What Drove the First Response to the COVID-19 Pandemic? The Role of Institutions and Leader Attributes

Hartwell, Christopher A. (2021): What Drove the First Response to the COVID-19 Pandemic? The Role of Institutions and Leader Attributes.

Abstract

What determines how a national government reacts in a crisis? The COVID-19 pandemic provides an opportunity to explore leadership behavior and crisis management, and this paper examines what drove the extent of the lockdown in countries around the world during the first wave of coronavirus. In particular, this paper posits that many of the policies undertaken were “extraordinary,” that is unlike those ever implemented or complemented by the leaders in charge at the start of the pandemic. Utilizing new and high-frequency data on government responses to COVID-19 and novel statistical techniques, the results of this analysis are that institutions and leadership attributes both matter, but for different policies; where the response called for more ‘normal” policies, it appeared that institutional mechanisms were adequate and played the largest role in influencing the extent of the lockdown. On the other hand, where the policies contemplated were very far from the ordinary (including stay-at-home orders or prohibitions on internal travel), the attributes of the leader determined the stringency of the lockdown more than institutions.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: COVID-19; leadership; crisis management; decision-making; institutions
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H4 - Publicly Provided Goods; H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health; P - Economic Systems > P5 - Comparative Economic Systems

References

Aldrich, D. P., & Meyer, M. A. (2015). Social capital and community resilience. American behavioral scientist, 59(2), 254-269.

Allison, G.T. (1971). Essence of Decision: Explaining the Cuban Missile Crisis. Boston: Little, Brown, and Company.

Allison, P. D. (2009). Fixed Effects Regression Models. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Ansell, C., Boin, A., & Keller, A. (2010). Managing transboundary crises: Identifying the building blocks of an effective response system. Journal of contingencies and crisis management, 18(4), 195-207.

Ayittey, G. B. N. (2008). The African development conundrum. In Powell, B. (Ed.), Making poor nations rich: entrepreneurship and the process of economic development. Palo Alto, CA: Stanford University Press.

Bajardi, P., Poletto, C., Ramasco, J. J., Tizzoni, M., Colizza, V., & Vespignani, A. (2011). Human mobility networks, travel restrictions, and the global spread of 2009 H1N1 pandemic. PloS one, 6(1), e16591.

Barker, K. (2012). Influenza preparedness and the bureaucratic reflex: anticipating and generating the 2009 H1N1 event. Health & place, 18(4), 701-709.

Besley, T., & Kudamatsu, M. (2006). Health and democracy. American Economic Review, 96(2), 313-318.

Birkmann, J., Buckle, P., Jaeger, J., Pelling, M., Setiadi, N., Garschagen, M., ... & Kropp, J. (2010). Extreme events and disasters: a window of opportunity for change? Analysis of organizational, institutional and political changes, formal and informal responses after mega-disasters. Natural hazards, 55(3), 637-655.

Bjørnskov, C., & Rode, M. (2019). Crisis, ideology, and interventionist policy ratchets. Political Studies, 67(4), 815-833.

Blondel, J. (1987). Political leadership: Towards a general analysis. London: Sage Publishing.

Boin, A., & 't Hart, P. (2010). Organising for effective emergency management: Lessons from research. Australian Journal of Public Administration, 69(4), 357-371.

Boin, A., & Bynander, F. (2015). Explaining success and failure in crisis coordination. Geografiska Annaler: Series A, Physical Geography, 97(1), 123-135.

Boin, A., & McConnell, A. (2007). Preparing for critical infrastructure breakdowns: the limits of crisis management and the need for resilience. Journal of contingencies and crisis management, 15(1), 50-59.

Boin, A., Stern, E., & Sundelius, B. (2016). The politics of crisis management: Public leadership under pressure. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Boin, A., 't Hart, P., & McConnell, A. (2009). Crisis exploitation: political and policy impacts of framing contests. Journal of European Public Policy, 16(1), 81-106.

Boin, A., ‘t Hart, P., McConnell, A., & Preston, T. (2010). Leadership style, crisis response and blame management: The case of Hurricane Katrina. Public Administration, 88(3), 706-723.

Bojar, A., & Kriesi, H. (2020). Action repertoires in contentious episodes: What determines governments’ and challengers’ action strategies? A cross‐national analysis. European Journal of Political Research. Online first, https://doi.org/10.1111/1475-6765.12386.

Brieba, D. (2018). State capacity and health outcomes: Comparing Argentina’s and Chile’s reduction of infant and maternal mortality, 1960–2013. World Development, 101, 37-53.

Battersby, B., Lam W.R., & Ture, E. (2020, May 20). Tracking the $9 Trillion Global Fiscal Support to Fight COVID-19. IMF Blog, https://blogs.imf.org/2020/05/20/tracking-the-9-trillion-global-fiscal-support-to-fight-covid-19/.

