Do carbon taxes affect economic and environmental efficiency? The case of British Columbia’s manufacturing plants

Kumbhakar, Subal C. and Badunenko, Oleg and Willox, Michael (2022): Do carbon taxes affect economic and environmental efficiency? The case of British Columbia’s manufacturing plants. Published in: Energy Economics , Vol. 115, (December 2022): p. 106359.

Abstract

This paper evaluates the impact of British Columbia’s carbon tax on manufacturers’ economic and environmental performance in a unified modeling framework that allows for making critical distinctions between efficiency, technical change, and total factor productivity as performance measures. In contrast to most papers that examine environmental policy impacts on either the economy or the environment, our approach combines a by-production model within a stochastic frontier framework to evaluate the tax’s impacts on both economic and environmental efficiency. Our findings suggest that a 1.0% increase in the carbon tax improved manufacturers’ efficiency in producing desirable output (real sales of manufactured goods) by 0.5%. In addition, the same 1.0% increase in the carbon tax improved manufacturers’ environmental efficiency for greenhouse gas (GHGs) and carbon monoxide (CO) emissions by the same amount, 0.2%. However, the carbon tax led to lower environmental efficiency for emissions of nitrogen oxides (NOx), -0.3%. In addition, our use of a rich plant-level dataset reveals considerable heterogeneity in manufacturers’ efficiency responses to the tax. Finally, we suggest that lower efficiency levels for undesirable outputs than desirable outputs indicate that the relative cost of adjusting production processes to improve efficiency favors economic efficiency over environmental efficiency

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Efficiency; Carbon tax; Stochastic frontier model; By-production model
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations > D24 - Production ; Cost ; Capital ; Capital, Total Factor, and Multifactor Productivity ; Capacity; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q51 - Valuation of Environmental Effects; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q58 - Government Policy

References

Ahmadi, Younes, Akio Yamazaki, and Philippe Kabore. 2022. “How Do Carbon Taxes Affect Emissions? Plant-Level Evidence from Manufacturing.” Environ. Resour. Econ., 1–41.

Apt, Jay, and Warren Katzenstein. 2011. “Thermal Plant Emissions Due to Intermittent Renewable Power Integration.” National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL). https://doi.org/10.2172/1556903.

Arcila, Andres, and John D. Baker. 2022. “Evaluating Carbon Tax Policy: A Methodological Reassessment of a Natural Experiment.”

Badunenko, Oleg, and Subal C. Kumbhakar. 2016. “When, Where and How to Estimate Persistent and Transient Efficiency in Stochastic Frontier Panel Data Models.” Eur. J. Oper. Res. 255 (1): 272–87.

———. 2017. “Economies of Scale, Technical Change and Persistent and Time-Varying Cost Efficiency in Indian Banking: Do Ownership, Regulation and Heterogeneity Matter?” 260 (2): 789–803.

Baumol, William J, and Wallace E Oates. 1988. The Theory of Environmental Policy. Cambridge University Press.

Bernard, Jean-Thomas, and Maral Kichian. 2021. “The Impact of a Revenue-Neutral Carbon Tax on GDP Dynamics: The Case of British Columbia.” Energy J. 42 (3): 205–24.

Bloom, Nicholas, Erik Brynjolfsson, Lucia Foster, Ron Jarmin, Megha Patnaik, Itay Saporta-Eksten, and John Van Reenen. 2019. “What Drives Differences in Management Practices?” 109 (5): 1648–83.

Bloom, Nicholas, Christos Genakos, Ralf Martin, and Raffaella Sadun. 2010. “Modern Management: Good for the Environment or Just Hot Air?” 120 (544): 551–72. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0297.2010.02351.x.

Bloom, Nicholas, and John Van Reenen. 2007. “Measuring and Explaining Management Practices Across Firms and Countries” 122 (4): 1351–1408.

Bonilla, Jorge, Jessica Coria, and Thomas Sterner. 2018. “Technical Synergies and Trade-Offs Between Abatement of Global and Local Air Pollution.” Environ. Resour. Econ. 70 (1): 191–221.

