay: Longmans. Champernowne, D. (1968). Seminar.

Chandra, M. (1943, August). Report to Calcutta Statesman. cited in Stephens (1966).

Charteris-Black, J. (2014). Analysing Political Speeches. Basingstoke and New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

Chatterton, Brian and Mukerjee, Madhusree, reply by Joseph Lelyveld. (2011, February 24). The Bengal Famine. New York Review of Books, pp. 1-2.

Clément, M. (2009). Amartya Sen et l’analyse socioéconomique des famines : portée, limites et prolongements de l’approche par les entitlements. Cahiers du GREThA 2009 – 25.

Cutler, P. V. (1988). The development of the 1983-85 famine in northern Ethiopia. PhD thesis, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine. . DOI: https://doi.org/10.17037/PUBS.00682234.

Daoud, A. (2018). Synthesizing the Malthusian and Senian approaches on scarcity: a realist account. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 42, 453-476.

Das, T. (1949). Bengal Famine. As revealed in a survey of the destitutes of Calcutta. Calcutta: University of Calcutta.

Das, T. (n.d.). Part II: Test Survey of Famine Condition in Bengal Villages from November 1943 to March 1944. In T. Das, Bengal Famine (1943): as revealed in a survey of the destitutes of Calcutta. Calcutta.: Calcutta University.

De Waal, A. (2018). Mass starvation: the history and future of famine. Polity Press.

Department of Agriculture, Bengal. (1922). Manual of Rules for the Preparation of Crop Reports and Agricultural Statistics. Calcutta: Bengal Secretariat Book Depot.

Desai, M., & Shah, C. (1949). Agricultural Statistics. Indian Journal of Agricultural Economics,, 4(2).

Desai, R. (1953). Standard of living in India and Pakistan, 1931-2 to 1940-41,. Bombay: Popular Book Depot.

Devereux, S. (2001). Sen’s Entitlement Approach: Critiques and Counter Critiques. Oxford Development Studies, Vol. 29, No. 3, 245-263.

Dewey, C. (1978). Patwari and Chaukidar: subordinate officials and the reliability of India’s agricultural statistics. In C. Dewey, & A. Hopkins, The Imperial Impact: Studies in the Economic History of Africa and India (pp. 280–314). Athlone Press.

Dewey, C. (1993). Anglo-Indian Attitudes: The mind of the Indian Civil Service. London: The Hambledon Press.

Dreze, J. (1995). The Political Economy of Hunger, volume 2 Famine Prevention.

Duhs, L. (2008). Sen’s economic philosophy: Capabilities and human development in the revival of economics as a moral science. Real-World Economics Review, , 47: 173-191.

Dutt, T. (1944). Hungry Bengal. Lahore: Indian Printing Works.

Dyson, T. (1991). On the Demography of South Asian Famines, Part 2. Population Studies,, 45:2.

Dyson, T. (1996). Population and Food: global trends and future prospects. London: Routledge.

Dyson, T. (2020). The 1943-44 Bengal famine and food availability decline. (PowerPoint presentation). Historical Economic Demography Workshop, LSE. London.

Dyson, T., & Maharatna, A. (1991). Excess mortality during the Great Bengal Famine: a Re-evaluation. The Indian Economic and Social History Review, 28:3.

Elahi, K. (2006). Entitlement failure and deprivation: A critique of Sen's famine philosophy. Journal of Development Studies .

Elahi, K. Q.-I. (2016-2017). Amartya Sen, FAD and the 1974 Famine in Bangladesh: a closer look. Bangladesh Journal of Agricultural Economics, 17-33.

Engler, S., Köster, J., & Siebert, A. (2014). Farmers Food Insecurity Monitoring: Identifying Situations of Food Insecurity and Famine. IFHV Working Paper , Vol. 4, No. 3,. Epstein, S. (1967). Productive Efficiency and Customary Systems of Reward in Rural South India. In F. Raymond, Themes in Economic Anthropology. London: Tavistock, for the Association of Social Anthropologists.

Epstein, S. (1994). Integration of the cognitive and the psychodynamic unconscious. American Psychologist, 49, 709-724.

Famine Inquiry Commission. (1945). Report on Bengal. New Delhi: Government of India.

Famine Inquiry Commission. (1945a). Report on Bengal. New Delhi: Government of India.

Famine Inquiry Commission. (1945b). Final Report. Madras,: Government of India.

