Zum Spannungsfeld zwischen staatlicher und privater Wirtschaft am Beispiel der postsowjetischen Staaten

Libman, Alexander (2006): Zum Spannungsfeld zwischen staatlicher und privater Wirtschaft am Beispiel der postsowjetischen Staaten.

Abstract

The paper discusses the impact of state-business conflicts on the process of economic and political transition in the post-Soviet countries. After providing a short overview of main aspects of state-business relations and of the institutional equilibrium in the post-Soviet world, it continues by setting up the list of possible variables influencing the outcomes and the process of conflicts, and determining whether the conflict is able to provide incentives for establishing more efficient institutions or will maintain (and even re-enforce) the existing inefficient paths of the post-Soviet countries.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• English Title: On the interaction of public and private businesses: Example of the post-Soviet space
• Language: German
• Keywords: Transition, state-business relations, conflict
• Subjects: P - Economic Systems > P3 - Socialist Institutions and Their Transitions > P37 - Legal Institutions ; Illegal Behavior; P - Economic Systems > P3 - Socialist Institutions and Their Transitions > P31 - Socialist Enterprises and Their Transitions; P - Economic Systems > P2 - Socialist Systems and Transitional Economies > P26 - Political Economy ; Property Rights

References

Akhmetova, G. (2002): Korrpuptsiia v Neftedobyvaiushikh Stranakh, Almaty, Kulzhahan

Andreff , V. (2004): Rosskiiskaia Privatizatsiia: Podhody i Posledstviia, Voprosy Ekonomiki, (6), 57-78

Andreff, V. (2004a): Would a Second Transition Stage Prolong the Initial Period of Post-Socialist Economic Transformation into Market Capitalism?, European Journal of Comparative Economics, 1, 7-31

Andreff, V. (2005): Corporate Governance Structures in Post-Socialist Economies: Toward a Central Eastern Model of Corporate Control?, EACES Working Paper No. 4

Aslund, A. (1999): Why Has Russia’s Economic Transformation Being so Arduous?, mimeo

Aslund, A. (2005): Comparative Oligarchy: Russia, Ukraine and the United States, CASE Studies and Analyses 296.

Baumol, W.J. (1990): Entrepreneurship: Productive, Unproductive and Destructive, Journal of Political Economy, 98, 893-921

Bayulgen, O. (2005): Foreign Capital in Central Asia and the Caucasus: Curse or Blessing? Communist and Post-Communist Studies, 38, 49-69

Belyaeva, I. (1999): Integratsiia Korporativnogo Kapitala i Formirovaniie Finansovo-Promyshlennoi Elity, Moskau, Finanzakademie bei der Regierung der Russischen Föderation

Belyaeva, I., und Eskindarov, M. (1998): Kapital Finansovo-Promyshlennykh Korporativnykh Struktur: Teoriia i Praktika, Moskau, Finanzakademie bei der Regierung der Russischen Föderation

Biriukov, V. (2000): Mekhanismy Upravleniia Ekonomikoi Regiona Kak Sostavnaia Chast Instrumentaria Regional’noi Politicheskoi Vlasti, Vestnik Moskovskogo Universiteta, Seria 18, (4)

Black, B., Kraakman, R., und Tarassova, A. (2000): Russian Privatization: What Went Wrong? Stanford Law Review, 52, 1731-1808

Brockheimer Th. (1997): Wettbewerb und Unternehmertum in der Systemtransformation – Das Problem des institutionellen Interregnums im Prozess des Wandels von Wirtschaftssystemen, Stuttgart, Lucius & Lucius

Bucar, B., Glas, M., und Hisrich, R.D. (2003) Ethics and Entrepreneurs: An International Comparative Study, mimeo Chebotarev, A. (2002): Bankovskie Lobbi v Respublike Kazakhstan, mimeo

Cherniavskii, S.P. (2002): Mezhdunarodnyi Offshornyi Bisnes i Banki, Moskau, Finansy i Statistika

CMAKP (2003): Tendenzii Ratsvitiia Bankovskoy Sistemy v 2002 godu, Moskau, CMAKP

CVEI (2003): Ekonomishekiie Strategii SNG i Rossiia, Moskau, RUDN Press

Darden, K. (2001): Blackmail as a Tool of State Domination: Ukraine under Kuchma, East European Constitutional Review, 10, 67-71

