What are asset price bubbles? A survey on definitions of financial bubbles

Baumann, Michael Heinrich and Janischewski, Anja (2025): What are asset price bubbles? A survey on definitions of financial bubbles.

Abstract

Financial bubbles and crashes have repeatedly caused economic turmoil notably but not only during the 2008 financial crisis. However, both in the popular press as well as scientific publications, the meaning of bubble is sometimes unspecified. Due to the multitude of bubble definitions, we conduct a systematic review with the following questions: What definitions of asset price bubbles exist in the literature? Which definitions are used in which disciplines and how frequently? We develop a system of definition categories and categorize a total of 122 papers from eleven research areas. Our results show that although one definition is indeed prevalent in the literature, the overall definition landscape is not uniform. Next to the mostly used definition as deviation from a present value of expected future cash flows, we identify several other definitions, which rely on price properties or other specifications of a fundamental value. This research contributes by shedding light on the possible variations in which bubbles are defined and operationalized.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: asset price bubble; fad; financial crisis; local martingale; fundamental analysis
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G0 - General > G01 - Financial Crises; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G12 - Asset Pricing ; Trading Volume ; Bond Interest Rates; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G14 - Information and Market Efficiency ; Event Studies ; Insider Trading; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G18 - Government Policy and Regulation

References

Abreu D, Brunnermeier M. 2003. Bubbles and Crashes. Econometrica 71(1):173–204

Acharya V, Naqvi H. 2012. The Seeds of a Crisis: A Theory of Bank Liquidity and Risk Taking over the Business Cycle. Journal of Financial Economics 106(2):349– 366

Adland R, Haiying J, Strandenes S. 2006. Asset Bubbles in Shipping? An Analysis of Recent History in the Drybulk Market Maritime Economics & Logistics 8:223–233

Allen F, Morris S, Postlewaite A. 1993. Finite Bubbles with Short Sales Constraints and Asymmetric Information. Journal of Economic Theory 61(2):206–229

Allen F, Carletti E. 2013. Systemic risk from real estate and macro-prudential reg- ulation International Journal of Banking, Accounting and Finance 5(1-2):28–48

Aliber RZ and Kindleberger CP. 2015. Manias, Panics, and Crashes: A History of Financial Crises. Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke Ambrose B W, Eichholtz P, Lindenthal T. 2013. House Prices and Fundamentals: 355 Years of Evidence. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 45(2-3):477–491

Barberis N, Greenwood R, Jin L, Shleifer A. 2018. Extrapolation and bubbles. Jour- nal of Financial Economics 129(2):203–227

Barberis N. 2018. Psychology-based Models of Asset Prices and Trading Volume. In: Handbook of Behavioral Economics: Applications and Foundations 1 (1):79–175. North-Holland.

Barlevy G. 2007. Economic Theory and Asset Bubbles. Economic perspectives. Fed- eral Reserve Bank of Chicago Third Quater 2007:44–59

Başoğlu Kabran F and Ünlü KD. 2021. A Two-Step Machine Learning Approach to Predict S&P 500 Bubbles. Journal of Applied Statistics 48(13-15):2776–2794

Baur D G, Glover K J. 2014. Heterogeneous Expectations in the Gold Market: Specification and Estimation. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 40:116– 133

Beja A and Goldman MB. 1980. On the Dynamic Behavior of Prices in Disequilib- rium. The Journal of Finance 35(2):235–248

Biagini F, Föllmer H, Nedelcu S. 2014. Shifting Martingale Measures and the Birth of a Bubble as a Submartingale. Finance and Stochastics 18(2):297–326

Biagini F, Nedelcu S. 2015. The Formation of Financial Bubbles in Defaultable Markets. SIAM Journal on Financial Mathematics 6(1):530–558

Bialkowski J, Bohl MT, Stephan PM, Wisniewski TP. 2015. The Gold Price in Times of Crisis. International Review of Financial Analysis 41:329–339

Biondo AE, Pluchino A, Rapisarda A, Helbing D. 2013. Reducing Financial Avalanches by Random Investments. Physical Review E 88(6):062814

Blanchard OJ, Watson MW. 1982. Bubbles, Rational Expectations and Financial Markets. NBER Working Paper w0945

Bourassa S C, Hendershott, P H, Murphy J. 2001. Further Evidence on the Existence of Housing Market Bubbles. Journal of Property Research 18(1):1–19

Brée D S, Joseph N L. 2013. Testing for Financial Crashes Using the Log Periodic Power Law Model. International Review of Financial Analysis 30:287–297

