Child Labour Ethics through the Prism of Utilitarianism and Deontology

Krummel, Daniel and Siegfried, Patrick (2021): Child Labour Ethics through the Prism of Utilitarianism and Deontology. Published in: Open Access Library Journal (OALJ) , Vol. 8, No. 2 (9 February 2021): pp. 1-14.

Abstract

Purpose: Grounded in the theoretical concepts of utilitarianism and deontology, this paper aims to evaluate the issue of child labour from an ethics perspective. By linking utilitarianism with normative stakeholder theory, relevant stakeholder groups are being identified in order to examine their influence on and role in the occurrence of child labour allowing for a practical reference. The findings may serve companies in particular as a basis for decision-making in the development of their value chains. Design/Methodology/Approach: The author uses a literature review in order to analyze the findings of existing literature on the topic of child labour in an ethics context, thereby drawing on literature, indexed in Web of Science and Google Scholar by employing forward and backward citation analysis. Findings: The investigation of child labour in terms of ethics yields conflicting results. From a deontological perspective, child labour can never be ethical and should always be rejected as it is not wanted to become a general law. In contrast, according to a utilitarian sentiment, child labour is ethically justifiable as long as the beneficiaries of the labour are greater in number than the children working or suffering. Originality/Value: The examination of child labour from the perspective of deontology and utilitarianism in conjunction with normative stakeholder theory constitutes a novelty in the ethics literature. The integration of theoretical findings into a practical business context provides additional value for managers and global supply chain managers.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Business Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility
• Subjects: J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J1 - Demographic Economics; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M1 - Business Administration; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M1 - Business Administration > M14 - Corporate Culture ; Diversity ; Social Responsibility

References

[1] Abe, K. and Ogawa, H. (2017). Globalization, child labour and adult unemploy-ment. The Ritsumeikan Economic Review 65(4):193–205.

[2] Amnesty International (2016). THIS IS WHAT WE DIE FOR - HUMAN RIGHTS ABUSES IN THE DEMOCRATIC REPUBLICOF THE CONGO POWER THE GLOBAL TRADE IN COBALT. [online]. Available at: https://www.amnesty.org/download/Documents/AFR6231832016ENGLISH.PDF.

[3] Amnesty International (2017). TIME TO RECHARGE: CORPORATE ACTION AND INACTION TO TACKLE ABUSES IN THE COBALT SUPPLY CHAIN. [online]. Available at: https://www.amnesty.org/download/Documents/AFR6273952017ENGLISH.PDF.

[4] Amnesty International (2018). Amnesty International Report 2017/2018 - The State of the Worlds Human Rights.

[5] Ballet, J., Bhukuth, A. and Carimentrand, A. (2014). Child Labor and Responsible Consumers: From Boycotts to Social Labels, Illustrated by the Indian Hand-Knotted Carpet Industry. Business & Society, 53(1), pp.71–104.

[6] Basu, K. (2003). The Global Child Labor Problem: What Do We Know and What Can We Do? The World Bank Economic Review, 17(2), pp.147–173.

[7] Bentham, J. (1996). (First published in 1789). An introduction to the principles of morals and legislation. (Edited by J. H. Burns & H. L. A. Hart.) New York: Oxford University Press.

[8] Blanchett, W.J and Shealey, M.W. (2013). Responding to the Needs of Ethnically and Culturally Diverse Learners with Exceptionalities and Their Families. Multiple Voices for Ethnically Diverse Exceptional Learners. April 2013, Vol. 13, No. 2, pp. 1-3.

[9] Carroll, A.B. and Shabana, K.M. (2010). The Business Case for Corporate Social Responsibility: A Review of Concepts, Research and Practice. International Journal of Management Reviews, 12(1), pp.85–105.

[10] Chakraborty, K. and Chakraborty, B. (2018). Low level equilibrium trap, unem-ployment, efficiency of education system, child labour and human capital for-mation. Journal of Economics, 125(1), pp.69–95.

