The Bitter Taste of Strawberry Jam: Distortions on Romanian Labour Market beyond 2007

Silasi, Grigore and Simina, Ovidiu Laurian (2007): The Bitter Taste of Strawberry Jam: Distortions on Romanian Labour Market beyond 2007.

Abstract

The paper is a contribution at the scientific debate of migration and mobility issues in the context of an enlarged European Union (EU-27). We consider that Romania, a country with a labour market that faces distortions, will benefit from migration on short term, but will need to import labour force in order to maintain the development trend. Remittances, as result of Romanians emigration after 2002, helped the economic development of the country in the last years (remittances’ inflow doubled the FDI). As a response to the media debate regarding Romania’s emigration, we consider that the fear of mass migration from Romania following the year 2007 is not justified. While the European (and mostly British) media cries on the threat of Bulgarians and Romanians’ emigration, as following to the 2007 accession, the scientific reports say that the A8 countries’ migration benefits to economy of the EU15 countries. In the same time, the Romanian media and the Romanian entrepreneurs announce the ‘Chinese invasion’ and the lack of labour in construction, industry and even agriculture. We see labour as goods: the economic theory say that goods are moving with the prices, the highest price attracts (more) goods. Romania is not only a gateway for the East-West international migration (like Portugal, Spain, Italy and Greece for the South-North direction), but a labour market in need of workers. While a big part of the labour force is already migrated, mostly to the SE Europe (some 2.5m workers are cited to be abroad, with both legal and illegal/irregular status), the Romanian companies could not find local workers to use them in order to benefit from the money inflow targeting Romania in the light of its new membership to the European Union (foreign investments and European post accession funds). Instead of increasing the salaries, the local employers rather prefer to ‘import’ workers from poorer countries (Chinese, Moldavians, Ukrainians, who still accept a lower wage as compared to the medium wage in Romania, but bigger enough as compared to those from their country of origin). The paper concludes with the case of the Banat region, considered the ‘Western Europe’ from Romania, as a small scale model for the labour market relations within the whole EU.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: labour migration, labour market distortions, South-Eastern Europe Syndrome, network effect, decision making, motivation, need for esteem, Banat region
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F2 - International Factor Movements and International Business > F22 - International Migration; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J61 - Geographic Labor Mobility ; Immigrant Workers; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R2 - Household Analysis > R23 - Regional Migration ; Regional Labor Markets ; Population ; Neighborhood Characteristics

References

Agunias, Dovelyn Rannveig (2006): From a Zero-Sum to a Win-Win Scenario? Literature Review on Circular Migration, Migration Policy Institute, Migration Information Source, September, available from www.migrationpolicy.org/pubs/CircularMigrationLitReview_9.06_DAgunias.pdf

ANBCC (2005), Romanians and Labour Force Migration in the European Union, Romanian National Association of Citizens Advice Bureaux, December

Berkeley, Rob, Omar Khan and Mohan Ambikaipaker (2006): What’s new about new immigrants in twenty-first century Britain?, Joseph Rowntree Foundation, York: York Publishing Services

Bruder, Jana (2003): East-West Migration in Europe 2004 – 2015. University of Rostock, Institut für Volkswirtschaftslehre, Thünen-Series of Applied Economic Theory, Working Paper no.40

Ciutacu, Constantin (2006): Growing Concern over Labour Shortage Due to Migration, European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions, Dublin, available at (29.11.2006): www.eurofound.europa.eu/eiro/2006/11/articles/ro0611049i.html

CNTR (2006): Flux migratoires en provenance des nouveaux Etats membres de l’Union Européenne vers la Belgique. Rapport d’analyse, Centre pour l’Egalite de Chances et la Lutte Conte le Racisme, Brussels, February 24

COM (2006): The Demographic Future of Europe – from Challenge to Opportunity, European Commission, Commission Communication COM(2006) 571 final, Brussels, October 12

COM (2005): Green Paper on an EU Approach to Managing Economic Migration, European Commission, COM(2004) 811 final, Brussels, 11.01.2005

Constantin, Daniela Luminita et al (2004): The Migration Phenomenon from the Perspective of Romania’s Accession to the European Union, Pre-Accession Impact Studies II, Study no.5, Bucharest: The European Institute of Romania

Constantinescu, Monica (2003): International Circular Migration to Spain – A Case Study, conference paper at “Globalization, Integration and Social Development in Central and Eastern Europe. A Round Table for Young Social Scientist from CEE Region”, Lucian Blaga University of Sibiu, Romania, 6-8 September 2003, retrieved from: www.iccv.ro/romana/conf/conf.sibiu.2003/pdf/18.%20monica%20constantinescu.pdf

DilemaVeche (2006): Munca de export (Labour for Export), supplement of Dilema Veche, Year III, No.133, 11-17 August 2006, Bucharest, pp 9-12 [in Romanian]

ECAS (2006a): Report on the Free Movement of Workers in EU-25: The Functional Arrangement – Two Years after Enlargement”, Brussels: European Citizen Action Service, July

