A novel research strategy of measuring housing disadvantages of vulnerable populations for all income levels: the Propensity Score Matching approach.

Heijs, Joost and Cruz-Calderón, Selene Cruz (2023): A novel research strategy of measuring housing disadvantages of vulnerable populations for all income levels: the Propensity Score Matching approach.

Abstract

Housing is an important inclusion factor that reflects the degree of stability of vulnerable groups in terms of ethnic or racial origin, who face several difficulties to access good housing. Many studies focused on the marginalisation of this social groups identifying important problems and policy recommendations. Though, there is still plenty of opportunity to broaden the scope of the existing evidence. We propose an analytical framework that solve one of the main methodological problems of the existing studies: the selection bias.

The proposed the Propensity Score Matching (PSM) technique in combination with the use of a housing quality indicator (HQI) with a continuous numeric scale. This combination offers several possibilities to tinge the results of former studies. The PSM method isolates that part of the difference in housing quality—defined here as the housing quality gap (HQG)—of the vulnerable people that is directly caused by their ethnic or racial origin from the fraction generated by other structural socio-economic differences between them and the rest of the Mexican population. In other words, it assesses whether the poorest vulnerable individuals suffer the same level of disadvantages as the non-vulnerable in the same socio-economic situation.

To broaden the scope of existing studies we quantify the size of the HQ gap for each vulnerable person, to identify the profile of those who have a larger HQ gap than others considering not only the most common aspects (sex, age, educational level, household income) but also some characteristics barely used (housing tenure, participation in public social program, mental of physical disabilities, remittances, housing loan, etc.). This approach permits to study not only the poorest sectors of the population, though we can analyse whether members of the vulnerable population in terms of ethnic or racial origin with higher income levels also suffer worse housing conditions due to their vulnerability and create the corresponding profile of the most affected.

Analysing the Mexican situation for the indigenous population and Afro-Mexican, we observed a negative gap for indigenous people, being wider for elderly, renters, single parents, those with higher educational level, those living in the so-called vecindades (poor multi-family dwellings) or house with no floor covering and those residing in the Central City or the largest localities. The model evaluates also some barely used aspects that intersect with ethnic vulnerability showing a wider gap for native speakers and those with physical or mental disabilities.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Housing Quality Gap, Propensity Score Matching, indigenous people, Profile
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F2 - International Factor Movements and International Business > F22 - International Migration; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J1 - Demographic Economics > J15 - Economics of Minorities, Races, Indigenous Peoples, and Immigrants ; Non-labor Discrimination; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R2 - Household Analysis > R21 - Housing Demand

References

References Arias, E., and De Vos, S. (1996). Using housing items to indicate socioeconomic status: Latin America. Social Indicators Research, 38(1), 53-80.

Bando, R., Patrinos, H. A., Bando, R., & López-Calva, L. F. (2005). Child labor, school attendance, and indigenous households: evidence from Mexico (Vol. 3487). World Bank Publications.

Bayoh, I., Irwin, E. G., and Haab, T. (2006). Determinants of residential location choice: How important are local public goods in attracting homeowners to central city locations?. Journal of Regional Science, 46(1), 97-120.

Barbary, O. (2015). Social inequalities and indigenous populations in Mexico: A plural approach. In Social statistics and ethnic diversity (pp. 209-228). Springer, Cham.

Basabe, N., and Bobowik, M. (2013). Estatus grupal, discriminación y adaptación en inmigrantes latinoamericanos y africanos en España. Psicoperspectivas, 12(1), 5-29.

Bayona i Carrasco, Jordy. (2007). La segregación residencial de la población extranjera en Barcelona:¿ una segregación fragmentada?. Scripta Nova: revista electrónica de geografía y ciencias sociales.

Benavides, Martín. 2006. Nota técnica sobre indígenas y afro peruanos. Unpublished report. Washington, DC/Lima: Inter-American Development Bank/ Grupo de Análisis para el Desarrollo.

Boarini, R., and d'Ercole, M. M. (2006). Measures of material deprivation in OECD countries.

Borg, I. (2012). Housing deprivation in Europe: On the role of rental tenure types.

Borg, I. (2015). Housing deprivation in Europe: On the role of rental tenure types. Housing, Theory and Society, 32(1), 73-93.

Bouillon, C. (Ed.) 2012. “Room for Development: Housing Markets in Latin America and the Caribbean.” InterAmerican Development Bank.

Bradley, R. H., and Putnick, D. L. (2012). Housing quality and access to material and learning resources within the home environment in developing countries. Child development, 83(1), 76-91.

Brandolini, A., and D’Alessio, G. (1998, October). Measuring well-being in the functioning space. In General Conference of The International Association for Research in Income and Wealth, Cracow, Poland.

