Why Do Firms Choose to Greenwash: An Evolutionary Analysis of Greenwashing Incentives and Deterrents

Ille, Sebastian and Carrera, Edgar J. Sanchez (2025): Why Do Firms Choose to Greenwash: An Evolutionary Analysis of Greenwashing Incentives and Deterrents. Published in: Macroeconomic Dynamics , Vol. 29, No. e140 (12 September 2025): pp. 1-20.

Abstract

With the increasing demand for sustainable products, greenwashing has become more prevalent and sophisticated over the past decade. To better understand the incentives for firms to greenwash, we develop an evolutionary game-theoretic model in which firms may choose to mimic green behavior without having to bear the cost linked to green investment and production. We provide the conditions for the different evolutionarily stable equilibria. In a second step, we extend the model using agent-based simulations to incorporate path-dependent investment/production costs, history-dependent mimicry effectiveness, peer effects, and localized firm interactions. We show that the simpler model with random matching offers good approximations of the equilibrium conditions in more complex setups, but market segmentation supports green investment and production in contrast to higher penalties. While curtailing opportunities to pretend green behavior boosts green production, we also find that increasing cost efficiencies encourage firms to engage in green production, even in the face of increasingly sophisticated deceptive strategies. Based on our results, we suggest trio-targeted policies that reduce the (initial) costs of green investment/production, curtail opportunities to mimic green behavior, and support segmentation.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: climate change; non-linear macroeconomic models; greenwashing; corporate sustainability
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C7 - Game Theory and Bargaining Theory; D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics

