Pretextual Traffic Stops and Racial Disparities in their Use.

Makofske, Matthew (2020): Pretextual Traffic Stops and Racial Disparities in their Use.

Abstract

Moving-violation traffic stops are pretextual when motivated by suspicion of unrelated crimes. Despite concerns that they are subject to racial bias, and recent reforms hoping to curb the practice; we lack empirical evidence to inform our understanding of pretextual stops. Using a decade's worth of traffic citation data from Louisville, KY, I provide evidence suggesting that pretextual stops predicated on a particular violation---failure to signal---were reasonably common. While arrest rates range from 0.01 to 0.09 in stops citing similarly common moving violations, stops citing failure-to-signal yield an arrest rate of 0.42. Importantly, pretext for a stop requires just one infraction. The arrest rate is 0.53 when failure-to-signal is the only cited traffic violation, and 0.21 otherwise. Prior to departmental deployment of body-worn cameras (BWCs), Black motorists account for a disproportionately high share of these likely pretextual stops (compared against observably similar conventional stops), but are arrested in them at significantly lower rates than other motorists. Both disparities are substantially larger during daylight, when driver race is more easily observed. The latter disparity dissipates following BWC deployment, which is found to initially reduce the frequency of these stops that fail to find contraband. Departmental prohibition of vehicle search based on a subject's nervousness was abruptly announced in May 2019, and immediately followed by a sharp 58% relative decrease in likely pretextual stop frequency.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: pretextual traffic stop, racial bias, law enforcement
• Subjects: J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J1 - Demographic Economics > J15 - Economics of Minorities, Races, Indigenous Peoples, and Immigrants ; Non-labor Discrimination; K - Law and Economics > K4 - Legal Procedure, the Legal System, and Illegal Behavior > K42 - Illegal Behavior and the Enforcement of Law

References

Andrews, D. W. (1993). Tests for parameter instability and structural change with unknown change point. Econometrica 61 (4), 821–856.

Antonovics, K. and B. Knight (2009). A new look at racial profiling: Evidence from the Boston Police Department. The Review of Economics and Statistics 91 (1), 163-177.

Anwar, S. and H. Fang (2006). An alternative test of racial prejudice in motor vehicle searches: Theory and evidence. American Economic Review 96 (1), 127-151.

Arnold, D., W. Dobbie, and C. S. Yang (2018). Racial bias in bail decisions. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 133 (4), 1885-1932.

Arrow, K. J. (1973). The Theory of Discrimination. Princeton University Press.

Baker, A. C., D. F. Larcker, and C. C. Wang (2022). How much should we trust staggered difference-in-differences estimates? Journal of Financial Economics 144 (2), 370–395.

Becker, G. (1957). The Economics of Discrimination. University of Chicago Press.

Bohren, J. A., K. Haggag, A. Imas, and D. G. Pope (2019). Inaccurate statistical discrimination. NBER Working Paper No. 25935.

Davis, A. J. (1996). Race, cops, and traffic stops. University of Miami Law Review 51, 425.

Davis, E., A. Whyde, and L. Langton (2018). Contacts between police and the public, 2015. US Department of Justice Office of Justice Programs Bureau of Justice Statistics Special Report, 1–33.

de Chaisemartin, C. and X. D’Haultfoeuille (2020). Two-way fixed effects estimators with heterogeneous treatment effects. American Economic Review 110 (9), 2964–96.

DeAngelo, G. and B. Hansen (2014). Life and death in the fast lane: Police enforcement and traffic fatalities. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 6 (2), 231–57.

Fryer, R. G. (2019). An empirical analysis of racial differences in police use of force. Journal of Political Economy 127(3), 1210-1261.

Gardner, J. (2022). Two-stage differences in differences. Working paper. https://arxiv.org/abs/2207.05943.

Garrett, T. and G. A. Wagner (2009). Red ink in the rearview mirror: Local fiscal conditions and the issuance of traffic tickets. Journal of Law and Economics 52 (1), 71-90.

Goncalves, F. and S. Mello (2021). A few bad apples? Racial bias in policing. American Economic Review 111 (5), 1406–41.

Goodman-Bacon, A. (2021). Difference-in-differences with variation in treatment timing. Journal of Econometrics 225 (2), 254–277.

Grogger, J. and G. Ridgeway (2006). Testing for racial profiling in traffic stops from behind a veil of darkness. Journal of the American Statistical Association 101 (475), 878-887.

Harris, D. A. (1996). Driving while black and all other traffic offenses: The supreme court and pretextual traffic stops. The Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology 87, 544.

Hecker, S. (1996). Race and pretextual traffic stops: An expanded role for civilian review boards. Columbia Human Rights Law Review 28, 551.

Hoekstra, M. and C. Sloan (2022). Does race matter for police use of force? Evidence from 911 calls. American Economic Review 112 (3), 827–60.

Horrace, W. and S. M. Rohlin (2016). How dark is dark Bright lights, big city, racial profiling. The Review of Economics and Statistics 98 (2), 226-232.

Kalinowski, J., S. Ross, and M. Ross (2017). Endogenous driving behavior in veil of darkness tests for racial profiling. Working Paper 2017-03, University of Connecticut, Department of Economics.

Kentucky State Police (2023). Collision Data. Retrieved from http://crashinformationky.org/ in June 2023.

Knowles, J., N. Persico, and P. Todd (2001). Racial bias in motor vehicle searches: Theory and evidence. Journal of Political Economy 109 (1), 203-232.

Louisville Metro Government (2019). Louisville Metro Open Data Portal: Uniform Citation Data. Retrieved from https://data.louisvilleky.gov/dataset/uniform-citation-data in August 2019.

Louisville Metro Government (2023a). Louisville Metro Open Data Portal: Uniform Citation Data (2012-2015). Retrieved from https://data.louisvilleky.gov/datasets/louisville-metro-ky-uniform-citation-data-2012-2015/about in June 2023.

Louisville Metro Government (2023b). Louisville Metro Open Data Portal: Uniform Citation Data (2016-2019). Retrieved from https://data.louisvilleky.gov/datasets/louisville-metro-ky-uniform-citation-data-2016-2019/about in June 2023.

Makowsky, M. D. and T. Stratmann (2009). Political economy at any speed: what determines traffic citations? American Economic Review 99 (1), 509–527.

Newey, W. and K. West (1987). A simple, positive semi-definite, heteroskedasticity and autocorrelation consistent covariance matrix. Econometrica 55 (3), 703–08.

Newey, W. and K. West (1994). Automatic lag selection in covariance matrix estimation. Review of Economic Studies 61 (4), 631–653.

O'Day, K. M. (1997). Pretextual traffic stops: Protecting our streets or racist police tactics. University of Dayton Law Review 23, 313.

Ritter, J. A. (2017). How do police use race in traffic stops and searches? Tests based on observability of race. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 135 (C), 82-98.

Rose, E. K. (2020). Who gets a second chance? effectiveness and equity in supervision of criminal offenders. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 136 (2), 1199–1253.

Schaefer, B., B. Campbell, T. Hughes, and J. Reed (2017). LMPDs wearable video system implementation: Year one report. Retrieved from https://www.louisville-police.org/Archive/ViewFile/Item/94 in September 2019.

Sklansky, D. A. (1997). Traffic stops, minority motorists, and the future of the fourth amendment. The Supreme Court Review 1997, 271-329.

StataCorp (2021). Stata statistical software: Release 17.

Sun, L. and S. Abraham (2021). Estimating dynamic treatment effects in event studies with heterogeneous treatment effects. Journal of Econometrics 225 (2), 175–199.

West, J. (2018). Racial bias in police investigations. Working paper.