Impacts of Bolsa Familia Program on multidimensional poverty

Ciula, Raffaele (2022): Impacts of Bolsa Familia Program on multidimensional poverty.

Abstract

Usually conditional cash transfer programs (CCTs) are interpreted as passive policies dealing with income maintenance, and needs fulfilment, however, recently some part of the literature has suggested a more active role for them. The aim of this article is to investigate the inclusive role of human rights-based CCTs, using Bolsa Familia (BF) policy as a case study. Specifically, I assess the effect of this program on human development as a proxi of achievements in fundamental capabilities and human rights. I choose this type of development because, compared to economic development, it puts at the centre of the analysis human life quality. In order to infer some causal relation between BF and human development I use the systematic review approach, based on natural, quasi-experimental, counterfactual, and longitudinal analysis. The main findings suggest some positive effect of the BF and human development. Hence, BF can be interpreted as human rights-oriented policy, which is able to create social inclusion in fundamental domains to some extent. The main policy implications deal with integrating BF with the education, and the health system as well as with complementary interventions more tightly, to ameliorate the advancement in human rights level.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Bolsa Familia, Capability, Human Rights, Multidimensional Poverty, Poverty Intensity
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H53 - Government Expenditures and Welfare Programs; H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H55 - Social Security and Public Pensions

References

Ahmad, E., Drèze, J.P., Hills, J., & Sen A. (eds), (1991). Social Security in Developing Countries. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Alkire, S. & Foster, J. (2007). Counting and Multidimensional Poverty Measurement. OPHI Working Paper 7, University of Oxford.

Alkire, S., Foster, J., Suman, S., Santos, M. Roche, J. & Ballon, P. (2015). Multidimensional Poverty Measurement and Analysis. Oxford University Press.

Alkire, S., Kanagaratnam, U. & Suppa, N. (2020). The Global Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI) 2020. OPHI MPI METHODOLOGICAL NOTE 49.

Amaral, E., Goncalves, G. & Weiss, C. (2014). The impact of Brazil's Bolsa Familia Program on School Attendance, Age-Grade Discrepancy, and Child Labour. Journal of Social Science for Policy Implications, Vol. 2, No. 1, pp. 101-125.

Andrade, M. V., Chein, F., de Souza, L. R. & Puig-Junoy, J. (2012). Income transfer policies and the impacts on the immunization of children: the Bolsa Familia Program. Cad. Saude Publica, 28(7): 1347-1358.

Barbosa, A. & Corseuil, C. (2014). Bolsa Familia, Occupational Choice and Informality in Brazil. In Campello, T. & Neri, M. (eds): Bolsa Familia Program: A Decade of Social Inclusion in Brazil. Ipea.

Barrientos, A., Debowicza, D. & Woolard, I. (2016). Heterogeneity in Bolsa Família outcomes. The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 62, 33-40.

Bastagli, F. (2006). The design, implementation and impact of conditional cash transfers targeted on the poor: an evaluation of Brazil's Bolsa Familia (unpublished doctoral dissertation). London School of Economics and Political Science, London, U.K. .

Becker, S. & Hvide, H. (2013). Do Entrepreneurs Matter? IZA Discussion Paper, No 7146.

Bohn, S., Veiga, L. F., Da Dalt, S., Brandao, A. & Gouvea, V. (2014). Can conditional cash transfer programs generate equality of opportunity in highly unequal societies? Evidence from Brazil. Revista de Sociologia e Politica, vol. 22, n. 51, p. 111-133

Bosch, M. & Manacorda, M. (2012). Social Policies and Labor Market Outcomes in Latin America and the Caribbean: A Review of the Existing Evidence. Center for Economic Performance, Occasional Paper, n. 32.

Burchardt, T. & Vizard, P. (2011). 'Operationalizing' the Capability Approach as a Basis for Equality and Human Rights Monitoring in Twenty-first-century Britain. Journal of Human Development and Capabilities: A Multidisciplinary Journal for People-Centered Development, 12:1, 91-119.

Caliendo, M. & Kopeinig, S. (2005). Some Practical Guidance for the Implementation of Propensity Score Matching, IZA Discussion Paper, n. 1588.

Cecchini, S., Filgueira, F., Rossel, C. & Brain, I. (2015). Towards universal social protection. Latin American pathways and policy tools. Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC).

CGAP (2011). Brazil Country Report.

Chitolina, L., Foguel, M. N. & Menezes-Filho, N. (2013). The impact of the expansion of the Bolsa Familia Program on the time allocation of youths and their parents. Insper Working Paper WPE: 326/2013.

Chirivi, E., Quiroz, O. & Rodriguez D. (2011). La vivienda social en America Latina: Una revision de politicas para atender las necesidades habitacionales de la region. Estudios Economicos, N° 30, Bogota, Camara Colombiana de la Construccion (CAMACOL).