References

Abdul Wahab, E.A., M.F. Jamaludin, D. Agustia and I. Harymawan. (2020). Director networks, political connections, and earnings quality in Malaysia. Management and Organization Review 16(3), 687–724. Agi, M.A.N., S. Faramarzi-Oghani and Ö. Hazır. (2021). Game theory-based models in green supply chain management: A review of the literature. International Journal of Production Research 59(15), 4736–4755. Al Ani, M.K. and K. Chavali. (2023). The relationship between investment intensity and profitability measures from the perspective of foreign investors. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 10(76). https://www.nature.com/ articles/s41599-023-01571-8. Alebrahim, E. and M. Alnahedh. (2024). Corporate network formation in kuwait: board interlocks network analysis using exponential random graph models. Corporate Governance: The International Journal of Business in Society 24(7), 1638– 1662. Bacchiocchi, A., S. Ille and G. Giombini. (2024). The effects of a green monetary policy on firms financing cost. Journal of Economic Interaction and Coordination 19(4), 727–757. Barabási, A.-L. and R. Albert. (1999). Emergence of scaling in random networks. Science 286(5439), 509–512. Baum, J.A.C., R. Cowan and N. Jonard. (2010). Network-independent partner selection and the evolution of innovation networks. Management Science 56(11), 2094–2110. Bernini, F., M. Giuliani and F. La Rosa. (2024). Measuring greenwashing: a systematic methodological literature review. Business Ethics, the Environment & Responsibility 33(4), 649–667. Besley, T. and T. Persson. (2023). The political economics of green transitions∗. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 138(3), 1863–1906. Cai, J., H. Sun, J. Shang and G.G. Hegde. (2023). Information structure selection in a green supply chain: impacts of wholesale price and greenness level. European Journal of Operational Research 306(1), 34–46. Carmona, R. and F. Delarue. (2018). Learning by examples: What is a mean field game? In Probabilistic Theory of Mean Field Games with Applications I. Probability Theory and Stochastic Modelling, vol. 83. Cham: Springer. Casey, W., S.E. Massey and B. Mishra. (2021). How signalling games explain mimicry at many levels: from viral epidemiology to human sociology. Journal of the Royal Society, Interface 18(175), 20200689. Chen, C., D. Jiang and W. Li. (2023). Keeping up with the csr joneses: the impact of industry peers on focal firms’ csr performance. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 10(106). Chen, M.-H., H. Wei, M. Wei, H. Huang and C.-H.J. Su. (2021). Modeling a green supply chain in the hotel industry: an evolutionary game theory approach. International Journal of Hospitality Management 92, 102716. CMA. (2021). Making environmental claims on goods and services. Competition and Markets Authority, UK Government. Delmas, M.A. and V.C. Burbano. (2011). The drivers of greenwashing. California Management Review 54(1), 64–87. Demirel, P., K. Iatridis and E. Kesidou. (2018). The impact of regulatory complexity upon self-regulation: evidence from the adoption and certification of environmental management systems. Journal of Environmental Management 207, 80–91. Dunz, N., A. Naqvi and I. Monasterolo. (2021). Climate sentiments, transition risk, and financial stability in a stock-flow consistent model. Journal of Financial Stability 54(C). EP. (2024a). Meps adopt new law banning greenwashing and misleading product information. European Parliament News, Press Release. EP. (2024b). Parliament wants to improve consumer protection against misleading claims. European Parliament News, Press Release. Eyraud, L., B. Clements and A. Wane. (2013) Green investment: trends and determinants. Energy Policy 60, 852–865. Faber, G., A. Ruttinger, T. Strunge, T. Langhorst, A. Zimmermann, M. van der Hulst, F. Bensebaa, S. Moni and L. Tao. (2022). Adapting technology learning curves for prospective techno-economic and life cycle assessments of emerging carbon capture and utilization pathways. Frontiers in Climate 4. Fiegenbaum, A. and H. Thomas. (1995). Strategic groups as reference groups: theory, modeling and empirical examination of industry and competitive strategy. Strategic Management Journal 16(6), 461–476. Flammer, C. (2021). Corporate green bonds. Journal of Financial Economics 142(2), 499–516. Fürer, M. (2023). Reprisk data suggest increase in greenwashing and rise of social washing. Accessed: 2024-09-30. Available at: https://www.reprisk.com/research-insights/news-and-media-coverage/reprisk-data-shows-increase-in-greenwashing- with-one-in-three-greenwashing-public-companies-also-linked-to-social-washing#:∼:text=While%20greenwashing%20 incidents%20have%20accelerated,banking%20and%20financial%20services%20sectors. Gaio, C. and C. Raposo. (2011). Earnings quality and firm valuation: international evidence. Accounting & Finance 51(2), 467–499. Gao, J., X. Gu and X. Yang. (2024). Three-dimensional institutional equivalence: how industry, community, and network peers influence corporate innovation quality in china. European Journal of Innovation Management. ahead of print(ahead of print). Gaonkar, S. and A. Mele. (2023). A model of inter-organizational network formation. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 214, 82–104. Gu, C. and M. Shen. (2022). Peer effect of environmental information disclosure behavior in china: empirical test based on ”real green” and ”fake green. Heliyon 10(23). Gupta, K. and N. Singh. (2024). A systematic review of literature on greenwashing. In Sustainability Development through Green Economics, Contemporary Studies in Economic and Financial Analysis, vol. 114. Emerald Group Publishing Limited, pp. 75–90. Hameed, I., Z. Hyder, M. Imran and K. Shafiq. (2021). Greenwash and green purchase behavior: an environmentally sustainable perspective. Environment, Development and Sustainability 23, 13113–13134. He, Q., Z. Wang, G. Wang, J. Xie and Z. Chen. (2022). The dark side of environmental sustainability in projects: unraveling greenwashing behaviors. Project Management Journal 53(4), 349–366. Hirsch, S., D. Lanter and R. Finger. (2021). Profitability and profit persistence in eu food retailing: differences between top competitors and fringe firms. Agribusiness 37(2), 235–263. Huang, S.