Distributional analysis of prospective 2009 US individual income taxes: current law and the candidates’ tax plans

Berliant, Marcus and Strauss, Robert P. (2008): Distributional analysis of prospective 2009 US individual income taxes: current law and the candidates’ tax plans.

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to compare the distributional characteristics of two presidential candidates’ proposed reforms to the US federal individual income tax. Using an anonymous sample of tax return data from the Brookings-Urban Institute Tax Policy Center and the Center’s simulations of 2009 tax law and the two proposals, we compare the vertical and horizontal equity of the three individual income tax regimes. Surprisingly, there is very little difference among the three proposed individual income tax regimes in terms of vertical and horizontal equity. However, when the initial effective tax rate positions and economic incomes of each pair of taxpayers are compared to the new effective tax rate positions under the two proposals, we find that the Obama proposal makes the tax system more progressive than 2009 law. This change is much more pronounced than under the McCain proposal. On the other hand, when these initial positions are compared to the two proposals viz. a viz. horizontal equity, the McCain proposed tax system is more horizontally equitable than 2009 tax law, and more horizontally equitable than the Obama proposal is when compared to 2009 tax law.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Tax equity; McCain tax plan; Obama tax plan
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D3 - Distribution > D31 - Personal Income, Wealth, and Their Distributions; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H24 - Personal Income and Other Nonbusiness Taxes and Subsidies

References

Aronson, J. R., P. Johnson, and P.J. Lambert, "Redistribute Effect and Unequal Income Tax Treatment," The Economic Journal, 104, 262-270.

Aronson, J.R. and P.J. Lambert, "Decomposing the Gini Coefficient to Reveal the Vertical, Horizontal and Reranking Effects of Income Taxation," National Tax Journal, 47, 273-294.

Atkinson, A.B. (1970), "On the Measurement of Inequality," Journal of Economic Theory, 2, 244-63.

Atkinson, A.B. (1980), "Horizontal Equity and the Distribution of the Tax Burden," in H.

Aaron and M. J. Boskin, eds., The Economics of Taxation, (Washington, D.C.: The Brookings Institution).

Berliant, M.C. and R.P. Strauss (1983), "Measuring the Distribution of Personal Taxes," in R. Zeckhauser and D. Leebaert, eds., What Role for Government? Lessons from Policy Research, (Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press), 97-115.

Berliant, M.C. and R.P. Strauss (1985), "The Vertical and Horizontal Equity Characteristics of the Federal Individual Income Tax," in David and Smeeding (editors), Horizontal Equity, Uncertainty, and Economic Well-being: Proceedings of the 1983 NBER Conference on Income and Wealth, (Chicago: University of Chicago Press).

Berliant, M.C. and R.P. Strauss (1993), "State and Federal Tax Equity: Estimates Before and After the Tax Reform Act of 1986," Journal of Public Policy Analysis and Management, 12, 1 (February), 9-43.

Berliant, M.C. and R.P. Strauss (1996), "On Recent Expositions on Horizontal Equity," Public Economics Review, 1, 1 (Spring, 1996), 129-150.

Blackorby, C. and D. Donaldson (1978), "Measures of Relative Equality and Their Meaning in terms of Social Welfare," Journal of Economic Theory, 18, 59-80.

Blackorby, C. and D. Donaldson (1980), "A Theoretical Treatment of Indices of Absolute Inequality," International Economic Review, 21, 107-136.

Bourguignon, F. (1979), "Decomposable Income Inequality Measures," Econometrica, 47, 4, 901-920.

Burtless, G. (1990), "Earnings Inequality over the Business and Demographic Cycles," in Gary Burtless, ed., A Future of Lousy Jobs?, (Washington, D.C.: Brookings), 77-117.

Clotfelter, C. (1984), "Tax Cut Meets Bracket Creep: The Rise and Fall of Marginal Tax Rates, 1965-1984," Public Finance Quarterly, 12, 131-52.

Cowell, F. and K. Kuga (1981a), "Inequality Measurement: An Axiomatic Approach," European Economic Review, 15, 287-305.

Cowell, F. and K. Kuga (1981b), "Additivity and the Entropy Concept: An Axiomatic Approach to Inequality Measurement," Journal of Economic Theory, 25, 131-143.

Dalton, H. (1925). Inequality of Incomes, London.

Ebert, U. (1987), "Size and Distribution of Incomes as Determinants of Social Welfare," Journal of Economic Theory, 41, 23-33.

Feldstein, M. (1976), "On the Theory of Tax Reform," Journal of Public Economics, 6, 1-2, 77-104.

Fields, G. S. and J. C. H. Fei (1978), "On Inequality Comparisons," Econometrica, 46, 2 (March), 303-316.

Formby, J.P. and D. Sykes (1984), "State Income Tax Progressivity," Public Finance Quarterly, 12, 2 (April), 153-65.