Boulhol, Hervé, Alain De Serres, and Margit Molnar. 2008. “The Contribution of Economic Geography to GDP Per Capita.” OECD J. Econ. Stud.

Boyd, Gale A., and Jonathan M. Lee. 2019. “Measuring Plant Level Energy Efficiency and Technical Change in the US Metal-Based Durable Manufacturing Sector Using Stochastic Frontier Analysis” 81: 159–74.

Brännlund, Runar, Tommy Lundgren, et al. 2009. “Environmental Policy Without Costs? A Review of the Porter Hypothesis.” Int. Rev. Environ. Resour. Econ. 3 (2): 75–117.

British Columbia Ministry of Finance. 2008. “Budget and Fiscal Plan 2008/09-2010/11.” https://www.bcbudget.gov.bc.ca/2008/default.htm .

———. 2022. “2022. “Budget and Fiscal Plan 2022/23- 2024/25.” https://www.bcbudget.gov.bc. ca/2022/pdf/2022_Budget_and_Fiscal_Plan.pdf.

Brunel, Claire. 2017. “Pollution Offshoring and Emission Reductions in EU and US Manufacturing.” Environ. Resour. Econ. 68 (3): 621–41.

Caballero, Ricardo J, Takeo Hoshi, and Anil K. Kashyap. 2008. “Zombie Lending and Depressed Restructuring in Japan.” Amer. Econ. Rev. 98 (5): 1943–77.

Carbone, Jared C., Nicholas Rivers, Akio Yamazaki, and Hidemichi Yonezawa. 2020. “Comparing Applied General Equilibrium and Econometric Estimates of the Effect of an Environmental Policy Shock.” J. Assoc. Environ. Resource Econ. 7 (4): 687–719.

Cherniwchan, Jevan. 2017. “Trade Liberalization and the Environment: Evidence from NAFTA and US Manufacturing” 105: 130–49.

Cherniwchan, Jevan, and Nouri Najjar. 2022. “Do Environmental Regulations Affect the Decision to Export?” Am. Econ. J. Econ. Policy 14 (2): 125–60.

Cifuentes, Luis, Victor H. Borja-Aburto, Nelson Gouveia, George Thurston, and Devra Lee Davis. 2001. “Assessing the Health Benefits of Urban Air Pollution Reductions Associated with Climate Change Mitigation (2000–2020): Santiago, Sao Paulo, Mexico City, and New York City.”

Cole, Matthew A., and Robert J. R. Elliott. 2003. “Determining the Trade–Environment Composition Effect: The Role of Capital, Labor and Environmental Regulations.” J. Environ. Econ. Manage. 46 (3): 363–83.

Colombi, Roberto, Subal C. Kumbhakar, Gianmaria Martini, and Giorgio Vittadini. 2014. “Closed-Skew Normality in Stochastic Frontiers with Individual Effects and Long/Short-Run Efficiency.” J. Product. Anal. 42 (2): 123–36.

De Loecker, Jan, and Frederic Warzynski. 2012. “Markups and Firm-Level Export Status” 102 (6): 2437–71.

Environment and Climate Change Canada. 1999. “National Pollutant Release Inventory (NPRI).” https://www.ec.gc.ca/inrp-npri/default.asp?lang=En&n .

———. 2015. “Summary Report: Reviewed Facility-Reported Data National Pollutant Release Inventory (NPRI) 2015.” https://publications.gc.ca/collections/collection_2017/eccc/En81-27-2015-eng.pdf.

Filippini, Massimo, and William Greene. 2016. “Persistent and Transient Productive Inefficiency: A Maximum Simulated Likelihood Approach.” J. Product. Anal. 45 (2): 187–96.

Førsund, Finn R. 2009. “Good Modelling of Bad Outputs: Pollution and Multiple-Output Production.” Int. Rev. Environ. Resour. Econ. 3 (1): 1–38.