ECAS (2006b): Report on the Free Movement of Workers in EU-25: Who’s Still Afraid of EU Enlargement, European Citizen Action Service, October

ECAS (2005): Report on the Free Movement of Workers in EU-25: Who’s Afraid of EU Enlargement?, European Citizen Action Service, September

Euwals, Rob and Ate Nieuwenhuis (2003): Immigration and the Labour Market, CPB Netherlands Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis, CPB Report 2003/2

Fidrmuc, Jan (2002): Migration and Regional Adjustment to Asymmetric Shocks in Transition Economies, CPB Netherlands Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis, CPB Discussion Paper No 007, July

Ghosh, Bimal (2005): Economic Effects of International Migration: A Synoptic Overview, in World Migration 2005. Costs and Benefits of International Migration, Volume 3 – IOM World Migration Report Series, Geneva: International Organisation for Migration, pp.163-183

Gilpin, Nicola et al (2006): The Impact of Free Movement of Workers from Central and Eastern Europe on the UK Labour Market, Department for Work and Pensions, Working Papers No.29

Ilie, L (2006): Banii trimisi din străinatate – fenomen social [Remittances send from abroad – social phenomenon], EurActiv.ro, July 17 [in Romanian], available from: www.euractiv.ro/uniunea-europeana/articles|displayArticle/articleID_7456/Banii-trimisi-din-strainatate-fenomen-social.html

IOM (2006): Global Labour Mobility: A Catalyst for Development, IOM Policy Focus, Geneva, September

ippr (2006a): EU Enlargement: Bulgaria and Romania - Migration Implication for the UK, Institute for Public Research, ippr FactFile, April 25

ippr (2006b): Irregular Migration in the UK, Institute for Public Research, ippr FactFile, March 31

ippr (2005): Selecting Wisely: Making managed migration work for Britain, Institute for Public Research, November 27 Krieger, Hubert (2005): Who Is Going Where? Migration Trends in the EU Context, European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions, Dublin, April; conference paper at SIPTU National Women’s Forum, Tralee, 22-24 April 2005, available from: www.eurofound.europa.eu/docs/areas/populationandsociety/Kriegen05042.pdf

Krieger, Hubert (2004): Migration Trends In An Enlarged Europe, European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions, Dublin, 2004 – VIII, Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, EF/03/109/EN, available from: www.eurofound.europa.eu/pubdocs/2003/109/en/1/ef03109en.pdf

Lazaroiu, Sebastian (2004): More ‘Out’ than ‘In’ at the Crossroads between Europe and the Balkans, in Migration Trends in Selected Applicant Countries, Volume IV - Romania, Vienna: International Organization for Migration

Maddison, Angus (2002): The West and the Rest in the International Economic Order, OECD Observer, no. 235, Paris: OECD

NBER (2006): Economic Progress of Immigrants, National Bureau of Economic Research, The NBER Digest, May

OECD (2006): International Migration Outlook. Annual Report [Sopemi] 2006 Edition, Paris: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development; retrieved from http://www.sourceoecd.org/926403627X

Piracha, Matloob and Roger Vickerman (2001): Immigration, Labour Mobility and EU Enlargement, ESRC One Europe or several? Programme: Borders, Migration and Labour Market Dynamics in Europe, UK Economic and Social Research Council, Grant No L213252042, available at: www.kent.ac.uk/economics/research/1europe/RIIAChapter-final.pdf

Portes, Jonathan and Simon French (2005): The Impact of Free Movement of Workers from Central and Eastern Europe on the UK Labour Market: Early Evidence, Department for Work and Pensions Working Papers No.18, London: Department for Work and Pensions

Potot, Swanie (2000): Mobilité en Europe. Etude de Deux Réseaux Migratoires Roumains, in Sociologie Romanească [Romanian Sociology] 2, pp. 97-115 [in French], retrieved from www.sociologieromaneasc.ro/2000/articole/sr2000.2-a5.pdf

Reichlová, Natálie (2005): Can the Theory of Motivation Explain Migration Decisions?, Charles University Prague, Faculty of Social Sciences, Institute of Economic Studies, IES Working Papers UK FSV-IES No.97, Prague, retrieved from (20.10.2006) http://ies.fsv.cuni.cz/storage/publication/686_wp_97_reichlova.pdf

Reichlová, Natálie (2004): New Member Countries and Migration Flows, Diplomová Práce [Master thesis], Univerzita Karlova v Praze, Fakulta sociálních ved, Institut ekonomických studií, retrieved from (12.11.2006) http://ies.fsv.cuni.cz/storage/user/121_reichlova-dp.pdf

Saleheen, Jumana and Chris Shadforth (2006): The Economic Characteristics of Immigrants and Their Impact on Supply, Bank of England, Quarterly Bulletin 2006 Q4, pp.372-385

Salt, John (2006): Current Trends in International Migration in Europe. Consultant’s Report to the Council of Europe, March 2006, Council of Europe, European Committee on Migration (CDMG), 51st meeting, 19-21 April 2006, Strasbourg; CDMG(2006) 22e, March 15