Gouveia, M. and R. P. Strauss (1994), "Effective Federal Tax Functions: An Exploratory Empirical Analysis," National Tax Journal, 47, 2 (June), 317-340.

Gramlich, E., R. Kasten, and F. Sammartino (1991), "Growing Inequality in the 1980's: The Role of Federal Taxes and Cash Transfers," in Uneven Tides: Rising Inequality in the 1980's ed. by S. Danziger and P. Gottschalk, Russell Sage.

Hagenaars, A. (1987), "A Class of Poverty Indices," International Economic Review, 28, 3, 583-607.

Jenkins, S. P. (1988), "Empirical Measurement of Horizontal Equity," Journal of Public Economics, 37, 3, 305-330.

Kakwani, N. (1977), "Measurement of Tax Progressivity: An International Comparison," The Economic Journal, 71-80.

Kaplow, L. (1989), "Horizontal Equity: Measures in Search of a Principle," National Tax Journal, 42, 2, 139-154.

Kendall, M. (1947), The Advanced Theory of Statistics, London: Griffin and Co.

Kern, B. B. (1990), "The Tax Reform Act of 1986 and the Progressivity of the Individual Income Tax," Public Finance Quarterly, 18, 3, 259-272.

Kiefer, D. W. (1984), "Distributional Tax Progressivity Indexes," National Tax Journal, 37, 4 (December), 487-514.

Kiefer, D. W. and S. Nelson (1986), "Distributional Effects of Federal Tax Reform," National Tax Association-Tax Institute of America Proceedings of the 79th Annual Conference, (Hartford, Connecticut).

King, M. A. (1983), "An Index of Inequality: with Applications to Horizontal Equity and Social Mobility," Econometrica, 51, 1, 99-115.

Kolm, S.C. (1976), "Unequal Inequalities," Journal of Economic Theory, 12/13, 82-112.

Kondor, Y. (1975), "Value Judgments Implied by the Use of Various Measures of Income Inequality," Review of Income and Wealth, 21, 309-321.

Lambert, Peter J. (1993), The Distribution and Redistribution of Income: A Mathematical Analysis. Second Edition, Manchester University Press, Manchester.

Lin, Sheila (1989), Revenue and Equity in Income Taxation, unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Rochester.

Michel, R. (1991), "Economic Growth and Income Equality Since the 1982 Recession," Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 2, 10, 181-203.

Musgrave, R. A. (1990), "Horizontal Equity, Once More," National Tax Journal, 42, 2, 139-154.

Musgrave, R. A. and P. B. Musgrave (1989), Public Finance in Theory and Practice, McGraw-Hill, fifth edition.

Musgrave, R. A. and T. Thin (1948), "Income Tax Progression, 1928 - 1948," Journal of Political Economy, 56, 6, 498-514.

Pfingsten, A. (1986), The Measurement of Tax Progression, Berlin: Springer-Verlag.

Plotnick, R. (1981), "A Measure of Horizontal Inequity," Review of Economics and Statistics, 63, 2, 283-288.

Plotnick, R. (1982), "The Concept and Measurement of Horizontal Equity," Journal of Public Economics, 17, 373-391.

Pyatt, G. (1976), "On the Interpretation and Disaggregation of the Gini Coefficient," Economic Journal, 86, 243-255.

Shorrocks, A.F. (1980), "The Class of Additively Decomposable Inequality Measures," Econometrica, 48, 613-625.

Shorrocks, A.F. (1984), "Inequality Decomposition by Population Subgroups," Econometrica, 52, 1369-1385.

Shorrocks, A.F. and J.E. Foster (1987), "Transfer Sensitive Inequality Measures," Review of Economic Studies, 54, 485-497.

Stodder, James (1991), "Equity-Efficiency Preferences in Poland and The Soviet Union: Order Reversals under the Atkinson Index," Review of Income and Wealth, 37, 3(September, 1991), 287-297.

Suits, D. (1977), "Measurement of Tax Progressivity," American Economic Review, 67, 4 (September), 747-752.

Theil, H. (1967), Economics and Information Theory, Amsterdam: North - Holland.

Thon, D. (1972), "An Axiomatization of the Gini Coefficient," Mathematical Social Sciences, 2, 131-43.

Thon, D. (1979), "On Measuring Poverty," Review of Income and Wealth, 25, 429-39. U.S. Department of Treasury, Internal Revenue Service. (1966-77). Statistics of Income: Individual Income Tax Returns. (Washington, D.C.: GPO).

Wertz, K.L. (1975), "Empirical Studies of Tax Burdens: Design and Interpretation," Proceedings of the National Tax Association, Houston, 115-22.

Wertz, K.L. (1978), "A Method of Measuring the Relative Taxation of Families," Review of Economics and Statistics, 60, 1 (February), 145-60.