Household-level welfare effects of land expropriation: Evidence from China

Randolph, Hannah (2023): Household-level welfare effects of land expropriation: Evidence from China.

Abstract

A number of developing countries use land expropriation policies to expand cities and develop peri-urban areas. In China alone, an average of 1,600 square kilometers were expropriated annually between 2004 and 2018. The impact of this urban development strategy on expropriated households is not well-understood. I estimate the causal effect of expropriation on Chinese households' livelihood choice and earned income, relying on panel data and comparison to non-expropriated households to observe how household-level outcomes change in response to expropriation. Controlling for baseline outcomes, I find that for at least the first two years, expropriation reduces household agricultural participation and production but does not increase other types of income-generating activities. The result is reduced food security and ability to earn income. Compensation paid to households does not fully offset these effects in cases where households lose all their land or are uncompensated. These findings suggest concrete policies governments can implement to lessen the negative welfare impacts of urban development on expropriated households: higher compensation rates, development of rural non-agricultural labor markets, and direct food assistance to expropriated households.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Land rights, Land expropriation, Household welfare, China
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H1 - Structure and Scope of Government > H13 - Economics of Eminent Domain ; Expropriation ; Nationalization; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O15 - Human Resources ; Human Development ; Income Distribution ; Migration; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q15 - Land Ownership and Tenure ; Land Reform ; Land Use ; Irrigation ; Agriculture and Environment

References

Adamopoulos, T., L. Brandt, J. Leight, and D. Restuccia (2022). Misallocation, Selection, and Productivity: A Quantitative Analysis With Panel Data From China. Econometrica 90 (3), 1261–1282.

Anderson, M. L. (2008, December). Multiple Inference and Gender Differences in the Effects of Early Intervention: A Reevaluation of the Abecedarian, Perry Preschool, and Early Training Projects. Journal of the American Statistical Association 103 (484), 1481–1495.

Bao, H., X.Wu, H.Wang, Q. Li, Y. Peng, and S. Lu (2019, January). Conflicts Induced by Different Responses to Land Expropriation Among the Farmers Involved During Urbanization in China. Journal of Artificial Societies and Social Simulation 22 (1).

Benjamin, D. (1992). Household Composition, Labor Markets, and Labor Demand: Testing for Separation in Agricultural Household Models. Econometrica 60 (2), 287–322.

Benjamin, D. and L. Brandt (2002). Property rights, labour markets, and efficiency in a transition economy: The case of rural China. Canadian Journal of Economics/Revue canadienne d’´economique 35 (4), 689–716.

Brandt, L., J. Huang, G. Li, and S. Rozelle (2002). Land Rights in Rural China: Facts, Fictions and Issues. The China Journal (47), 67–97.

Broderick, T., R. Giordano, and R. Meager (2021, April). An Automatic Finite-Sample Robustness Metric: Can Dropping a Little Data Change Conclusions? arXiv:2011.14999 [econ, stat].

Cai, M., J. B. Murtazashivili, I. Murtazashvili, and H. Wang (2020, September). Sugarcoating the bitter pill: Compensation, land governance, and opposition to land expropriation in China. The Journal of Peasant Studies 47 (6), 1371–1392.

Carletto, C., S. Gourlay, and P. Winters (2015, November). From Guesstimates to GPStimates: Land Area Measurement and Implications for Agricultural Analysis. Journal of African Economies 24 (5), 593–628.

Chan, K. W. (2019). The Chinese Hukou System at 60. In R. Yep, J. Wang, and T. Johnson (Eds.), Handbook on Urban Development in China, Handbooks of Research on Contemporary China. Cheltenham ; Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar.

Chen, E. H. and W. J. Dixon (1972, September). Estimates of Parameters of a Censored Regression Sample. Journal of the American Statistical Association 67 (339), 664–671.

Chen, X., J. Chen, and C.-Y. Huang (2019, January). Too Risky to Focus on Agriculture? An Empirical Study of China’s Agricultural Households’ Off-Farm Employment Decisions. Sustainability 11 (3), 697.

de Janvry, A., M. Fafchamps, and E. Sadoulet (1991). Peasant Household Behaviour with Missing Markets: Some Paradoxes Explained. The Economic Journal 101 (409), 1400–1417.

Deaton, A. (2019, January). The Analysis of Household Surveys (Reissue Edition with a New Preface): A Microeconometric Approach to Development Policy. The World Bank.

