The complementarity of low taxes and pro-social guidelines when polluters have moral preferences

Caffera, Marcelo and Chávez, Carlos and Lopez, Carolina and Murphy, James J and Briozzo, Juan (2025): The complementarity of low taxes and pro-social guidelines when polluters have moral preferences.

Abstract

We present the results of a series of public-bad laboratory experiments in which we assess whether a salient message suggesting pro-social behavior with an implicit moral appeal, and a tax that is insufficient to induce the optimal level of the externality, can complement each other when implemented jointly. Our results suggest that, on average, (a) behavior is consistent with subjects having moral preferences, (b) a salient message suggesting pro-social behavior can be effective, (c) preferences are non-separable from the choice of instrument (i.e, the tax crowds-out part of the subjects´ moral preferences), and crucially, (d) the tax and the informative message do not complement each other. The tax has a greater impact on reducing the externality than the prosocial guideline, even though the tax was only half of that needed to reach the socially optimal level. Nevertheless, when implemented together, the total effect of both instruments is similar to that of the tax alone. This result is stronger for those subjects that are more “nudgeable” by the prosocial guideline. These results challenge the policy recommendation that nudges can effectively complement low taxes while awaiting the political will to raise them.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Economic experiment, nudge, prosocial guideline, public bad, tax
• Subjects: Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q58 - Government Policy

References

Allcott, H. and Kessler, J. B. (2019). “The Welfare Effects of Nudges: A Case Study of Energy Use Social Comparisons.” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 11 (1): 236-76.

Ambec, S., Andersson, H., Cezera, S., Kanay, A., Ouvrard, B., Panzone, L. and Simon, S. (2024). “Taxing and nudging to reduce carbon emissions: Results from an online shopping experiment.” Working Paper

Andreoni, J. (1990). Impure Altruism and Donations to Public Goods: A Theory of Warm-Glow Giving. The Economic Journal, 100(401), 464–477.

Antinyan, A., Horváth, G., & Jia, M. (2020). Curbing the consumption of positional goods: Behavioral interventions versus taxation. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 179, 1-21.

Bandura, A. (1991). Social cognitive theory of moral thought and action. In W. M. Kurtines & J. L. Gewirtz (Eds.), Handbook of moral behavior and development (Vol. 1, pp. 45-103). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

Bicchieri, C., & Dimant, E. (2022). Nudging with care: The risks and benefits of social information. Public choice, 191(3-4), 443-464.

Blanchard, O., Gollier, C., & Tirole, J. (2023). The portfolio of economic policies needed to fight climate change. Annual Review of Economics, 15(1), 689-722.

Bowles, S., and S. Polania-Reyes (2012). “Economic incentives and social preferences: substitutes or complements?” Journal of Economic Literature, 50(2), 368-425.

Bucholz, M., & Musshoff, O. (2021). Tax or green nudge? An experimental analysis of pesticide policies in Germany. European Review of Agricultural Economics, 48(4), 940-982.

Buckley, P., & Llerena, D. (2022). Nudges and peak pricing: A common pool resource energy conservation experiment. Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics, 101, 101928.

Carattini, S., Carvalho, M., & Fankhauser, S. (2018). Overcoming public resistance to carbon taxes. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change, 9(5), e531.

Carlsson, F. and O. Johansson-Stenman (2019). “Optimal Prosocial Nudging.” Working Paper in Economics No 757, Department of Economics, University of Gothenburg.

Carlsson, F., Gravert, C., Johansson-Stenman, O., & Kurz, V. (2021). The use of green nudges as an environmental policy instrument. Review of Environmental Economics and Policy, 15(2), 216-237

Cherry, T. L., Kallbekken, S., & Kroll, S. (2014). The impact of trial runs on the acceptability of environmental taxes: Experimental evidence. Resource and Energy Economics, 38, 84-95.

Croson, R, and Marks, M. (2001). The Effect of Recommended Contributions in the Voluntary Provision of Public Goods. Economic Inquiry, 39, issue 2, p. 238-49

Dal Bó, E. and P. Dal Bó (2014). “"Do the right thing:" The effects of moral suasion on cooperation.” Journal of Public Economics 117: 28-38.