DeLong, B.J. „Robber Barons“, in: Ocherki o Mirovoi Ekonomike, Moskau, Gendalf

De Soto, H. (1989): The Other Path: The Invisible Revolution in the Third World, New York, Harper & Row

Erickson, R.E. (2000): The Post-Soviet Economic System: An Industrial Feudalism, BOFIT Online, 8

Eskindarov, M. (1999): Razvitie Korporativnkyh Otnoshenii v Sovremennoi Rossiyskoi Ekonomike, Moskau, Respublika

Fortescue, S. (2002): Pravit li Rossiiei Oligarhiia? POLIS, 5, 64-73

Fukuyama, F. (1999): Social Capital and Civil Society, mimeo Frye, Th. (1997): Politics of Institutional Choice: Post-Communist Presidencies, Comparative Political Studies, 30, 523-552

Frye, Th. (2002): Capture of Exchange? Business Lobbying in Russia, Euro-Asian Studies, 54, 1017-1036

Furman, D. (1995): Perevernutyi Istmat, Svobodnaya mysl, (3), 12-25

Furman, D. (2004): Postsovetskii Politicheskii Rezhim Kazakhstana, Bericht des Europa-Instituts Nr. 142

Furman, D. (2005): Demokraticheskie Revolucii v Stranakh Central’noi Azii I Kavakaza: Vslgliad iz Rossii, Ekskulsiv, (9)

Gaddy, C., und Ickes, B.W. (2001): Stability and Disorder: an Evolutionary Analysis of Russia’s Virtual Economy, in Bonnell, V.E. und Breslauer, G. (Hrsg.): Russia in the New Century: Stability or Disorder, Boulder, Westview

Gel’man, V. (2003): Post-Soviet Transitions and Democratization: Towards Theory-Building, Democratization, 10, 87-104

Gel’man, V. (2003a): Institucional’noe Stroitel’stvo i Neformal’nye Instituty v Sovremennoi Rossiiskoi Politike. POLIS, 4, 6-25

Gel’man, V. (2005): Uroki Ukrainskogo, POLIS, 1, 36-49 Goldman, M. (2003): The Piratization of Russia: Russian Reform Goes Awry, London, Routledge

Grzymala-Busse, A., und Jones Luong, P. (2002): Reconceptualizing the State: Lessons from Post-Communism, Politics and Society, 30, 529-554

Guriev, S., und Rachinsky, A. (2005): Oligarchs: The Past or the Future of the Russian Capitalism, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 19, 131-150

Hale, H.E. (2005): ‘Interpreting the Colored Revolutions and Prospects for Post-Soviet Democratization: Breaking the Cycle, policy memo for the Program on New Approaches to Russian Security series.

Heinrich, A. (2003): Globale Einflüsse und die Corporate Governance des russischen Erdöl- und Erdgassektors, Arbeitspapiere der Forschungsstelle Osteuropa Bremen Nr. 46

Hellman, J.S. (1998): Winners Take All: The Politics of Partial Reform in Postcommunist Transitions, World Politics, 50, 203-234

Hellman, J.S., Jones, G., Kaufmann, D., und Schankerman, M. (2000): Measuring Governance, Corruption, and State Capture: How Firms and Bureaucrats Shape the Business Environment in Transition Economies, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 2312

Hellman, J.S., Jones, G., und Kaufmann, D. (2000): Are Foreign Investors and Multinationals Engaging in Corrupt Practices in Transition Economies, Transition, May-Juni-July, 4-7

Hellman, J.S., Jones, G., und Kaufmann, D. (2000b): Seize the State, Seize the Day: State Capture, Corruption and Influence in Transition, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 2444

Hellman, J.S., Jones, G., und Kaufmann, D. (2000a): Beyond the ‘Grabbing Hand’ of Government in Transition: Facing up to ‘State Capture’ by the Corporate Sector, Transition, May-June-July, 1-4

Hoffmann, Ch. (2000): Vom administrativen Markt zur virtuellen Ökonomie – Russlands scheinbare Transformation, Arbeitspapiere Osteuropa-Institut der Freien Universitaet Berlin No.26/2000

