Ex ante and ex post institutional convergence: Case of the post-Soviet space

Libman, Alexander (2007): Ex ante and ex post institutional convergence: Case of the post-Soviet space.

Abstract

Abstract: The paper discusses the interaction of ex ante and ex post institutional convergence in the post-Soviet world, i.e. 12 members of the Commonwealth of Independent States. It starts with analysing empirical evidence for institutional convergence in the CIS, and then considers two channels of convergence: institutional competition for mobile capital and ex ante harmonization via interaction in political sphere. In both cases the paper points out potential positive and negative features of the processes from the point of view of institutional transformation. The influence of institutional competition is ambiguous, as both factors of “demand for good institutions” and “demand for bad institutions” influence corporate behaviour. The ex ante harmonization is much less influential and seems to be most successful in preserving semi-authoritarian regimes from potential competitors and therefore supports inefficient equilibrium. Finally, the paper focuses on interaction between ex ante and ex post harmonization, i.e. demand for harmonization from businesses and support of institutional competition environment from the governments. For the governments ex post harmonization could be an attractive way to avoid long and costly bargaining: this factor is probably relevant for the current support of business expansion of Russian corporations by Russian government. For the businesses the situation is more difficult: since historically post- Soviet business did not express significant interest in formal integration (associated with ex ante harmonization), the paper discusses three variables (lobbying, changes in market structure and preferences of the demand side) able to influence their decisions.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Institutional convergence, institutional competition, regionalization
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F15 - Economic Integration; P - Economic Systems > P2 - Socialist Systems and Transitional Economies > P26 - Political Economy ; Property Rights

References

Andersson, F., and R. Forslid (1999): Tax Competition and Economic Geography, CEPR Working Paper

Aslund, A. (2005): Betraying a Revolution. Washington Post, May 18

Bardhan, P., and D. Mookherjee (2000): Capture and Governance on Local and National Level. American Economic Review 90

Bayulgen, O. (2005): Foreign Capital in Central Asia and the Caucasus: Curse or Blessing? Communist and Post-Communist Studies 38

Beck U. (2002): Macht und Gegenmacht im globalen Zeitalter, Frankfurt a.M., Surkampf Verlag

Bernauer, Th., and V. Styrsky (2004): Adjustment or Voice: Corporate Responses to International Tax Competition. European Journal of International Relations 10

Besley, T., and A.C.Case (1995): Incumbent behavior: Vote seeking, tax-setting, and yardstick competition. American Economic Review 85(1)

Bevan, A.A., Estrin, S., Hare, P.G., and J. Stern (2001): Extending the Economics of Disorganization. Economics of Transition 9(1)

Bogdanov, A., and S. Sukhanov (2004): SNG: Vtoraia Rossiia? Ezhemesiachnyi Obzor Rynka Alfa-Banka, November (in Russian: CIS: The Second Russia?)

Bohnet, A., and M. Schratzenstaller (2001): Der Einfluss der Globalisierung auf staatliche Handlungsspielräume und die Zielverwirklichungsmöglichkeiten gesellschaftlicher Gruppen. Mimeo

Bordignon, M., Colombo, L., and U. Galmarini (2005): Fiscal Federalism and Lobbying. Mimeo

Bornschier, V. and B. Trezzini (1996): Jenseits von Depenencia- vs. Modernisierungstheorie: Differenzierungsprozesse in der Weltgesellschaft und ihre Erklärung, in: Müller, H.-P. (Ed.) Weltsystem und kulturelles Erbe, Berlin

Brennan, G., and J.M. Buchanan (1980): The Power to Tax. New York

Brockheimer, Th. (1997): Wettbewerb und Unternehmertum in der Systemtransformation – Das Problem des institutionellen Interregnums im Prozess des Wandels von Wirtschaftssystemen. Stuttgart

Brunner, G. (1996): Rechtskultur in Osteuropa: Das Problem der Kulturgrenzen, in Brunner, G. (Ed.): Politische und ökonomische Transformation in Osteuropa. Berlin

Bucovetsky, S. (2005): Tax Bloc Formation among Leviathans, Mimeo

Burbidge, J.B., DePater, J.A., Myers, G.A., and A. Sengupta (1997): A Coalition-Formation Approach to Equilibrium Federations and Trading Blocs. American Economic Review 87

Chong A., and M. Gradstein M. (2004): Inequality and Institutions. Inter-American Development Bank Working Paper No. 506