Deci, E. L., & Ryan, R. M. (2013). Intrinsic motivation and self-determination in human behavior. Springer Science & Business Media.

Delaney, J., & Jacobson, S. (2016). Payments or persuasion: common pool resource management with price and non-price measures. Environmental and Resource Economics, 65, 747-772.

DellaVigna, S., & Linos, E. (2022). RCTs to scale: Comprehensive evidence from two nudge units. Econometrica, 90(1), 81-116.

Dolan, P., & Metcalfe, R. (2015). Neighbors, knowledge, and nuggets: two natural field experiments on the role of incentives on energy conservation. Becker Friedman Institute for Research in Economics Working Paper, (2589269).

Drews S., Exadaktylos F., van den Bergh J C. (2020). Assessing synergy of incentives and nudges in the energy policy mix. Energy Policy, Volume 144, 111605, ISSN 0301-4215.

Fanghella, V., Ploner, M., & Tavoni, M. (2021). Energy saving in a simulated environment: An online experiment of the interplay between nudges and financial incentives. Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics, 93, 101709.

Frank, R. H., Gilovich, T., & Regan, D. T. (1993). Does studying economics inhibit cooperation? Journal of Economic Perspectives, 7(2), 159-171.

Frey, B.S. (1992). Tertium Datur: Pricing, Regulating and Intrinsic Motivation. Kyklos, 45(2), 161-184.

Frey, B. S., & Meier, S. (2003). Are political economists selfish and indoctrinated? Evidence from a natural experiment. Economic Inquiry, 41(3), 448-462.

Frey, B. S., & Oberholzer-Gee, F. (1997). The cost of price incentives: An empirical analysis of motivation crowding-out. The American economic review, 87(4), 746-755.

Frey, B. S., and A. Stutzer (2008). "Environmental Morale and Motivation." In The Cambridge Handbook of Psychology and Economic Behaviour, edited by Alan Lewis, 406-28. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press.

Gravert, C., & Olsson Collentine, L. (2021). When nudges aren’t enough: Norms, incentives and habit formation in public transport usage. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 190, 1–14. htps://doi.org/10.1016/j.jebo.2021.07.012

Hahn, R. W. and Hendren, N. and Metcalfe, R. and Sprung-Keyser, B., 2024. “A Welfare Analysis of Policies Impacting Climate Change”. NBER Working Paper No. w32728, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4908545

Hernández, F., Jaime, M., and F. Vásquez (2024). Nudges versus prices: Lessons and challenges from a water-savings program. Energy Economics 134: 107546.

Hilton, D., L. Charalambides, C. Demarque, L. Waroquier and C. Raux (2014), "A Tax Can Nudge: The Impact of an Environmentally Motivated Bonus/Malus Fiscal System on Transport Preferences," Journal of Economic Psychology, 42, 17-27.

Ito, Koichiro, Takanori Ida, and Makoto Tanaka. 2018. "Moral Suasion and Economic Incentives: Field Experimental Evidence from Energy Demand." American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 10 (1): 240-6

Johansson, O. (1997). Optimal Pigovian taxes under altruism. Land Economics, 297-308.

Levitt, S. and J. List (2007). “What Do Laboratory Experiments Measuring Social Preferences Reveal about the Real World?” Journal of Economic Perspectives 21(2): 153-174.

Lilliestam, J., Patt, A., & Bersalli, G. (2021). The effect of carbon pricing on technological change for full energy decarbonization: A review of empirical ex‐post evidence. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change, 12(1), e681.

López, M. C., J. Murphy, J. Spraggon and J. Stranlund (2012). “Comparing the Effectiveness of Regulation and Pro‐Social Emotions to Enhance Cooperation: Experimental Evidence from Fishing Communities in Colombia.” Economic Inquiry 50(1): 131-142.

Mackay, M., Yamazaki, S., Jennings, S., Sibly, H., van Putten, I. E., & Emery, T. J. (2019). The influence of nudges on compliance behaviour in recreational fisheries: a laboratory experiment. ICES Journal of Marine Science, 77(6), 2319-2332.