Brkanić, I. (2017). Housing quality assessment criteria. Electronic Journal of the Faculty of Civil Engineering Osijek-e-GFOS, 8(14), 37-47.

Canedo, A. (2019). Labor market discrimination against indigenous peoples in Mexico: A decomposition analysis of wage differentials. Iberoamericana–Nordic Journal of Latin American and Caribbean Studies, 48(1).

Castellino, J. (2009). The MDGs and international human rights law: a view from the perspective of minorities and vulnerable groups. The International Journal of Human Rights, 13(1), 10-28.

Castillo-Camporro, A. S., & Vargas-Solar, G. (2020). A holistic approach for measuring quality of life in" La Condesa" district in Mexico City. ILCEA: Revue de l’Institut des langues et cultures d'Europe, Amérique, Afrique, Asie et Australie, 9.

Clark, W. A. (2009). Changing residential preferences across income, education, and age: Findings from the multi-city study of urban inequality. Urban Affairs Review, 44(3), 334-355.

Clark, W. A., and Onaka, J. L. (1983). Life cycle and housing adjustment as explanations of residential mobility. Urban studies, 20(1), 47-57.

Clapham, D. 2009. “Introduction to the Special Issue– A Theory of Housing: Problems and Potential.” Housing, Theory and Society 26 (1): 1–9.

CEPAL/OIT. (2018). Coyuntura Laboral en América Latina y el Caribe. La inserción laboral de las personas mayores: necesidades y opciones. Recuperado de https://www.cepal.org/es/ publicaciones/43603-coyuntura-laboral-america-latina-caribe-la-insercion-laboral-personas-mayores

CEPAL, N. (2021). Afrodescendants and the matrix of social inequality in Latin America: challenges for inclusion. Summary.

CEPAL, N. (2021). Las personas afrodescendientes y el COVID-19: develando desigualdades estructurales en América Latina.

Choi, J., Dekkers, O. M., & le Cessie, S. (2019). A comparison of different methods to handle missing data in the context of propensity score analysis. European journal of epidemiology, 34, 23-36.

Coates, D., Anand, P., and Norris, M. (2013). Housing and quality of life for migrant communities in Western Europe: A capabilities approach. Journal on Migration and Human Security, 1(4), 163-209.

Coley, R. L., Leventhal, T., Lynch, A. D., and Kull, M. (2013). Relations between housing characteristics and the well-being of low-income children and adolescents. Developmental psychology, 49(9), 1775.

Cruz-Calderón, S. (2023) heterogeneous living conditions for vulnerable groups: segregation and housing quality in Spain in Mexico PhD Thesis, Universidad Complutense Madrid

Dalton, R. J. (2017). The participation gap: Social status and political inequality. Oxford University Press.

Delgadillo, V. (2011). Indígenas, vivienda y trabajo en el centro histórico de la ciudad de México. TERRITORIOS Y SOCIEDADES EN UN MUNDO EN CAMBIO, 219.

Deng Z, Law YW (2020) Rural-to-urban migration, discrimination experience, and health in China: Evidence from propensity score analysis. PLoS ONE 15(12): e0244441. https://doi.org/ 10.1371/journal.pone.0244441

Desai, R. J., & Franklin, J. M. (2019). Alternative approaches for confounding adjustment in observational studies using weighting based on the propensity score: a primer for practitioners. bmj, 367

Diario Oficial de la Federación (2019). D. O. DECRETO por el que se adiciona un apartado C al artículo 2 de la constitución política de los Estados Unidos Mexicanos.

Espinosa Trujillo, Marco Antonio, Reyes de la Cruz, Virginia Guadalupe, Torres Sombra, Jesús, and Pérez Vera, Flor del Carmen. (2015). Programas sociales como alternativa para generar la redistribución del ingreso: un estudio de caso. Estudios sociales (Hermosillo, Son.), 23(46), 272-288. Recuperado en 28 de diciembre de 2022, de http://www.scielo.org.mx/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0188-45572015000200011&lng=es&tlng=es.

Evans, G. W., Wells, N. M., Chan, H. Y. E., and Saltzman, H. (2000). Housing quality and mental health. Journal of consulting and clinical psychology, 68(3), 526.

Farrell, A. M., and Rudd, J. M. (2009). Factor analysis and discriminant validity: A brief review of some practical issues. Anzmac.

Gandelman, N., Ñopo, H., and Ripani, L. (2011). Traditional excluding forces: A review of the quantitative literature on the economic situation of indigenous peoples, Afro‐descendants, and people living with disability. Latin American Politics and Society, 53(4), 147-179.

González, M. L. (2006). Más allá de los promedios: afrodescendientes en América Latina. Los afrohondureños. World Bank, Washington, DC.