Deininger, Songqing, K. J. and S. Jin (2007). Securing property rights in transition: Lessons from implementation of China’s rural land contracting law. Working Paper 4447, World Bank, Washington, DC.

D´emurger, S., M. Fournier, and W. Yang (2010, September). Rural households’ decisions towards income diversification: Evidence from a township in northern China. China Economic Review 21, S32–S44.

Ding, S., J. Yang, and Y. Chen (2018, July). Income Mobility of Farm Households with Landexpropriated in the Process of Industrialization and Urbanization in China. 2018 Conference, July 28-August 2, 2018, Vancouver, British Columbia 276962, International Association of Agricultural Economists.

Du, J., J.-C. Thill, C. Feng, and G. Zhu (2017, September). Land wealth generation and distribution in the process of land expropriation and development in Beijing, China. Urban Geography 38 (8), 1231–1251.

Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (2021). FAO Statistical Database: Land Use Domain. Rome: FAO.

Frison, L. and S. J. Pocock (1992). Repeated measures in clinical trials: Analysis using mean summary statistics and its implications for design. Statistics in Medicine 11 (13), 1685–1704.

Gan, L., Z. Yin, N. Jia, S. Xu, S. Ma, and L. Zheng (2014). Data You Need to Know about China: Research Report of China Household Finance Survey. Springer.

Ghatak, M., S. Mitra, D. Mookherjee, and A. Nath (2013). Land Acquisition and Compensation: What Really Happened in Singur? Economic and Political Weekly 48 (21), 32–44.

Glennerster, R. and K. Takavarasha (2013). Running Randomized Evaluations: A Practical Guide. Princeton, UNITED STATES: Princeton University Press.

Gr¨oger, A. and Y. Zylberberg (2016, April). Internal Labor Migration as a Shock Coping Strategy: Evidence from a Typhoon. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics 8 (2), 123–153.

Guo, X. (2001, June). Land Expropriation and Rural Conflicts in China. The China Quarterly 166, 422–439.

Hagenaars, A., K. de Vos, and M. Zaidi (1994). Poverty Statistics in the Late 1980s: Research Based on Micro-data. Technical report, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg.

Hannum, E., J. Liu, and E. A. Frongillo (2014, January). Poverty, food insecurity and nutritional deprivation in rural China: Implications for children’s literacy achievement. International Journal of Educational Development 34, 90–97.

He, Z., S. T. Nelson, Y. Su, A. L. Zhang, and F. Zhang (2022, September). Industrial Land Discount in China: A Public Finance Perspective.

Hui, E. C. M., H. J. Bao, and X. L. Zhang (2013, May). The policy and praxis of compensation for land expropriations in China: An appraisal from the perspective of social exclusion. Land Use Policy 32, 309–316.

Jay Chen, C.-J. (2020, September). Peasant protests over land seizures in rural China. The Journal of Peasant Studies 47 (6), 1327–1347.

Jiao, X., C. Smith-Hall, and I. Theilade (2015, November). Rural household incomes and land grabbing in Cambodia. Land Use Policy 48, 317–328.

Ju, Q., J. Ni, D. Ni, and Y. Wu (2016, August). Land Acquisition, Labor Allocation, and Income Growth of Farm Households. Emerging Markets Finance and Trade 52 (8), 1744–1761.

Key, N., E. Sadoulet, and A. D. Janvry (2000). Transactions Costs and Agricultural Household Supply Response. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 82 (2), 245–259.

Le, K. and M. Nguyen (2020). The impacts of farmland expropriation on Vietnam’s rural households. Review of Development Economics 24 (4), 1560–1582.

Li, C., M.Wang, and Y. Song (2018, September). Vulnerability and livelihood restoration of landless households after land acquisition: Evidence from peri-urban China. Habitat International 79, 109–115.

Li, H., X. Huang, M.-P. Kwan, H. X. H., and S. Jefferson (2015). Changes in farmers’ welfare from land requisition in the process of rapid urbanization. Land Use Policy 42, 635–641.

Lin, G. C. S. and S. P. S. Ho (2005, June). The State, Land System, and Land Development Processes in Contemporary China. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 95 (2), 411–436.

Ling, Z. (2001). Food Security of Low Income Groups in Rural China. In C. Riskin, R. Zhao, and S. Li (Eds.), China’s Retreat from Equality: Income Distribution and Economic Transition, pp. 229–244.

