Market Concentration, Privatization Policies, and Heterogeneity among Private Firms in Mixed Oligopolies

Haraguchi, Junichi and Matsumura, Toshihiro (2021): Market Concentration, Privatization Policies, and Heterogeneity among Private Firms in Mixed Oligopolies.

Abstract

Mixed oligopolies are characterized by the coexistence of private and public enterprises. The literature on mixed oligopolies indicates that, assuming all private firms are identical, the optimal degree of privatization increases with the number of private firms. In other words, the more concentrated the market is, the more the government should privatize public firms. We revisit this problem by introducing cost-heterogeneity among private firms. We show that under the assumption of constant marginal costs, a new entry by a private firm will not reduce the optimal degree of privatization, regardless of the cost differences among private firms. However, under the assumption of increasing marginal costs, we show that a new entry will reduce the optimal degree of privatization when the new entrant is significantly less efficient than the private firms already present. Our results imply that the relationship between competition and privatization policies are more complicated than the literature suggests, and they depend on the cost structure of private firms.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: privatization and competition policies, market concentration index, partial privatization, new entry, production substitution
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D4 - Market Structure, Pricing, and Design > D43 - Oligopoly and Other Forms of Market Imperfection; H - Public Economics > H4 - Publicly Provided Goods > H44 - Publicly Provided Goods: Mixed Markets; L - Industrial Organization > L3 - Nonprofit Organizations and Public Enterprise > L33 - Comparison of Public and Private Enterprises and Nonprofit Institutions ; Privatization ; Contracting Out

References

Barcena-Ruiz, J. C., Garzon, M. B. (2005).International trade and strategic privatization. Review of Development Economics, 9(4), 502--513.

Cato, S., Matsumura, T. (2015). Optimal privatization and trade policies with endogenous market structure, Economic Record, 91(294), 309--323.

Chang, W. W. (2005). Optimal trade and privatization policies in an international duopoly with cost asymmetry. Journal of International Trade and Economic Development, 14, 19--42.

Chang, W. W. (2007). Optimal trade, industrial, and privatization policies in a mixed duopoly with strategic managerial incentives. Journal of International Trade and Economic Development, 16(1), 31--52.

Chang, W. W., Ryu H. E. (2015). Vertically related markets, foreign competition and optimal privatization policy. Review of International Economics, 23(2), 303--319.

Chen, T. L. (2017). Privatization and efficiency: a mixed oligopoly approach. Journal of Economics, 120(3), 251--268.

Corneo, G., Jeanne, O. (1994). Oligopole mixte dans un marche commun. Annales d'Economie et de Statistique, 33, 73--90.

De Fraja, G., Delbono, F. (1989). Alternative strategies of a public enterprise in oligopoly. Oxford Economic Papers, 41, 302--311.

Fjell, K., Pal, D. (1996). A mixed oligopoly in the presence of foreign private firms. Canadian Journal of Economics, 29(3), 737--743.

Fridman, A (2018). Partial privatization in an exhaustible resource industry. Journal of Economics, 124(2), 159--173.

Ghandour, Z., Straume, O. R. (2020) Quality competition in mixed oligopoly. NIPE Working Papers, No. 10/2020

Gupta, N. (2005). Partial privatization and firm performance. Journal of Finance}, 60(2), 987--1015

Haraguchi, J., Matsumura, T. (2020a). Lack of commitment to future privatization policies may lead to worst welfare outcome. Economic Modelling, 88, 181--187.

Haraguchi, J., Matsumura, T. (2020b). Implicit protectionism via state enterprises and technology transfer from foreign enterprises. Review of International Economics, 28(3), 723--743.

Haraguchi, J., Matsumura, T. (2020c). Asymmetry among private firms and optimal privatization policy. Bulletin of Economic Research, 72(3), 213--224.

Haraguchi, J., Matsumura, T. (2020d). Endogenous public and private leadership with diverging social and private marginal costs. Manchester School 88(5), 699--730.

Heywood, J. S., Wang, S., and Ye, G. (2021). Partial privatization upstream with spatial price discrimination downstream. Review of Industrial Organization. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11151-020-09804-9

Kawasaki, A., Ohkawa, T., Okamura, M. (2020). Endogenous timing game in a mixed duopoly with partial foreign ownership and asymmetric increasing marginal costs. Australian Economic Papers, 59(2), 71--87.

Kim, S.-L., Sang-Ho Lee, S.-H., Matsumura, T. (2019). Corporate social responsibility and privatization policy in a mixed oligopoly. Journal of Economics 128(1), 67--89.

Kowalski, P., Buge, M., Sztajerowska, M., Egeland, M. (2013). State-owned enterprises: Trade effects and policy implications. OECD Trade Policy Papers No.147.

La Porta, R., Lopez-De-Silanes, F., Shleifer, A. (2002). Government ownership of banks. Journal of Finance, 57(1), 265--301.

Lahiri, S., Ono, Y. (1988). Helping minor firms reduces welfare. Economic Journal 98, 1199--1202.

Lee, S.-H., Matsumura, T., Sato, S. (2018). An analysis of entry-then-privatization model: welfare and policy implications. Journal of Economics, 123(1), 71--88.

Lin, M. H., Matsumura, T. (2012). Presence of foreign investors in privatized firms and privatization policy. Journal of Economics, 107(1), 71--80.

Liu, L., Wang, X. H., and Zeng, C. (2020). Endogenous horizontal product differentiation in a mixed duopoly. Review of Industrial Organization, 56, 435--462.

Matsumura, T. (1998). Partial privatization in mixed duopoly. Journal of Public Economics, 70(3), 473--483.

Matsumura, T., Kanda, O. (2005). Mixed oligopoly at free entry markets. Journal of Economics, 84(1), 27--48.

Matsumura, T., Matsushima, N. (2004). Endogenous cost differentials between public and private enterprises: a mixed duopoly approach. Economica 71:671--688.

Matsumura, T., Okamura, M. (2015). Competition and privatization policies revisited: The payoff interdependence approach. Journal of Economics, 116(2), 137--150.

Matsumura, T. and Shimizu, D. (2010). Privatization waves. Manchester School, 78(6), 609--625.

Megginson, W., Netter, J. M. (2001). From state to market: a survey of empirical studies on privatization. Journal of Economic Literature, 39(2),321--389.

Mujumdar, S., Pal, D. (1998). Effects of indirect taxation in a mixed oligopoly. Economics Letters, 58(2), 199--204.

Pal, D. (1998). Endogenous timing in a mixed oligopoly. Economics Letters, 61(2), 181--185.

Pal, D., White, M. D. (1998). Mixed oligopoly, privatization, and strategic trade policy. Southern Economic Journal, 65(2), 264--281.

Sato, S., Matsumura, T. (2019). Shadow cost of public funds and privatization policies. North American Journal of Economics and Finance, 50, 101026.