Cireno, F., Silva, J. & Proença, P. (2014). Conditionalities, School Performance and Progression of Bolsa Familia Program Recipients. In Campello, T. & Neri, M. (eds): Bolsa Familia Program: A Decade of Social Inclusion in Brazil. Ipea.

Cruz, M. & Zeigelhofer Z. (2014). Beyond the Income Effect. Impact of Conditional Cash Transfer Programs on Private Investments in Human Capital. Policy Research Working Paper, No 6867, World Bank.

da Fonseca Menezes F., Brait-Poplawski, L. & Roversi, M. (2012). Aspects of Social Security in Brazil. From Fome Zero to Brasil Sem Miséria. Instituto Brasileiro de Análises Sociais e Econômicas, Analysis n 33.

Da Silva Santos, A., Loureiro, P. & Mueller, B. (2016). The Impact of the Bolsa Familia Program on the Labor Market in Brazil. Proceedings of the 43rd Brazilian Economics Meeting 069, Brazilian Association of Graduate Programs in Economics.

De Brauw, A., Gilligan, D. O., Hoddinot, J. & Roy, S. (2012). The Impact of Bolsa Familia on Child, Maternal and Household Welfare. International Food Policy Research Institute.

De Brauw, A., Gilligan, D. O., Hoddinot, J. & Roy, S. (2013). Bolsa Familia and Household Labour Supply. Working Paper. Washington, DC, International Food Policy Research Institute.

De Brauw, A., Gilligan, D. O., Hoddinott, J. & Roy, S. (2015). The Impact of Bolsa Familia on Schooling. World Development, Vol. 70, pp. 303-316.

de Melo, A., Starzec, C. & Gardes, F. (2016). The “Bolsa-Família” Program and the Food Insecurity in Brazilian household between 2009 and 2013. IFAMA 26th Annual World Conference, 2016, Aarhus Denmark.

da Silva e Silva, M. O. (2008). O Bolsa Familia no Enfrentamento a Pobreza no Maranhao e Piaui. Sao Paulo: Cortez Editoria.

da Silva e Silva, M. O. & de Almada Lima, V. F. (2014). Avaliando o Bolsa Familia. Unificacao, Focalizacao e Impactos. Cortez Editoria.

de Oliveira, H. C. (2005). An Evaluation of the Bolsa Familia Program in Brazil: Expenditures, Education and Labour Outcomes. Unpublished Report.

de Oliveira, L., Correa, M., Nascimento, G., Goettems, M., Tarquinio, S., Torriani, D. & Demarco, F. (2013). Iniquidade em saude bucal: escolares beneficiarios do Bolsa Familia sao mais vulneraveis? Rev. Saude Publica, 47(6): 1039-47.

de Souza, S., Filho, N. & Dantas, H. (2015). Food Security in Brazil: An Analysis of the Effects of the Bolsa Família Programme. Review of Agrarian Studies, vol. 5, no. 2.

Dest, M. F. (2009). The Impact of Brazil's Bolsa Familia Program on Food Security in Santo Antonio de Jesus, Bahia. Independent Study Project (ISP) Collection. Paper 756.

do Monte, P. & Filho, H. (2013). The Brazilian Cash Transfer Program, Regional Effects, and its Impact on the Labour Market. International Review of Applied Economics, Issue 2.

Drèze J. & Sen, A. (1989). Hunger and Public Action. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Drèze J. & Sen, A. (2013). An Uncertain Glory. India and its Contradictions. Penguing Books.

Drèze J. & Sen, A. (1996). India: Development and Participation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Ferrario, M. (2014). The impacts on family consumption of the Bolsa Família subsidy programme. CEPAL Review, 112.

Ferro, A. & Nicollela, A. (2007). The Impact of Conditional Cash Transfer Programs on Household Work Decisions in Brazil. Research in Labor Economics, Volume 31.

Gaiger, S. & Van Horn R. (2013). Bolsa Familia's effects on the combination of work and school for children and adolescents aged 10-18. International Policy Center for Inclusive Growth Working Paper, n. 121.

Gertler, P., Martinez, S., Premand, P., Rawlings, L. & Vermeersch, M. (2016) Impact Evaluation in Practice, second edition. Washington, DC: Inter-American Development Bank and World Bank.

Gottschalk Guab, I. (2012). Ex-Ante Evaluation of the Conditional Cash Transfers of the Brazilian Bolsa Família. Unpublished Master Thesis, Tilburg University.

Gregol de Farias, T. (2014), Estudio de caso sobre la insercion productiva y laboral de los beneficiarios de los programas de transferencias condicionadas en Brasil. Santiago de Chile, Comision Economica para America Latina y el Caribe (CEPAL)/EUROsocial, inedito.