Crane, K., Peterson, D.J., and O. Oliker (2005): Russian Investment in the Commonwealth of Independent States. Eurasian Geography and Economics 46(4)

D’Anieri, P. (1997): International Cooperation among Unequal Partners: the Emergence of Bilateralism in the former Soviet Union. International Politics 34

Denzau, A.T., and D.C. North (1994): Shared Mental Models, Ideologies and Institutions. Kyklos 47

Doner, R.F., Ritchie, B.K., and D. Slater (2005): Systemic Vulnerability and the Origins of Developmental States: Northeast and Southeast Asia in Comparative Perspective. International Organization 59

Fel’dman, D. (2005): Vsaimodeistvie Elit Stran SNG. POLIS – Politicheskie Issledovania (4) (in Russian: Interaction of Elites of the CIS Countries)

Freriks, R., and U, Widmaier (2000): Die Veränderung der Strategie ökonomischer Akteure im Prozess der Entstehung eines europäischen Binnenmarktes, in: Czada, R., and S. Lütz (Hrsg.): Die politische Konstitution von Märkten, Wiesbaden

Frey, B.S., and R.Eichenberger (1996): To Harmonize or to Compete? That’s Not the Question. Journal of Public Economics 60

Furman, D. (2004): Postsovetskii Politicheskii Rezhim Kazakhstana. Report of the Institute of Europe No. 142 (in Russian: Post-Soviet Political Regime of Kazakhstan)

Furman, D. (2004): Rossia, SNG i ES. Mir peremen (3) (in Russian: Russia, CIS and EU).

Furman, D. (2005): Perevernutyi Istmat. Svobodnaya mysl (3) (in Russian: Historical Materialism Reversed)

Gaddy, C., and B.W. Ickes (2001): Stability and Disorder: An Evolutionary Analysis of Russia’s Virtual Economy, in: Bonnell, V.E. and Breslauer, G.W. (Eds.) Russia in the New Century: Stability or Disorder. Boulder

Gel’man V. (2003): Post-Soviet Transitions and Democratization: Towards Theory-Building. Democratization 10

Genschel, Ph., and Th. Plümper (1997): Regulatory Competition and International Cooperation. Journal of European Public Policy 4

Gradstein, M. (2004): Inequality, Democracy and the Emergence of Institutions. CEPR Working Paper No. 4187

Haas, P. (1992): Introduction: Epistemic Communities and International Policy Coordination. International Organization 46

Heifetz, B.A. (2005): Vsaimnye Investicii v SNG. Ekonomist (8) (in Russian: Mutual Investments in the CIS)

Heinrich, A. (2003): Globale Einflüsse und die Corporate Governance des russischen Erdöl- und Erdgassektors. Forschungsstelle Osteuropa Bremen. Mimeo

Hellman, J. (1998): Winners Take All: The Politics of Partial Reform in Postcommunist Transitions. World Politics 50

Hellman, J.S., Jones G., and D. Kaufmann (2000a): Beyond the ‘Grabbing Hand’ of Government in Transition: Facing up to ‘State Capture’ by the Corporate Sector. Transition, May-June-July, 1-4

Hellman, J.S., Jones G., and D. Kaufmann (2000b): Seize the State, Seize the Day: State Capture, Corruption and Influence in Transition. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 2444

Hendley, K. (2001): “Demand for Law” in Russia – A Mixed Picture. East European Constitutional Review 10(4)

Hirschman, A.O. (1997): Exit, Voice and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States. Cambridge MA

Hoff, K., and G.E. Stiglitz (2003): A Dynamic Model of the Demand for the Rule of Law, with Applications to Post-Communist Transition. World Bank manuscript

Hoff, K., and G.E. Stiglitz (2004a): After the Big Bang? Obstacles to the Emergence of the Rule of Law in Post- Communist Societies. American Economic Review 94

Hoff, K., and G.E. Stiglitz (2004b). The Transition from Communism: A Diagrammatic Exposition of Obstacles to the Demand for the Rule of Law. World Bank Working Paper No.3352

Inozemtsev, V. (2005): Prodavtsy i Pokupateli. Business Week Russia, October 31 (in Russian: Sellers and Byers)

Inozemtsev, V. (2006): Vinnoyi Gripp. Business Week Russia, April 24 (in Russian: Wine Flue)

Iradian, G. (2003): Armenia: The Road to Sustained Rapid Growth, Cross-Country Evidence. IMF Working Paper WP/03/103

