Elective social insurance systems in developing East and South-East Asian countries

Cousins, Mel (2022): Elective social insurance systems in developing East and South-East Asian countries.

Abstract

Expanding social protection coverage is a key policy issue in many developing countries and social insurance schemes form one important mechanism for achieving this. Normally social insurance systems are described as ‘mandatory’ or, alternatively, as ‘voluntary’ i.e whether the targeted workers should be obliged to join or should have a choice as to joining the scheme or not. In the case of many developing countries, participation in social insurance is, in theory, mandatory for those within the scope of the relevant legislation as participation is required by law and non-participation is subject to legal penalties. However, in many such countries, there is a limited expectation that the law will be enforced and no expectation that all employers and employees subject to the law will actually be covered. Such systems might better be called ‘elective’ as they depend on the decision (‘election’) of various key stakeholders to participate or to require participation. Thus, the government must decide to enforce participation; relevant ministries and agencies must have a political mandate (in addition to the formal legal mandate) to enforce the law and the capacity to do so; and employers and employees must also decide to participate and to pay contributions. In order to support enforcement of the law in such elective systems, it is necessary to engage with all these different key stakeholders, i.e. government, enforcement agencies, employers and employees (and of course employer and employee representative organisations). This paper suggests that while many existing studies have correctly identified factors relation to non-enforcement (or partial enforcement) of mandatory coverage, they have incorrectly assumed that such lack of implementation is due to a failure to enforce rather than a decision not do so. Therefore, measures to improve enforcement have focussed on ‘technical’ issues such as capacity and information. While these are important factors, it is argued that the political economy reasons why states and employers elect not to enforce the law needs to be recognised and such enforcement measures need to be set in the appropriate policy context.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Social insurance; social protection; political economy; Eat Asia, South-east Asia, China
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H55 - Social Security and Public Pensions; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I38 - Government Policy ; Provision and Effects of Welfare Programs

References

Baldwin, Peter, 1990. The Politics of Social Solidarity: Class Bases of the European Welfare State, 1875-1975 Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Beck, Hermann. 1995. The Origins of the Authoritarian Welfare State in Prussia: Conservatives, Bureaucracy, and the Social Question, 1815-70. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

Better Work. 2017. Annual Report 2017: An Industry and Compliance Review – Indonesia. Geneva: ILO.

Bowen, Thomas, Carlo del Ninno, Colin Andrews, Sarah Coll-Black, Ugo Gentilini, Kelly Johnson, Yasuhiro Kawasoe, Adea Kryeziu, Barry Maher, and Asha Williams. 2020. Adaptive Social Protection: Building Resilience to Shocks. International Development in Focus. Washington, DC: World Bank.

Castel, Paulette and Alexander Pick. 2018. Increasing social insurance coverage in Viet Nam’s SMEs. Paris: OECD.

Juan Chen and Mary Gallagher. 2013. ‘Urban Social Insurance Provision: Regional and Workplace Variations’ in Douglas Besharov and Karen Baehler (eds). Chinese Social Policy at a Time of Transition. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 86-100

Asif Bin Farooq, Making Welfare Work for Autocracy: Wealth, Will & Woes in the Politics of Welfare in China, 2021, University of Toronto

Fritz, Verena; Levy, Brian; Ort, Rachel. (eds) 2014. Problem-Driven Political Economy Analysis: The World Bank's Experience, Washington, DC: World Bank.

Gao, Qin and Johanna Rickne. 2015. ‘Inequality in Social Insurance Participation and Generosity: Do Firm Characteristics Matter?’ Social Policy & Administration, Volume 51, Issue 5, p. 755-775

Giles, John. Dewen Wang, Albert Park. 2013. Expanding Social Insurance Coverage in Urban China. Washington, DC: World Bank.

Guo, Yu. 2016 Processes and activities of policy transmission and implementation carried out at central and local levels of Social Assistance. Beijing: EU-China Social Protection Reform Project.

Huang, & Gao, Q. 2018. ‘Does social insurance enrollment improve citizen assessment of local government performance? Evidence from China’. Social Science Research Vol. 70, pp. 28–40

In Hyee HWANG, 2018. Managing the Threat to Social Stability: Authoritarian Survival through Selective Welfare Provision in China, PhD, University of Chicago

ILO, 2017. Operational Review of the Cambodian National Social Security Fund. ILO available at https://www.social-protection.org/gimi/gess/ShowRessource.action;jsessionid=5xFlp8Wy1XMDvitfH0XzpqoXxxSk7IjM4etR5W9LUO3pxPU2xLyg!318093981?lang=EN&id=55154

ILO. 2019. Extending social security to workers in the informal economy: Lessons from international experience. Geneva: ILO.

Jiang, J., Qian, J., & Wen, Z. (2018). ‘Social protection for the informal sector in urban China: institutional constraints and self-selection behaviour’. Journal of Social Policy, 47(2), 335 335-357 .

Sabina Lawreniuk & Veasna Nuon, 2022. Social Protection for The Apparel Industry in Cambodia: Gaps and Opportunities. Prohm Penh: Oxfam Cambodia.

