Vehicle taxes as a climate policy instrument: econometric evidence from Spain

Léon-Gómez, Carlos R. and Teixidó, Jordi J. and Verde, Stefano F. (2024): Vehicle taxes as a climate policy instrument: econometric evidence from Spain.

Abstract

We study the local distortionary effects of notches in Spain’s CO2-based vehicle registration tax on the distribution of new car CO2 performance. These effects are the smoking gun of carmaker strategic behaviour and affect in turn tax revenue and CO2 emissions. Using model-level data on all car registrations in Spain 2010-2020, we apply the bunching approach to the three thresholds of the tax scheme: 120, 160, and 200 gCO2/km. We find that the tax notches strongly affected market outcomes, resulting in the sale of about 388,000 more cars (overall) at or just below the thresholds compared to the respective counterfactuals without the thresholds. This translates into about €335 million of foregone tax revenue and only very limited extra abatement of CO2 emissions. Over 90-95% of all estimated bunching took place at the first threshold (120 gCO2/km). Over 60% of all estimated bunching took place before 2015. Bunching diminished over time, which reflects diminished effectiveness of the tax in both reducing CO2 emissions and generating revenue. Taking the interactions with both EU vehicle emission standards and similar CO2-related policies in other Member States into consideration is important for interpreting these results.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: CO2-based vehicle taxes, Notches, Bunching, Carmakers, Strategic behaviour, Emissions, Tax revenue, Policy interactions
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H23 - Externalities ; Redistributive Effects ; Environmental Taxes and Subsidies; H - Public Economics > H3 - Fiscal Policies and Behavior of Economic Agents > H30 - General; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q58 - Government Policy

References

Anderson, S.T. and J.M. Sallee (2016), Designing policies to make cars greener, Annual Review of Resource Economics, 8, 157-180.

Chetty, R., Friedman, J.N., Olsen, T. and L. Pistaferri (2011), Adjustment costs, firm responses, and micro vs. macro labor supply, Econometrica, 80, 969-1018.

Craglia, M. and J. Cullen (2019), Do technical improvements lead to real efficiency gains? Disaggregating changes in transport energy intensity, Energy Policy, 134, 110991.

Dornoff, J., Valverde Morales, V. and U. Tietge (2024), CO2 emissions from new passenger cars in Europe: car manufacturers’ performance in 2022, Briefing, The International Council on Clean Transportation.

EEA (2024), EEA greenhouse gases – data viewer, European Environment Agency, at: https://www.eea.europa.eu/en/analysis/maps-and charts/greenhouse-gases-viewer-data-viewers

EC (2019), Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, The European Council, The Council, The European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions, The European Green Deal, COM/2019/640 final, 11 December 2019.

EP (2009), Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council setting emission performance standards for new passenger cars as part of the Community’s integrated approach to reduce CO2 emissions from light-duty vehicles, Regulation (EC) 443/2009, 23 April 2009.

EP (2011), Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council setting emission performance standards for new light commercial vehicles as part of the Union’s integrated approach to reduce CO2 emissions from light-duty vehicles, Regulation (EU) 510/2011, 11 May 2011.

EP (2019), Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council setting CO2 emission performance standards for new passenger cars and for new light commercial vehicles, and repealing Regulations (EC) No 443/2009 and (EU) No 510/2011, Regulation (EU) 2019/631, 17 April 2019.

EP (2021), Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing the framework for achieving climate neutrality and amending Regulations (EC) No 401/2009 and (EU) 2018/1999 (‘European Climate Law’), Regulation (EU) 2021/1119, 30 June 2021.

EP (2023), Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Regulation (EU) 2019/631 as regards strengthening the CO2 emission performance standards for new passenger cars and new light commercial vehicles in line with the Union’s increased climate ambition, Regulation (EU) 2023/851, 19 April 2023.

German, J. and D. Meszler (2010), Best practice for feebate program design and implementation, International Council on Clean Transportation, Washington DC.