INDEM (2005): Diagnostika Rossiiskoi Corrupcii: 2001-2005, http://www.anti-corr.ru/indem/2005diagnost/2005diag_present.ppt, 01.03.2006

INION (2003): Privatizatsiia v Rossii i Drugikh Stranakh SNG, Moskau, INION

Iwasaki, I. (2004): Evolution of the Government-Business Relationships in the Former Soviet States – Order State, Rescue State, Punish State, Economics of Planning, 36, 223-257

Kapelyushnikov, R. (2001): Gde Nacahlo Togo Perekhoda (KVoprosu ob Okonchanii Perekhodnoho Perioda v Rossii, Voprosy Ekonomiki, (1), 138-156

Kapelyushnikov, R. (2001a): ‘Institutcional’naya Priroda Perekhodnykh Ekonomik: Rossiiskiy Obyt’, in Zaslavskaya, T. (Hrsg.) Kto i Kuda Stremitsya Vesti Rossiyu? Aktory Marko-, Mezo- i Mikrourovney Sovremennogo Transformacionnogo Prozessa, Moskau, MVShSEN

Khantadze, D. (2006): Transformationsprobleme in Georgien – eine Hayekianische Perspektive, mimeo

Kliamkin, I. (2006): Prikaz i Zakon: Problema Modernisatsyi Rossii, mimeo

Kliamkin, I., und Timofeev, L. Tenevoi Obraz Zhysni: Sociologicheskii Avtoportret Rossiiskogo Predprinimatelia, POLIS, (4) und (5)

Knight, J. (1992): Institutions and Social Conflict, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press

Kolchin, S. (1998): Neft’ i Gaz Kaspiia: Strategicheskie Interesy Rossii, Mirovaia Ekonomika i Mezhdunarodnye Otnosheniia, (3), 97-103

Kollontai, V. (2002): The “New” Political Economy (A View from Russia), American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 61, 217-232

Kordonskii, S. (2000): Rynki Wlasti: Administraivnye Rynki SSSR i Rossii, Moskau, OGI

Kosikova, L. (2001): Rossiisko-Ukrainskie Economicheskiie Otnosheniia v Postsovetskii Period, Moskau, IMEPI

Kosikova, L. (2002): Privatizatsiia Ukrainskoi Promyshlennosti i Rol’ Rossiiskikh Kompanii v Etom Protsesse, in Vardomskii, L. (Hrsg.): Globalizatsiia i Regionalizatsiia na Postsovetskom Prostranstve, Moskau, IMEPI

Kowall, T, und Zimmer, K. (2002): Der politische Einfluss von Wirtschaftseliten in der Ukraine, Arbeitspapiere der Forschungsstelle Osteuropa Bremen No. 42

Kryshtanovskaya, O. (2002): Bisnes-elita i Oligarhi: Itogi Desyatiletiia, Mir Rossii, (4), 3-60

Kryshtanovskaya, O., und White, S. (2005): The Rise of the Russian Business Elite, Communist and Post-Communist Studies, 38, 239-307

Lapina, N. (2004): Bisnes i Vlast’ v Rossiiskih Regionah: Voprosy Vzaimodeistviia, Rossiia i Sovremennyi Mir, (4), 56-67

Leipold, H. (1997): Der Zusammenhang zwischen gewachsener und gesetzten Ordnung: Einige Lehren aus den postsozialistischen Reformerfahrungen, in Cassel, D. (Hrsg.): Institutionelle Probleme der Systemtransformation, Berlin, Duncker&Humblott

Levitsky, S., und Way, L.A. (2002): The Rise of Competitive Authoritarianism, Journal of Democracy, 13, 51-65

Libman A. (2005a), ‘Vsaimodeistvie Gosudarstva i Bisnesa na Postsovetskom Prostranstve: Vosmozhnosti i Riski’, Obshestvennye Nauki i Sovremennost’, (4), 63-74

Libman, A. (2005), Bottom-Up and Top-Down Integration in the Post-Soviet Space, paper presented at the CSGR/CIGI/UNU-CRIS Conference on “Regionalisation and the Taming of Globalisation”, Warwick, UK, October 28