Brunnermeier M K, Oehmke M. 2013. Bubbles, financial crises, and systemic risk. Handbook of the Economics of Finance 2: 1221–1288

Brzezicka J. 2020. Towards a Typology of Housing Price Bubbles: A Literature Review. Housing, Theory and Society 1–23

Caballero R, Krishnamurthy A. 2006. Bubbles and Capital Flow Volatility: Causes and Risk Management. Journal of Monetary Economy 53(1):35–53

Cajueiro D O, Tabak B M, Werneck F K. 2009. Can We Predict Crashes? The Case of the Brazilian Stock Market. Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applica- tions 388(8):1603–1609

Camerer C. 1989. Bubbles and Fads in Asset Prices. Journal of Economic Surveys 3(1):3–41

Campbell S D, Davis M A, Gallin J, Martin R F. 2009. What Moves Housing Mar- kets: A Variance Decomposition of the Rent-Price Ratio. Journal of Urban Eco- nomics 66(2):90–102

Carter C A, Rausser G C, Smith A. 2011. Commodity Booms and Busts. Annual Review of Resource Economics 3(1):87–118

Cheung S L, Palan, S. 2012. Two heads are less bubbly than one: team decision- making in an experimental asset market. Experimental Economics 15(3):373–397

Chiarella C, Dieci R, He X Z. 2009. Heterogeneity, Market Mechanisms, and Asset Price Dynamics. Handbook of financial markets: Dynamics and evolution, North- Holland 277–344

Clark G L, Durán-Fernández R, Strauss K. 2010. ‘Being in the market’: the UK house-price bubble and the intended structure of individual pension investment portfolios. Journal of Economic Geography 10(3):331–359

Clement D. 2007. Interview with Eugene Fama. The Region; 2 Novem- ber 2007 resp. 1 December 2007 https://www.minneapolisfed.org/article/ 2007/interview-with-eugene-fama Checked: 20 September 2022

Cogley T. 1999. Should the Fed take Deliberate Steps to Deflate Asset Price Bubbles? Economic Review. Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco 1:42–52 Conlon J. 2004. Simple Finite Horizon Bubbles Robust to Higher Order Knowledge. Econometrica 72(3):927–936

Cox A, Hobson D G. 2005. Local Martingales, Bubbles and Option Prices. Finance and Stochastics 9(4):477–492

Criens D. 2020. No Arbitrage in Continuous Financial Markets. Mathematics and Financial Economics 14:461–506

Criens DBM. 2020. Essays on Stochastic Processes and their Applications. Doctoral thesis, Technische Universität München

Day R H, Huang W. 1990. Bulls, Bears and Market Sheep. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 14(3):299–329

Delbaen F, Schachermayer W. 1994. A General Version of the Fundamental Theorem of Asset Pricing. Mathematical Annals 300:463–520

Delbaen F, Schachermayer W. 1998. The Fundamental Theorem of Asset Pricing for Unbounded Stochastic Processes. Mathematical Annals 312:215–250

Delbaen F, Schachermayer W. 2004. What is . . . a Free Lunch? Notices of the AMS 51(5):526–528

De Long JB, Shleifer A, Summers L, Waldmann R. 1990. Noise Trader Risk in Financial Markets. Journal of Political Economy 98(4):703–738

Diamond P. 1965. National Debt in a Neoclassical Growth Model. Part 1. American Economic Review 55(5):1126–1150

Diba BT, Grossman HI. 1988. The Theory of Rational Bubbles in Stock Prices. The Economic Journal 98(392):746–754

Doblas-Madrid A. 2012. A Robust Model of Bubbles with Multidimensional Uncer- tainty. Econometrica 80(5):1845–1883

Downarowicz A. 2010. The First Fundamental Theorem of Asset Pricing. Revista de Economı́a Financiera 21:23–35

Dreger C, Zhang Y. 2013. Is there a bubble in the Chinese housing market? Urban Policy and Research 31(1):27–39

Elsner W, Heinrich T, Schwardt H. 2014. The microeconomics of complex economies: Evolutionary, institutional, neoclassical, and complexity perspectives. Academic Press.