Goulder, L.H., Jacobsen, M.R. and A.A. van Benthem (2012), Unintended consequences from nested state and federal regulations: the case of the Pavley greenhouse-gas-per-mile limits, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 63, 187-207.

Goulder, L.H. and R.N. Stavins (2011), Challenges from state federal interactions in US climate change policy, American Economic Review: Papers and Proceedings, 101(3), 253-257.

Greene, D.L., Patterson P.D., Singh, M. and J. Li (2005), Feebates, rebates and gas-guzzler taxes: a study of incentives for increased fuel economy, Energy Policy, 33, 757-775.

Hart, R., Kyriakopoulou, E. and T. Lu (2024), Urban transport policies and net zero emissions in the European Union, Annual Review of Resource Economics, 16, 1-20.

IMF (2024), A comprehensive climate mitigation strategy for Mexico, IMF Working Paper WP/21/246, International Monetary Fund.

Kessler, L., Morvillier, F. Perrier, Q. and K. Rucheton (2023), An ex ante evaluation of the French car feebate, Energy Policy, 173, 11335.

Kleven, H.J. (2016), Bunching, Annual Review of Economics, 8, 435-464.

Kleven, H.J. and M. Waseem (2013), Using notches to uncover optimization frictions and structural elasticities: theory and evidence from Pakistan, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 669-723.

Klier, T. and J. Linn (2012), New-vehicle characteristics and the cost of the Corporate Average Fuel Economy standards, The RAND Journal of Economics, 43(1), 186-213.

Klier, T. and J. Linn (2015), Using taxes to reduce carbon dioxide emissions rates of new passenger vehicles: evidence from France, Germany, and Sweden, American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 7(1), 212-242.

Knittel, C. (2012), Automobiles on steroids: product attribute trade offs and technological progress in the automobile sector, American Economic Review, 101, 3368-3399.

Linn, J. and V. McConnell (2019), Interactions between federal and state policies for reducing vehicle emissions, Energy Policy, 126, 507-517.

Liu, C., Greene, D.L. and D.S. Bunch (2014), Vehicle manufacturer technology adoption and pricing strategies under fuel economy/emissions standards and feebates, The Energy Journal, 35, 3, 71-89.

Liu, C., Cooke, E.C., Greene, D.L., and D.S. Bunch (2011), Feebates and fuel economy standards – Impacts on fuel use in light-duty vehicles and greenhouse gas emissions, Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2252, 23–30.

Noussan, M., Hafner, M., and S. Tagliapietra (2020), Policies to decarbonise the transport sector, in Noussan, M., Hafner, M., and S. Tagliapietra (eds.), The future of transport between digitalization and decarbonization – Trends, strategies and effects on energy consumption, Springer.

Parry, I., Walls, M. and W. Harrington (2007), Automobile externalities and policies, Journal of Economic Literature, XLV, 373-399.

Ramji, A., Sperling, D. and L. Fulton (2024), Sustainable market incentives: lessons from European feebates for a ZEV future, Mimeo.

Saez, E. (2010), Do taxpayers bunch at kink points?, American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 2, 180-212.

Sallee, J. (2011), The taxation of fuel economy, Tax Policy and the Economy, 25, 1-37.

Sallee, J. and J. Slemrod (2012), Car notches: strategic automaker responses to fuel economy policy, Journal of Public Economics, 96, 981-999.

Slemrod, J. (2013), Buenas notches: lines and notches in tax system design, eJournal of Tax Research, 11(3), 259-283.

Tanaka, S. (2020), When tax incentives drive illicit behavior: the manipulation of fuel economy in the automobile industry, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 104, 102367.

Turano, E. and T. Van Ierland (2024), Climate-related regulations in the field of energy, transport, F-gases and methane, in: Delbeke, J. (ed.), Delivering a climate neutral Europe, Routledge.

Whitefoot, K.S., Fowlie, M.L. and S.J. Skerlos (2017), Compliance by design: influence of acceleration tradeoffs on CO2 emissions and costs of fuel economy and greenhouse gas regulations, Environmental Science and Technology, 51(18), 10307-10315.