Competitive Balance in the National Hockey League after Unrestricted Free Agency and the Salary Cap

Lee, Travis (2020): Competitive Balance in the National Hockey League after Unrestricted Free Agency and the Salary Cap.

Abstract

In the large literature on issues related to competitive balance, studies tend to find no significant effect of structural changes. However in the National Hockey League, the introduction of unrestricted free agency in 1995 and a hard salary cap in 2005 might reasonably be expected to affect competitiveness. The present note measures between-season competitive balance as the correlation between the current and prior years’ winning percentages. The method is to regress winning percentage on lagged winning percentage and a set of controls. The finding is that competitive balance increased after unrestricted free agency and the salary cap were implemented.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: National Hockey League, competitive balance, collective bargaining, unrestricted free agency, salary cap
• Subjects: Z - Other Special Topics > Z0 - General > Z00 - General

References

Addesa, F. A. (2011). Competitive balance in the Italian basketball championship. Rivista di Diritto ed Economia dello Sport, 7(1).

Adgate, B. (2019). Hockey's big pay day is coming. Forbes. Retrieved from https://www.forbes.com/sites/bradadgate/2019/01/15/hockeys-big-pay-day-is-coming/#600de0844e44

Balfour, A., & Porter, P. K. (1991). The reserve clause in professional sports: Legality and effect on competitive balance. Labor Law Journal, 42(1), 8-18.

Bowman, R. A., Lambrinos, J., & Ashman, T. (2013). Competitive balance in the eyes of the sports fan: Prospective measures using point spreads in the NFL and NBA. Journal of Sports Economics, 14(5), 498-520.

Bowman, R. A., Lambrinos, J., & Ashman, T. (2018). Prospective measures of competitive balance application to money lines in the national hockey league. Applied Economics, 50(46), 4925-4936.

Büschemann, A., & Deutscher, C. (2011). Did the 2005 collective bargaining agreement really improve team efficiency in the NHL. International Journal of Sport Finance, 6(4), 298-306.

Butler, M. R. (1995). Competitive balance in Major League Baseball. The American Economist, 39(2), 46-52.

Buzzacchi, L., Szymanski, S., & Valletti, T. (2003). Equality of opportunity and equality of outcome: Open leagues, closed leagues, and competitive balance. Journal of Industry, Competition and Trade, 3, 167-186.

Claxton, L. J. (2014). Factors that Motivate Attendance At NCAA Division II Football Games: A Multiple Case Study. Northcentral University.

Coates, D., & Humphreys, B. R. (2012). Game Attendance and Outcome Uncertainty in the National Hockey League. Journal of Sports Economics, 13(4), 364-377.

Daly, G. (1992). Diamonds are forever: The business of baseball. In M. Sommers Paul (Ed.), The Baseball Player’s Labor Market Revisited (pp. 11-28). Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.

Daly, G., & Moore, W. (1981). Externalities, property rights, and the allocation of resources in Major League Baseball. Economic Inquiry, 19, 77-95.

Eckard, W. (1998). The NCAA cartel and competitive balance in college football. Review of Industrial Organization, 13, 347-369.

Eckard, W. (2001a). Baseball’s blue ribbon economic report: Solutions in search of a problem. Journal of Sports Economics, 2, 213-227.

Eckard, W. (2001b). Free agency, competitive balance, and diminishing returns to pennant contention. Economic Inquiry, 39, 430-443.

El-Hodiri, M., & Quirk, J. (1971). The economic theory of a professional sports league. Journal of Political Economy, 79, 1302-1319.

Evans, R. (2014). A review of measures of competitive balance in the “analysis of competitive balance” literature. Working Paper. Birkbeck, University of London, London, UK.

Feddersen, A., & Maennig, W. (2005). Trends in competitive balance: Is there evidence for growing imbalance in professional sport leagues?. Hamburg Contemporary Economic Discussion Paper, (01).

Forbes. (2011). Forbes Releases 21st Annual NHL Team Valuations [Press release]. Retrieved from https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbespr/2019/12/11/forbes-releases-21st-annual-nhl-team-valuations/#7c65f3125d83

Fort, R. (2006). Competitive balance in North American professional sports. Handbook of sports economics research, 190-206.

Fort, R., & Lee, Y. H. (2007). Structural change, competitive balance, and the rest of the major leagues. Economic Inquiry, 45(3), 519-532.

Fort, R., Maxcy, J., & Diehl, M. (2016). Uncertainty by regulation: Rottenberg׳ s invariance principle. Research in Economics, 70(3), 454-467.

Fort, R., & Quirk, J. (1995). Cross-subsidization, incentives, and outcomes in professional team sports leagues. Journal of Economic Literature, 33, 1265-1299.

Grant, M. (2008). Competitive Balance in the National Hockey League After the Salary Cap (Doctoral dissertation, Colorado College.).