Lieberthal, Kenneth G., and David M. Lampton, editors Bureaucracy, Politics, and Decision Making in Post-Mao China. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1992

Jing Lin, Social Security under Decentralized Authoritarianism: Politics of The Public Pension Program in China, 2017, PhD, Syracuse University

Yang Luo, Social Insurance for Rural Urban Migrant Workers in China: Regional Disparities, PhD, 2019, University of Sheffield

Pushkar Maitra, Russell Smyth, Ingrid Nielsen, Chris Nyland and Cherrie Zhu, 2007. "Firm Compliance with Social Insurance Obligations Where There Is a Weak Surveillance and Enforcement Mechanism: Empirical Evidence from Shanghai," Pacific Economic Review, Wiley Blackwell, vol. 12(5), pages 577-596

Belinda S. Mandigma, 2016. ‘Determinants of Social Insurance Coverage in the Philippines’ International Journal of Social Science and Humanity, Vol. 6, No. 9, pp 660-666

Mares, Isabella. 2003. ‘The Sources of Business Interest in Social Insurance: Sectoral versus National Differences’ World Politics, Volume 55, Issue 2, January 2003, pp. 229 – 258.

Ka Ho Mok & Xiao Fang Wu (2013) ‘Dual decentralization in China's transitional economy: Welfare regionalism and policy implications for central–local relationship’, Policy and Society, 32:1, 61-75

Catharina Nawangpalupi. 2019. Social security gap in the coffee sector in Indonesia. Geneva: ILO.

Ngo Thi Nhung, Duong Thi Cam Nhung, Nguyen Hai Khanh, 2021. ‘Implementation of Social Insurance Policy: Research in Thai Nguyen Province, Viet Nam’ European Journal of Research in Social Sciences Vol. 9 No. 2, pp. 56-64.

Ingrid Nielsen, Russell Smyth, 2008. ‘Who bears the burden of employer compliance with social security contributions? Evidence from Chinese firm level data’, China Economic Review, Volume 19, Issue 2, Pages 230-244,

NSSF, 2021. Report on Annual Achievements 2020 and Action Plans of the National Social Security Fund. Phnom Penh: NSSF.

Chris Nyland, Russell Smyth and Cherrie Jiuhua Zhu. 2006. ‘What Determines the Extent to Which Employers Will Comply with Their Social Security Obligations? Evidence from Chinese Firm Level Data’. Social Policy & Administration 40(2):196 – 214.

Jiwei Qian and Zhuoyi Wen. 2021. ‘Extension of social insurance coverage to informal economy workers in China: An administrative and institutional perspective’. International Social Security Review, Vol. 74, 1/2021, pp. 79-102

Qu Xiaobo, 2018. ‘Effectiveness of China's Labor Contract Law- Evidence from China Employer-Employee Survey’ China Economist; Vol. 13, Iss. 5, 116-126.

Johanna Rickne. 2013. ‘Labor Market Conditions and Social Insurance in China’. China Economic Review, Volume 27, December 2013, Pages 52-68.

Pratan Thavorn, Suriyan Nontasak, Chalong Tubsree, 2013. ‘The Extension of Social Insurance Coverage to Informal workers’ Vol. 4 (1), 123-130.

Trieu, Huong T., Building a Welfare State: A Case Study of Rural Migrant Medical Insurance in Urban China. University of Michigan, 2013

Yan Wang, Social Policy, State Legitimacy and Strategic Actors: Governmentality and Counter-conduct in Authoritarian Regime, 2020, PhD, London School of Economics

Yuan Wang, Understanding the implementation gap of China’s urban pension scheme at the level of rural-urban migrant workers, PhD, 2016, University of Queensland

Nada Wasi, Chinnawat Devahastin Na Ayudhya, Pucktada Treeratpituk, and Chommanart Nittayo, 2021. Understanding a Less Developed Labor Market through the Lens of Social Security data. Puey Ungphakorn Institute for Economic Research (PIER), Discussion Paper No. 147.

Wu Xiaofang, Welfare regionalism in China: A study of social insurance implementation in Wenzhou and Kunshan, PhD, 2013, Educational University of Hong Kong

Wu Yuling and Hong Xiao. 2018. ‘Social insurance participation among rural migrants in reform era China’ Asian and Pacific Migration Journal, Volume: 27 issue: 4, page(s): 383-403.

Yujeong Yang, Politics of Inclusion and Exclusion: Dual Pension Regimes in China, PhD, 2018, University of Michigan

Yujeong Yang, 2020. "The Politics of Inclusion and Exclusion: Chinese Dual-Pension Regimes in the Era of Labor Migration and Labor Informalization." Politics & Society, Vol 49, Issue 2, 2021, pp. 147-180

Yujeong Yang, 2021. ‘"Towards an Inclusive System for Informal Workers? Diverging Impacts of Labor Informality on Chinese Workers' Pension Enrollment.", International Journal of Social Welfare, Online First.

Yang, Wenhui, and Xiaoxiao Shen. 2020. “Can Social Welfare Buy Mass Loyalty?” Governance 34.4 1213–1233.

Ye, Jing and Shu Keng, ‘Development Paths, Government-Business Relations and Local Social Security Systems: A Comparison of Two Cities in China’, China An International Journal 13(2):67-87

Randong Yuan, Financial Sustainability of the Pension System in China: Impact of Fragmented Administration and Population Ageing, PhD, 2020, University of Melbourne

Zhou, H., Zhu, L. (2019). “Two Chinas”: Social Equity, Social Policies, and the Urban-Rural Divide in China. In: Johansen, M. (eds) Social Equity in the Asia-Pacific Region. Palgrave Macmillan