———. 2018. “Pollution Meets Efficiency: Multi-Equation Modelling of Generation of Pollution and Related Efficiency Measures.” In Energy, Environment and Transitional Green Growth in China, 37–79. Springer.

Galloway, Emily, and Erik Paul Johnson. 2016. “Teaching an Old Dog New Tricks: Firm Learning from Environmental Regulation.” Energy Econ. 59: 1–10.

Glass, Anthony J., Karligash Kenjegalieva, and Robin C. Sickles. 2016. “A Spatial Autoregressive Stochastic Frontier Model for Panel Data with Asymmetric Efficiency Spillovers” 190 (2): 289–300.

Greenstone, Michael. 2002. “The Impacts of Environmental Regulations on Industrial Activity: Evidence from the 1970 and 1977 Clean Air Act Amendments and the Census of Manufactures” 110 (6): 1175–1219.

Grifell-Tatjé, Emili, Knox C. A. Lovell, and Robin C. Sickles. 2018. “Overview of Productivity Analysis.” In The Oxford Handbook of Productivity Analysis, edited by Emili Grifell-Tatjé, Knox C. A. Lovell, and Robin C. Sickles, 3–73. Oxford University Press.

Griliches, Zvi. 1957. “Hybrid Corn: An Exploration in the Economics of Technological Change.” Econometrica, J. Econ. Soc. 25 (4): 501–22.

Gu, Wulong, Jakir Hussain, and Michael Willox. 2019. “Environmentally Adjusted Multifactor Productivity Growth for the Canadian Manufacturing Sector.” Statistics Canada, Analytical Studies Branch Research Paper Series, no. Catalogue no. 11F0019M — No. 425.

Haltiwanger, John, L. Foster, and C. Krizan. 2001. “Aggregate Productivity Growth: Lessons from Microeconomic Evidence.” New Direct. Product. Anal., 303–72.

Harrington, James W., and Barney Warf. 2002. Industrial Location: Principles, Practice and Policy. Routledge.

Harrison, Kathryn. 2012. “A Tale of Two Taxes: The Fate of Environmental Tax Reform in Canada.” Rev. Policy Res. 29 (3): 383–407.

Holland, Stephen P. 2011. “Spillovers from Climate Policy to Other Pollutants.” In The Design and Implementation of US Climate Policy, edited by Don Fullerton and Catherine Wolfram, 79–90. University of Chicago Press.

Hsieh, Chang-Tai, and Peter J. Klenow. 2009. “Misallocation and Manufacturing TFP in China and India.” Q. J. Econ. 124 (4): 1403–48.

Kube, Roland, Kathrine von Graevenitz, Andreas Löschel, and Philipp Massier. 2019. “Do Voluntary Environmental Programs Reduce Emissions? EMAS in the German Manufacturing Sector.” Energy Economics 84: 104558.

Kumbhakar, Subal C. 2012. “Specification and Estimation of Primal Production Models” 217 (3): 509–18.

Kumbhakar, Subal C., and Efthymios G. Tsionas. 2016. “The Good, the Bad and the Technology: Endogeneity in Environmental Production Models” 190 (2): 315–27.

Lai, Hung-pin, and Subal C. Kumbhakar. 2018. “Panel Data Stochastic Frontier Model with Determinants of Persistent and Transient Inefficiency” 271 (2): 746–55.

Lee, Jeong-Dong, Jong-Bok Park, and Tai-Yoo Kim. 2002. “Estimation of the Shadow Prices of Pollutants with Production/Environment Inefficiency Taken into Account: A Nonparametric Directional Distance Function Approach” 64 (4): 365–75.

Levinson, Arik. 2015. “A Direct Estimate of the Technique Effect: Changes in the Pollution Intensity of US Manufacturing, 1990–2008.” J. Assoc. Environ. Resour. Econ. 2 (1): 43–56.

Lutz, Benjamin Johannes. 2016. “Emissions Trading and Productivity: Firm-Level Evidence from German Manufacturing.”