Hadley, L., Cieka, J., & Krautmann, A. (2005). Competitive balance in the aftermath of the 1994 players’ strike. Journal of Sports Economics, 6, 379-389.

Humphreys, B. (2002). Alternative measures of competitive balance in sports leagues. Journal of Sports Economics, 3, 133-148.

Jeglic, A. A. (2005). Can the New Collective Bargaining Agreement Save the NHL. Entertainment & Sports Lawyer, 23, 1.

Kahn, L. (1993). Managerial quality, team success, and individual player performance in Major League Baseball. Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 46, 531-547.

Kahn, L. M. (2000). The sports business as a labor market laboratory. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 14(3), 75-94.

Kahn, L. (2007a). Cartel behavior and amateurism in college sports. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 21, 209-226.

Kahn, L. (2007b). Sports league expansion and consumer welfare. Journal of Sports Economics, 8, 115-138.

Késenne, S. (2000). Impact of salary caps in professional team sports. Scottish Journal of Political Economy, 47, 422-430.

Kim, M. S., Won, D., & Han, J. W. (2017). Structural changes and competitive balance in the Korean professional baseball league. International Journal of Applied Sports Sciences, 29(2), 195-208.

Knowles, G., Sherony, K., & Haupert, M. (1992). The demand for major league baseball: A test of the uncertainty of outcome hypothesis. American Economist, 36, 72-89.

Larsen, A., Fenn, A., & Spenner, E. (2006). The impact of free agency and the salary cap on competitive balance in the National Football League. Journal of Sports Economics, 7, 374-390.

Lee, T. (2010). Competitive balance in the national football league after the 1993 collective bargaining agreement. Journal of Sports Economics, 11(1), 77-88.

Levin, M. A., & McDonald, R. E. (2009). The value of competition: competitive balance as a predictor of attendance in spectator sports. International Journal of Sports Marketing & Sponsorship, 11(1).

Maxcy, J. (2002). Rethinking restrictions on player mobility in Major League Baseball. Contemporary Economic Policy, 20, 145-159.

Maxcy, J., & Mondello, M. (2006). The impact of free agency on competitive balance in North American professional team sports leagues. Journal of Sport Management, 20, 345-365.

McKenzie, R., & Sullivan, T. (1987). Does the NCAA exploit college athletes? An economics and legal reinterpretation. Antitrust Bulletin, 32, 373-399.

Neale, W. (1964). The peculiar economics of professional sports. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 78, 1-14.

Noll, R. (1974). Government and the sport business. In G. Noll Roger (Ed.), Attendance and price setting (pp. 115-158). Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.

Peters, D. (2011). Winning percentage and attendance in the NHL. Sport Management Undergraduate. Paper 23.

Quirk, J., & Fort, R. (1992). Pay dirt: The business of professional team sports. Princeton, New Jersey (NJ): Princeton University Press.

Richardson, D. H. (2000). Pay, performance, and competitive balance in the National Hockey League. Eastern Economic Journal, 26(4), 393-417.

Rottenberg, S. (1956). The baseball players' labor market. Journal of political economy, 64(3), 242-258.

Salaga, S., & Fort, R. (2017). Structural change in competitive balance in big-time college football. Review of Industrial Organization, 50(1), 27-41.

Scelles, N., Durand, C., Bonnal, L., Goyeau, D., & Andreff, W. (2013). Competitive balance versus competitive intensity before a match: Is one of these two concepts more relevant in explaining attendance? The case of the French football Ligue 1 over the period 2008–2011. Applied Economics, 45(29), 4184-4192.

Šíma, J., & Procházka, J. (2014). Competitive Balance in the Austrian, Czech, Hungarian and Ukrainian Soccer Leagues. Acta Universitatis Carolinae Kinanthropologica, 50(1), 83-92.

Spalding, R. L. (2014). Fan Response to League Playoff Structure and Consecutive Season Competitive Balance in Professional Sports. Doctoral Dissertations. 142

Surdam, D. G. (2006). The Coase theorem and player movement in major league baseball. Journal of Sports Economics, 7(2), 201-221. Totty, E. S., & Owens, M. F. (2011). Salary caps and competitive balance in professional sports leagues. Journal for Economic Educators, 11(2), 45-56.

Trandel, G. A., & Maxcy, J. G. (2011). Adjusting winning-percentage standard deviations and a measure of competitive balance for home advantage. Journal of Quantitative Analysis in Sports, 7(1).

Yam, N. (2015). The New Landscape of the NBA: The 2011 Collective Bargaining Agreement’s Impact on Competitive Balance and Players’ Salaries (Undergraduate thesis, Duke University).

York, K. M., & Miree, C. E. (2018). Averting a tragedy of the commons: Revenue sharing and competitive balance in the NHL. Sport, Business and Management: An International Journal.