Grigolon, A., Dane, G., Rasouli, S., & Timmermans, H. (2014). Binomial random parameters logistic regression model of housing satisfaction. Procedia environmental sciences, 22, 280-287.

Guo, S., and Fraser, M. W. (2014). Propensity score analysis: Statistical methods and applications (Vol. 11). SAGE publications.

Guo, S., Fraser, M., & Chen, Q. (2020). Propensity score analysis: recent debate and discussion. Journal of the Society for Social Work and Research, 11(3), 463-482.

Gutiérrez, J. P., and Atienzo, E. E. (2011). Socioeconomic status, urbanicity and risk behaviors in Mexican youth: an analysis of three cross-sectional surveys. BMC Public Health, 11(1), 1-10.

Hastings, I. (2011). Análisis cualitativo de la vivienda popular en la ciudad de México. La vivienda popular en México. Retos para el siglo XXI, UAM, México, 121-145.

Hatuka, T., and Bar, R. (2017). Navigating housing approaches: A search for convergences among competing ideas. Housing, Theory and Society, 34(3), 277-296.

Hopenhayn, M. (2008). Recognition and distribution: equity and justice policies for disadvantaged groups in Latin America. Inclusive States. Washington, DC: World Bank, 145-73.

Imbens, G. W., and Rubin, D. B. (2015). Causal inference in statistics, social, and biomedical sciences. Cambridge University Press.

Jennings, W. G., Richards, T. N., Smith, M. D., Bjerregaard, B., and Fogel, S. J. (2014). A critical examination of the “White victim effect” and death penalty decision-making from a propensity score matching approach: The North Carolina experience. Journal of Criminal Justice, 42(5), 384-398.

Kain, J. F., and Quigley, J. M. (1970). Measuring the value of housing quality. Journal of the American statistical association, 65(330), 532-548.

Keele, Luke. 2015b. “The Statistics of Causal Inference: A View from Political Methodology.” Political Analysis 23 (3): 313–35.

Kutty, N. (1999). Determinants of structural adequacy of dwellings. Journal of housing research, 10(1), 27-43.

Lara, G. (2011). La construction politique d’un sujet «afro» ou «noir» au Mexique. Revue européenne des migrations internationales, 27(1), 89-106.

López, A. C. (2019). Racism in Mexico: Ojos que no ven, corazón que no siente. In Y tú ¿qué hora traes? (pp. 62-78). Brill

Marr, W. L., and Mccready, d. J. (1997). Housing quality and affordability among female householders in Canada. Genus, 215-241.

McTarnaghan, S., Martín, C., Srini, T., Collazos, J., Gold, A., Suminski, M., and Guzman, Y. (2016). Literature Review of Housing in Latin America and the Caribbean. Urban Institute, Habitat for Humanity.

Mercado, A. (2011). La habitabilidad de la vivienda pública bajo el régimen del libre mercado. Andrade Narváez, J. y E. Carballo Cruz, (2011). La vivienda popular en México. Retos para el siglo XXI. Serie Pensar el Futuro de México, (14).

Módenes, J. A., Bayona, J., and López‐Colás, J. (2013). Immigration and residential change in Spain. Population, space and place, 19(3), 294-310.

Mustapha, F., Al-Abed, A., and Wild, S. (1995). A model for assessing the effectiveness of public housing in Sana'a (Republic of Yemen). Construction management and economics, 13(6), 457-465.

Navarro, C., and Ayala, L. (2008). Multidimensional housing deprivation indices with application to Spain. Applied Economics, 40(5), 597-611.

Newdick, V. (2005). The indigenous woman as victim of her culture in neoliberal Mexico. Cultural Dynamics, 17(1), 73-92.

Nelbach, P. E. (1950). An Appraisal Method for Measuring the Quality of Housing: A Yardstick for Health Officers, Housing Officials and Planners. Part III. Appraisal of Neighborhood Environment.

Nieto, N. (2018). Postcolonialism and social exclusion of indigenous people in Mexico. Revista Debates, 12(1).

Ñopo, H., Chong, A., and Moro, A. (2009). What do we know about discrimination in Latin America? Very Little!. Discrimination in Latin America, an Economic Perspective, Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo, Washington DC, 1-12.

Oehmichen, Cristina. (2001). Espacio urbano y segregación étnica en la ciudad de México. Papeles de población, 7(28), 181-197. Recuperado en 01 de diciembre de 2022, de http://www.scielo.org.mx/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1405-74252001000200008&lng=es&tlng=es.

Onibokun, A. (1975). A critical review of the Nigerian government housing policy and programmes.

Osili, U. O. (2004). Migrants and housing investments: Theory and evidence from Nigeria. Economic development and cultural change, 52(4), 821-849.