Iwasaki, I. (2003): Evolution of Government-Business Relationship and Economic Performance in the Former Soviet States. Economics of Planning 36

Kalotay, K. (2004): Outward FDI from Central and Eastern European Countries. Economics of Planning 37

Kaufmann A., Kraay A., and M. Mastruzzi (2005): Governance Matters IV: Governance Indicators for 1996- 2004. World Bank Working Paper

Kliamkin, I., and L. Timofeev (2000): Tenevoi Obrats Zhisni: Soziologicheskii Avtoportret Postsovetskogo Obshestva. POLIS – Politicheskie Issledovaniia, (4) and (5) (in Russian: Shadow Way of Living – a Self- Portrait of the Post-Soviet Society)

Knight, J. (1992): Institutions and Social Conflict. Cambridge

Konzelmann, S., Wilkinson, F., Crypo, Ch., and R. Aridi (2005): The Export of National Varieties of Capitalism: The Cases of Wal-Mart and IKEA. CBR Working Paper No. 314

Kordonskii, S. (2000): Rynki Wlasti: Administraivnye Rynki SSSR i Rossii. Moscow (in Russian: Power Markets – Administrative Markets of the USSR and Russia)

Lake, D.A. (2004): International Political Economy: A Maturing Interdiscipline. Mimeo

Latov, Y. (2003): “Antikapitalisticheskaia Mentalnost’ Rossiian – Barier na Puti k Legalisacii.” Neprikosnovennyi Zapas (29) (in Russian: Anti-Capitalistic Mentality of Russians – A Barrier for Legalization)

Lebedev, A. (2005). Edinoe Ekonomicheskoe Prostranstvo: Vosmozhnosti Integracii so Storony Bisnesa i Otkrytogo Regionalisma. Mimeo (in Russian: Common Economic Space: Options for Business Integration and Open Regionalism)

Ledeneva, A. (2001): Unwritten Rules: How Russia Really Works. CER Essay

Leipold, H. (1997): Der Zusammenhang zwischen gewachsener und gesetzten Ordnung: Einige Lehren aus den postsozialistischen Reformerfahrungen, in: Cassel, D. (Hrsg.): Institutionelle Probleme der Systemtransformation

Levi, D.L., and A. Prakash (2003): Bargains Old and New: Multinational Corporations in Global Governance. Business and Politics 5

Levitsky S., and L.A. Way (2002): The Rise of Competitive Authoritarianism. Journal of Democracy 13

Libman, A. (2005): Institutional Competition and Evolution of Perception of Norms. Paper presented at the EAEPE annual conference, Bremen, Germany

Libman, A. (2005a): Bottom-Up and Top-Down Integration in the Post-Soviet Space. Paper presented at the CSGR/CIGI/UNU-CRIS Annual Conference, Warwick, UK

Libman, A. (2006): Konkurentsia Nacional’nykh i Rossiiskikh Bisnes Struktur i Mezhdunarodnykh TNK na Postsovetskom Prostranstve. Report of the Center for Problems of Integration of the Institute of Economics RAS 2006-2 (in Russian: Competition among National and Russian Business Structures and International TNCs in the Post-Soviet Countries)

Libman, A. (2006a): Russia’s Integration into the World Economy: An Interjurisdictional Competition View, in Broadman, H., Paas, T., and P.J.J. Welfens (Eds.): Economic Liberalization and Integration Policy: Options for Eastern Europe and Russia. Heidelberg

Linn, J.F. (2004): Economic (Dis)Integration Matters: The Soviet Collapse Revised. Paper presented at conference on “Transition in the CIS: Achievements and Challenges” at the Academy for National Economy, Moscow, September 13-14

Lorz, O. (1997): Standortwettbewerb bei internationaler Kapitalmobilität. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck

Lorz, O. (1998): Capital Mobility, Tax Competition and Lobbying for Redistributive Capital Taxation. European Journal of Political Economy 14 Mummert, A. and Mummert, U. (2000): Institutioneller Wettbewerb in Entwicklungsländern im institutionellen Wettbewerb. Max-Planck Institut zur Erforschung von Wirtschaftssystemen Diskussionsbeitrag No. 03-00

Murphy, D. (2002): The Business Dynamics of Global Regulatory Competition, in Vogel, D., and R. Kagan (Eds.), Dynamics of Regulatory Change: How Globalization Affects National Regulatory Policies. University of California Press/University of California International and Area Studies Digital Collection, Edited Volume #1