List, J. A., A. M. Shaikh, and Y. Xu (2019, December). Multiple hypothesis testing in experimental economics. Experimental Economics 22 (4), 773–793.

Lora-Wainwright, A. (2012). Rural China in ruins: The rush to urbanize China’s countryside is opening a moral battleground. Anthropology Today 28 (4), 8–13.

Ma, S. and R. Mu (2020, August). Forced off the farm? Farmers’ labor allocation response to land requisition in China. World Development 132, 104980.

Mao, W. and S. Qiao (2021, February). Legal Doctrine and Judicial Review of Eminent Domain in China. Law & Social Inquiry, 1–34.

McKenzie, D. (2012, November). Beyond baseline and follow-up: The case for more T in experiments. Journal of Development Economics 99 (2), 210–221.

National Bureau of Statistics of China (2020a). Expropriated land area (square kilometers). https://data.stats.gov.cn/.

National Bureau of Statistics of China (2020b). Urban land area (sq. km.). https://data.stats.gov.cn/.

OECD (2008). Growing Unequal? Income Distribution and Poverty in OECD Countries. OECD.

Paik, W. and K. Lee (2012, March). I Want To Be Expropriated!: The politics of xiaochanquanfang land development in suburban China. Journal of Contemporary China 21 (74), 261–279.

People’s Republic of China (1998). Land Administration Law.

Romano, J. P., A. M. Shaikh, and M. Wolf (2010, September). Hypothesis Testing in Econometrics. Annual Review of Economics 2 (1), 75–104.

Sargeson, S. (2013, November). Violence as development: Land expropriation and China’s urbanization. The Journal of Peasant Studies 40 (6), 1063–1085.

Singh, I., L. Squire, J. Strauss, and World Bank (1986). Agricultural Household Models: Extensions, Applications, and Policy. A World Bank Research Publication. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.

Tan, R., F. Qu, N. Heerink, and E. Mettepenningen (2011, December). Rural to urban land conversion in China — How large is the over-conversion and what are its welfare implications? China Economic Review 22 (4), 474–484.

Tang, Y., R. J. Mason, and P. Sun (2012, July). Interest distribution in the process of coordination of urban and rural construction land in China. Habitat International 36 (3), 388–395.

Taylor, J. E. and I. Adelman (2003, January). Agricultural Household Models: Genesis, Evolution, and Extensions. Review of Economics of the Household 1 (1), 33–58.

Tuan, N. T. (2021). The consequences of expropriation of agricultural land and loss of livelihoods on those households who lost land in Da Nang, Vietnam. Environmental and Socio-economic Studies 9 (2), 26–38.

Tuyen, T. Q., S. Lim, M. P. Cameron, and V. Van Huong (2014). Farmland loss, nonfarm diversification and inequality among households in Hanoi’s peri-urban areas, Vietnam. International Development Planning Review 36 (3), 357–379.

Wang, D., W. Qian, and X. Guo (2019a). Gains and losses: Does farmland acquisition harm farmers’ welfare? Land use policy 86, 78–90.

Wang, Y., W. Li, J. Xiong, Y. Li, and H. Wu (2019b). Effect of Land Expropriation on Land-Lost Farmers’ Health: Empirical Evidence from Rural China. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health; Basel 16 (16).

Wang, Y., X. Li, W. Li, and M. Tan (2018, May). Land titling program and farmland rental market participation in China: Evidence from pilot provinces. Land Use Policy 74, 281–290.

Wooldridge, J. M. (2002, August). Inverse probability weighted M-estimators for sample selection, attrition, and stratification. Portuguese Economic Journal 1 (2), 117–139.

Wooldridge, J. M. (2007, December). Inverse probability weighted estimation for general missing data problems. Journal of Econometrics 141 (2), 1281–1301.

Yang, F., Y. Shen, and D. Nehring (2021, April). Maltreatment and depression among left-behind adolescents in rural China: The moderating roles of food security and depression literacy. Child Abuse & Neglect 114, 104976.

Yang, Y.-f. (2012). Basic Land Security and Livelihood: A Study of Compensation and Social Security Policy for Land-Expropriated Peasants in China. Public Administration and Development 32 (4), 385–401.

Zhao, J. and P. J. Barry (2014). Income Diversification of Rural Households in China. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics/Revue canadienne d’agroeconomie 62 (3), 307–324.