Bias or ignorance? The politics and economics behind sovereign credit ratings

Dähler, Timo (2020): Bias or ignorance? The politics and economics behind sovereign credit ratings.

Abstract

Given that sovereign bond markets may be vulnerable to multiple equilibria and self-fulfilling prophecies, a debate exists over whether and in what way credit rating agencies (CRAs) are politically biased and may weaponize sovereign credit ratings. Recent research by Fuchs and Gehring (2017) suggests that CRAs are not biased in favor of countries which are geo-politically aligned with their home country. In this paper, I argue that such a bias exists and that it should manifest empirically once two features of the global economy are controlled for: hidden debt owed to China and the global network of central bank swap line arrangements. To provide support for my argument, I first replicate the results reported by Fuchs and Gehring and then extend the analysis in several ways to account for these two features that have recently emerged in global finance to show that an in-group bias is present across major CRAs.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: home bias; in-group bias; sovereign credit ratings; credit rating agencies; international finance
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F3 - International Finance > F34 - International Lending and Debt Problems; F - International Economics > F6 - Economic Impacts of Globalization > F65 - Finance; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G24 - Investment Banking ; Venture Capital ; Brokerage ; Ratings and Ratings Agencies; H - Public Economics > H6 - National Budget, Deficit, and Debt > H63 - Debt ; Debt Management ; Sovereign Debt

References

Afonso, A. (2003). Understanding the determinants of sovereign debt ratings: Evidence for the two leading agencies. Journal of Economics and Finance, 27(1):56–74.

Afonso, A., Furceri, D., and Gomes, P. (2012). Sovereign credit ratings and financial markets linkages: application to european data. Journal of International Money and Finance, 31(3):606–638.

Aizenman, J. and Pasricha, G. K. (2010). Selective swap arrangements and the global financial crisis: Analysis and interpretation. International Review of Economics & Finance, 19(3):353–365.

Ammer, J. and Packer, F. (2000). How consistent are credit ratings? a geographic and sectoral analysis of default risk. The Journal of Fixed Income, 10(3):24–30.

Archer, C. C., Biglaiser, G., and DeRouen, K. (2007). Sovereign bonds and the “democratic advantage”: Does regime type affect credit rating agency ratings in the developing world? International organization, 61(2):341–365.

Baker, C. (2013). The federal reserve’s use of international swap lines. Ariz. L. rev., 55:603. Bar-Isaac, H. and Shapiro, J. (2011). Credit ratings accuracy and analyst incentives. American Economic Review, 101(3):120–24.

Barro, R. J. and Lee, J.-W. (2005). Imf programs: Who is chosen and what are the effects? Journal of monetary Economics, 52(7):1245–1269.

Becker, G. S. (2010). The economics of discrimination. University of Chicago press.

Borensztein, E., Cowan, K., and Valenzuela, P. (2013). Sovereign ceilings “lite”? the impact of sovereign ratings on corporate ratings. Journal of Banking & Finance, 37(11):4014–4024.

Cantor, R., Packer, F., et al. (1994). The credit rating industry. Quarterly Review, pages 1–26.

Chey, H.-k. (2013). The fed swap lines and the global lender of last resort: The politics of international monetary relations. In APSA 2013 Annual Meeting Paper.

Cole, H. L. and Kehoe, P. J. (1998). Models of sovereign debt: Partial versus general reputations. International Economic Review, pages 55–70.

Dale, R. S. and Thomas, S. H. (1991). The regulatory use of credit ratings in international financial markets. Journal of International Securities Markets, 5(3):9–18.

DiGiuseppe, M. R., Barry, C. M., and Frank, R. W. (2012). Good for the money: Inter- national finance, state capacity, and internal armed conflict. Journal of Peace Research, 49(3):391–405.

Dreher, A. and Gassebner, M. (2008). Does political proximity to the us cause terror? Economics Letters, 99(1):27–29.

Durbin, E. and Ng, D. (2005). The sovereign ceiling and emerging market corporate bond spreads. Journal of international Money and Finance, 24(4):631–649.

Feldstein, M. and Horioka, C. (1979). Domestic savings and international capital flows. Technical report, National Bureau of Economic Research.