Libman, A. (2006): Ex Ante and Ex Post Institutional Convergence: Case of the Post-Soviet Space, Paper presented at the ESNIE 2006

Libman, A. (2006a): „Human Action, but not Human Design”: Entstehung und Zerfall des (post)sowjetischen administrativen Marktes. Aufsatz für den Hayek-Essay-Wettbewerb 2006

Libman, A. (2006b): Different Paths of the Second Transition in the Post-Soviet World: A Political-Economic Analysis. Paper prepared for the EACES Annual Conference, Brighton, UK, September

Lysenko, V. (2003): Vzaimodeistvie Vlasti i Biznesa v Regionakh: Rossiiskaia Versiia, Federalism, (4) Marchenko, A. (2005): Interview für die Zeitschrift Vestnik NAUFOR, (5), 25-30

Menshikov, S. (2004): Anatomiia Rossiiskogo Kapitalisma, Moskau, Mezhdunarodnye Otnosheniia

Menshikov, S. (2004a): Nash Kapitalizm: Meshdu Oligarhicheskim i Biurokraticheskim. Svobodnaia Mysl, (10), 25-32

Moskovskaya, A. (2005): Puti Ekonomicheskoi i Social’noi Transformacii Stran SNG, in Glinkina, S., und Chebotareva, T. (Hrsg.): Modeli Sistemnoi Transformacii i Social’naya Tsena Reform, Moskau, IMEPI

Naishul, V. (1991): Vysshaia i Posledniaia Stadiia Socialisma, in: Porguzhenie v Triasinu, Moskau

Nureev, R. (2001): Sozialnye Subiekty Postsovetskoy Rossii: Istoriia i Sovremennost’, Mir Rossii, (3), 3-66

Nureev, R., und Runov, B. (2002): Nazad k Chastnoi Sobstvennosti ili Vpered k Chastnoi Sobstvennosti? Obshestvennye Nauki i Sovremennost, (5)

Nikolaev, I., Tochilkina, O., und Kalinin, A. (2005): Dolgii Perekhod k Rynku. Moskau: FBK

Oberender, P, und Fleischmann, J. (2005): Zur Notwendigkeit eines „starken“ Staates im Transformationsprozeß, in

Leipold, H., und Wenzel, D. (Hrsg.): Ordnungsökonomik als aktuelle Herausforderung, Stuttgart, Lucius & Lucius

Olcott, M.B. (2002): Kazakhstan: Unfulfilled Promise, Washington, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace

Olcott, M.B., und Ottaway, M. (1999): Challenge of Semi-Authoritarianism, Carnegie Paper No. 7

Oleinik, A. (2003): Konstitutcia Rossiiskogo Rynka: Soglasie na Osnove Pessimizma? SOCIS, (9)

Oleinik, A. (2005): A Distrustful Economy: An Inquiry into Foundations of the Russian Market, Journal of Economic Issues, 39, 53-74

Oleinik, A. (2005a): Transfer of Institutions: Actors and Constraints -The Russian Case in a Global Context, HWWA Discussion Paper 320

Oleinik, A. (2005b): Preface: Institutional Traps in the Post-Privatization Development of the Russian Economy, in Oleinik, A. (Hrsg.): Institutional Economics of Russia’s Transformation, Aldershot, Hants, England, Burlington , VT , Ashgate

Offe, K. (1991): Capitalism bz Democratic Design? Democratic Theory Facing the Triple Trabsition in East Central Europe. Social Research, 58 (4)

Orlova, N. (2003): Undermining Business Confidence is Dangerous for Reform’ Alfa Bank Monthly Market Outlook, (11), 15-17

Pappe, Y. (2000): ‘Oligarhi’: Ekonomicheskaia Khronika 1992-2000, Moskau, Hochschule für Wirtschaft

Pappe, Y. (2004): Rossiyskii Krupnyi Bisnes: Sobytiia i Tendenzii v 2003 godu, Moskau, CMAKP

Pappe, Y. (2005): Rossiyskii Krupnyi Bisnes: Sobytiia i Tendenzii v 2004 godu, Moskau, CMAKP

