Fiscal federalism and equalization design under the growing public finance constraint: a case of Italian municipalities

Brugnano, Carmela and Ferraina, Giuseppe and Loi, Francesca and Minzyuk, Larysa and Nitti, Marianna (2020): Fiscal federalism and equalization design under the growing public finance constraint: a case of Italian municipalities.

Abstract

Recently, the issue of federalism has turned at the centre of the political debate in Italy. It is basically due to the growing demand of rich northern regions who in 2018 laid down the requests to exercise additional functions retaining a more significant part of revenues that the central government collects in their territories. Another reason for attention to this issue is that the long period of public finance consolidation in Italy (2011-15) put the implementation of fiscal federalism to a standstill. There is a growing demand to ascertain the measure to which this implementation has been biased o remained undone. This paper focuses on this second issue investigating to which extent the design of fiscal federalism reform has been applied to the Italian municipalities with a special focus on the equalization system. The paper first proposes a review on the evolution of public finance setting in Italy before the crisis (2008-09), considering the decentralization process in the 1990s and the Constitutional reform of 2001 followed by the enabling law 42 in 2009. Then it looks at the period of fiscal consolidation after the financial crisis in 2011 focusing on the burden of adjustment measures imposed to Italian municipalities. Finally, it tries to summarize the contradictions that the overlapping of two contrasting political agendas – the centralization of public finance under fiscal consolidation and the ongoing fiscal federalism reform – created for the equalization system of municipalities.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Fiscal federalism, Public finance consolidation, Equalization system, Italian municipalities
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H50 - General; H - Public Economics > H6 - National Budget, Deficit, and Debt > H60 - General; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H70 - General

References

Ambrosanio, M., & Bordignon, M. (2007). Il federalismo fiscale in Italia: fatti e problemi. Quaderni rossi ASSBB, 234, 1-104.

Ambrosanio, M., Bordignon, M. & Cerniglia, F.M. (2010). Constitutional Reforms, fiscal decentralization and regional fiscal flows in Italy. In Bosch, N., Espasa, M. & M. Sole Ollè (eds.), The Political Economy of Inter-Regional Fiscal Flows (75-107). Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Bordignon, M., Ambrosanio, M., & Balduzzi, P. (2016). Economic crisis and fiscal federalism in Italy. In Ahmad, E., Bordignon, M., Brosio, G. (eds.), Multi-level Finance and the Euro Crisis (212-246), Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Ambrosanio, M., & Balduzzi, P. (2013). La situazione della finanza pubblica italiana. Osservatorio Monetario, 2, 43-55.

Balduzzi, P., Ambrosanio, M., & Bordignon, M. (2014). Case study: Economic crisis and fiscal federalism in Italy. Working paper series, 16, 1-34.

Blochliger, H., & King, D. N. (2007). Less than you thought: the fiscal autonomy of sub-central governments. OECD Economic Studies, 2006 (2), 155-188.

Brugnano, C., Ferraina, G., Ferri, A., Minzyuk, L. & Russo, F (2017). Federalismo municipale e nuovo sistema perequativo: il Fondo di solidarietà comunale 2016. Economia Pubblica 2/2017, 93-133.

COPAFF First Report 2014, Condivisione tra i livelli di governo dei dati sull’ entità e la ripartizione delle misure di consolidamento della finanza pubblica. [http://www.mef.gov.it/ministero/commissioni/copaff/documenti/Primo_rapporto_Copaff_su_entitx_e_ripartizione_misure_finanza_pubblica_gennaio_2014.pdf].

Dafflon, B., & Mischler, P. (2007). Expenditure needs equalisation at the local level: methods and practice. In Kim, J. and Lotz, J. (eds.), Measuring Local Government Expenditure Needs, 213-240. The Copenhagen Workshop.

Brosio, G. (2018). Ambition beyond feasibility? Equalization transfers to regional and local governments in Italy. Working Papers FEDEA 2018-09.

IFEL (2019). La finanza comunale in sintesi - Rapporto 2019. [https://www.fondazioneifel.it/documenti-e-pubblicazioni/item/download/3410_1784abea3a086d86f6363eaf17c6d78f].

IFEL (2016). Capacità fiscali e fabbisogni standard: la nuova perequazione comunale per il 2017 [https://www.fondazioneifel.it/documenti-e-pubblicazioni/item/8582-capacita-fiscali-e-fabbisogni-standard-la-nuova-perequazione-comunale-per-il-2017]

Monteduro, M.T. (2019). Legge di Bilancio 2019 e autonomia tributaria: quali prospettive per la finanza comunale? Federalismo in Toscana 1(2). [http://www.irpet.it/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/art--2-federalismo-in-toscana-1_2019.pdf].

Pedaci, M., Betti, M., & Di Federico, R. (2018) Industrial relations, employment and the economic crisis in the Italian public sector. An analysis on primary education, hospitals and municipalities. Amsterdam AIAS [https://www.researchgate.net/publication/324482758_Industrial_relations_employment_and_the_economic_crisis_in_the_Italian_public_sector_An_analysis_on_primary_education_hospitals_and_municipalities].

Reschovsky, A. (2007). Compensating local governments for differences in expenditure needs in a horizontal fiscal equalization program. In Boadway, R. and Shah, A. (eds.) The Theory and Practice of Intergovernmental Fiscal Transfers, 397-424. Washington, DC: The World Bank.

Rodean, N. (2012). Fiscal federalism in Italy. Between necessity and sustainability. Revista Española de Derecho Constitucional, 95, 215-239.

UPB Nota n.1/2017. Fabbisogni standard e capacità fiscali nel sistema perequativo dei Comuni. [http://www.upbilancio.it/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Nota-1_2017.pdf].