Fine, B. (1997). Entitlement Failure? Development and Change, 617-647.

Fisher. (1937). Agriculture and Animal Husbandry in India 1935-36. Imperial Council for Agricultural Research.

Frere, S. B. (1874). On the Impending Bengal Famine: How it will be met and how to prevent future famines in India. London: John Murray.

Ghosh, K. (1944). Famines in Bengal, 1170-1943 . Calcutta: Indian Associated Publishing.

Ghosh, T. (1944). The Bengal Tragedy. Lahore: Hero Publications.

Goswami, O. (1990). The Bengal Famine of 1943: Re-examining the data. Indian Economic and Social History Review, 27:4.

Government of India. (1946). Census of India, 1941. Delhi: Manager of Publications.

Greenough, P. R. (1982). Prosperity and Misery in Modern Bengal - The famine of 1943-1944. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Griffiths, P. (2003). The Economist's Tale: a consultant encounters hunger and the World Bank. London and New York: Zed Books.

Hoffer, P. (2004). Past Imperfect. New York: Public Affairs.

Huddleston, H. J. (1978). Sampling techniques for measuring and forecasting crop yields. Washington DC: USDA.

Hunter, W. (1873). Famine Aspects of Bengal. Simla.

Imperial Council of Agricultural Research. (1950). Sample Surveys for the Estimation of Yield of Foodcrops, 1944-49. . Cited in Dewey, C., (1978).

Islam, M. M. (2007). The Great Bengal famine and the Question of FAD Yet Again. Modern Asian Studies , 41(2): 421-40.

Kahneman, D. (2012). Thinking, Fast and Slow. London: Penguin.

Knight, H. (1954). Food Administration in India, 1939-47. Palo Alto.

Kuhn, T. (1962). Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Leith, S. (2011). You talking to me? Rhetoric from Aristotle to Obama. London: Profile Books.

Magee, H. (1951). Nutrition lessons of the Berlin Blockade. Public Health Reports, 622-666.

Mahalanobis. (1943). Organisation of Statistics in the Post-War Period. Symposium, (pp. 69-78).

Mahalanobis. (1968). Sample Census of area under jute in Bengal 1940. cambs sas 541:633.52.

Mahalanobis, P. (1944). Organisation of Statistics in the Post-War Period. Proceedings of the National Institute of Sciences of India, x P.71.

Mahalanobis, P. (1945-6). Sample Surveys of Crop Yields in India. Sankhya, 7 269.

Mahalanobis, P. (1946). Recent experiments in statistical sampling in the Indian Statistical Institute. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, , Part iv, pp326–378.

Mahalanobis, P., Mukkerjee, R., & Ghosh, A. (1946). A sample survey of after effects of Bengal famine of 1943. . Sankhya, 7(4),337-400.

Mansergh, N. (. (1973). The transfer of power 1942-7 vol IV. London: HMSO.

Maxwell, N. (1987, July). Letter on the suppression of the Famine Inquiry Commission Report. Institute of Commonwealth Studies, Queen Elizabeth House, Oxford.

Mishra, A. (2000). Reviewing the Impoverishment Process: The Great Bengal Famine of 1943. Indian Historical Review , 27: 79.

Moon, P. (1973). Wavell: the Viceroy’s journal. Oxford : OUP.

Morgenstern, O. (1963). On the accuracy of economic observations. Princeton N.Y.: Princeton University Press.

Mukerjee, Madhusree, reply by Amartya Sen. (2011, February 24). The Bengal Famine. The New York Review of Books.

Mukherjee, A. (1995-1996 ). Institutional Sanctions, Choice and the Secondary Food System: Incompleteness of Sen’s Entitlement and Deprivation Thesis as an Explanation of Hunger. Indian Economic Journal, Vol. 43, No. 4, April-June.

Neumayer, E. (2008). Famine Mortality, Rational Political Inactivity, and International Food Aid. SSRN Electronic Journal.

Nolan, P. (1991). Why do famines occur and how can they be avoided? A critique of A.K. Sen on famine, with special reference to China. Famine Conference, Jesus College. Cambridge.

Nolan, P. (1993). The causation and prevention of famines: a critique of A.K. Sen. Journal of Peasant Studies, 21(1), 1-28.

Nolan, P., & Sender, J. (1992). Death rates, life expectancy and China's economic reforms, A critique of A.K.Sen. World Development.