Engsted T. 2016. Fama on Bubbles. Journal of Economic Surveys 30(2):370–376 Evans G W. 1986. A test for speculative bubbles in the sterling-dollar exchange rate: 1981-84. The American Economic Review 621–636

Fama E F. 1970. Efficient Capital Markets: A Review of Theory and Empirical Work. Journal of Finance 25(2):383–417

Fama EF. 2013. Price Lecture. The Nobel Prize https://www.nobelprize.org/ prizes/economic-sciences/2013/fama/lecture/

Fama E F. 2014. Two pillars of asset pricing. American Economic Review 104(6):1467–1485

Farhi E, Tirole J. 2012. Bubbly Liquidity. Review of Economic Studies 79(2):678–706

Franke R, Westerhoff F. 2016. Why a Simple Herding Model may Generate the Styl- ized Facts of Daily Returns: Explanation and Estimation. Journal of Economic Interaction and Coordination 11(1):1–34

Friede G, Busch T, Bassen A. 2015. ESG and Financial Performance: Aggregated Evidence from more than 2000 Empirical Studies. Journal of Sustainable Finance & Investment 5(4):210–233

Friedman D, Abraham R. 2009. Bubbles and Crashes: Gradient Dynamics in Finan- cial Markets. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 33(4):922–937

Fry J, Cheah E-T. 2016. Negative Bubbles and Shocks in Cryptocurrency Markets. International Review of Financial Analysis 47:343–352

Gallant C. 2021. How Are Book Value and Intrinsic Value Different? Investope- dia, https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/05/bookvintrinsic.asp, checked: 2024-02-20

Garber PM. 2001. Famous First Bubbles: The Fundamentals of Early Manias. The MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, London, England

Girdzijauskas S, Štreimikienė D. 2009. Application of Logistic Models for Stock Mar- ket Bubbles Analysis. Journal of Business Economics and Management 10(1):45– 51

Glaeser E L, Nathanson C G. 2015. Housing Bubbles. In: Handbook of regional and urban economics, Elsevier 5:701–751

Greenwood R, Shleifer A, You Y. 2019. Bubbles for Fama. Journal of Financial Economics 131:20–43

Guasoni P, Rásonyi M, Schachermayer W. 2010. The Fundamental Theorem of As- set Pricing for Continuous Processes under Small Transaction Costs. Annals of Finance 6(2):157–191

Gusenbauer M, Haddaway N R. 2020. Which academic search systems are suitable for systematic reviews or meta-analyses? Evaluating retrieval qualities of Google Scholar, PubMed, and 26 other resources. Research synthesis methods 11(2):181– 217

Gürkaynak R S. 2008. Econometric tests of asset price bubbles: taking stock. Journal of Economic surveys 22(1):166–186

Harras G, Sornette D. 2011. How to grow a bubble: A model of myopic adapting agents. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 80(1):137–152

Haruvy E, Lahav Y, Noussair C. 2007. Traders’ expectations in asset markets: ex- perimental evidence. American Economic Review 97(5):1901–1920

Hayashi F. 1982. Tobin’s Marginal q and Average q: A Neoclassical Interpretation. Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society 50(1):213–224

Hayes A. 2023. Book Value: Definition, Meaning, Formula, and Examples. Investope- dia, https://www.investopedia.com/terms/b/bookvalue.asp, checked: 2024- 02-20

Hirota S, Sunder S. 2016. Price bubbles sans dividend anchors: Evidence from lab- oratory stock markets. In: Behavioral Interactions, Markets, and Economic Dy- namics Springer, Tokyo. 357–395

Hommes C. 2006. Heterogeneous Agent Models in Economics and Finance. Handbook of Computational Economics 2:1109–1186

Hommes C. 2021. Behavioral and experimental macroeconomics and policy analysis: A complex systems approach. Journal of Economic Literature 59(1):149–219

Horst U. 2005. Financial price fluctuations in a stock market model with many interacting agents. Economic Theory 25(4):917–932

Hott C. 2009. Herding behavior in asset markets. Journal of Financial Stability 5(1):35–56

Jarrow RA, Protter P, Shimbo K. 2010. Asset Price Bubbles in Incomplete Markets. Mathematical Finance: An International Journal of Mathematics, Statistics and Financial Economics 20(2):145–185 Jarrow RA, Larsson M. 2012. The Meaning of Market Efficiency. Mathematical Finance 22(1):1–30

Jarrow R A, Protter P, Roch A F. 2012. A liquidity-based model for asset price bubbles. Quantitative Finance 12(9):1339–1349

Jarrow RA. 2015. Asset Price Bubbles. Annual Review of Financial Economics 7:201–218

Jarrow RA. 2016. Testing for Asset Price Bubbles: Three New Approaches. Quan- titative Finance Letters 4(1):4–9