[11] Chamarbagwala, R. (2008). Regional Returns to Education, Child Labour and Schooling in India. The Journal of Development Studies, 44(2), pp.233-257.

[12] Chen, J.C. and Roberts, R.W. (2010). Toward a More Coherent Understanding of the Organization–Society Relationship: A Theoretical Consideration for Social and Environmental Accounting Research. Journal of Business Ethics, 97(4), pp.651–665.

[13] Cheng, B., Ioannou, I. and Serafeim, G. (2014). Corporate social responsibility and access to finance. Strategic Management Journal, 35(1), pp.1–23.

[14] CLW (2016). Working 10 hours every day, a 14 year old child worker from Foshan dies from exhaustion. [online]. Available at: http://www.chinalaborwatch.org/newscast/596 [Accessed April 28, 2020].

[15] CorpAbuse (2020). Companies – CorpAbuse. [online]. Available at: https://corpabuse.org/companies/?filter_type=global-brands [Accessed April 28, 2020].

[16] Donaldson, T. and Dunfee, T.W. (1995). Integrative Social Contracts Theory: A Communitarian Conception of Economic Ethics. Economics and Philosophy, 11(1), pp.85–112.

[17] Donaldson, T. and Preston, L.E. (1995). The Stakeholder Theory of the Corpora-tion: Concepts, Evidence, and Implications. The Academy of Management Review, 20(1), p.65.

[18] Donaubauer, J. and Dreger, C. (2018). The End of Cheap Labor: Are Foreign In-vestors Leaving China? Asian Economic Papers, 17(2), pp.94–107.

[19] Ferrell, O.C., Fraedrich, J. and Ferrell, L. (2015). Business ethics: ethical decision making and cases. 10. ed. Stamford: Cengage Learning.

[20] Freeman, R. E. (1984). Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Perspective. Boston: Pitman.

[21] Gawronski, B. and Beer, J.S. (2016). What makes moral dilemma judgments “util-itarian” or “deontological”? Social Neuroscience, pp.1–7.

[22] Gray, K. and Schein, C. (2012). Two Minds Vs. Two Philosophies: Mind Percep-tion Defines Morality and Dissolves the Debate Between Deontology and Utilitar-ianism. Review of Philosophy and Psychology, 3(3), pp.405–423.

[23] Greene, J.D. et al. (2008). Cognitive load selectively interferes with utilitarian moral judgment. Cognition, 107(3), pp.1144–1154.

[24] Harari, R., Forastiere, F. and Axelson, O. (1997). Unacceptable “occupational” ex-posure to toxic agents among children in Ecuador. American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 23(3), pp.185–190.

[25] Hart, O. and Zingales, L. (2017). Companies Should Maximize Shareholder Wel-fare Not Market Value. Journal of Law, Finance, and Accounting, 2(2), pp.247–275.

[26] Hindman, H.D. and Smith, C.G. (1999). Cross-Cultural Ethics and the Child Labor Problem. Journal of Business Ethics, 19(1), pp.21–33.

[27] Höffe, O. (1977). Kants kategorischer Imperativ als Kriterium des Sittlichen. Zeitschrift für philosophische Forschung, 31(3), pp.354–384.

[28] Hume, D. (2000). (First published in 1740). A treatise of human nature. (Edited by D. F. Norton & M. J. Norton.) New York: Oxford University Press.

[29] ILAB (2018). Findings on the Worst Forms of Child Labor - Colombia | U.S. De-partment of Labor. [online]. Available at: https://www.dol.gov/agencies/ilab/resources/reports/child-labor/colombia [Ac-cessed May 1, 2020].

[30] ILO (2004). Child labour: a textbook for university students. Geneva: International Labour Office.

[31] ILO (2017). Ending child labour by 2025: A review of policies and programmes. [online]. Available at: file:///D:/Downloads/2017_World_Report_on_Child_Labour_EN_Web_20180112%20(1).pdf.