Guo, S. & Fraser, M. (2015). Propensity Score Analysis. Statistical Methods and Applications. SAGE Publications.

Hellmann, A. (2015). How does Bolsa Familia work? Best practices in the implementation of conditional cash transfer programs in Latin America and the Caribbean. IDB Technical Note, n 856.

Jannuzzi, P. & Pinto, A. (2014). Bolsa Familia and its Impacts on the Living Conditions of the Brazilian Population: a Summary of the Main Findings of the II Impact Assessment Research of the Bolsa Familia. In Campello, T. & Neri, M. (eds.): Bolsa Familia Program: A Decade of Social Inclusion in Brazil. Ipea.

Shahidur, K. R., Gayatri, B. K. & Hussain, A. S. (2009). Handbook on impact evaluation: quantitative methods and practices (English). Washington, DC: World Bank.

Kanbur, R., & Squire, L. (1999). The Evolution of Thinking about Poverty: Exploring the Interactions Mimeographed Document. Washington DC: World Development Report Office, Washington DC World Bank.

Ichino, A., Schwerdt, G., Winter-Ebmer, R. & Zweimüller, J. (2007). Too Old to Work, Too Young to Retire? IZA Discussion Paper, No. 3110.

ILO (2009). Bolsa Familia in Brazil: Context, Concept and Impacts. Report, ILO.

Kamakura, W. & Mazzon, J. (2014). Measuring the Impact of a Conditional Cash Transfer Program on Consumption Behavior with Propensity Scoring. Cognitive Social Science eJournal.

Lignani, J., Sichieri, R., Burlandy, L. & Salles-Costa, R. (2010). Changes in food consumption among the Programa Bolsa Familia participant families in Brazil. Public Health Nutrition: 14(5), 785-792.

Machado, A., Fontes, G., Antigo, M., Gonzalez, R. & Soares, F. V. (2011). Assessment of the Implications of the Bolsa Familia Programme for the Decent Work Agenda. International Policy Center for Inclusive Growth, Working paper n. 85.

Marinho, E. & Mendes, S. (2012). The Impact of Government Income Transfers on the Brazilian Job Market. Est. Econ., São Paulo, vol. 43, n.1, p. 29-50.

Midgley, J. and Piachaud, D. (2013). Social Protection, Economic Growth and Social Change: Goals Issues and Trajectories in China, India, Brazil and South Africa, Edward Elgar.

Ministério do Desenvolvimento Social e Combate à Fome (2012). Avaliacao de Impacto do Programa Bolsa Familia - 2a Rodada (AIBF II).

Ministerio de Desarrollo Social del Brasil (2013). Programa Nacional de Promocao do Acesso ao Mundo do Trabalho – Acessuas Trabalho.

Morgan, S. & Winship, C. (2015). Counterfactuals and Causal Inference. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Mourao, L., Ferreira, M. C. & de Jesus, M. (2012). Evaluation of the Brazilian Family Grant Program: A Quasi-Experimental Study in the State of Rio de Janeiro. Revista Psicologia: Reflexão e Crítica, Porto Alegre, v. 25, n. 4, p. 719-729.

Ministerio del Trabajo y Empleo del Brasil (2013). MTE e MDS firmam parceria para atender beneficiarios do Brasil Sem Miseria nos postos do Sine.

Mu, R. and Van de Walle, D. (2011). Rural Roads and Local Market Development in Vietnam. The Journal of Development Studies, 47:5, 709-734.

National Insitute of Population and Social Security Research (2003). Child Related Social Policies in Japan.

Nazareno, L. (2016). O Programa Bolsa Familia e o Mercado de Trabalho Informal: uma Analise de Impacto da Acao Brasil Carinhoso. Economia Aplicada, v. 20, n. 4, 2016, pp. 457-470.

Neri, M. C. (2008). Income Policies, Income Distribution, and the Distribution of Opportunities in Brazil. Ensaios Economicos, No 678.

Nilsson, H. & Sjoberg, K. (2013). An Evaluation of the Impacts of Bolsa Familia on Schooling (Unpublished thesis). University of Lund, Germany.

Otuonye, C. (2015). Brazil Bolsa Familia Program: Analysing the Impact of The Conditionalities on School Enrolment, Health and Child Labor. Unpublished Bachelor Thesis, Lund University, Faculty of Social Sciences.

Paes-Sousa, R. & Santos, L. (2009). Measuring the impact of Bolsa Familia program based on data from health and nutrition days (Brazil). FAO Working Papers.

Paes-Sousa, R., Santos, L. & Miazaki, E. (2011). Effects of conditional cash transfer programme on child nutrition in Brazil. Bullettin of World Health Organization, 89.

Parsons, K. (2015). Reaching out to the persistently poor in rural areas: an analysis of Brazil’s Bolsa Família conditional cash transfer programme. PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE).