Jiang Z-Q, Zhou W-X, Sornette D, Woodard R, Bastiaensen K, Cauwels P. 2010. Bubble diagnosis and prediction of the 2005-2007 and 2008-2009 Chinese stock market bubbles. Journal of economic behavior & organization, 74(3):149–162

Johansen A. Characterization of Large Price Variations in Financial Markets. Phys- ica A 324:157–166

Johansen A, Ledoit O, Sornette D. 2000. Crashes as critical points. International Journal of Theoretical and Applied Finance 3(02):219–255

Juvenal L, Petrella I. 2015. Speculation in the oil market. Journal of applied econo- metrics 30(4):621–649

Kaizoji T. 2000. Speculative Bubbles and Crashes in Stock Markets: An Interacting- Agent Model of Speculative Activity. Physica A 287:493–506

Kindleberger CP. 1978. Manias, Panics, and Crashes New York: Basic Books

Kindleberger CP. 1996. Manias, Panics, and Crashes: A History of Financial Crises Wiley

Kindleberger CP, Aliber RZ. 2005. Manias, Panics, and Crashes: A History of Fi- nancial Crises Wiley

Aliber RZ, Kindleberger CP, RN McCauley. 2023. Manias, Panics, and Crashes: A History of Financial Crises Wiley

Komarek L, Kubicová I. 2011. The Classification and Identification of Asset Price Bubbles. Czech Journal of Economics and Finance (Finance a Uver) 61(1):34–48

Kyriazis N, Papadamou S, Corbet S. 2020. A Systematic Review of the Bubble Dy- namics of Cryptocurrency Prices. Research in International Business and Finance 101254

Lei V, Noussair C N, Plott C R. 2001. Nonspeculative bubbles in experimental asset markets: Lack of common knowledge of rationality vs. actual irrationality. Econometrica 69(4):831–859

Lee CM, Myers J, Swaminathan B. 1999. What is the Intrinsic Value of the Dow? The Journal of Finance 54(5):1693–1741

Loewenstein M, Willard GA. 2000. Rational Equilibrium Asset-Pricing Bubbles in Continuous Trading Models. Journal of Economic Theory 91(1):17–58

Martin A, Ventura J. 2018. The Macroeconomics of Rational Bubbles: A User’s Guide. Annual Review of Economics 10(1):505–539

Malkiel BG. 1989. Efficient Market Hypothesis. In: Eatwell J, Milgate M, Newman P (eds): Finance. The New Palgrave. Palgrave Macmillan, London

Malkiel BG. Reflections on the Efficient Market Hypothesis: 30 Years Later. Finan- cial Review, 40(1):1–9

Mas-Colell A, Whinston M D, Green J R. 1995. Microeconomic theory (Vol. 1). New York: Oxford university press.

Miao J, Wang P, Xu Z. 2015. A Bayesian dynamic stochastic general equilibrium model of stock market bubbles and business cycles. Quantitative Economics, 6:599–635

Milgrom P, Stokey N. 1982. Information, Trade, and Common Knowledge. Journal of Economic Theory 26(1):991–1009

Noussair C N, Robin S, Ruffieux B. 2001. Price bubbles in laboratory asset markets with constant fundamental values. Experimental Economics 4:87–105

Ozgur O, Yilanci V, Ozbugday FC. 2021. Detecting Speculative Bubbles in Metal Prices: Evidence from GSADF Test and Machine Learning Approaches. Resources Policy 74:102306

Page M J, McKenzie J E, Bossuyt P M, Boutron I, Hoffmann T C, Mulrow C D, ... and Moher D. 2021. The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. bmj, 372

Palan S. 2013. A review of bubbles and crashes in experimental asset markets. Jour- nal of Economic surveys 27(3): 570–588

Phillips P, Wu Y, Yu J. 2011. Explosive behavior in the 1990s Nasdaq, when did exuberance escalate asset values? International Economic Review 52:201–206

Phillips PC, Yu J. 2011. Dating the timeline of financial bubbles during the subprime crisis. Quantitative Economics 2(3):455–491

Phillips P C, Shi S, Yu J. 2012. Testing for multiple bubbles.