O Grada, C. (2007). Making Famine History. Journal of Economic Literature, 5-38.

O Grada, C. (2008). The Ripple that Drowns? Twentieth-century Famines in China and India as Economic History. The Economic History Review, 61(s1):5 - 37.

O Grada, C. (2010). Sufficiency and Sufficiency and Sufficiency: Revisiting the Great Bengal Famine of 1943-44. Dublin: University College Dublin.

O'Grada, C. (2007). Making Famine History. Journal of Economic Literature, 5-38.

Osmani, S. (1993). The entitlement approach to famine: an assessment. Helsinki: Working paper UNU.

Padmanabhan, S. (1973). The Great Bengal Famine. Annual Review of Phytopathology, 11:11-24.

Padmanabhan, S., & Ganguly, D. (1953). Relation between the age of rice plant and its susceptibility to helminthosporium and blast diseases. Proceedings of the Indian Academy of Sciences, Section B, 39 (2). pp. 44-50.

Padmanabhan, S., Raichoudhury, K., & Ganguly, D. (1948). Helminthosporium disease of rice, I Nature and extent of damage caused by the disease. Indian Phytopathology, I, 1, 34-47.

Panse, V. (1954b). Estimation of Crop Yields. Rome: FAO.

Panse, V. G. (1954 ). Report on the Scheme for the Improvement of the Agricultural Statistics . Delhi. : http://203.200.22.249:8080/jspui/bitstream/123456789/753/1/Report_on_the_scheme_for_the_improvement_agricultural_statistics.pdf.

Panse, V. G., & Sukhatme, P. (1954c). Statistical Methods for Agricultural Workers. New Delhi: Indian Council of Agricultural Research.

Pinnell, L. (1944). The Pinnell Archive on the Bengal Famine: Evidence to the Famine Inquiry Commission. British Library doc EUR Doc 911.

Plümper, T., & Neumayer, E. (2009). Famine mortality, rational political inactivity, and international food aid. World development .

Popper, K. (1974). Conjectures and refutations: the growth of scientific knowledge. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. Popper, K. (1975). The Logic of Scientific Discovery. London: Hutchinson.

Pretty, J., Thompson, J., & Hinchcliffe, F. (2019). Sustainable Agriculture: impacts on production and challenges for food security. International Institute for Envirionment and Development.

Proctor, R. N. (2008). Agnotology: a missing term to describe the cultural production of ignorance (and its study). In R. N. Proctor, & L. Shiebinger, Agnotology: The Making and Unmaking of Ignorance (pp. 1-36). Stanford: Stanford University Press.

Rajan, N. (1944). Famine in retrospect. Bombay: Pamda Publications.

Ravallion, M. (1987). Market Responses to Anti-Hunger Policies: Effects on wages, prices and employment . World Institute for Development Economics Research, UN University.

Ravallion, M. (1990). Market Responses to Anti Hunger Policies. In J. Dreeze, The Political Economy of Hunger, voume 2 Famine Prevention (p. 258). Clarendon Press.

Ravallion, M. (1997). Famines and Economics . Journal of Economic Literature, 205-242.

Ravallion, M. (1998, April 17). email.

Research Triangle Institute. (1995). Consequences of Whistleblowing for the Whistleblower in Misconduct in Science Cases. Office of Scientific Integrity.

Royal Commission on Agriculture in India. (1928). Report of the Royal Commission on Agriculture in India. Parliamentary Papers, VIII, P.605.

Rubin, O. (2009). The entitlement approach - a case for framework development rather than demolition. Journal of Development Studies , 622-641.

Rubin, O. (2016). Contemporary Famine Analysis. Springer.

Rubin, O. (2018). The Precarious State of Famine Research. The Journal of Development Studies.

Sanderson, F. H. (1954). Methods of Crop Forecasting. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.

Sarracino. (2010). Explaining famines: a critical review of main approaches and further causal factors. NAF-IRN Working Paper.

Seaman, J., & Holt, J. (1980). Markets and Famines in the Third World. Disasters, 283-297.

Sen, A. ( 1984). Resources, values and development. Oxford, UK: Blackwell.

Sen, A. (1976). Famines as failures of entitlements. Economic and Political Weekly, Special No. August.

Sen, A. (1977). Starvation and exchange entitlements: a general approach and its application to the Great Bengal Famine. Cambridge Journal of Economics, No 1, , pp 33--59, .