Painter, G., Gabriel, S., and Myers, D. (2001). Race, immigrant status, and housing tenure choice. Journal of Urban Economics, 49(1), 150-167.

Pais, J. (2011). Socioeconomic background and racial earnings inequality: A propensity score analysis. Social science research, 40(1), 37-49.

Palvarini, P., and Pavolini, E. (2010). Housing deprivation and vulnerability in Western Europe. In Social Vulnerability in Europe (pp. 126-158). Palgrave Macmillan, London.

Ponce, Juan. 2006. Más allá de los promedios: afrodescendientes en América Latina. Los afroecuatorianos. Washington, DC: World Bank.

Rindfuss, R. R., Piotrowski, M., Thongthai, V., and Prasartkul, P. (2007). Measuring housing quality in the absence of a monetized real estate market. Population Studies, 61(1), 35-52.

Rohe, W. M., and Stegman, M. A. (1994). The effects of homeownership: On the self-esteem, perceived control and life satisfaction of low-income people. Journal of the American Planning Association, 60(2), 173-184.

Rosenbaum, P. R., and Rubin, D. B. (1983). The central role of the propensity score in observational studies for causal effects. Biometrika, 70(1), 41-55.

Roy, D., Bernal, D., and Lees, M. (2020). An exploratory factor analysis model for slum severity index in Mexico City. Urban studies, 57(4), 789-805.

Sabater, l. A., and Martí, J. S. B. (2012). Spatial localisation strategies of immigrants in Spain.

Saiz, A. (2022). CONFRONTING THE HOUSING CHALLENGE IN LATIN AMERICA.

Saporito, E. (2011). Mexico City. The marginal communities: social and ethnic segregation of the native population. TERRITORIO.

Schmelkes, S. (2009). Intercultural universities in Mexico: progress and difficulties. Intercultural Education, 20(1), 5-17.

Schill, M., Friedman, S., and Rosenbaum, E. (1998). The housing conditions of immigrants in New York City. Journal of Housing Research, 9(2), 201-235.

Sengupta, U., and Tipple, A. G. (2007). The performance of public-sector housing in Kolkata, India, in the post-reform milieu. Urban Studies, 44(10), 2009-2027.

Sinha, R. C., Sarkar, S., and Mandal, N. R. (2017). An overview of key indicators and evaluation tools for assessing housing quality: A literature review. Journal of The Institution of Engineers (India): Series A, 98(3), 337-347.

Sirgy, M. J., & Cornwell, T. (2002). How neighbourhood features affect quality of life. Social indicators research, 59(1), 79-114.

Soja, E. (2000) Postmetropolis. Blackwell, Oxford.

Spain, D. (1990). The effect of residential mobility and household composition on housing quality. Urban Affairs Quarterly, 25(4), 659-683.

Streimikiene, D. (2015). Quality of life and housing. International Journal of Information and Education Technology, 5(2), 140.

Stringer, R. J., and Holland, M. M. (2016). It's not all black and white: A propensity score matched, multilevel examination of racial drug sentencing disparities. Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice, 14(4), 327-347.

Torre-Cantalapiedra, E., and Sánchez-Soto, G. (2019). Afro-descendants and social stratification in Mexico. New evidence from the 2015 Intercensal Survey. Papeles de población, 25(100), 273-302.

Toscana Aparicio, A., and Pimienta, R. D. J. (2018). Migración intercontorno en la Zona Metropolitana de la Ciudad de México. Un estudio desde la justicia espacial. Política y cultura, (49), 93-120.

Uehara, E. S. (1994). Race, gender, and housing inequality: An exploration of the correlates of low-quality housing among clients diagnosed with severe and persistent mental illness. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 309-321.

Vaughn, B. (2013). Mexico Negro: From the shadows of nationalist mestizaje to new possibilities in Afro-Mexican identity. The Journal of Pan African Studies, 6(1), 227-240.

Velázquez, M. E., and Iturralde, G. (2012). Afrodescendientes en México. Una historia de silencio y discriminación.

Vera-Toscano, E., and Ateca-Amestoy, V. (2008). The relevance of social interactions on housing satisfaction. Social indicators research, 86(2), 257-274.

Viljoen, C., Lowies, B., Lushington, K., and McGreal, S. (2020). Female perspectives on housing quality and household characteristics, perceptions and challenges: Evidence from Australia. Habitat International, 105, 102276.

Wong, R., and Espinoza, M. (2003). Ingreso y bienes de la población de edad media y avanzada en México. Papeles de población, 9(37), 129-166.

Zhu, L. Y., and Shelton, G. G. (1996). The relationship of housing costs and quality to housing satisfaction of older American homeowners: Regional and racial differences. Housing and Society, 23(2), 15-35.