Phillips P C, Shi S, Yu J. 2015. Testing for multiple bubbles: Historical episodes of exuberance and collapse in the S&P 500. International economic review 56(4):1043–1078

Platen E, Tappe S. 2020. The Fundamental Theorem of Asset Pricing for Self- Financing Portfolios. arXiv preprint

Platen E, Tappe S. 2021. No Arbitrage and Multiplicative Special Semimartingales arXiv preprint

Protter P. 2016. Bubbles and Crashes – Mathematical Models of Bubbles. Quanti- tative Finance Letters 4(1):10–13

Rocheteau G, Wright R. 2011. Liquidity and Asset Market Dynamics. Mimeo, Uni- versity of Wisconsin

Samuelson P. 1958. An Exact Consumption-Loan Model of Interest with or without the Social Contrivance of Money. Journal of Political Economy 66:467–482

Schatz M, Sornette D. 2020. Inefficient bubbles and efficient drawdowns in financial markets. International Journal of Theoretical and Applied Finance 23(07):2050047

Shiller R J. 2014. Speculative asset prices. American Economic Review 104(6):1486– 1517

Siegel JJ. 2003. What Is an Asset Price Bubble? An Operational Definition. Euro- pean Financial Management 9:11–24

Sin CA. 1996. Strictly Local Martingales and Hedge Ratios on Stochastic Volatility Models. PhD thesis, Cornell University

Sornette D, Johansen A, Bouchaud J P. 1996. Stock market crashes, precursors and replicas. Journal de Physique I 6(1):167–175

Sornette, D. 2003. Critical market crashes. Physics Reports 378(1):1–98

Sornette D, Cauwels P. 2014. 1980–2008: The Illusion of the Perpetual Money Ma- chine and What it Bodes for the Future. Risks 2:103–131

Sornette D, Cauwels P, Smilyanov G. 2018. Can We Use Volatility to Diagnose Financial Bubbles? Lessons from 40 Historical Bubbles. Quantitative Finance and Economics 2(1):486–594

Stöckl T, Huber J, Kirchler M. 2010. Bubble Measures in Experimental Asset Mar- kets. Experimental Economics 13(3):284–298

Summers L H. 1986. Does the stock market rationally reflect fundamental values? The Journal of Finance 41(3), 591–601

Thurner S, Farmer JD, Geanakoplos J. 2012. Leverage Causes Fat Tails and Clus- tered Volatility. Quantitative Finance 12(5):695–707

Tirole J. 1982. On the Possibility of Speculation under Rational Expectations. Econometrica 50(5):1163–1182

Tirole J. 1985. Asset Bubbles and Overlapping Generations. Econometrica 53(6):1499–1528

Tobin J. 1969. A General Equilibrium Approach to Monetary Theory. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Ohio State University Press, 1(1):15–29

Townsend B. 1980. Models of Money with Spatially Separated Agents Models of Monetary Economies. Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis

van Zanten H. 2008. Lectures on the FTAP—Notes Complementing Delbaen and Schachermayer’s Book “The Mathematics of Arbitrage”

Vissing-Jorgensen A. 2003. Perspectives on behavioral finance: Does ”irrationality” disappear with wealth? Evidence from expectations and actions. NBER macroe- conomics annual, 18:139–194

Vogel HL. 2018. Financial Market Bubbles and Crashes: Features, Causes, and Effects. Springer

Werner J. 1997. Arbitrage, Bubbles, and Valuation. International Economic Review 453–464

Wilson R. (1997). Islamic Finance and Ethical Investment. International Journal of Social Economics

Yan W, Woodard R, Sornette D. 2010. Diagnosis and Prediction of Tipping Points in Financial Markets: Crashes and Rebounds. Physics Procedia 3(5):1641–1657

Yiu M S, Yu J, Jin L. 2013. Detecting Bubbles in Hong Kong Residential Property Market. Journal of Asian Economics 28:115–124

Youssefmir M, Huberman B A, Hogg T. 1998. Bubbles and Market Crashes. Com- putational Economics 12(2):97–114

Zeeman E C. 1974. On the Unstable Behaviour of Stock Exchanges. Journal of mathematical economics 1(1):39–49

Zeng Y. 2009. Fundamental Theorem of Asset Pricing in a Nutshell: With a View toward Numéraire Change.

Zhang Q, Sornette D, Balcilar M, Gupta R, Ozdemir Z A, Yetkiner H. 2016. LPPLS Bubble Indicators over two Centuries of the S& P 500 Index. Physica A: statistical Mechanics and its Applications 458:126–139

Zhang Y J, Wang J. 2015. Exploring the WTI Crude Oil Price Bubble Process using the Markov Regime Switching Model. Physica A: Statistical mechanics and its applications, 421:377–387

Zhang Y J, Yao T. 2016. Interpreting the movement of oil prices: driven by funda- mentals or bubbles? Economic Modelling 55:226–240