Sen, A. (1980). Famine Mortality: a study of the Bengal Famine of 1943. In H. e. al., Peasants in History: Essays in Memory of Daniel Thorner. Calcutta: OUP.

Sen, A. (1980b). Famines. World Development, 613-21.

Sen, A. (1981). Poverty and Famines. Oxford, UK: Clarendon Press .

Sen, A. (1981b). Ingredients of famine analysis: availability and entitlements. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 433-464.

Sen, A. (1984). Resources, values and development. Oxford: Blackwell.

Sen, A. (1986). The causes of famine: a reply. Food Policy, 11(2) 125-132.

Sen, A. (1987). Reply: famine and Mr Bowbrick. Food Policy , 12(1) 10-14.

Sen, A. (1991). A bewildered response to Peter Nolan. Famine Conference. Cambridge.

Sen, A. (1992). Life and death in China: a reply. World Development.

Sen, A. (1993). The Causation and Prevention of Famines: a reply. The Journal of Peasant Studies, 29-40.

Sen, Amartya . (2011, February 24). The Bengal Famine. The New York Review of Books.

Sen, B. R. (1982). Towards a Newer World. Dublin: Tycooly International Publishing Ltd.

Sen, Shila. (1976). Muslim Politics in Bengal, 1937-1947. New Delhi: Impex India.

Slovic, P. (2007). 'If I look at the mass I will never act'. Psychic numbing and genocide. Judgement and Decision Making, 79-95.

Spinks, G. R. (1956). Uses and methods of crop forecasting. Review of Marketing and Agricultural Economics, 18-32.

Stevens, I. (1966). Monsoon morning. London: Ernest Benn.

Stevenson, R. (2005). Bengal Tiger and British Lion: an account of the Bengal Famine of 1943. New York: Universe.

Sukatme, P. (1945). Random Sampling for Estimating Rice Yield in Madras Province. Indian Journal of Agricultural Science.

Sukatme, P. (1947). The Problem of Plot Size in Large-Scale Yield Surveys. Journal of the American Statistical Association.

Sukatme, P. (1947). Use of Small Size Plots in Yield Surveys. Nature.

Sukatme, P. (1954). Sampling Theory of Surveys with Applications. Indian Society of Agricultural Statistics and Iowa State University Press.

Sukatme, P., & Kishen, K. (1951). Systems of Agricultural Statistics. Bulletin of International Statistical Institute.

Sukatme, P., & Panse, V. (1951). Crop Surveys in India — II . Journal of Indian Society of Agricultural Statistics.

Sukatme, P., & V G Panse, V. (1954). Statistical Methods for Agricultural Workers. Indian Council of Agricultural Research.

Sweeney, S. (2009). Indian railroading: floating railway companies in the late nineteenth century. Economic History Review, pp. 57-59.

Tauger, M. (2003). Entitlement, Shortage and the 1943 Bengal Famine: Another Look. The Journal of Peasant Studies, 31:45 - 72.

Tauger, M. (2006). Entitlement, Shortage, and The 1943 Bengal Famine. Journal of Peasant Studies.

Tauger, M. (2009). The Indian Famine Crisis of World War II. British Scholar, Vol. I, Issue 2 (March).

Tauger, Mark and reply by Amartya Sen. (2011, March 24). The Truth About the Bengal Famine. The New York Review of Books, pp. 2-3.

Thompson, P. B. (2015). From world hunger to food sovereignty: food ethics and human development. Journal of Global Ethics,, 11:3, 336-350.

Trevaskis, H. K. (1931). The Punjab of Today. Lahore: 2 vols, Cited in Dewey (1978).

Tversky, A., & Kahneman, D. (1974). Judgement Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. Science, 184:

Vedhyasekaran, N., Ramadoss, N., & Srinivasalu, N. (1973). Quantitative and qualitative losses in paddy due to helminthosporiose epidemic. Indian Phytopathology.

Westmoreland, D., & McCormick, C. (2020, January 11). Make Deniers your Friends. New Scientist, p. 21.

Williams, G. (1999). Assessing poverty and poverty alleviation: evidence from West Bengal. Trans Inst Br Geogr NS , 24 193–212 .

Wollstoncroft, M. (1792 [1994]). A Vindication of the Rights of Women and A Vindication of the Rights of Men. Oxford: Oxford World Classics.