Melitz, Marc J., and Sašo Polanec. 2015. “Dynamic Olley-Pakes Productivity Decomposition with Entry and Exit.” The Rand J. Econ, 46 (2): 362–75.

Murty, Sushama, R. Robert Russell, and Steven B. Levkoff. 2012. “On Modeling PollutionGenerating Technologies.” J. Environ. Econ. Manage. 64 (1): 117–35. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jeem.2012.02.005.

Najjar, Nouri, and Jevan Cherniwchan. 2021. “Environmental Regulations and the Cleanup of Manufacturing: Plant-Level Evidence” 103 (3): 476–91.

Olley, Steven, and Ariel Pakes. 1996. “The Dynamics of Productivity in the Telecommunications Equipment Industry” 126: 3–97.

Porter, Michael E. 1991. “Towards a Dynamic Theory of Strategy.” Strategic Manage. J. 12: 95–117.

Porter, Michael E., and Claas Van der Linde. 1995. “Toward a New Conception of the Environment-Competitiveness Relationship” 9 (4): 97–118.

Pretis, Felix. 2022. “Does a Carbon Tax Reduce C02 Emissions? Evidence from British Columbia.” Environ. Resource Econ., 1–30.

Quick, Jeffrey C. 2014. “Carbon Dioxide Emission Tallies for 210 US Coal-Fired Power Plants: A Comparison of Two Accounting Methods.” J. Air Waste Manage. Assoc. 64 (1): 73–79.

Reinhard, Stijn, Knox C. A. Lovell, and Geert Thijssen. 1999. “Econometric Estimation of Technical and Environmental Efficiency: An Application to Dutch Dairy Farms.” Am. J. Agricult. Econ. 81 (1): 44–60.

Reinhard, Stijn, Knox C. A. Lovell, and Geert J. Thijssen. 2000. “Environmental Efficiency with Multiple Environmentally Detrimental Variables; Estimated with SFA and DEA” 121 (2): 287–303.

Saha, Anjan K., and Vinod Mishra. 2020. “Genetic Distance, Economic Growth and Top Income Shares: Evidence from OECD Countries” 92: 37–47.

Shapiro, Joseph S., and Reed Walker. 2018. “Why Is Pollution from US Manufacturing Declining? The Roles of Environmental Regulation, Productivity, and Trade” 108 (12): 3814–54.

Si, Shuyang, Mingjie Lyu, C.-Y. Cynthia Lin Lawell, and Song Chen. 2021. “The Effects of Environmental Policies in China on GDP, Output, and Profits” 94.

Stern, Nicholas. 2006. The Economics of Climate Change: The Stern Review. Cambridge University Press.

Tsionas, Efthymios G., and Subal C. Kumbhakar. 2014. “Firm Heterogeneity, Persistent and Transient Technical Inefficiency: A Generalized True Random-Effects Model” 29 (1): 110–32.

Wang, Hung-Jen. 2002. “Heteroscedasticity and non-monotonic efficiency effects of a stochastic frontier model.” J. Product. Anal. 18 (3): 241–53.

Wang, Hung-Jen, and Peter Schmidt. 2002. “One-Step and Two-Step Estimation of the Effects of Exogenous Variables on Technical Efficiency Levels.” J. Product. Anal. 18 (2): 129–44.

Xiang, Di, and Chad Lawley. 2019. “The Impact of British Columbia’s Carbon Tax on Residential Natural Gas Consumption” 80: 206–18.

Yamazaki, Akio. 2017. “Jobs and Climate Policy: Evidence from British Columbia’s Revenue Neutral Carbon Tax.” J. Environ. Econ. Manage. 83: 197–216.

———. 2022. “Environmental Taxes and Productivity: Lessons from Canadian Manufacturing.” J. Public Econ. 205.

Yang, Zhenbing, Shuai Shao, and Lili Yang. 2021. “Unintended Consequences of Carbon Regulation on the Performance of SOEs in China: The Role of Technical Efficiency” 94 (C). https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eneco.2020.105072.