Munich Personal RePEc Archive

Production and Scale Efficiency of South African Water Utilities: The Case of Water Boards

Ngobeni, Victor and Breitenbach, Marthinus C (2021): Production and Scale Efficiency of South African Water Utilities: The Case of Water Boards.

[img]
Preview
PDF
MPRA_paper_106242.pdf

Download (638kB) | Preview

Abstract

South Africa is a water scarce country with deteriorating water resources. Faced with tight fiscal and water resource constraints, water utilities would have to adopt technically efficient water management technologies to meet developmental socio-economic objectives of universal coverage, aligned to the United Nation’s Sustainable Development Goal 6 (SDG 6). It is important to measure the technical efficiency of utilities as accurately as possible in order to inform policy. We do this by using a non-parametric method known as Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) to determine, measure, analyse and benchmark the technical efficiency of all water boards in South Africa. Our contribution to the literature is twofold: This is the first paper to model technical efficiency of water boards as utility suppliers and guardians of water services in South Africa, and second, we address the over- and under estimation issues of technical efficiency measurement in the water sector. We do this by modelling one of the most pronounced negative externalities from water provision (water losses) as an undesirable output using the approach developed by You & Yan (2011). We find on average, technical efficiency of water boards is 49 per cent, with only three of the nine water boards technically efficient. Six of the smaller water boards showed high levels of inefficiency. Six water boards operate at increasing returns to scale (IRS) and two are scale efficient. Only Rand and Sedibeng water boards exhibited decreasing returns to scale (DRS). Therefore, redirecting potential efficiency savings to optimal uses could result in technical and scale efficiency for the sector. Scale efficiency results seems to support larger regional water boards as small to medium-sized water boards are scale inefficient with low technical efficiency. The ratio model with undesirable output outperforms previous methods to deal with undesirable (bad) outputs, which either provide an over- or underestimation of technical efficiency.

Logo of the University Library LMU Munich
MPRA is a RePEc service hosted by
the University Library LMU Munich in Germany.