Pappe, Y., und Galukhina, Y. (2006): Rossiyskiy Krupnyi Bisnes: Sobytiya i Tendencii v 2005 Godu, Moskau: CMAKP

Peregudov S. (2002): Corporativnyi Capital i Instituty Vlasti: Kto v Dome Hosiain?, POLIS, 5, 74-85

Peregudov, S. (2003): Korporazii, Obshestvo, Gosudarstvo, Moskau, Nauka

Peregudov, S., Lapina, N., und Semenenko, I. (1999): Gruppy Interesov I Rossiiskoe Gosudarstvo, Moskau, URSS

Piel, E., Schulze, P., und Timmermann, H. (2005): Die offene Flanke der Europäischen Union: Russische Föderation, Belarus, Ukraine und Moldau, Berlin, BWV Berliner Wissenschafts-Verlag

Polishchuk, L. (2002): Evolving Demand for Institutions in Transition Economies, mimeo

Polishchuk, L., und Savvateev, A. (2004): Spontaneous (Non)emergence of Property Rights, Economics of Transition, 12, 103-127

Priban, J. (2004): A Taste of the Orange Revolution: Ukraine and the Spirit of Constitutionalism, mimeo

Radaev, V. (1998): Formirovaniie Novykh Rossiiskikh Rynkov: Transaktsionnye Izdershki, Formy Kontrolia I Delovaia Etika, Moskau, CPT

Radaev, V. (1998a):‘Nekotorye Institutzional’nye Usloviia Formirovaniia Rossiyskikh Rynkov, Soziologicheskii Zhurnal, (3-4), 57-85

Radygin, A., Entov, R., Mezherapus, I. (2002): Problemy Pravpprimemeniia (Inforsmenta) v Sfere Zashity Prav Akcionerov. Moscow: IET

Raiser, M. (1997): Informal Institutions, Social Capital and Economic Transition: Reflection of a Neglected Dimension, EBRD Working Paper No. 25

Raiser, M. (1999): Trust in Transition, EBRD Working Paper No. 39

Razuvaev, V. (1999): Krupnyi Bisnes Vne Sfery Vidimosti, Pro et Contra, 4, 84-94

Rozmarinski, I. (2002): Osnovnye Kharakteristiki Semeino-Klanovogo Kapitalisma v Rossii na Rubezhe Tysyacheletii, Ekonomicheskii Vestnik Rostovskogo Unversiteta, (1)

Runov, A. (2003): Izmenenie Sprosa na Prava Sobstevnnosti: Neoinstitucional’nyi Analiz Privatizacii, in: Nureev, R. (Hrsg.): Ekonomicheskie Subiekty Postsovetskoi Rossii (Institutcional’nyi Analiz), Band 2, Moskau, MONF

Ryabchuk, M. (2004): Mozhno Li Poshatnut’ Shantazhistskoe Gosudarstvo, Neprikosnovennyi Zapas, (1)

Ryterman, R., und Recanatini, F. (2001): Disorganization or Self-Organization: The Emergence of Business Associations in a Transition Economy, mimeo

Satarov, G., und Parhomenko, S. (2001): Raznoobrazie Stran i Raznoobrazie Korrupzii (Analiz Sravnitel’nyk Issledovanii), Moskau, Indem

Schattenschneider, E. (1960): The Semisouvereign People: A Realist’s View of Democracy in America, Hinsdale, Dryden

Schneider, F. (2004): Arbeit im Schatten, Wiesbaden, Dr. Th. Gabler

Schneider, F. (2004a): The Size of the Shadow Economy in 145 Countries from 1999 to 2003, mimeo

Schularik, M. (2005): Ukraine: Der weite Weg nach Westen, Deutsche Bank Research Aktuelle Themen

Shkrapova, E., und Duborgryz, E. (2005): Pan-Evropeici, Galickie Contakty, (42)

Slinko, I., Yakovlev, E., und Zhuravskaya, E. (2005): Laws for Sale: Evidence from Russia, American Law and Economics Review, 7, 284-318

Sonin, K. (2003): Why the Rich May Favor Poor Protection of Property Rights, Journal of Comparative Economics, 3, 715-731

Sonin, K. (2005): Institucional’naya Ekonomika Beskonechnogo Peredela, Voprosy Ekonomiki, (7), 4-18