[32] ILO (2017a). Global Estimates of Child Labour: RESULTS AND TRENDS, 2012-2016. [online]. Available at: https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/@dgreports/@dcomm/documents/publication/wcms_575499.pdf.

[33] Korsgaard, C.M. (1985). Kant’s Formula of Universal Law. [online]. Available at: https://dash.harvard.edu/handle/1/3201869 [Accessed April 29, 2020].

[34] Kreikebaum, H. (2006). Internationale Unternehmensethik. In H. Albach, ed. Un-ternehmensethik und globale Märkte. Zeitschrift für Betriebswirtschaft Special issue. Wiesbaden: Gabler.

[35] Lund‐Thomsen, P. (2008). The Global Sourcing and Codes of Conduct Debate: Five Myths and Five Recommendations. Development and Change, 39(6), pp.1005–1018.

[36] Maki, R. (2017). Child labour coalition statement on new estimates of child labor – stopchildlabor. [online]. Available from: http://stopchildlabor.org/?p=4443 [Ac-cessed April 28, 2020].

[37] Manda, D.K., Kimalu, P.K., Nafula, N.N., Kimani, D.N., Nyaga, R.K., Mutua, J.M., Mwabu, G. and Kimenyi, M.S. (2003). Costs and benefits of eliminating child la-bour in Kenya. Nairobi, Kenya: Kenya Institute for Public Policy Research and Analysis.

[38] Marques, J. (2015). Universalism and Utilitarianism: An Evaluation of Two Popu-lar Moral Theories in Business Decision Making. The Journal of Values-Based Leadership, 8, p.Art. 3, 1-11.

[39] McWilliams, A. and Siegel, D. (2001). Corporate Social Responsibility: a Theory of the Firm Perspective. Academy of Management Review, 26(1), pp.117–127.

[40] Meiklejohn, D. (1998). ‘Child Labour’. Ethical Consumer. No.51, p.30.

[41] Mill, J. S. (1998). (First published in 1863). Utilitarianism. (Edited by R. Crisp.) New York: Oxford University Press.

[42] Morris, R.C. (2010). Can the subaltern speak? reflections on the history of an idea. New York: Columbia Univ. Press.

[43] Pierik, R. (2007). Fighting child labor abroad: conceptual problems and practical solutions. In V. Gehrig, ed. The ethical dimensions of global development. Lan-ham : Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, pp. 47–57.

[44] Posner, R.A. (1979). Utilitarianism, Economics, and Legal Theory. The Journal of Legal Studies, 8(1), pp.103–140.

[45] Potter, C. and Lupilya, A.C. (2016). ‘You have hands, make use of them!’ Child labour in Artisanal and Small-scale Mining in Tanzania: ‘You Have Hands, Make use of Them!’ Journal of International Development, 28(7), pp.1013–1028.

[46] Quattri, M. and Watkins, K. (2019). Child labour and education – A survey of slum settlements in Dhaka (Bangladesh). World Development Perspectives, 13, pp.50–66.

[47] Radfar, A., Asgharzadeh, S.A., Quesada, F. and Filip, I. (2018). Challenges and perspectives of child labor. Industrial Psychiatry Journal, 27(1), p.17.

[48] Reath, A. (1994). Legislating the Moral Law. Noûs, 28(4), pp.435–464.

[49] Reath, A. (1989). The Categorical Imperative and Kant's Conception of Practical Rationality. The Monist, 72(3), pp.384–410.

[50] Scheffler, S. (1994). The Rejection of Consequentialism. Oxford University Press. [online]. Available at: http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/view/10.1093/0198235119.001.0001/acprof-9780198235118 [Accessed May 4, 2020].

[51] Shoemaker, D.W. (1999). Utilitarianism and Personal Identity. The Journal of Val-ue Inquiry, 33(2), pp.183–199.