Ferri, G., Liu, L.-G., and Stiglitz, J. E. (1999). The procyclical role of rating agencies: Evidence from the east asian crisis. Economic Notes, 28(3):335–355.

Fitch Ratings, F. (2018). Fitch Ratings–Rating Definitions. Retrieved from https://www.fitchratings.com/site/dam/jcr:6b03c4cd-611d-47ec-b8f1- 183c01b51b08/Rating

French, K. R. and Poterba, J. M. (1991). Investor diversification and international equity markets. Technical report, National Bureau of Economic Research.

Fuchs, A. and Gehring, K. (2017). The home bias in sovereign ratings. Journal of the European Economic Association, 15(6):1386–1423.

Gartner, M., Griesbach, B., and Jung, F. (2011). Pigs or lambs? the european sovereign debt crisis and the role of rating agencies. International advances in economic research, 17(3):288.

Gehrig, T. (1993). An information based explanation of the domestic bias in international equity investment. The Scandinavian Journal of Economics, pages 97–109.

Giannetti, M. and Yafeh, Y. (2012). Do cultural differences between contracting parties matter? evidence from syndicated bank loans. Management Science, 58(2):365–383.

Grinblatt, M. and Keloharju, M. (2001). How distance, language, and culture influence stockholdings and trades. The Journal of Finance, 56(3):1053–1073.

Guiso, L., Sapienza, P., and Zingales, L. (2006). Does culture affect economic outcomes? Journal of Economic perspectives, 20(2):23–48.

Horn, S., Reinhart, C. M., and Trebesch, C. (2019). China’s overseas lending. Technical report, National Bureau of Economic Research.

Huberman, G. (2001). Familiarity breeds investment. The Review of Financial Studies, 14(3):659–680.

Jaramillo, L. and Tejada, M. (2011). Sovereign credit ratings and spreads in emerging markets: does investment grade matter? IMF Working Papers, pages 1–17.

Kolo, P. (2012). Measuring a new aspect of ethnicity: The appropriate diversity index. Technical report, Discussion Papers, Ibero America Institute for Economic Research.

McCallum, J. (1995). National borders matter: Canada-us regional trade patterns. The American Economic Review, 85(3):615–623.

McDowell, D. (2019). The (ineffective) financial statecraft of china’s bilateral swap agreements. Development and Change, 50(1):122–143.

Melitz, J. (2008). Language and foreign trade. European Economic Review, 52(4):667–699.

Mosler, M. and Potrafke, N. (2020). International political alignment during the Trump presidency: voting at the UN general assembly. International Interactions, pages 1–17.

Obstfeld, M., Shambaugh, J. C., and Taylor, A. M. (2009). Financial instability, reserves, and central bank swap lines in the panic of 2008. American Economic review, 99(2):480–86.

Panizza, U., Sturzenegger, F., and Zettelmeyer, J. (2009). The economics and law of sovereign debt and default. Journal of economic literature, 47(3):651–98.

Ravina, E. et al. (2008). Love & loans: The effect of beauty and personal characteristics in credit markets. Journal of Finance.

Reinhart, C. (2019). The curious case of the missing defaults. HKS Working Paper No. RWP19-004.

Rigobon, R. (2002). The curse of non-investment grade countries. Journal of Development Economics, 69(2):423–449.

Samuelson, W. and Zeckhauser, R. (1988). Status quo bias in decision making. Journal of risk and uncertainty, 1(1):7–59.

Shin, Y. S. and Moore, W. T. (2003). Explaining credit rating differences between Japanese and US agencies. Review of Financial Economics, 12(4):327–344.

Tesar, L. L. and Werner, I. M. (1995). Home bias and high turnover. Journal of international money and finance, 14(4):467–492.

Tomz, M. and Wright, M. L. (2007). Do countries default in “bad times”? Journal of the European Economic association, 5(2-3):352–360.

Voeten, E. (2019). Data and analyses of voting in the united nations general assembly. In Routledge handbook of international organization, pages 80–92. Routledge.

White, L. J. (2010). Markets: The credit rating agencies. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 24(2):211–26.

Wolf, H. C. (2000). Intranational home bias in trade. Review of economics and statistics, 82(4):555–563.