Maris, R., Dorner, Z., & Carlsson, F. (2024). Nudges and Monetary Incentives: A Green Partnership? Working Papers in Economics 842, University of Gothenburg, Department of Economics.

Marks, M.B., Schansberg, D.E. and Croson, R.T.A. (1999) ‘Using Suggested Contributions in Fundraising for Public Good’, Nonprofit Management & Leadership, 9(4), p. 369. doi:10.1002/nml.9403.

Mertens, S., Herberz, M., Hahnel, U. J., & Brosch, T. (2022). The effectiveness of nudging: A meta-analysis of choice architecture interventions across behavioral domains. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 119(1), e2107346118.

Mizobuchi, K., & Takeuchi, K. (2013). The influences of financial and non-financial factors on energy-saving behaviour: A field experiment in Japan. Energy Policy, 63, 775-787.

My B. and B. Ouvrard (2019). "Nudge and Tax in an Environmental Public Goods Experiment: Does Environmental Sensitivity Matter?" Resource and Energy Economics, 55, 24-48.

Nakagawa, M., Lefebvre, M., & Stenger, A. (2022). Long-lasting effects of incentives and social preference: A public goods experiment. Plos one, 17(8), e0273014.

Panzone, L., A. Ulph, D. Zizzo, D. Hilton and A. Clear (2021). “The impact of environmental recall and carbon taxation on the carbon footprint of supermarket shopping.” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 102137.

Romaniuc, R. (2016). What makes law to change behavior? An experimental study. Review of Law & Economics, 12(2), 447-475. Rubinstein, A. (2006). A Sceptic's Comment on the Study of Economics. The Economic Journal, 116(510), C1-C9.

Schall, D. L., Wolf, M., & Mohnen, A. (2016). Do effects of theoretical training and rewards for energy-efficient behavior persist over time and interact? A natural field experiment on eco-driving in a company fleet. Energy Policy, 97, 291-300.

Schwartz, S. H. (1977). Normative influences on altruism. In Advances in experimental social psychology (Vol. 10, pp. 221-279). Academic Press.

Spraggon J, J. Oxoby R (2010). Ambient-Based Policy Instruments: The Role of Recommendations and Presentation. Agricultural and Resource Economics Review. 2010;39(2):262-274.

Stern, P.C. (1999). Information, Incentives, and Proenvironmental Consumer Behavior. Journal of Consumer Policy 22, 461–478. Sterner, T., & Coria, J. (2013). Policy instruments for environmental and natural resource management. Routledge.

Sterner, T., Ewald, J., & Sterner, E. (2024). Economists and the climate. Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics, 109, 102158.

Stiglitz, J., Barrett, S., & Kaufman, N. (2024). How Economics Can Tackle the ‘Wicked Problem’of Climate Change.

Sudarshan A. (2017). Nudges in the marketplace: The response of household electricity consumption to information and monetary incentives. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, Volume 134, Pages 320-335, ISSN 0167-2681.

Sunstein, Cass and Thaler, Richard. (2008). NUDGE: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness. Penguin Books. Sunstein, Cass. (2014). Nudging: a very short guide. The Handbook of Privacy Studies, 173-180.

Szaszi, B., Palinkas, A., Palfi, B., Szollosi, A., & Aczel, B. (2018). A systematic scoping review of the choice architecture movement: Toward understanding when and why nudges work. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 31(3), 355-366.

Szaszi, B., Higney, A., Charlton, A., Gelman, A., Ziano, I., Aczel, B., ... & Tipton, E. (2022). No reason to expect large and consistent effects of nudge interventions. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 119(31), e2200732119.

van den Bergh, J., and Savin, I. (2021). Impact of carbon pricing on low-carbon innovation and deep decarbonisation: controversies and path forward. Environmental and Resource Economics, 80(4), 705-715.

Xu, L., Ling, M., & Wu, Y. (2018). Economic incentive and social influence to overcome household waste separation dilemma: A field intervention study. Waste management, 77, 522-531.