Piperata, B., McSweeney, K. & Murrieta, R. S. (2016). Conditional Cash Transfers, Food Security, and Health. Current Anthropology, Volume 57, Number 6.

Quinhoes, T. & Fava, V. (2010). Intersetorialidade e transversalidade: a estrategia dos programas complementares do Bolsa Familia. Revista do Servico Publico Brasilia, 61 (1): 67-96.

Racchumi, J. & Carvalho, R. (2013). Bolsa Família Program in Brazil: assessing the impact on educational indicators of children and adolescents by regions. XXVII IUSSP – International Population Conference. Busan, South Korea.

Retherford, R. & Ogawa, N. (2006). Japan’s Baby Bust: Causes, Implications and Policy Responses. In: Harris, F. (eds): The Baby Bust, Who will Do the Work? Who will Pay the Taxes? Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.

Ribas, R. P. & Soares, F. V. (2011). Is the effect of conditional transfers on labor supply negligible everywhere? SSRN Electronic Journal.

Robles, C. & Mirosevic, V. (2013). Sistemas de proteccion social en America Latina y el Caribe: Brasil. Documentos de Proyecto, No 532 (LC/W.532), Santiago de Chile, Comision Economica para America Latina y el Caribe (CEPAL).

Rosenbaum, P. R. & Rubin, D. B. (1983). The central role of the propensity score in observational studies for causal effects. Biometrika, 70, 1, pp. 41-55.

Rosenbaum, P. R. & Rubin, D. B. (1985). Constructing a Control Group Using Multivariate Matched Sampling Methods that Incorporate the Propensity Score. The American Statistician, 39(1), 33-38.

Rubin, D. B. (2001). Using Propensity Scores to Help Design Observational Studies: Application to the Tobacco Litigation. Health Services & Outcomes Research Methodology, 2, 169-188.

Ryan A. M., Kontopantelis E., Linden, A. & Burgess, J. F. Jr. (2019). Now trending: Coping with non-parallel trends in difference-in-differences analysis. Stat Methods Med Res., 28(12):3697-3711.

Santos, E. (2012). Bolsa Familia’s impacts on children’s schooling and time allocation. Thesis for the Environmental and Development Economics, Master Programme Department of Economics, Universitetet i Oslo.

Sen, A. (1981). Poverty and Famines. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Sen, A. (1999). Development as Freedom. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Sen A. (1988) Africa and India: what do we have to learn from each other? In: Arrow K.J. (eds): The Balance between Industry and Agriculture in Economic Development. International Economic Association Series. Palgrave Macmillan, London.

Sen, A. (1987). Hunger and Entitlements. WIDER research for action.

Sen, A. (1994). Why does poverty persist in rich countries? In Guidicini P., & Pieretti G. (eds): Urban Poverty and Human Dignity. Franco Angeli Editore.

Sen, A. (2015). The Country of First Boys and Other Essays. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Schaffland, E. (2014). Conditonal Cash Transfer in Brazil: Treatment Evaluation of the “Bolsa Familia” Program on Education. In: Schaffland, E. (doctoral thesis), Essays on Development and Behavior Economics: An Impact Evaluation of the “Bolsa Família” - Conditional Cash Transfer on Education and the Effect of Leadership Identity on Group Cooperation and Elite Capture. University of Gottingen.

Shei, A., Costa, F., Mitermayer, R. & Ko, A. (2014). The impact of Brazil's Bolsa Familia conditional cash transfer proram on children's health care utilization and health outcomes. BMC International Health and Human Rights, 14:10.

Simoes, A. & Sabates, R. (2014). The contribution of Bolsa Familia the educational achievement of economically disadvantaged children in Brazil. International journal of Educational Development, 39, 151-166.

Soares, S. (2012). Bolsa Família, its design, its impacts, and possibilities for the future. Working Paper, International Policy Centre for Inclusive Growth, No. 89.

Tatagiba, L., Teixeira, A. C., Blikstad, K. & Paterniani, S. (2014). Inovacoes participativas nas politicas habitacionais para populacao de baixa renda. Um estudo de caso sobre o Programa Minha Casa, Minha Vida – Entidades. Critica y emancipacion. Revista Latinoamericana de Ciencias Sociales, ano VI, N° 11.

Teixeira, C. G. (2010). A heterogeneity analysis of the Bolsa Família Programme effect on men and women's work supply. Working Paper, International Policy Centre for Inclusive Growth, No. 61.

Trubek, D., Garcia, H., Coutinho, D. & Santos, A. (2013). Law and the New Developmental State. Cambridge University Press.

Valenca, M. & Bonates, M. (2010). The trajectory of social housing policy in Brazil: From the National Housing Bank to the Ministry of the Cities. Habitat International, vol. 34, N. 2, Amsterdam, Elsevier.