Sandu, Dumitru et al (2004): A Country Report of Romanian Migration Abroad: Stocks and Flows after 1989, Multicultural Centre Prague, migrationonline.cz, retrieved from: http://aa.ecn.cz/img_upload/f76c21488a048c95bc0a5f12deece153/RomanianMigrationAbroad.pdf

Sandu, Dumitru (2000a): Migratia circulatorie ca strategie de viata, in Sociologie Româneasca 2, pp.5-29 [in Romanian], available from: www.sociologieromaneasca.ro/2000/articole/sr2000.2-a1.pdf. English version available as Circulatory Migration as Life Strategy, in Sociologie Românească / Romanian Sociology – Annual English Electronic Edition – issue 2 (2000), from: www.sociologieromaneasca.ro/eng/aeee-pdf/sr-rs.aeee.2000.5.pdf

Sandu, Dumitru (2000b): Migratia transnationala a românilor din perspectiva unui recesamânt comunitar [The Romanian Transnational Migration from the Perspective of a Communitary Census], in Sociologie Românească [Romanian Sociology] 3-4, pp.5-52, available on-line from: www.sociologieromaneasca.ro/2000/articole/sr2000.3+4-a1.pdf

Sandu, Dumitru (1985): Fluxurile de migratie în România [Migratory Flows in Romania], Bucharest: Editura Academiei; [in Romanian] available on-line from: http://193.231.1.3/mod/resource/view.php?id=334&subdir=/Fluxurile_de_migratie_in_Romania

Schiff, Maurice (2006): Migration, Trade and Investment: Complements or Substitutes?, Centre for International Studies on Economic Growth, CEIS Tor Vergata Research Paper Series, Vol.30, No.89, November; available at: http://pappers.ssrn.com/paper.taf?abstract_id=944458

Silasi, Grigore et al (2005): Migration and Foreign Direct Investments: Substitutes or Complements?, West University of Timisoara, Jean Monnet European Centre of Excellence, SISEC Discussion Papers vol.2 No.9, December

Simina, Ovidiu Laurian (2005): Next in Line - Romanians at the Gates of the EU (Emigrants, Border Control, Legislation) in Koźluk T (ed.): The 4th International Immigration Conference, Independent University of Business and Administration, Warsaw: PWSBiA, pp 115-167

Simina, Ovidiu Laurian (2004): Inequality and Poverty in the EU and the Accession Countries from Central and Eastern Europe. The Implications of Migration. The Case of Romania, in Tadeusz Koźluk (ed.): International Immigration and Naturalization Conference (2003), pp. 249-270, Warsaw: PWSBiA

Simina, Ovidiu Laurian (2003): Migration – Fake or Threat? It Is Romania a Real Risk for the European Space After the Enlargement Process, as Source for European Migration?, in Lehoczy, L and Kalmár, L (eds.): 4th International Conference of PhD Students, Volume „Economics 2”, Miskolc: Miskolci Egyetem, pp 439 – 446

Simina, Ovidiu Laurian (2002): Romania – Source Country and Transit Country for International Migration, UNU/WIDER Conference on Poverty, International Migration and Asylum, Helsinki, September; on-line: www.wider.unu.edu/conference/conference-2002-3/conference2002-3.htm, published as SISEC Discussion Papers vol.1 no.1, October 2002, West University of Timisoara

Strielkowski, Wadim and Cathal O’Donoghue (2004): The Impact of the EU accession on international labour migration, Charles University, Faculty of Social Sciences, Institute of Economic Studies, Jean Monnet Workshop, Prague, September; retrieved from (12.10.2006) http://ies.fsv.cuni.cz/storage/user/117_jmw2004phdr.wadimstrielkowskipaper.pdf

Serban, Monica and Vlad Grigoraş (2000): The „Dogenii” from Teleorman in Romania and Abroad. A Study on Circular Migration to Spain, in Sociologie Românească/Romanian Sociology – Annual English Electronic Edition – Issue 2 (2000), available on line from http://www.sociologieromaneasca.ro/eng/aeee-pdf/sr-rs.aeee.2000.5.pdf

van Krieken, Peter J. (2005): A Shoe Factory and Migratory Movement in Eleven Paragraphs, in Pop, L. and C. Matiuta (eds.): European Identity and Free Movement of Persons, University of Oradea Publishing House, 2005, pp 112-118 van Krieken, Peter J. (2004): A need to reinvent the wheel?, European Population Forum 2004, Geneva, February 12 -14, retrieve from (15.07.2005): http://www.unece.org/ead/pau/epf/present/ts4/vankrieken.pdf

Whittal, Michael (2006): Report of Mobility Highlights Economic Benefits of Migrant Labour, European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions, Dublin, available at (29.10.2006): www.eurofound.europa.eu/eiro/2006/09/articles/eu0609029i.html

Williamson, Jeffrey G. (1998): The Economics of Mass Migrations, National Bureau of Economic Research, NBER Research Summary, Summer

Zaiceva, Anzelika (2006): Reconciling the Estimates of Potential Migration into the Enlarged European Union, Institute for the Study of Labor, IZA Discussion Paper No.2519, December