-M., S.H. Chung, C.F. Huang and K.-Q. Zhan. (2024). Discovering greenwashing behavior patterns: a systematic literature review approach. International Journal of Computer Auditing 6(1), 3–24. Huang, Z., Y. Shi and M. Jia. (2025). Greenwashing: a systematic literature review. Accounting & Finance 65(1), 857–882. Ille, S. (2022). Models of Society and Complex Systems. London: Routledge. Ioannou, I., G. Kassinis and G. Papagiannakis. (2023). The impact of perceived greenwashing on customer satisfaction and the contingent role of capability reputation. Journal of Business Ethics 185(2), 333–347. Jaumotte, F., J. Kim, S. Pienknagura and G. Schwerhoff. (2024). Policies to foster green fdi: best practices for emerging market and developing economies. Staff Climate Notes 2024(004), A001. Juliana Fernandes, S.S. and J.K. Leopold. (2020). When consumers learn to spot deception in advertising: testing a literacy intervention to combat greenwashing. International Journal of Advertising 39(7), 1115–1149. Karásek, J. and J. Pavlica. (2016). Green investment scheme: experience and results in the czech republic. Energy Policy 90, 121–130. Karpf, A. and A. Mandel. (2018). The changing value of the ‘green’ label on the us municipal bond market. Nature Climate Change 8, 161–165. Kesidou, E. and P. Demirel. (2012). On the drivers of eco-innovations: empirical evidence from the uk. Research Policy 41(5), 862–870. Laufer, W.S. (2003). Social accountability and corporate greenwashing. Journal of Business Ethics 43(3), 253–261. Leng, M. and M. Parlar. (2005). Game theoretic applications in supply chain management: a review. INFOR: Information Systems and Operational Research 43(3), 187–220. Liu, C., Y. Song, W. Wang and X. Shi. (2023). The governance of manufacturers’ greenwashing behaviors: a tripartite evolutionary game analysis of electric vehicles. Applied Energy 333, 120498. Liu, Z., Y.-Q. Huang, W.-L. Shang, Y.-J. Zhao, Z.-L. Yang and Z. Zhao. (2022b). Precooling energy and carbon emission reduction technology investment model in a fresh food cold chain based on a differential game. Applied Energy 326, 119945. Liu, Z., Q. Qian, B. Hu, W.-L. Shang, L. Li, Y. Zhao, Z. Zhao and C. Han. (2022a). Government regulation to promote coor- dinated emission reduction among enterprises in the green supply chain based on evolutionary game analysis. Resources, Conservation and Recycling 182, 106290. Lyon, T.P. and J.W. Maxwell. (2011). Greenwash: corporate environmental disclosure under threat of audit. Journal of Economics & Management Strategy 20(1), 3–41. Ma, P., L. Cui and D. Xu. (2024). Social comparison inside business groups and strategic change: evidence from group- affiliated chinese firms. Journal of Management Studies 61(8), 3533–3565. Maris, R., Z. Dorner and F. Carlsson. (2022). Nudges and monetary incentives: A green partnership? Working Paper in Economics No. 842 - University of Gothenburg. Marquis, C., M.W. Toffel and Y. Zhou. (2016). Scrutiny, norms, and selective disclosure: a global study of greenwashing. Organization Science 27(2), 483–504. Martin, P.R. and D.V. Moser. (2016). Managers’ green investment disclosures and investors’ reaction. Journal of Accounting and Economics 61(1), 239–254. Massini, S., A.Y. Lewin and H.R. Greve. (2005). Innovators and imitators: organizational reference groups and adoption of organizational routines. Research Policy 34(10), 1550–1569. Nieto, M.J. and C. Papathanassiou. (2025). Different shades of green: Eu corporate disclosure rules and their effectiveness in limiting “greenwashing”. Occasional Paper Series, European Central Bank (370). Ohtsuki, H. and M.A. Nowak. (2006). The replicator equation on graphs. Journal of Theoretical Biology 243(1), 86–97. Parguel, B., F. Benoît-Moreau and F. Larceneux. (2011). How sustainability ratings might deter ”Greenwashing”: a closer look at ethical corporate communication. Journal of Business Ethics 102(1), 15–28. Pekovic, S., G. Grolleau and N. Mzoughi. (2018). Environmental investments: too much of a good thing? International Journal of Production Economics 197, 297–302. RepRisk Report, J. (2022). Spotting greenwashing with esg data. Accessed: 2024-09-30. Available at: https://www.reprisk.com/ research-insights/reports/spotting-greenwashing-with-esg-data. Rezende, S., A. Alves, D. Bicalho and Â. Versiani. (2022). The network evolution of the internationalizing firm. Brazilian Business Review 19, 116–132. Schnabel, I. (2023). Monetary policy tightening and the green transition. Central bank speech, 11 January. Available at: https://www.bis.org/review/r230110k.pdf. Wang, Y. and G. Hou. (2020). A duopoly game with heterogeneous green supply chains in optimal price and market stability with consumer green preference. Journal of Cleaner Production 255, 120161. Wu, M.-W. and C.-H. Shen. (2013). Corporate social responsibility in the banking industry: motives and financial performance. Journal of Banking & Finance 37(9), 3529–3547. Xu, W., M. Li and S. Xu. (2023). Unveiling the “veil” of information disclosure: sustainability reporting “greenwashing” and “shared value. PLOS ONE 18(1), e0279904. Yadav, P.L., S.H. Han and J.J. Rho. (2016). Impact of environmental performance on firm value for sustainable investment: evidence from large us firms. Business Strategy and the Environment 25(6), 402–420. Yule, G. U. (1925). Ii.—a mathematical theory of evolution, based on the conclusions of dr. j. c. willis, f. r. s. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Containing Papers of a Biological Character 213(402–410), 21–87. Zeng, F., J. Wang and C. Zeng. (2025). An optimized machine learning framework for predicting and interpreting corporate esg greenwashing behavior. PLOS ONE 20(3), e0316287. Zhang, D. (2022a). Environmental regulation, green innovation, and export product quality: what is the role of greenwashing? International Review of Financial Analysis 83, 102311. Zhang, D. (2022b). Green financial system regulation shock and greenwashing behaviors: evidence from chinese firms. Energy Economics 111, 106064. Zhou, Y. and A. Gu. (2019). Learning curve analysis of wind power and photovoltaics technology in us: cost reduction and the importance of research, development and demonstration. Sustainability 11(8), 2310.