Stark, D., und Bruszt, L. (1998): Postsocialist Pathways: Transforming Politics and Property in East Central Europe, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Tambovtsev, V. (1999): Ekonomicheskie Instituty Rossiyskogo Kapitalisma, in Zaslavskaya, T. (Hrsg.) Kuda Idet Rossiya? Krizis Institucional’nykh Sistem, Moskau, Logos

Timofeev, L. (2000): Pravo Sobstvennosti v SSSR: Kommunisticheskaia Doktrina i Tenevaia Real’nost’, Rossia i sovremennyi mir, (4), 50-70

Transparency International (2004): Corruption Perception Index, Press Release, 20. Oktober

Trenin, D. (2005): Vneshnee Vmeshatelstvo v Sobytiia na Ukraine i Rossiisko-Zapadnye Otnosheniia. Moscow Carnegie Center Briefing, Februar

UNCTAD (2005): World Investment Report 2005: Transnational Corporations and the Internationalization of the R&D

Vahtra, P. and Liuhto, K. (2004): Expansion or Exodus? Foreign Operations of Russia’s Largest Corporations, Turku School of Economics and Business Administration, Pan-European Institute Working Paper No. 2004/8.

Vasiliev, A., Kukushkin, V., und Tkachenko, A. (2002): Privatizatsiia: Rossia, Zentral’naia Azia, Arabskie Strany, Moskau, Vostohnaia Literatura

Verk, V. (2004): Oligarkhi v Kazakhstane: Sushestvuiut Li Oni i Kto Oni? Politon Analythical Review, 20, Juli

Volkov, V. (2002): Silovoe Predprinimatel’stvo, St. Petersburg, Letnii Sad

Way, L.A. (2005): Rapacious Individualism and Political Competition in Ukraine, 1992-2004, Communist and Post-Communist Studies, 38, 191-205

Woodruff, D.M. (2000): Rules for Followers: Institutional Theory and the New Politics of Economic Backwardness in Russia, Politics and Society, 28, 437--82

World Bank (1997): World Development Report 1997: The State in a Changing World

World Bank (2004): From Transition to Development, A Country Economic Memorandum for the Russian Federation

Yakovlev A. (2003): Interaction of Interest Groups and Their Impact on Economic Reforms in Contemporary Russia, Arbeitspapiere der Forschungsstelle Osteuropa Bremen Nr. 51

Yakovlev, A. (2003a): Vozmozhnye Strategii Ekonomicheskih Agentov po Otnosheniiu k Institutam Korporativnogo Upravleniia, in Yakovlev, A. (Hrsg.), Razvitie Sprosa na Pravovoe Regulirovanie Korporativnogo Upravleniia v Chastnom Sektore, Moskau, MONF

Yakovlev, A. (2005): Evoluciia Strategii Vzaimodeistviia Bisnesa i Vlasti v Rossiiskoi Ekonomike, Rossiiskii Zhurnal Menedzhmenta, 3, 27-52

Yevstigneev V. (1997): Valutno-finansovaia integraciia v ES i SNG: Sravnitelnii semanticheskii analiz, Moskau, Nauka

Zlotnikov, S., und Chebotarev, A. (2001): Legalizatsiiia Kapitalov v Respublike Kazakhstan, K obshchestvu bez korruptsii, (2), 16-21

Zubarevich, N. (2002): Prishel, Uvidel, Pobedil? (Krupnyi Bisnes I Regional’naya Vlast’) Pro et Contra, 7, 107-119

Zubarevich, N. (2003): Izmenenie Roli i Strategii Krupnogo Bisnesa v Regionakh Rossii, in: Regional’nye Prozessy v Sovremennoi Rossii, Moskau, INION

Zudin, A. (1996): Bisnes i Politika Presidentskikh Vyborov 1996 goda, Pro et Contra, 1, 46-60

Zudin, A. (1999): ‘’Oligarhia’ Kak Politicheskaia Problema Rossiiskogo Postkommunizma, Obshestvennye Nauki i Sovremennost’, (1), 45-65

Zudin, A: (20001): Neokorporativism v Rossii, Pro et Contra, 6(4)