Delayed privatization in Kosovo: causes, consequences, and implications in the ongoing process

Mulaj, Isa (2005): Delayed privatization in Kosovo: causes, consequences, and implications in the ongoing process. Published in: (January 2005): pp. 123-163.

Abstract

Kosovo is distinguished from other transition countries by being the last country to embark on privatization. The wave of revolutionary political and economic changes spreading like wildfire across the Central and Eastern European countries and in former Soviet Union since 1989 found Kosovo under occupation for a full decade. Privatization as one of the most crucial elements of market-oriented reforms was not extended to socially owned enterprises (SOEs) in Kosovo, despite the fact that it was originally initiated by the last president of the Federal Executive Council of former Yugoslavia, Ante Marković and used in a limited number of enterprises. The overwhelming majority of SOEs in Kosovo came under a series of the so-called emergency measures introduced by Serbia during the 1990s, resulting in the dismissal of the Albanian employees at large, the de facto occupation of Kosovar SOEs, and the forced merger with Serbian companies. For nearly a decade, SOEs in Kosovo became subject to illegal ownership transactions and transformation with serious implications for the post-war legal privatization. With the disappearance of the Serbian state control after the 1999 war, in accordance with United Nations Security Council Resolution 1244, the United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo (UNMIK) has been in charge of Kosovo’s development. At the beginning of the transition to a market system, the discussion of privatization also resurfaced under the UNMIK. It took nearly one year to come with the first privatization proposal. Other proposals followed, until June 2002 when the final proposal, envisaging privatization via the spin-off approach and reorganisation or liquidation through the bankruptcy process was approved. In this paper we look at the specific features of the delayed privatization in Kosovo, emphasising in particular two stages: i) the events during 1990s, including the consequences of emergency measures, ii) the impact of an autonomous privatization in the early 1990s in a limited number of SOEs in the Gjakova region based on a survey of these enterprises, and iii) the critical assessment of the privatization proposals and the challenges in continuing the ongoing privatization process after the war.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: SOEs, emergency measures, UNMIK, Kosovo Trust Agency, privatization.
• Subjects: K - Law and Economics > K1 - Basic Areas of Law > K11 - Property Law; N - Economic History > N9 - Regional and Urban History; N - Economic History > N9 - Regional and Urban History > N94 - Europe: 1913-; P - Economic Systems > P2 - Socialist Systems and Transitional Economies > P26 - Political Economy ; Property Rights; P - Economic Systems > P3 - Socialist Institutions and Their Transitions > P31 - Socialist Enterprises and Their Transitions

References

ANDERSON, L., AND E. HUGGINS (2003): "Property Rights: A practical Guide to Freedom and Prosperity," Hoover Institution Press, (515).

BAJT, A. (1988): Samoupravni Oblik Drusteuene Svojine {Self-management Type of Social Ownership}. Globus, Zagreb.

BARTLETT, w., J. CABLE, s. ESTRlN, c. JONES, AND c. SMITH (1992): "Labor-managed Cooperatives and Private Firms in Northern Italy: An Empirical Comparison," Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 45(1), 103-118.

BERG, A., AND E. BERG (1997): "Methods of Privatization," Journal of International Affairs, 50(2), 357-390.

BLAIR, M. (1995): Ownership and Control: Rethinking Corporate for the Twenty-first Century. The Brookings Institution.

BOGETIC, V. (1993): "The Role of Employee Ownership in Privatisation of State Enterprises in Eastern and Central Europe," Europe-Asia Studies, 45(3), 463-481.

BUCK, T., I. FILATOTCHEV, AND M. WRIGHT (1994): "Employee Buyouts and the Transformation of Russian Industry," Comparative Economic Studies, 36(2), 1-15.

COMMANDER, S., F. CORICELLI, AND K. STAEHR (1991): "Wages and Employment in the Transition to a Market Economy," World Bank Working

DoucoULIAGOS, C. (1995): "Worker Participation and Productivity in Labor-managed and Participatory Capitalist Firms: A Meta-analysis," Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 49(1), 58-77.

