Fifty Years of Debate on Hardin's Tragedy of the Commons – A Reflection

Hasan, Lubna (2020): Fifty Years of Debate on Hardin's Tragedy of the Commons – A Reflection.

Abstract

This paper critically reviews Garrett Hardin’s “The Tragedy of the Commons”. Hardin’s thesis about the impossibility of collective action for achieving mutually beneficial outcomes in a group setting has divided the scholarly community since its publication in 1968, while its most perennial object being the communal management of resources, which was banned on account of being inherently inefficient. This paper argues that much of the criticism against common property regimes stems from incorrect modeling of a common property situation, and misunderstandings about the terms and their wrong usage. Specifically, models of collective action - in particular, Hardin’s tragedy of the Commons, but also Olson’s Logic of Collective Action, and the Prisoner’s Dilemma, which is used as a critique against common property regimes, are not based on an accurate depiction of reality and many of their assumptions are untrue. The purpose is to drive home the point that common property regimes are not inherently inferior types of regimes; and causes of success, and of failures, of these regimes lie elsewhere. Secondly, both public [and also private] management of natural resources has not had universal success. It is time to think out of the usual ‘either public or private’ dichotomy. Combining elements of both public and communal management in a pragmatic way is necessary. It is time to give co-management a serious thought.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Natural Resource Management, Property Institutions, Co-management of Resources.
• Subjects: P - Economic Systems > P1 - Capitalist Systems > P14 - Property Rights; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q2 - Renewable Resources and Conservation

References

Arnold, J. E. M., and Campbell, J. G. (1986) Collective management of hill forests in Nepal: The community forestry development project, in Proceedings of the conference on Common Property Resource Management (April 21-26, 1985), Washington D. C.: National Academy Press.

Azhar, R. A. (1993) Commons, regulations, and rent-seeking behaviour: The dilemma of Pakistan’s guzara forests. Economic Development and Cultural Change, 42(19): 115-129.

Blaike, P. M., (1985) The Political Economy of Soil Erosion in Developing Countries. Longman, University of Minnesota.

Berkes, F. (ed.) (1989) Common Property Resources: Ecology and Community-Based Sustainable Development. Belhaven Press, London

Bromley, D. W. (ed.) (1992) Making the Commons Work: Theory, Practice, and Policy, San Francisco: Institute for Contemporary Studies Press.

Bromley, D. W., and Chapagain, D. P. (1984) The village against the center: resource depletion in South Asia. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 66: 868-873.

Bromley, D. W., and Cernea, M. M. (1989) The management of Common Property Resources: Some Conceptual and Operational Fallacies. World Bank Discussion Papers, No 57, Washington D. C.: The World Bank.

Browder, J. (1988) Public Policy and the Deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon, in R. Repetto and M. Gillis (eds.) Public Policies and the Misuse of Forest Resources. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Commander, S. (1986) Managing India’s Forests: A Case Study for the Reforms of Property Rights. Development Policy Review, 4(4): 325-344.

Dasgupta, P., and K. G. Mäler (1994) The environment: The environment and emerging development issues, in: R. Layard, and S. Glaister, (eds.), Cost-Benefit Analysis, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Demsetz, H. (1967) Towards a theory of property rights. American Economic Review, 57: 347-359.

Dove, M. (1994) Jungle in Nature and Culture, in R. Guha (ed.) Social Ecology. Delhi: Oxford University Press. 90-111.

Hardin, G. (1968) The tragedy of the commons, Science, 162: 1234-1248.

Hasan, L,. (2007) An Anatomy of State Failures in Forest Management in Pakistan. The Pakistan Development Review, 46:4, pp 1189-1203.

Hasan, L. (2001) Analysing Institutional Set-up of Forest Management in Pakistan. Research Report 182. Pakistan Institute of Development Economics. Islamabad.

Jodha, N. S. (1992) Common Property Resources; A Missing Dimension of Development Strategies. World Bank Discussion Paper, No 169, Washington D. C.: The World Bank.

Jodha, N. S. (1994) Common Property Resources and the Rural Poor, in R. Guha (ed.) Social Ecology. Oxford in India Readings in Sociology and Social Anthropology. Oxford University Press. Delhi.

Khan, J., and R. Zurflueh. (1994) The Timber Harvesting Ban and Its Implications. Kalam Integrated Development Project, Kalam, Pakistan.

Knudsen, A. J (1996) Entrepreneurship and Deforestation in the North West Frontier Province, Pakistan. CMI Working Paper 1996: II. Chr Michelsen Institute. Bergen, Norway.

McCay, B. J., and J. M. Acheson (eds.) (1987) The Question of the Commons: The Culture and Ecology of Communal Resources. Tucson, Arizona: The University of Arizona Press.

Messerschmidt, D. A. (1986) People and resources in Nepal: Customary resources management systems in upper Kali Gandaki, in Proceedings of the conference on Common Property Resource Management (April 21-26, 1985), Washington D. C.: National Academy Press.

Mumtaz, S., and D. Nayab (1992) The rationale of common property in the development context. The Pakistan Development Review, 31(3): 259-285.

Mumtaz, S., and D. Nayab (1991) Management arrangements of the Chaprote forest and their implications for sustainable development. The Pakistan Development Review, 30(4): 1075-1086.

Ostrom, E., and R. Gardner (1993) Coping with asymmetries in the commons: Self-governing irrigation systems can work. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 7(4):93-112.

Ostrom, E. (1999) Private and Common Property Rights, in B. Bouckaert and G. D. Geest (eds.) Encyclopedia of Law and Economics. Available at http://encyclo.findlaw.com/2000book.pdf

Ostrom, E. (1990) Governing the Commons: Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Poffenberger, M. (1995) The Resurgence of Community Forest Management in the Jungle Mahals of West Bengal, in D. Arnold and R. Guha (eds.) Nature, Culture, Imperialism- Essays on the Environmental History of South Asia. Delhi: Oxford University Press.

Reeve, A. (1986) Property. London and Hampshire: Macmillan.

Runge, C. F. (1981) Common property externalities: Isolation, assurance, and resource depletion in a traditional grazing context. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, (November) 63: 595-606.

Runge, C. F. (1984) Strategic independence in the model of property rights. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 66: 807-813.

Runge, C. F. (1992) Common property and collective action in economic development, in D. Bromley (ed.), Making the Commons Work. San Francisco: ICS Press.

Sinha, S. and R. Herring (1993) Common Property, Collective Action and Ecology. Economic and Political Weekly, July 3-10; 1425-1432.

Tisdell, C. (1993) Environmental Economics: Policies for Environmental Management and Sustainable development.

Townsend, R., and J. A Wilson (1987) An economic view of the tragedy of the commons, in B. J. McCay, and J. M. Acheson, (eds.) (1987) The Question of the Commons: The Culture and Ecology of Communal Resources. Tucson, Arizona: The University of Arizona Press.

Wade, R. (1992) Common property resource management in South Indian Villages, in D. Bromley (ed.), Making the Commons Work. San Francisco: ICS Press.

Wade, R. (1987) The management of common property resources: collective action as an alternative to privatization or state regulation. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 11(2): 96-106.