Christensen, T., & Painter, M. (2004). The politics of SARS–rational responses or ambiguity, symbols and chaos? Policy and Society, 23(2), 18-48.

Connelly, S., & Zaccaro, S. J. (2017). Leadership and creativity in military contexts. In Handbook of Research on Leadership and Creativity. Edward Elgar Publishing.

Cooper, H. T. (2007). Decision making in a crisis. Journal of Police Crisis Negotiations, 7(2), 5-28.

Correa, H., & Namkoong, K. (1992). Determinants and effects of health policy. Journal of Policy Modeling, 14(1), 41-63.

Cram, L. (2001). Governance ‘to go’: domestic actors, institutions and the boundaries of the possible. JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 39(4), 595-618.

De Leeuw, E., Clavier, C., & Breton, E. (2014). Health policy–why research it and how: health political science. Health research policy and systems, 12(1), 55.

DeLeo, R. A. (2018). Indicators, agendas and streams: analysing the politics of preparedness. Policy & Politics, 46(1), 27-45.

Doyle, E. E., McClure, J., Paton, D., & Johnston, D. M. (2014). Uncertainty and decision making: Volcanic crisis scenarios. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 10, 75-101.

Ferreira, F., & Gyourko, J. (2014). Does gender matter for political leadership? The case of US mayors. Journal of Public Economics, 112, 24-39.

Gagnon, F., Bergeron, P., Clavier, C., Fafard, P., Martin, E., & Blouin, C. (2017). Why and how political science can contribute to public health? Proposals for collaborative research avenues. International journal of health policy and management, 6(9), 495-499.

Garcelon, M. (2018). Colonizing the subject: The genealogy and legacy of the Soviet internal passport. In Caplan, J. & Torpey, J. (eds.), Documenting individual identity: The development of state practices in the modern world. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, pp. 83-100.

Gelpi, C., & Grieco, J. M. (2001). Attracting trouble: Democracy, leadership tenure, and the targeting of militarized challenges, 1918-1992. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 45(6), 794-817.

Gerring, J., Thacker, S. C., & Alfaro, R. (2012). Democracy and human development. The Journal of Politics, 74(1), 1-17.

Goudarzi, S. (2020). Lessons from Past Outbreaks Could Help Fight the Coronavirus Pandemic. Scientific American, March 23, available at https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/lessons-from-past-outbreaks-could-help-fight-the-coronavirus-pandemic1/.

Haeffele, S., & Storr, V. H. (Eds.). (2020). Government Responses to Crisis. Heidelberg: Springer Nature.

Hale, T., Petherick, A., Phillips, T., & Webster, S. (2020). Variation in government responses to COVID-19. Blavatnik School of Government Working Paper, 31.

Hartwell, C.A. (2013). Institutional barriers in the transition to market: examining performance and divergence in transition economies. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

Hartwell, C.A., Lawton, T., & Tingbani, I. (2021). Identifying Obstacles to Collective Action during a Pandemic: A Meta-Organizational Perspective. Unpublished manuscript (under review).

Hermann, C.F. (ed.) (1972). International Crises: Insights from Behavioral Research. New York: Free Press. Hermann, M.G. (2005) Assessing leadership style: trait analysis. In Post, J.M. (ed.), The Psychological Assessment of Political Leaders. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, pp. 178–212.

Huber, E., Mustillo, T., & Stephens, J. D. (2008). Politics and social spending in Latin America. The Journal of Politics, 70(2), 420-436.

Kavanagh, M. M. (2020). Authoritarianism, outbreaks, and information politics. The Lancet Public Health, 5(3), e135-e136.

Keele, L. (2015). The Statistics of Causal Inference: A View from Political Methodology. Political Analysis, 23(3), 313-335.

Keeler, J. T. (1993). Opening the window for reform: Mandates, crises, and extraordinary policy-making. Comparative Political Studies, 25(4), 433-486.

Kingdon, J. W., & Stano, E. (1984). Agendas, alternatives, and public policies (Vol. 45, pp. 165-169). Boston: Little, Brown.

Klaiman, T., Kraemer, J. D., & Stoto, M. A. (2011). Variability in school closure decisions in response to 2009 H1N1: a qualitative systems improvement analysis. BMC public health, 11, 73-73.

Kripfganz, S., & Schwarz, C. (2015). Estimation of linear dynamic panel data models with time-invariant regressors. ECB Working Paper 1838. Frankfurt: European Central Bank.

Lai, A. Y., & Tan, T. B. (2012). Combating SARS and H1N1: insights and lessons from Singapore’s public health control measures. ASEAS-Austrian Journal of South-East Asian Studies, 5(1), 74-101.

Ligon, G. S., Harris, D. J., & Hunter, S. T. (2012). Quantifying leader lives: What historiometric approaches can tell us. The Leadership Quarterly, 23(6), 1104-1133.

