Market structure, competition, and pricing in United States international telephone service markets

Madden, Gary G and Savage, Scott J (2000): Market structure, competition, and pricing in United States international telephone service markets. Published in: The Review of Economics and Statistics , Vol. 2, No. 82 (2000): pp. 291-296.

Abstract

Abstract—Several national governments argue international telephone prices are high because of asymmetric competition and inefficiencies in the accounting arrangements that govern the telecommunications services trade. This paper develops a model of U.S. international telephone pricing that allows for the accounting rate system and contains market-structure variables for both the U.S. and foreign ends of bilateral markets. Model estimation is on 39 bilateral telephone markets from 1991 through 1994. Parameter estimates reveal that settlement rates, market concentration, competition at either end of the bilateral market, and ownership are significant determinants of prices. These findings support initiatives promoting accounting-rate reductions and increased competition.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: United States international telephone service markets
• Subjects: L - Industrial Organization > L9 - Industry Studies: Transportation and Utilities > L96 - Telecommunications

References

Acton, Jan Paul, and Ingo Vogelsang, ‘‘Telephone Demand Over the Atlantic: Evidence from Country-Pair Data,’’ The Journal of Industrial Economics, 40 (1992), 1–19.

Alleman, James, and Barbara Sorce, ‘‘International Settlements: A Time for a Change,’’ Proceedings of the Global Networking ’97 Conference, Calgary, Canada, (June 15–18, 1997).

Bali Online, http://www.indo.com/corp/bali_online.html (1997).

Borenstein, Severin, ‘‘Hubs and High Fares: Dominance and Market Power in the US Airline Industry,’’ Rand Journal of Economics 20 (1989), 344–365.

Bresnahan, Timothy, ‘‘Empirical Studies of Industries with Market Power,’’ in Richard Schmalensee and Robert Willig (Eds.), Handbook of Industrial Organisation Volume II (Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publishers, 1989).

Cave, Martin, and Mark Donnelly, ‘‘The Pricing of International Telecommunications Services by Monopoly Operators,’’ Information Economics and Policy 8 (1996), 107–123. Cowling, Keith, and Michael Waterson, ‘‘Price-Cost Margins and Market Structure,’’ Economica 43 (1976), 267–274.

Ergas, Henry, and Paul Patterson, ‘‘International Telecommunications Settlement Arrangements:An Unsustainable Inheritance,’’Telecommunications Policy 15 (1991), 29–48. FCC, Statistics of Communications Common Carriers (Washington: FCC, various issues, 1991–1995).

Ergas, Henry, and Paul Patterson Policy Statement on International Accounting Rate Reform, 96–37, (Washington: FCC, January 31, 1996).

Ergas, Henry, and Paul Patterson 1997 Trends in the U.S. International Telecommunications Industry, Common Carrier Bureau (Washington: FCC, 1997).

Frieden, Rob, International Telecommunications Handbook (London: Artech House, 1996).

Hakim, Sam Ramsey, and Ding Lu, ‘‘Monopolistic Settlement Agreements in International Telecommunications,’’ Information Economics and Policy 5 (1993), 145–157.

Hsiao, Cheng, Trent Appelbe, and Christopher Dineen, ‘‘A General Framework for Panel Data Models with Application to Canadian Customer-Dialled Long Distance Telephone Service,’’ Journal of Econometrics 59 (1993), 63–86. IMF, Direction of Trade Yearbook 1996 (Washington: IMF, 1996).

ITU, Direction of Traffıc: Trends in International Telephone Tariffs, 2nd ed. (Geneva: ITU/TeleGeography, 1996a).

ITU, World Telecommunications Indicators Database (Geneva: ITU/TeleGeography, 1996b).

Larson, Alexander, Dale Lehman, and Dennis Weisman, ‘‘A General Theory of Point-to-Point Long Distance Demand,’’ in Alain De Fontenay, Mary Shugard, and David Sibley (Eds.), Telecommunications Demand Modelling (Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1990).

Oum,Tae Hoon, andYimin Zhang, ‘‘Competition andAllocative Efficiency: The Case of the US Telephone Industry,’’ this REVIEW 77 (1995), 82–96.

Porter, Robert, ‘‘A Study of Cartel Stability: The Joint Executive Committee,’’ Bell Journal of Economics 8 (1983), 301–314.

Stanley, Ken, ‘‘Balance of Payments Deficits and Subsidies in International Telecommunications: A New Challenge to Regulation,’’ Administrative Law Review 43 (1991), 411–438.

Sullivan, Daniel, ‘‘Testing Hypotheses about Firm Behavior in the Cigarette Industry,’’ Journal of Political Economy 93 (1985), 586–598.

TeleGeography, Inc., TeleGeography 1995: Global Telecommunications Traffıc Statistics and Commentary (Washington: TeleGeography, 1995).

World Bank, 1997 World Development Indicators (Washington: World Bank, 1997).

World Tourism Organisation, Yearbook of Tourism Statistics, Vol. 2, 49 ed., (Madrid:World Tourism Organisation, 1997).

WTO, The Agreement on Basic Telecommunications Services (Geneva: WTO Publications Service, February 15, 1997).

Yun, Kyoung Lim, Hyun Woo Choi, and Byong Hun Ahn, ‘‘The Accounting Revenue Division in International Telecommunications: Conflicts and Inefficiencies,’’ Information Economics and Policy 9 (1997), 71–92.