[52] Shumetie, A. and Mamo, K. (2019). Effect of cropland and livestock ownership on child labour in eastern Ethiopia: empirical examination of the Wealth Paradox. In-ternational Journal of Child Care and Education Policy, 13(1), p.5.

[53] Siegfried, P. (2011): Die Bedeutung des Ethischen für den ökonomischen Prozess, AVM Akademische Verlagsgemeinschaft, p 100.

[54] Siegfried, P. (2015a): Business Ethics, Sustainability and CSR, Volume 1, AVM Akademische Verlagsgemeinschaft, p.135.

[55] Siegfried, P. (2015b): Business Ethics, Sustainability and CSR, Volume 2, AVM Akademische Verlagsgemeinschaft,p. 87.

[56] Sinnott-Armstrong, W. (2014). Consequentialism. In Zalta, E. N. (editor) The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Spring 2014 edition.

[57] SOMO, ALR and LRDP (2017). The Myanmar Dilemma: Can the garment industry deliver decent jobs for workers in Myanmar? [online]. Available at: file:///D:/Downloads/170731-The-Myanmar-Dilemma-update-web-1.pdf [Accessed May 2, 2020].

[58] Sprinkle, G. and Maines, L., (2010). The benefits and costs of corporate social re-sponsibility. Business Horizons, 53(5), pp.445-453.

[59] Sullivan, R.J. (1997). An introduction to Kant’s ethics. Reprinted. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.

[60] The World Bank (2018). Population, worldwide | Data. [online]. Available at: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.TOTL [Accessed April 28, 2020].

[61] TheWorldCounts (2020). Global challenges. [online]. Available at: https://www.theworldcounts.com/challenges [Accessed April 28, 2020].

[62] UN (2019). World Day Against Child Labour, 12 June. [online]. Available at: https://www.un.org/en/events/childlabourday/background.shtml [Accessed April 28, 2020].

[63] UNCRC (1989). The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. Unicef UK. [online]. Available at: https://downloads.unicef.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/unicef-convention-rights-child-uncrc.pdf?_ga=2.123746762.1370693363.1588103156-190427524.1588103156 [Accessed April 28, 2020].

[64] UNICEF (2014). Child Labour and UNICEF in Action: Children at the Centre. [online]. Available at: https://www.unicef.org/protection/files/Child_Labour_and_UNICEF_in_Action.pdf.

[65] UNICEF (2004). Eliminating child labour: The costs and benefits. [online]. Availa-ble at: http://www.ilo.org/global/about-the-ilo/newsroom/news/WCMS_075570/lang--en/index.htm [Accessed May 1, 2020].

[66] Van Staveren, I. (2007). Beyond Utilitarianism and Deontology: Ethics in Eco-nomics. Review of Political Economy, 19(1), pp.21–35.

[67] Vogel, D.J. (2005). Is There a Market for Virtue?: The Business Case for Corporate Social Responsibility. California Management Review, 47(4), pp.19–45.

[68] Von Ebert, T. (1976). Kants kategorischer Imperativ und die Kriterien gebotener, verbotener und freigestellter Handlungen. Kant-Studien, 67(1–4). [online]. Availa-ble at: https://www.degruyter.com/view/j/kant.1976.67.issue-1-4/kant.1976.67.1-4.570/kant.1976.67.1-4.570.xml [Accessed April 29, 2020].

[69] Weiss, J. (2014). Business Ethics, 6th ed. [online]. Available at: https://www.safaribooksonline.com/library/view//9781626561427/?ar [Accessed April 29, 2020].

[70] Wilk, V.A. (1993). “Health hazards to children in agriculture”. American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 24 (3), 283-290.

[71] Wiredu, K. (2008). Social Philosophy in Postcolonial Africa: Some Preliminaries Concerning Communalism and Communitarianism. South African Journal of Phi-losophy, 27(4), pp.332–339.

[72] Yovel, Y. (1998). Kant’s Practical Reason as Will: Interest, Recognition, Judgment, and Choice. The Review of Metaphysics, 52(2), pp.267–294.