Lim, P. L. (2011). Influenza and SARS: the impact of viral pandemics on maritime health. International maritime health, 62(3), 170-175.

Majumdar, S., & Mukand, S. W. (2004). Policy gambles. American Economic Review, 94(4), 1207-1222.

Markel, H., Lipman, H. B., Navarro, J. A., Sloan, A., Michalsen, J. R., Stern, A. M., & Cetron, M. S. (2007). Nonpharmaceutical interventions implemented by US cities during the 1918-1919 influenza pandemic. Journal of the American Medical Association, 298(6), 644-654.

Meder, B., Le Lec, F., & Osman, M. (2013). Decision making in uncertain times: what can cognitive and decision sciences say about or learn from economic crises? Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 17(6), 257-260.

Medvedev, D., Rama, M., & Ikeda, Y. (2019). Advanced‐country policies and emerging‐market currencies: The impact of US tapering on India's rupee. International Finance, 22(1), 35-52.

Møller, J., & Skaaning, S. E. (2013). Autocracies, democracies, and the violation of civil liberties. Democratization, 20(1), 82-106.

Muntaner, C., Borrell, C., Ng, E., Chung, H., Espelt, A., Rodriguez‐Sanz, M., Benach, J. and O’Campo, P. (2011). Politics, welfare regimes, and population health: controversies and evidence. Sociology of health & illness, 33(6), 946-964.

Nai, A. (2019). Disagreeable narcissists, extroverted psychopaths, and elections: A new dataset to measure the personality of candidates worldwide. European Political Science, 18(2), 309-334.

Park, D. (1996). Gender role, decision style and leadership style. Women in Management Review, 11(8), 13-17.

Patterson, A. C., & Veenstra, G. (2016). Politics and population health: testing the impact of electoral democracy. Health & Place, 40, 66-75.

Pei, S., Kandula, S., & Shaman, J. (2020). Differential Effects of Intervention Timing on COVID-19 Spread in the United States. medRxiv. Retrieved from https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.05.15.20103655v2.

Pesaran, M. H., & Zhou, Q. (2018). Estimation of time-invariant effects in static panel data models. Econometric Reviews, 37(10), 1137-1171.

Provost, C., & Teske, P. (2009). Extraordinary powers, extraordinary policies? In Provost, C., & Teske, P. (eds.), President George W. Bush’s Influence over Bureaucracy and Policy (pp. 1-15). Palgrave Macmillan, New York.

Rosenthal, U., & Kouzmin, A. (1997). Crises and crisis management: Toward comprehensive government decision making. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 7(2), 277-304.

Saint-Michel, S. E. (2018). Leader gender stereotypes and transformational leadership: Does leader sex make the difference? M@n@gement, 21(3), 944-966.

Satter, D. (2016). The Less You Know, the Better You Sleep: Russia's Road to Terror and Dictatorship Under Yeltsin and Putin. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

Scheidel, W. (2020). The Spanish Flu Didn’t Wreck the Global Economy. Foreign Affairs, May 28, available at https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/2020-05-28/spanish-flu-didnt-wreck-global-economy.

Schunck, R. (2013). Within and between estimates in random-effects models: Advantages and drawbacks of correlated random effects and hybrid models. The Stata Journal, 13(1), 65-76.

Stoker, J. I., Garretsen, H., & Soudis, D. (2019). Tightening the leash after a threat: A multi-level event study on leadership behavior following the financial crisis. The Leadership Quarterly, 30(2), 199-214.

Swagel, P. (2015). Legal, political, and institutional constraints on the financial crisis policy response. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 29(2), 107-22.

Tang, B., Xia, F., Tang, S., Bragazzi, N. L., Li, Q., Sun, X., ... & Wu, J. (2020). The effectiveness of quarantine and isolation determine the trend of the COVID-19 epidemics in the final phase of the current outbreak in China. International Journal of Infectious Diseases, 95, 288-293.

Uitdewilligen, S., & Waller, M. J. (2018). Information sharing and decision‐making in multidisciplinary crisis management teams. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 39(6), 731-748.

Van Laere, J. (2013). Wandering through crisis and everyday organizing; Revealing the subjective nature of interpretive, temporal and organizational boundaries. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 21(1), 17-25.

Vecchio, R. P. (2002). Leadership and gender advantage. The Leadership Quarterly, 13(6), 643-671.

Wallace, M. D., & Suedfeld, P. (1988). Leadership performance in crisis: The longevity-complexity link. International Studies Quarterly, 32(4), 439-451.

Weisæth, L., Knudsen Jr, Ø., & Tønnessen, A. (2002). Technological disasters, crisis management and leadership stress. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 93(1), 33-45.

Yousef, D. A. (1998). Correlates of perceived leadership style in a culturally mixed environment. Leadership and Organization Development Journal, 19(5), 275-284