EARLE, S. (1998): "Post-privatization Ownership Structure and Productivity in Russian Industrial Enterprises," Upjohn Institute for Employment Research, Central European University; Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA}, Working Paper.

EUROPEAN STABILITY INITIATIVE ESI (2002}: The Ottoman Dilemma: Power and Property Relations Under the United Nations Mission in Kosovo, Lessons Learned and Analysis Unit of the EU Pillar of UNMIK in Kosovo.

FEDERATION OF INDEPENDENT TRADE UNIONS OF Kosovo – BSPK (1993): "Plackitja e Kapitalit te Ndermarrjeve te Kosoves (Plundering of the Capital of Kosovo's Enterprises)," Proceedings from the Press Conference, 13 October.

FETAHU, A. (1992): "Masat e Perkohshme: Akte te Shkaterrimit te Ndermarrjeve dhe Institucioneve te Kosoves (Interim Measures: Destructive Actions Against Kosovo's Enterprises and Institutions)," Bashkimi i Sindikatava te Pavarura te Kosoves, ed., Siprint, Prizren.

FURUBOTN, E., AND S. PEJOVICH (1970): "Property Rights and the Behaviour of the Firm in a Socialist State: The Example of Yugoslavia," Zeitschrift fiir NationalOkonomie, 30, 430-454.

GROSSMAN, S. J., AND 0. HART (1986): "The Costs and Benefits of Ownership: A Theory of Lateral and Vertical Integration," Journal of Political Economy, 94(4), 691-719.

HART, 0. (1995): Firms, Contracts and Financial Structure. Clarendon Press, Oxford.

HASHI, I. (1998): "Employee Ownership and Enterprise Behavior: Evidence from Poland's Privatization by Liquidation," Russian and East European Finance and Trade, 34(2), 58-84.

HORVAT, B. (1982): The Political Economy of Socialism: A Marxist Social Theory. Martin Robertson, Oxford.

HORVAT (1986): "The Theory of the Worker-managed Firm Revisited," Journal of Comparative Economics, 10(1), 9-'20.

IRELAND, N., AND P. LAW (1982): The Econon.ics of Labor – managed Enterprises. Grow Helm, London.

JONES, D., AND MYGIND (2000): "The Effects of .Privatization on Productive Efficiency: Evidence from the Baltic Repubiics," Annals of Public & Cooperative Economics, 71(3), 415-439.

KALMI, 0. (2002): On the (ln)stability of Employees Ownership: Evidence From Estonia and Lessons for Transition Economies, PhD dissertation (manuscript). Copenhagen.

KAUFMANN, D., AND P. SIEGELBAUM (1996): "Privatization and Corruption in Transition Economies," Journal of International Affairs, 50(2).

PALAIRET, M. (2001): "The Economic Consequences of Slobodan Milosevic," Europe-Asia Studies, 53(6), 903-919.

RIINVEST (2001): "Socially Owned Enterprises and their Privatization," Research Report, Riinvest, Pristina.

RIINVEST (2002): "SME Development in Kosova," Survey Report, Riinvest, Pristina.

SHACHMUROVE, Y., AND U. SPIEGEL (1995): "Labor-managed Firms in Transition Economies," Comparative Economic Studies, 37(1), 39-53.

SMITH, S. (1994): "On the Law and Economics of Employee Privatization in Developing and transition Countries," Annals of f3 Cooperative Economics, 65(3), 437-468.

TIJANIC, A., AND S. CURUVIJA (1999): What's Next Mr. Milosevic'? Institute of War and Peace Reporting, London.

UVALIC, M. (1997): "Privatization in the Yugoslav Successor States: Con­verting Self-management into Property Rights," in Privatisation Surprises in Central and Eastern Europe, ed. by M. Uvalle, and D. Vaughan­Whitehead, pp. 267-302. Edwar Elgar, Aldershot.