Murphy, D. (2004): The Structure of Regulatory Competition: Corporations and Public Policies in a Global Economy, Oxford

Myers, G.M., and A. Sengupta (2002): Equilibrium Constitution in a Federal System. Mimeo

Nikolaev, I.A., Shulga, I.E., Artemieva, S.A., and A.M. Kalinin (2003): Economics of Privileges. A report issued by FBK Department for Strategic Analysis (in Russian)

Nureev, R. (2005): Vlast’-Sobstvennost’ v Postsovetskoi Rossii: Problemy Zavisimosti ot Puti Razvitia. Mimeo (in Russian: Power-Property in the Post-Soviet Russia: Path Dependence Problems)

Olcott M.B., and M. Ottaway (1999): Challenge of Semi-Authoritarianism. Carnegie Paper No. 7

Oleinik, A. (2005): A Distrustful Economy: An Inquiry into Foundations of the Russian Market. Journal of Economic Issues 39(1)

Pappe, Y. (2000): ‘Oligarhi’: Ekonomicheskaia Khronika 1992-2000. Moscow (in Russian: The Oligachs: Economic Chronics 1992-2000)

Pauly, L.W., and S. Reich (1997): National Structures and Multinational Corporate Behavior: Enduring Differences in the Age of Globalization. International Organization 51(1)

Penz, R. (1998): Legitimität und Viabilität: Zur Theorie der institutionellen Steuerung der Wirtschaft. Marburg Peregudov, S. (2003): Korporacii, Obshestvo, Gosudarstvo. Moscow (in Russian: Corporations, Society, State)

Perroni, C. (2001): Tiebout with Politics: Capital Tax Competition and Constitutional Choices. Review of Economic Studies 68

Pitsoulis, A. (2004): Entwicklungslinien ökonomischen Denkens über Systemwettbewerb. Marburg

Polishchuk, L. (2002): Evolving Demand for Institutions in Transition Economies. Mimeo

Polishchuk, L., and A. Savvateev (2004): Spontaneous (Non)emergence of Property Rights. Economics of Transition 12

Polterovich, V. (1999): Institutional Trap and Transition. Mimeo

Priban, J. (2004): A Taste of the Orange Revolution: Ukraine and the Spirit of Constitutionalism. Mimeo

Prud’homme, R. (1994): The Dangers of Decentralization. World Bank Research Observer 10(2)

Radaev V. (1998): Nekotorye Institutzional’nye Usloviia Formirovaniia Rossiyskikh Rynkov. Soziologicheskii Zhurnal, (3-4) (in Russian: Some Institutional Conditions of Russian Markets’ Formation)

Radaev, V. (1998a): Formirovaniie Novykh Rossiiskikh Rynkov: Transaktsionnye Izdershki, Formy Kontrolia I Delovaia Etika, Moscow (in Russian: Formation of New Russian Markets: Transaction Costs, Forms of Control and Business Ethics)

Raiser, M. (1997): Informal Institutions, Social Capital and Economic Transition: Reflection of a Neglected Dimension. EBRD Working Paper No. 25, 1997

Raiser, M. (1999): Trust in Transition. EBRD Working Paper No. 39, 1999

Rajan, R. and L. Zingales (2003): Saving Capitalism from the Capitalists: Unleashing the Power of Financial Markets to Create Wealth and Spread Opportunity. New York

Redoano, M. (2004): Does Centralization Affect the Number and Size of the Lobbies? CSGR Working Paper No. 146/04

Roelfsema, H. (2004): Legislative Bargaining and Lobbying in the EU. Mimeo

Rosenbaum, E. F. (2004): Culture, Cognitive Models and the Performance of Institutions in Transformation Countries. Journal of Economic Issues 35

Rugman, A. (2005): The Regional Multinationals: MNEs and “Global” Strategic Management. Cambridge

Runov, A. (2003): Ismenenia Sprosa na Prava Sobstvennosti: Neoinstitucional’nyi Analiz Privatizacii, in:

Nureev, R. (Ed.): Ekonomicheskie Subiekty Postsovetskoi Rossii (Institutcional’nyi Analiz). Part 2. Moscow (in Russian: Changes of Demand for Property Rights: A Neo-Institutional Analysis of Privatization)

Ruta, M. (2004): Lobbying for Decentralization. Mimeo Ryvkina, R. (2001): “Rossiiskoe Obshestvo Kak Tenevaia Socioekonomicheskaia Sistema. Mirovaia Ekonomika i Meshdunarodnye Otnoshenia (4) (in Russian: Russian Society as a Shadow Socioeconomic System)

Scharpf, F. (1998): Globalisierung als Beschränkung der Handlungsmöglichkeiten nationalstaatlicher Politik. Jahrbuch für Neue Politische Ökonomie 17

Schneider F. (2004): The Size of the Shadow Economy in 145 Countries from 1999 to 2003. Mimeo

Slinko I., Yakovlev E., and E. Zhuravskaya (2005): Laws for Sale: Evidence from Russia. American Law and Economics Review 7

Sonin, K. (2003): Why the Rich May Favour Poor Protection of Property Rights. Journal of Comparative Economics 31

Sterzhneva, M. (1999): Evropeiskii Soiuz i SNG: Sravnitelnyi Analiz Institutov. Moscow (in Russian: European Union and the CIS: Comparative Institutional Analysis)

Streit, M. (1996): Systemwettbewerb und Harmonisierung im europäischen Integrationsprozess. in: Cassel, D. (Ed.). Entstehung und Wettbewerb von Systemen, Berlin

Sukharev, M.V. (2004): Sozialnye antiinstituty. Economicheskaya Soziologiia 5 (5) (in Russian: Social Anti- Institutions).

Timofeev, L. (2000): Pravo Sobstvennosti v SSSR: Kommunisticheskaia Doktrina i Tenevaia Real’nost. Rossia i sovremennyi mir (4) (in Russian: Property Rights in the USSR: Communist Doctrine and Shadow Practice)

Tratchman, J.P. (1993): International Regulatory Competition, Externalization and Jurisdiction. Harvard International Law Review 47

Ugur, M. (2004): (Re)theorising European Integration under Globalization: A Political Economy Approach. European Political Economy Reivew 2

United Nations (1993): Transnational Corporations from Developing Countries: Impact on Their Home Countries. New York

Vahtra, P. (2005): Russian Investments in the CIS – Scope, Motivation and Leverage. Turku School of Economics and Business Administration, Pan-European Institute. 9/2005

Vanberg, V., and W. Kerber. (1994): Institutional Competition among Jurisdictions: An Evolutionary Approach. Constitutional Political Economy 5

Voigt, S., and D. Kiwit (1995): Black Markets, Mafia and the Prospects for Economic Development in Russia – Analyzing the Interplay of External and Internal Institutions. Max-Planck-Institut zur Erforschung von Wirtschaftssystemen Diskussionsbeitrag No. 05-1995

Volckart, O. (2002): Wettbewerb und Wettbewersbeschränkung in Politik und Wirtschaft. Marburg

Wegner, G. (2004): Nationalstaatliche Institutionen im Wettbewerb. Erfurter Beiträge zu den Staatswissenschaften 2

Welfens, P. (2003). Regionale Integration in der Ordnungs-, Außenwirtschafts- und Wachstumtheorie. Paper presented at the Radain Seminar on Institutional Economics Wohlgemuth, M. (1999): Systemwettbewerb als Entdeckungsverfahren, in: Streit, M.E., and M. Wohlgemuth (Eds.). Systemwettbewerb als Herausforderung an Politik und Theorie, Baden-Baden

Woodruff, D.M. (2000): Rules for Followers: Institutional Theory and the New Politics of Economic Backwardness in Russia. Politics and Society 28 World Bank (1997): World Development Report 1997: The State in a Changing World. Washington

Yakovlev, A. (2003): Vozmozhnye Strategii Ekonomicheskikh Agentov po Otnosheniu k Institutam Korporativnogo Upravlenia, in: Razvities Sprosa na Pravovoe Regulirovanie Korporativnogog Upravlenia v Chastnom Sektore. Moscow (in Russian: Possible Strategies of Economic Agents Regarding the Institutions of Corporate Governance)

Yakovlev, A. (2005): Evoluciia Strategii Vzaimodeistviia Bisnesa i Vlasti v Rossiiskoi Ekonomike. Rossiiskii Zhurnal Menedzhmenta 3 (in Russian: Evolution of Strategies of Interaction of Business and Power in the Russian Economy)

Yevstigneev, V. (1997): Valutno-finansovaia integraciia v ES i SNG: Sravnitelnii semanticheskii analiz. Moscow (in Russian: Monetary and Financial Integration in the EU and the CIS: Comparative Semantic Analysis)